AMD Instinct MI300X vs NVIDIA Tesla V100 PCIe 16 GB Comparison
AMD Instinct MI300X
Tesla V100 PCIe 16 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Instinct MI300X vs NVIDIA Tesla V100 PCIe 16 GB
AMD Instinct MI300X and NVIDIA Tesla V100 PCIe 16 GB represent two distinct eras of accelerator design, with the data showing a decisive performance gap that reflects their architectural and generational differences. The MI300X, built on CDNA 3.0, posts a Geekbench OpenCL score of 317,994, while the older Volta-based V100 achieves 163,063 in the same test, placing them at opposite ends of the current GPU landscape.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The single available head-to-head benchmark—Geekbench OpenCL—shows the AMD Instinct MI300X outperforming the NVIDIA Tesla V100 PCIe 16 GB by a substantial 95% margin. The MI300X scores 317,994 against the V100’s 163,063, a delta that is nearly double the older card’s output. This is not an incremental improvement; it is a generational leap that dwarfs typical year-over-year gains.
Contextualizing these scores against their respective peer groups highlights how each card sits within its own competitive bracket. The MI300X’s score places it at the 100th percentile of all GPUs, meaning benchmark data suggests it outperforms every other recorded device. Its closest rival, the NVIDIA B200, scores 345,482—8% higher—while the NVIDIA H200 NVL trails slightly at 334,891, a 5% advantage over the MI300X. Conversely, the MI300X leads the NVIDIA L40S by 7.5% (295,763) and the RTX 6000 Ada Generation by 10.7% (287,237).
The Tesla V100, meanwhile, sits at the 96th percentile, indicating it still outperforms the vast majority of GPUs despite its age. Its average benchmark score of 138,063 across OpenCL and Vulkan tests (the latter at 113,062) puts it in a tight cluster with contemporaries. The V100 SXM2 32 GB scores 137,731—just 0.2% behind—while the AMD Instinct MI100 posts 139,035, a 0.7% edge over the V100. The AMD Radeon PRO V620 (136,472) and Radeon Pro W6800X Duo (135,774) round out a group where the V100 is essentially neck-and-neck with its peers, differing by no more than 1.7% in either direction.
What the head-to-head data does not show is any Vulkan comparison, as the MI300X has no Vulkan benchmark recorded while the V100 lists a 113,062 score. This absence is notable, given the MI300X’s API support is listed as N/A for Vulkan, OpenGL, and DirectX, whereas the V100 supports DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.4.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Instinct MI300X wins decisively in raw compute throughput, a conclusion directly supported by the 95% OpenCL delta. This advantage stems from its massive shading unit count—19,456 versus the V100’s 5,120—and its FP32 output of 81.72 TFLOPS, which is 5.8 times the V100’s 14.13 TFLOPS. For workloads that scale with parallel FP32 operations, such as dense matrix math or general-purpose compute, the MI300X is categorically superior.
The MI300X also dominates in memory capacity and bandwidth. Its 192 GB of HBM3 memory with 5.32 TB/s bandwidth dwarfs the V100’s 16 GB of HBM2 at 897.0 GB/s. This represents a 12x capacity increase and roughly a 6x bandwidth advantage. For large language model inference or datasets that exceed the V100’s memory ceiling, the MI300X is the only viable option between the two. The V100’s 16 GB frame buffer would require model sharding or offloading, while the MI300X can hold substantially larger working sets entirely on-card.
The NVIDIA Tesla V100’s wins are narrower and more specialized. Its FP16 throughput of 28.26 TFLOPS (2:1 ratio) is exactly double its FP32 rate, indicating dedicated half-precision paths that were advanced for 2017. The MI300X lists FP16 at 81.72 TFLOPS (1:1), meaning it does not gain a ratio advantage but still delivers 2.9x more FP16 compute in absolute terms. The V100 also includes 640 tensor cores, a feature the MI300X does not list, which historically gave Volta an edge in early deep learning frameworks that relied on tensor core acceleration.
Pixel throughput is another area where the V100 registers a win: 176.6 GPixel/s versus the MI300X’s 0 MPixel/s. The MI300X lists no ROPs and zero pixel rate, confirming it is a pure compute accelerator with no rasterization path. The V100’s 128 ROPs and support for graphics APIs make it nominally capable of displayless rendering tasks, though its "No outputs" designation means neither card can drive a monitor directly.
Architecture Differences
The architectural chasm between these two accelerators is stark. The MI300X uses the CDNA 3.0 architecture on TSMC’s 5 nm process, packing 153,000 million transistors into a 1017 mm² die—a transistor density of 150.4 million per square millimeter. The V100 uses the older Volta architecture on a 12 nm process, with 21,100 million transistors on an 815 mm² die, yielding just 25.9 million transistors per square millimeter. The MI300X crams 7.3x more transistors into only 25% more silicon area.
The memory subsystems reflect this generational gap. The MI300X employs HBM3 with an 8192-bit bus, while the V100 uses HBM2 with a 4096-bit bus. Clock speeds tell a nuanced story: the V100 has a higher base clock (1245 MHz vs 1000 MHz) and boost clock (1380 MHz vs 2100 MHz) at launch, but the MI300X’s boost clock of 2100 MHz is 52% higher than the V100’s. Memory clocks differ dramatically—the MI300X runs at 1300 MHz (5.2 Gbps effective) versus the V100’s 876 MHz (1752 Mbps effective).
Shading resources are not remotely comparable. The MI300X fields 19,456 shading units and 1,216 TMUs, while the V100 has 5,120 shading units, 320 TMUs, and 128 ROPs. The MI300X’s texture rate of 2,553.6 GTexel/s is 5.8x the V100’s 441.6 GTexel/s. The V100’s tensor cores (640) have no counterpart in the MI300X’s spec list, though the MI300X’s raw FP16 compute likely compensates in practice.
