AMD Radeon PRO V710 vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB Comparison
AMD Radeon PRO V710
Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Radeon PRO V710 vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB
The Verdict
The recorded data shows two accelerators aimed at completely different workload profiles. The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB is an older, end-of-life compute card with a 92nd percentile rank among all GPUs, while the AMD Radeon PRO V710 is a newer, more efficient design sitting at the 88th percentile. In the only shared benchmark, Geekbench OpenCL, the AMD card wins decisively, scoring 116460 against the Tesla's 79396, a 31.8% margin in AMD's favor.
The Tesla P100 remains a viable option for legacy compute environments that rely on Pascal-era software stacks or NVIDIA's CUDA ecosystem, particularly where its 12 GB of HBM2 memory and 549.1 GB/s bandwidth are already integrated into existing infrastructure. The AMD Radeon PRO V710, however, is the stronger choice for new deployments: it delivers vastly higher FP32 throughput (27.65 TFLOPS versus 9.526 TFLOPS), uses substantially less power (158 W versus 250 W), supports PCIe 4.0, and offers 28 GB of GDDR6 memory. Buyers should note the AMD card has no launch MSRP recorded, while the Tesla launched at 4,599 USD, but pricing is not the focus here; performance and capability per watt clearly favor the Radeon PRO V710.
Architecture Differences
The two cards come from different design philosophies separated by eight years of process technology. The Tesla P100 uses the GP100 chip on TSMC's 16 nm node, packing 15,300 million transistors into a 610 mm² die, yielding a transistor density of 25.1M per mm². The Radeon PRO V710 uses Navi 32 on TSMC's 5 nm node, integrating 28,100 million transistors into a much smaller 346 mm² die, achieving 81.2M per mm², more than three times the density.
The Tesla's architecture is Pascal, a compute-focused design from 2016. It has 3584 shading units, 224 texture mapping units, and 96 render output units. Its memory subsystem uses HBM2 across a 3072-bit bus, providing 549.1 GB/s of bandwidth. The card has no ray tracing cores and no tensor cores; its FP16 throughput is 19.05 TFLOPS at a 2:1 ratio relative to FP32, meaning half-rate FP16.
The Radeon PRO V710 uses RDNA 3.0, a modern graphics architecture. It has 3456 shading units, 216 texture mapping units, and 96 render output units, closely matching the Tesla's count. Crucially, it includes 54 ray tracing cores, which the Tesla lacks entirely. Its memory is GDDR6 on a 224-bit bus, delivering 504.0 GB/s, slightly below the Tesla's HBM2 bandwidth. The AMD card computes FP16 at 27.65 TFLOPS with a 1:1 ratio, meaning full-rate FP16, which is a significant advantage for mixed-precision workloads.
The Tesla supports DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3. The AMD card supports DirectX 12 Ultimate (12_2), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.4, adding newer API features. Both cards have no display outputs, confirming their compute-only purpose.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The database contains one direct comparison between these two cards: Geekbench OpenCL. The AMD Radeon PRO V710 scores 116460, while the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB scores 79396. The delta is recorded as -31.8% from AMD's perspective, meaning the Tesla trails by 31.8%. This is a substantial margin, roughly one-third lower performance in a general-purpose compute workload.
Context from the nearest rivals list reinforces this gap. The Tesla P100's closest competitors are the Tesla P100 16 GB (score 79605, delta -0.3%), the GeForce RTX 5090 (score 79842, delta -0.6%), the AMD Radeon RX 6850M XT (score 78940, delta +0.6%), and the AMD Radeon Pro Vega 64X (score 80959, delta -1.9%). All four sit within roughly 2% of the Tesla's score, indicating the 12 GB P100 is tightly clustered with its immediate peers, none of which come close to the AMD PRO V710's OpenCL result.
The AMD card's nearest rivals tell a different story. Its average benchmark score across all tests is 58657, which is dragged down by its 3DMark Steel Nomad DX12 score of 853. Its rivals include the NVIDIA P102-100 (avg 58528, delta +0.2%), AMD Radeon RX 6950 XT (avg 58392, delta +0.5%), Intel Arc A570M (avg 58239, delta +0.7%), and AMD Radeon RX 5600 OEM (avg 58085, delta +1.0%). The OpenCL result of 116460 is nearly double the card's average score, indicating that 3DMark Steel Nomad is a much tougher test for this architecture, while OpenCL plays to its strengths.
Specification Differences
The two cards differ in nearly every measurable specification. The Tesla P100 has a base clock of 1190 MHz and a boost clock of 1329 MHz, while the Radeon PRO V710 runs at 1900 MHz base and 2000 MHz boost, a substantial clock advantage of roughly 50% at both points. Memory clocks differ as well: the Tesla runs at 715 MHz with 1430 Mbps effective, while the AMD card runs at 2250 MHz with 18 Gbps effective.
