AMD Instinct MI300X vs NVIDIA Tesla V100 PCIe 32 GB Comparison
AMD Instinct MI300X
Tesla V100 PCIe 32 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Instinct MI300X vs NVIDIA Tesla V100 PCIe 32 GB
The AMD Instinct MI300X and NVIDIA Tesla V100 PCIe 32 GB represent two distinct eras of accelerator design, and the benchmark data quantifies that gap precisely. The head-to-head comparison shows a single Geekbench OpenCL test where the MI300X scores 317,994 against the V100's 168,763, a decisive 88.4% advantage. This places the MI300X in the 100th percentile of all GPUs, while the V100 sits at the 96th percentile, a reminder that while the older card remains capable, the newer silicon operates in a different performance class entirely. The data does not offer a direct Vulkan comparison, as only the V100 has a recorded Geekbench Vulkan score of 131,847, leaving that API as a point of differentiation rather than a head-to-head metric.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The sole direct benchmark result is overwhelmingly one-sided. In Geekbench OpenCL, the AMD Instinct MI300X delivers 317,994 points, while the NVIDIA Tesla V100 PCIe 32 GB manages 168,763 points. The 88.4% delta is not a marginal improvement; it is a generational leap. To contextualize the MI300X's score, its nearest rivals include the NVIDIA B200 at 345,482 (8% ahead), the NVIDIA H200 NVL at 334,891 (5% ahead), and the NVIDIA L40S at 295,763 (7.5% behind). This means the MI300X is not merely faster than the V100; it sits comfortably within the top tier of contemporary accelerators, outpacing the L40S and trailing only the highest-end NVIDIA parts by single-digit percentages.
In contrast, the V100's average benchmark score is 150,305, derived from its OpenCL result and its Vulkan score of 131,847. Its nearest rivals include the NVIDIA A100 PCIe 40 GB at 162,504 (7.5% ahead) and the AMD Radeon Pro W6800X at 160,671 (6.5% ahead), while it edges out the AMD Instinct MI100 at 139,035 by 8.1%. The data shows the V100 is not obsolete; it is competitive with mid-range and previous-generation flagship accelerators, but it is simply outclassed by the MI300X's raw compute throughput. The MI300X's FP32 throughput of 81.72 TFLOPS dwarfs the V100's 14.13 TFLOPS, and even the V100's FP16 advantage (28.26 TFLOPS) is less than half of the MI300X's FP16 figure of 81.72 TFLOPS, despite the latter operating at a 1:1 ratio versus the V100's 2:1 ratio.
The Verdict
The verdict from the data is unambiguous for raw performance: the AMD Instinct MI300X is the superior choice. Its OpenCL score is nearly double, its memory bandwidth is 5.32 TB/s versus 897.0 GB/s, and its FP32 compute is over five times higher. The percentile ranking of 100th versus 96th confirms that the MI300X is at the absolute top of the database, while the V100, though strong, is not. For any workload that is compute-bound or memory-bandwidth-bound, the MI300X will deliver significantly higher throughput.
However, the V100 is not without its merits, and the choice depends entirely on use case. The V100 is a dual-slot PCIe card with a 250 W TDP and 2x 8-pin power connectors, making it far easier to integrate into existing servers with standard power delivery. The MI300X is an OAM Module with no power connectors and a 750 W TDP, requiring specialized chassis and power infrastructure. The V100 also supports a broader set of APIs, including DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.4, while the MI300X reports N/A for all three, indicating a compute-only focus. The V100 is end-of-life production, but its PCIe 3.0 x16 interface and established ecosystem mean it can be dropped into legacy systems. The MI300X, with a PCIe 5.0 x16 interface, is designed for modern, high-density compute nodes.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Instinct MI300X wins in every scenario that demands maximum compute throughput and memory capacity. Its 192 GB of HBM3 memory versus the V100's 32 GB of HBM2 allows it to hold vastly larger datasets in on-chip memory, reducing the need for constant host-device transfers. The 8192-bit memory bus versus the V100's 4096-bit bus, combined with the higher HBM3 clock, yields a 5.32 TB/s bandwidth that is nearly six times the V100's 897.0 GB/s. This makes the MI300X ideal for large-scale AI training, massive batch inference, and scientific simulations that process multi-gigabyte matrices. Its texture rate of 2,553.6 GTexel/s is also over five times the V100's 441.6 GTexel/s, though the MI300X's 0 MPixel/s pixel rate versus the V100's 176.6 GPixel/s indicates the MI300X is not designed for rasterization workloads.