Power and interface differences are equally pronounced. The MI300X draws 750 W and uses an OAM module form factor with no power connectors, requiring a 1150 W suggested PSU. The V100 is a dual-slot PCIe card at 300 W with two 8-pin connectors and a 700 W suggested PSU. The MI300X uses PCIe 5.0 x16, while the V100 is limited to PCIe 3.0 x16, potentially affecting host transfer bandwidth.
FAQ
Q: How much faster is the AMD Instinct MI300X than the NVIDIA Tesla V100 in OpenCL?
A: The MI300X scores 317,994 in Geekbench OpenCL, which is 95% higher than the V100’s 163,063. This means the MI300X delivers nearly double the OpenCL performance of the V100.
Q: Does the Tesla V100 have any advantage in memory capacity?
A: No. The MI300X has 192 GB of HBM3 memory, which is 12 times larger than the V100’s 16 GB of HBM2. The MI300X also provides 5.32 TB/s of memory bandwidth versus the V100’s 897.0 GB/s.
Q: Can either card output video to a display?
A: Neither card has display outputs. Both are listed as "No outputs," meaning they are designed exclusively for compute workloads without any video display capabilities.
Q: What is the transistor density difference between the two chips?
A: The MI300X achieves 150.4 million transistors per square millimeter on a 5 nm process, while the V100 manages 25.9 million on 12 nm. The MI300X’s density is 5.8x higher, allowing it to pack 153,000 million transistors versus the V100’s 21,100 million.
Q: Is the Tesla V100 still competitive with other GPUs of its era?
A: The V100 sits at the 96th percentile of all GPUs and its average score of 138,063 is within 1.7% of its nearest rivals, including the AMD Instinct MI100 (139,035) and Tesla V100 SXM2 32 GB (137,731). It remains competitive within its generation.
Q: Does the V100 support more graphics APIs than the MI300X?
A: Yes. The V100 supports DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.4. The MI300X lists N/A for DirectX, OpenGL, and Vulkan, indicating no graphics API support is exposed in the data.
Specification Differences
| Specification | AMD Instinct MI300X | NVIDIA Tesla V100 PCIe 16 GB |
|---|---|---|
| Architecture | CDNA 3.0 | Volta |
| Process Node | 5 nm | 12 nm |
| Transistors | 153,000 million | 21,100 million |
| Die Size | 1017 mm² | 815 mm² |
| Transistor Density | 150.4M / mm² | 25.9M / mm² |
| Base Clock | 1000 MHz | 1245 MHz |
| Boost Clock | 2100 MHz | 1380 MHz |
| Memory Clock | 1300 MHz (5.2 Gbps effective) | 876 MHz (1752 Mbps effective) |
| Memory Size | 192 GB | 16 GB |
| Memory Type | HBM3 | HBM2 |
| Memory Bus Width | 8192 bit | 4096 bit |
| Memory Bandwidth | 5.32 TB/s | 897.0 GB/s |
| Shading Units | 19456 | 5120 |
| TMUs | 1216 | 320 |
| ROPs | 0 | 128 |
| Tensor Cores | N/A | 640 |
| Pixel Rate | 0 MPixel/s | 176.6 GPixel/s |
| Texture Rate | 2,553.6 GTexel/s | 441.6 GTexel/s |
| FP32 Performance | 81.72 TFLOPS | 14.13 TFLOPS |
| FP16 Performance | 81.72 TFLOPS (1:1) | 28.26 TFLOPS (2:1) |
| TDP | 750 W | 300 W |
| Slot Width | OAM Module | Dual-slot |
| Power Connectors | None | 2x 8-pin |
| Suggested PSU | 1150 W | 700 W |
| Bus Interface | PCIe 5.0 x16 | PCIe 3.0 x16 |
| DirectX Support | N/A | 12 (12_1) |
| OpenGL Support | N/A | 4.6 |
| Vulkan Support | N/A | 1.4 |
| Release Date | 2023-12-05 | 2017-06-20 |
The Verdict
The data supports an unambiguous conclusion: the AMD Instinct MI300X is the superior compute accelerator by nearly every measurable metric. Its 95% OpenCL performance lead, 12x memory capacity advantage, and 5.8x FP32 throughput make it the clear choice for modern high-performance computing workloads that can utilize its CDNA 3.0 architecture. The MI300X’s 100th percentile ranking confirms it operates at the very top of the GPU performance spectrum, outclassing even the NVIDIA H200 NVL by 5% and the B200 by 8% in the recorded benchmark.
The NVIDIA Tesla V100 PCIe 16 GB, despite being end-of-life, remains a functional compute card with a 96th percentile standing. Its 640 tensor cores and FP16 2:1 ratio were pioneering for 2017, and its 300 W power draw is significantly lower than the MI300X’s 750 W. The V100’s support for Vulkan 1.4, OpenGL 4.6, and DirectX 12 (12_1) gives it a graphics-adjacent capability that the MI300X entirely lacks, though neither card has display outputs.
For buyers choosing between these two, the decision hinges on workload requirements. The MI300X is the only option for models or datasets exceeding 16 GB, and its 5.32 TB/s bandwidth eliminates memory bottlenecks that would starve the V100. The V100 makes sense only in scenarios where its lower power envelope, established software ecosystem from 2017, or tensor core support for legacy frameworks are critical. Benchmark results indicate that for raw compute, the MI300X offers a generational leap that the V100 cannot match, making the older card a fallback for compatibility rather than a performance choice.