NVIDIA RTX A4500 Mobile vs NVIDIA Tesla V100 SXM2 16 GB Comparison
NVIDIA RTX A4500 Mobile
Tesla V100 SXM2 16 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: NVIDIA RTX A4500 Mobile vs NVIDIA Tesla V100 SXM2 16 GB
NVIDIA's Tesla V100 SXM2 16 GB and RTX A4500 Mobile represent two distinct eras of GPU design, yet both occupy a similar performance tier in the current benchmark landscape. The data reveals a fascinating split: the older Volta flagship dominates in Vulkan workloads, while the newer Ampere mobile part takes a clear lead in OpenCL. This head-to-head comparison is not a simple generational victory, but a nuanced story of architecture priorities and workload-specific strengths.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The two GPUs split their two benchmark wins exactly evenly, but the margins are anything but symmetrical. In the Geekbench Vulkan test, the Tesla V100 SXM2 16 GB delivers a commanding score of 141336, which is a massive 83.6% higher than the RTX A4500 Mobile's 76960. This is not a marginal victory; it is a near-doubling of performance. The V100's Vulkan result is so strong that it pushes the card's average benchmark score to 114395, placing it in the 95th percentile of all GPUs. This suggests that the Volta architecture's compute-centric design, with its dedicated tensor cores and high-bandwidth HBM2 memory, translates exceptionally well to Vulkan's low-level API, which can expose raw hardware capabilities more directly.
Conversely, the RTX A4500 Mobile wins the Geekbench OpenCL test decisively, scoring 105307 against the V100's 87454. That is a 17% advantage for the Ampere part. The A4500 Mobile's OpenCL score is a significant contributor to its own average benchmark score of 91134, though this average is dragged down considerably by its Vulkan result, landing it in the 93rd percentile of all GPUs. The delta between the two cards in OpenCL is far smaller than the delta in Vulkan, indicating that the V100's weakness is not a general lack of compute power, but rather a specific inefficiency in this particular API workload. The A4500 Mobile's 17% OpenCL lead is substantial, but it pales in comparison to the V100's 83.6% Vulkan blowout.
When looking at the aggregate average benchmark scores, the V100 has the higher overall number at 114395, but this is almost entirely due to its exceptional Vulkan performance. The A4500 Mobile's average of 91134 is lower, but its two scores are more consistent with each other. The nearest rival data for the V100 shows it is 0.4% ahead of the NVIDIA RTX A5500 Mobile (113944) and 2.3% behind the RTX 4000 SFF Ada Generation (117088), suggesting it sits in a tight competitive cluster. The A4500 Mobile, by contrast, is 0.6% behind the desktop RTX A4500 (91671) and 4.2% ahead of the Quadro GP100 (87445), indicating a slightly more spread-out field at its performance level.
Where Each One Wins
The benchmark results paint a clear picture of distinct use-case advantages. The NVIDIA Tesla V100 SXM2 16 GB is the unequivocal winner for Vulkan-based workloads. The 83.6% lead over the A4500 Mobile in this test is the single largest performance gap in the entire comparison, making it the obvious choice for any application that leverages Vulkan for rendering or compute. This could include professional visualization tools, game engines, or scientific computing frameworks that have optimized for Vulkan's explicit control over GPU resources. The V100's 141336 Vulkan score is its standout feature, and it is what boosts it above its rivals in the average benchmark ranking.
The NVIDIA RTX A4500 Mobile wins in OpenCL, a more widely used and established compute API. A 17% lead in this test is significant for professional applications like video encoding, physics simulations, and machine learning inference that rely on OpenCL. The A4500 Mobile's 105307 OpenCL score is its primary strength, and it demonstrates that the Ampere architecture, despite its lower memory bandwidth (512.0 GB/s vs 897.0 GB/s), can outperform the older card in compute tasks where raw memory throughput is not the sole bottleneck. The A4500 Mobile's higher FP32 performance (17.66 TFLOPS vs 15.67 TFLOPS) likely plays a role here, as OpenCL workloads often rely heavily on standard single-precision math.
The wins are split, but they are not equal in magnitude. The V100's Vulkan victory is so dominant that it makes the card a specialist tool for that API. The A4500 Mobile's OpenCL win is more moderate, but it is combined with a much stronger Vulkan showing relative to its own average, making it a more balanced performer overall. The data suggests that if a user's primary workload is Vulkan, the V100 is clearly superior. If the workload is OpenCL or a mix of APIs, the A4500 Mobile is the safer, more consistent choice.