The NVIDIA Tesla V100 PCIe 32 GB wins in compatibility and deployment flexibility. Its 12 nm TSMC process and 815 mm² die are older, but the card's 250 W TDP and dual-slot form factor allow it to be used in standard workstations and servers without custom power cabling. The 640 Tensor Cores provide dedicated hardware for matrix operations, a feature that is not listed for the MI300X. The V100 also has a Vulkan score of 131,847, indicating it can handle graphics-adjacent compute tasks, whereas the MI300X has no API support listed. For organizations with existing PCIe 3.0 infrastructure or those needing a low-power accelerator for inference at the edge, the V100 remains a viable, if dated, option.
FAQ
Q: Which GPU has a higher Geekbench OpenCL score?
A: The AMD Instinct MI300X scores 317,994, which is 88.4% higher than the NVIDIA Tesla V100's 168,763.
Q: What is the memory capacity difference?
A: The MI300X has 192 GB of HBM3 memory, while the V100 has 32 GB of HBM2, a six-fold difference in capacity.
Q: Does the V100 support any graphics APIs?
A: Yes, the V100 supports DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.4, whereas the MI300X lists N/A for all three.
Q: How do their compute throughputs compare?
A: The MI300X delivers 81.72 TFLOPS FP32 and 81.72 TFLOPS FP16 (1:1), while the V100 delivers 14.13 TFLOPS FP32 and 28.26 TFLOPS FP16 (2:1).
Q: What is the power consumption difference?
A: The MI300X has a 750 W TDP, while the V100 has a 250 W TDP.
Q: Which card has a higher memory bandwidth?
A: The MI300X has 5.32 TB/s, compared to the V100's 897.0 GB/s, a difference of roughly 5.9 times.
Architecture Differences
The architectural gap between the two is foundational. The MI300X uses the CDNA 3.0 architecture on TSMC's 5 nm process, packing 153,000 million transistors onto a 1017 mm² die, yielding a density of 150.4M transistors per mm². The V100 uses the Volta architecture on TSMC's 12 nm process, with 21,100 million transistors on an 815 mm² die, for a density of 25.9M per mm². The MI300X has 19,456 shading units and 1,216 TMUs, while the V100 has 5,120 shading units and 320 TMUs. The MI300X also features 0 ROPs and no listed Tensor or RT cores, while the V100 has 128 ROPs and 640 Tensor Cores. The memory subsystems are equally divergent: the MI300X uses HBM3 with a 8192-bit bus and 1300 MHz clock (5.2 Gbps effective), whereas the V100 uses HBM2 with a 4096-bit bus and 876 MHz clock (1752 Mbps effective). The MI300X's FP16 throughput is 1:1 with FP32, indicating a compute-focused design, while the V100's FP16 is 2:1, suggesting a more balanced approach with dedicated Tensor Cores for mixed-precision work.
Specification Differences
The two accelerators differ across nearly every specification field. The MI300X has a base clock of 1000 MHz and boost clock of 2100 MHz, while the V100 has a higher base clock of 1230 MHz but a lower boost of 1380 MHz. Memory type, size, bus width, and bandwidth all favor the MI300X: HBM3 192 GB, 8192-bit, 5.32 TB/s versus HBM2 32 GB, 4096-bit, 897.0 GB/s. The MI300X has 19,456 shading units and 1,216 TMUs versus 5,120 and 320, respectively; the V100 has 128 ROPs while the MI300X has 0. The MI300X's pixel rate is 0 MPixel/s versus the V100's 176.6 GPixel/s, and its texture rate is 2,553.6 GTexel/s versus 441.6 GTexel/s. FP32 compute is 81.72 TFLOPS versus 14.13 TFLOPS, and FP16 is 81.72 TFLOPS versus 28.26 TFLOPS. TDP is 750 W versus 250 W, with the MI300X as an OAM Module and the V100 as a dual-slot card. Power connectors are none on the MI300X versus 2x 8-pin on the V100, and suggested PSU is 1150 W versus 600 W. Bus interface is PCIe 5.0 x16 versus PCIe 3.0 x16. The release dates are 2023-12-05 for the MI300X and 2018-03-26 for the V100, with the V100 being end-of-life and the MI300X having no listed production status.