AMD Instinct MI300X vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB Comparison

AMD
RADEON

AMD Instinct MI300X

CORE STATE Aqua Vanjaram
VRAM 192 GB
CLOCK SPEED 2100 MHz
TDP 750 W
BUS WIDTH 8192 bit
ARCHITECTURE CDNA 3.0
nm
PROCESS 5 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2023
VS
NVIDIA
GEFORCE

Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB

CORE STATE GP100
VRAM 12 GB
CLOCK SPEED 1329 MHz
TDP 250 W
BUS WIDTH 3072 bit
ARCHITECTURE Pascal
nm
PROCESS 16 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2016

PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS

geekbench_opencl
317,994
79,396

Analysis: AMD Instinct MI300X vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB

Head-to-Head Benchmarks

The recorded data contains a single head-to-head comparison between the AMD Instinct MI300X and the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB, using the Geekbench OpenCL benchmark. The results show a decisive victory for the AMD part, with a score of 317,994 against 79,396 for the NVIDIA Tesla P100. This translates to a delta of 300.5% in favor of the AMD Instinct MI300X. In relative terms, the MI300X delivers roughly four times the compute throughput of the older Tesla part in this specific workload.

Contextualizing the AMD Instinct MI300X's score within its nearest rivals in the database reveals its position. The MI300X's 317,994 average score sits 7.5% above the NVIDIA L40S, which achieves 295,763. However, it trails the NVIDIA H200 NVL, which scores 334,891, a 5% advantage for the H200. The NVIDIA B200 leads the pack with 345,482, which is 8% higher than the MI300X. This places the MI300X solidly within the upper echelon of accelerators, though not at the absolute top. Its percentile rank of 100 among all GPUs in the database underscores that it outperforms virtually every other recorded processor in this test.

For the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB, its score of 79,396 places it at the 92nd percentile of all GPUs. Its nearest rivals show a tightly clustered performance band. The Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB scores 79,605, a negligible 0.3% difference. The NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5090 scores 79,842, just 0.6% ahead. The AMD Radeon RX 6850M XT is 0.6% behind at 78,940, and the AMD Radeon Pro Vega 64X is 1.9% ahead at 80,959. The data suggests that the 12 GB Tesla P100 is still competitive with much more recent consumer and workstation parts in raw OpenCL performance, but it belongs to a different performance tier entirely when compared to the MI300X.

Architecture Differences

The architectural gap between these two accelerators is vast, reflecting their different eras and design philosophies. The AMD Instinct MI300X is built on a 5 nm process at TSMC, while the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB uses a 16 nm process, also from TSMC. This process difference is a primary driver of the performance disparity. The MI300X's chip, codenamed "Aqua Vanjaram," packs a staggering 153,000 million transistors onto a 1017 mm² die, yielding a transistor density of 150.4 million per square millimeter. In contrast, the P100's GP100 chip contains 15,300 million transistors on a 610 mm² die, with a density of just 25.1 million per square millimeter.

The compute architectures are fundamentally different as well. The MI300X uses AMD's CDNA 3.0 architecture, designed for data center compute, while the P100 uses NVIDIA's Pascal architecture, which was introduced for the Tesla Pascal generation. The MI300X is equipped with 19,456 shading units and 1,216 texture mapping units. The P100 has 3,584 shading units and 224 texture mapping units. The MI300X reports 0 ROPs and a pixel rate of 0 MPixel/s, indicating a pure compute focus with no graphics output. The P100, despite being a compute card, retains 96 ROPs and a 127.6 GPixel/s pixel rate.

Memory subsystems are another major differentiator. The MI300X has 192 GB of HBM3 memory on an 8192-bit bus, delivering 5.32 TB/s of bandwidth. The P100 features 12 GB of HBM2 on a 3072-bit bus, with 549.1 GB/s of bandwidth. The MI300X offers 16 times the capacity and nearly 10 times the bandwidth. Clock speeds also differ: the MI300X runs at a 1000 MHz base and 2100 MHz boost, while the P100 operates at 1190 MHz base and 1329 MHz boost. The MI300X's higher boost clock, combined with its massive shader count, explains its dominant FP32 performance of 81.72 TFLOPS versus the P100's 9.526 TFLOPS.

The MI300X also shows a different FP16 strategy, with 81.72 TFLOPS at a 1:1 ratio to FP32, whereas the P100 achieves 19.05 TFLOPS at a 2:1 ratio. The MI300X's memory clock is listed as 1300 MHz with 5.2 Gbps effective, while the P100's memory runs at 715 MHz with 1430 Mbps effective. Power consumption reflects these differences: the MI300X has a TDP of 750 W and requires a 1150 W power supply, while the P100 has a 250 W TDP and a 600 W suggested PSU. The MI300X is an OAM Module with no power connectors, while the P100 is a dual-slot card with a single 8-pin connector. The bus interfaces differ too, with the MI300X using PCIe 5.0 x16 and the P100 using PCIe 3.0 x16.