Memory capacity and type diverge sharply. The Tesla offers 12 GB of HBM2 on a 3072-bit bus, while the AMD card provides 28 GB of GDDR6 on a 224-bit bus. Bandwidth is close: 549.1 GB/s versus 504.0 GB/s, favoring the Tesla by 9%. Shading unit counts are similar (3584 versus 3456), as are TMUs (224 versus 216) and ROPs (96 versus 96), but the AMD card adds 54 ray tracing cores.
Pixel rate and texture rate favor the AMD card. The Tesla achieves 127.6 GPixel/s and 297.7 GTexel/s, while the AMD card reaches 192.0 GPixel/s and 432.0 GTexel/s, gains of roughly 50% and 45% respectively. FP32 throughput is dramatically different: 9.526 TFLOPS for the Tesla versus 27.65 TFLOPS for the AMD card, a 2.9x advantage. FP16 is 19.05 TFLOPS (2:1) versus 27.65 TFLOPS (1:1), meaning the AMD card is faster and does not halve its rate.
Power consumption favors the AMD card strongly. The Tesla has a 250 W TDP and requires a 600 W suggested PSU, while the AMD card draws 158 W and needs a 450 W PSU. The Tesla is dual-slot, the AMD card is single-slot. Both use a single 8-pin power connector. The Tesla uses PCIe 3.0 x16; the AMD card uses PCIe 4.0 x16, doubling interface bandwidth.
Physical dimensions differ: the Tesla is 267 mm (10.5 inches) long, while the AMD card's length is not recorded. Production status also differs: the Tesla is end-of-life, while the AMD card has no recorded status. Release dates are June 2016 for the Tesla and October 2024 for the AMD card.
FAQ
Q: Which card is faster in OpenCL compute?
A: The AMD Radeon PRO V710 scores 116460 in Geekbench OpenCL, while the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB scores 79396. The AMD card leads by 31.8%.
Q: Does the Tesla P100 have ray tracing cores?
A: No, the Tesla P100 has no ray tracing cores. The AMD Radeon PRO V710 includes 54 ray tracing cores.
Q: How much memory does each card have and what type?
A: The Tesla P100 has 12 GB of HBM2 on a 3072-bit bus. The AMD Radeon PRO V710 has 28 GB of GDDR6 on a 224-bit bus.
Q: What is the power draw difference?
A: The Tesla P100 has a 250 W TDP and suggests a 600 W power supply. The AMD Radeon PRO V710 has a 158 W TDP and suggests a 450 W power supply.
Q: Which card supports newer PCIe and API standards?
A: The AMD Radeon PRO V710 uses PCIe 4.0 x16 and supports DirectX 12 Ultimate (12_2) and Vulkan 1.4. The Tesla P100 uses PCIe 3.0 x16 and supports DirectX 12 (12_1) and Vulkan 1.3.
Q: Is the Tesla P100 still in production?
A: No, the Tesla P100 is marked as end-of-life. The AMD Radeon PRO V710 has no recorded production status.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Radeon PRO V710 wins in every measured performance category except raw memory bandwidth. Its FP32 throughput of 27.65 TFLOPS is nearly triple the Tesla's 9.526 TFLOPS, making it the clear choice for general compute, simulation, and AI inference workloads that rely on dense FP32 math. Its FP16 performance is also superior: 27.65 TFLOPS at a 1:1 ratio versus the Tesla's 19.05 TFLOPS at a 2:1 ratio, meaning the AMD card sustains full-rate FP16 while the Tesla halves its rate. The 54 ray tracing cores give it an advantage in any workload that uses RT acceleration, which the Tesla cannot handle at all.
The AMD card also wins on efficiency and deployment flexibility. A 158 W TDP versus 250 W means less heat, lower cooling requirements, and a smaller power supply (450 W versus 600 W). Single-slot width versus dual-slot allows denser server configurations. PCIe 4.0 doubles host transfer rates, which helps with data movement in and out of the card. The 28 GB memory capacity is more than double the Tesla's 12 GB, allowing larger datasets to reside on-card without spilling to system memory.
The NVIDIA Tesla P100 retains one advantage: memory bandwidth. Its HBM2 implementation delivers 549.1 GB/s across a 3072-bit bus, 9% higher than the AMD card's 504.0 GB/s. For memory-bound workloads that are already optimized for HBM2 and cannot be retargeted, this bandwidth edge may matter. Additionally, the Tesla's nearest rivals all score within 2% of it in OpenCL, meaning it is a stable, predictable performer within its generation, and its Pascal architecture may be the only supported option for legacy software stacks that predate RDNA.
The final split is clear: the AMD Radeon PRO V710 wins for new compute deployments, mixed-precision workloads, ray tracing, and efficiency-sensitive environments. The Tesla P100 wins only where HBM2 bandwidth is critical or where software compatibility with Pascal is mandatory. Given the AMD card's 31.8% OpenCL lead, 2.9x FP32 throughput, 158 W power draw, and 28 GB memory, the data points decisively toward the Radeon PRO V710 for most modern use cases.