FAQ

Q: How much faster is the AMD Instinct MI300X than the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB in OpenCL?

A: The MI300X scores 317,994 in Geekbench OpenCL, which is 300.5% higher than the P100's score of 79,396. This represents a roughly fourfold performance advantage.

Q: What are the memory capacity and bandwidth differences?

A: The MI300X has 192 GB of HBM3 memory with 5.32 TB/s bandwidth on an 8192-bit bus. The P100 has 12 GB of HBM2 with 549.1 GB/s bandwidth on a 3072-bit bus. The MI300X has 16 times the capacity and approximately 9.7 times the bandwidth.

Q: Which GPU has a higher transistor density?

A: The MI300X has a transistor density of 150.4 million per mm², based on 153,000 million transistors on a 1017 mm² die. The P100 has 25.1 million per mm², with 15,300 million transistors on a 610 mm² die.

Q: What are the thermal design power ratings?

A: The MI300X has a TDP of 750 W with a suggested power supply of 1150 W. The P100 has a TDP of 250 W with a suggested power supply of 600 W.

Q: How does the MI300X compare to its nearest rivals like the NVIDIA H200 NVL?

A: The MI300X's average score of 317,994 is 5% lower than the NVIDIA H200 NVL's 334,891. It is also 8% lower than the NVIDIA B200's 345,482. However, it is 7.5% higher than the NVIDIA L40S.

Q: Is the Tesla P100 still competitive with modern GPUs?

A: The data shows the P100's score of 79,396 is within 1.9% of the AMD Radeon Pro Vega 64X and 0.6% of the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5090. It sits at the 92nd percentile of all GPUs, indicating it remains viable in OpenCL workloads, though far behind the MI300X.

The Verdict

The benchmark data presents a clear hierarchy. The AMD Instinct MI300X is a modern, high-capacity compute accelerator that dominates the older NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB in raw OpenCL performance by 300.5%. Its score places it in the top tier of all recorded GPUs, trailing only the NVIDIA H200 NVL and B200 among its nearest rivals. The MI300X is designed for massive parallel workloads with its 192 GB memory pool, 5.32 TB/s bandwidth, and 81.72 TFLOPS of FP32 compute. It is a data center part that requires a 750 W TDP and an OAM module form factor.

The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB, despite being end-of-life and released in 2016, still holds a respectable 92nd percentile rank. Its performance is closely matched with the RTX 5090 and Radeon Pro Vega 64X, which is notable given its age. The P100 offers 12 GB of HBM2, 9.526 TFLOPS of FP32, and a much lower 250 W TDP. For users with legacy infrastructure or power constraints, the P100 remains a functional option, but it cannot compete with the MI300X in any performance metric recorded here.

The choice between them is not about value, but about capability and system integration. The MI300X is for workloads that require the absolute maximum memory capacity and compute throughput, such as large-scale AI training or inference. The P100 is a more modest accelerator that can fit into standard PCIe 3.0 slots with a single 8-pin power connector. The data does not support any scenario where the P100 outperforms the MI300X, but it does show the P100 as a competent, lower-power alternative for less demanding tasks.

Specification Differences

| Field | AMD Instinct MI300X | NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB |

| :--- | :--- | :--- |

| Architecture | CDNA 3.0 | Pascal |

| Process Node | 5 nm | 16 nm |

| Transistors | 153,000 million | 15,300 million |

| Die Size | 1017 mm² | 610 mm² |

| Transistor Density | 150.4M / mm² | 25.1M / mm² |

| Base Clock | 1000 MHz | 1190 MHz |

| Boost Clock | 2100 MHz | 1329 MHz |

| Memory Clock | 1300 MHz (5.2 Gbps effective) | 715 MHz (1430 Mbps effective) |

| Memory Size | 192 GB | 12 GB |

| Memory Type | HBM3 | HBM2 |

| Memory Bus | 8192 bit | 3072 bit |

| Memory Bandwidth | 5.32 TB/s | 549.1 GB/s |

| Shading Units | 19456 | 3584 |

| TMUs | 1216 | 224 |

| ROPs | 0 | 96 |

| Pixel Rate | 0 MPixel/s | 127.6 GPixel/s |

| Texture Rate | 2,553.6 GTexel/s | 297.7 GTexel/s |

| FP32 Performance | 81.72 TFLOPS | 9.526 TFLOPS |

| FP16 Performance | 81.72 TFLOPS (1:1) | 19.05 TFLOPS (2:1) |

| TDP | 750 W | 250 W |

| Slot Width | OAM Module | Dual-slot |

| Power Connectors | None | 1x 8-pin |

| Suggested PSU | 1150 W | 600 W |

| Bus Interface | PCIe 5.0 x16 | PCIe 3.0 x16 |

| DirectX Support | N/A | 12 (12_1) |

| OpenGL Support | N/A | 4.6 |

| Vulkan Support | N/A | 1.3 |

| Length | Not recorded | 267 mm (10.5 inches) |

| Release Date | 2023-12-05 | 2016-06-19 |

| Production Status | Not recorded | End-of-life |

| Predecessor | Radeon Instinct | Tesla Maxwell |

| Successor | Not recorded | Tesla Volta |

| Launch MSRP | Not recorded | 4,599 USD |

Where Each One Wins

AMD Instinct MI300X Wins:

  • The MI300X wins the only recorded benchmark, Geekbench OpenCL, with a 300.5% higher score than the P100.
  • It offers vastly superior memory capacity and bandwidth, with 192 GB and 5.32 TB/s versus 12 GB and 549.1 GB/s.
  • Its FP32 compute is 81.72 TFLOPS, more than eight times the P100's 9.526 TFLOPS.
  • The MI300X has a higher texture rate at 2,553.6 GTexel/s compared to 297.7 GTexel/s.
  • The 5 nm process node and higher transistor density (150.4M / mm²) provide a clear architectural advantage.

NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB Wins:

  • The P100 has a lower TDP at 250 W versus 750 W, making it more power-efficient in absolute terms.
  • It supports standard graphics APIs (DirectX 12, OpenGL 4.6, Vulkan 1.3), while the MI300X lists N/A for all.
  • The P100 has ROPs and a pixel rate (127.6 GPixel/s), while the MI300X has none, making the P100 capable of some display-related tasks despite having no outputs.
  • The P100 is a dual-slot card with a single 8-pin connector, which may be easier to integrate into existing systems than the OAM Module format of the MI300X.
  • Its base clock of 1190 MHz is higher than the MI300X's 1000 MHz, though the MI300X boosts higher.
  • The P100's FP16 performance ratio (2:1) means it can process half-precision at twice its FP32 rate, though its absolute FP16 throughput of 19.05 TFLOPS is still far below the MI300X's 81.72 TFLOPS.

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS

SPECIFICATION
Instinct MI300X
Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB
Core Specs
Shading Units
19,456
3,584 -81.6%
Shaders
19,456
3,584 -81.6%
TMUs
1,216
224 -81.6%
ROPs
0
96 +∞%
Compute Units
304
—
SM Count
—
56
Clocks
Base Clock
1000 MHz
1190 MHz
Boost Clock
2100 MHz
1329 MHz
Memory Clock
1300 MHz 5.2 Gbps effective
715 MHz 1430 Mbps effective
Memory
Memory Size
192 GB
12 GB
VRAM (MB)
196,608
12,288 -93.8%
Memory Type
HBM3
HBM2
Memory Bus
8192 bit
3072 bit
Bandwidth
5.32 TB/s
549.1 GB/s
Cache
L1 Cache
16 KB (per CU)
24 KB (per SM)
L2 Cache
16 MB
3 MB
L3 Cache
256 MB
—
Performance
Pixel Rate
0 MPixel/s
127.6 GPixel/s
Texture Rate
2,553.6 GTexel/s
297.7 GTexel/s
FP32 (TFLOPS)
81.72 TFLOPS
9.526 TFLOPS
FP64 (TFLOPS)
40.86 TFLOPS (1:2)
4.763 TFLOPS (1:2)
FP16 (TFLOPS)
81.72 TFLOPS (1:1)
19.05 TFLOPS (2:1)
AI/RT
Matrix Cores
1,216
—
Power
TDP
750 W
250 W
TDP (W)
750
250 -66.7%
Suggested PSU
1150 W
600 W
Power Connectors
None
1x 8-pin
Architecture
Architecture
CDNA 3.0
Pascal
GPU Name
Aqua Vanjaram
GP100
Generation
Instinct (MIx)
Tesla Pascal (Pxx)
Process Size
5 nm
16 nm
Transistors
153,000 million
15,300 million
Die Size
1017 mm²
610 mm²
Foundry
TSMC
TSMC
Density
150.4M / mm²
25.1M / mm²
AMD MCM
MCM
2
—
API Support
DirectX
—
12 (12_1)
OpenGL
—
4.6
Vulkan
—
1.3
OpenCL
3.0
3.0
CUDA
—
6.0
Shader Model
—
6.0
Physical
Slot Width
OAM Module
Dual-slot
Length
—
267 mm 10.5 inches
Outputs
No outputs
No outputs
Bus Interface
PCIe 5.0 x16
PCIe 3.0 x16
Other
Launch Price
—
4,599 USD
Production
—
End-of-life
Predecessor
Radeon Instinct
Tesla Maxwell
Successor
—
Tesla Volta
View Instinct MI300X Details View Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB Details