Architecture Differences
The two GPUs are built on fundamentally different architectures, which explains their divergent benchmark behavior. The Tesla V100 uses the GV100 chip, based on the Volta architecture, fabricated on a 12 nm process at TSMC. This is a massive chip, with 21,100 million transistors on an 815 mm² die. The A4500 Mobile uses the GA104 chip, based on the Ampere architecture, built on Samsung's 8 nm process. It has 17,400 million transistors on a much smaller 392 mm² die. The transistor density tells the story of process advancement: the V100 has 25.9 million transistors per mm², while the A4500 Mobile packs 44.4 million transistors per mm².
This architectural divergence leads to different resource allocations. The V100 has 640 tensor cores, which are dedicated to AI and deep learning workloads. The A4500 Mobile has 184 tensor cores, but it also introduces 46 RT cores for real-time ray tracing, a feature the Volta card lacks entirely. The V100 has more TMUs (320 vs 184) and ROPs (128 vs 96), but the A4500 Mobile has more shading units (5888 vs 5120). The memory subsystems are also radically different: the V100 uses HBM2 with a 4096-bit bus and 897.0 GB/s bandwidth, while the A4500 Mobile uses GDDR6 with a 256-bit bus and 512.0 GB/s bandwidth. The V100's memory bandwidth advantage is enormous, but the A4500 Mobile's GDDR6 operates at a much higher effective clock speed (16 Gbps vs 1752 Mbps).
The FP16 compute capabilities highlight a key philosophical difference. The V100's FP16 performance of 31.33 TFLOPS is listed as "2:1" relative to FP32, meaning it leverages its tensor cores for accelerated half-precision math. The A4500 Mobile's FP16 performance is 17.66 TFLOPS, listed as "1:1" with FP32. This means the Ampere card does not have a dedicated FP16 boost; it processes half-precision at the same rate as full precision. For workloads that can utilize FP16, the V100 has a theoretical 77% advantage over the A4500 Mobile.
Specification Differences
The two cards differ significantly in several key specifications, beyond just their architecture and memory type. The V100 has a higher base clock of 1312 MHz compared to the A4500 Mobile's 930 MHz, though their boost clocks are closer (1530 MHz vs 1500 MHz). The V100 also has a significantly higher TDP of 250 W, while the A4500 Mobile is rated at 140 W. This makes the A4500 Mobile far more power-efficient, a critical factor for a mobile part.
The bus interface is another differentiator: the V100 uses PCIe 3.0 x16, while the A4500 Mobile uses the newer PCIe 4.0 x16, offering double the theoretical bandwidth for data transfer to the host system. The V100 is an SXM Module with no display outputs, while the A4500 Mobile has portable device-dependent outputs. The V100's pixel rate is 195.8 GPixel/s versus 144.0 GPixel/s for the A4500 Mobile, and its texture rate is 489.6 GTexel/s versus 276.0 GTexel/s. The A4500 Mobile supports DirectX 12 Ultimate (12_2), while the V100 only supports DirectX 12 (12_1), indicating the Ampere card has more modern feature support for gaming and real-time graphics. The V100 was released in mid-2017, while the A4500 Mobile came in early 2022. Both are end-of-life products, with the V100's predecessor being Tesla Pascal and its successor Tesla Turing, while the A4500 Mobile's predecessor is Quadro Turing-M and its successor is Ada-MW.
FAQ
Q: Which GPU has the higher average benchmark score?
A: The NVIDIA Tesla V100 SXM2 16 GB has a higher average benchmark score of 114395, compared to the NVIDIA RTX A4500 Mobile's 91134. The V100 also sits in the 95th percentile of all GPUs, while the A4500 Mobile is in the 93rd percentile.
Q: How large is the Vulkan performance gap between the two cards?
A: The Tesla V100 SXM2 16 GB scores 141336 in Geekbench Vulkan, which is 83.6% higher than the RTX A4500 Mobile's 76960. This is the largest single-test margin in the comparison.
Q: Does the RTX A4500 Mobile have any significant advantage over the V100?
A: Yes, in Geekbench OpenCL, the RTX A4500 Mobile scores 105307, which is 17% higher than the V100's 87454. The A4500 Mobile also has a much lower TDP of 140 W versus the V100's 250 W.
Q: What are the differences in memory bandwidth?
A: The Tesla V100 SXM2 16 GB has a memory bandwidth of 897.0 GB/s using HBM2 on a 4096-bit bus. The RTX A4500 Mobile has 512.0 GB/s using GDDR6 on a 256-bit bus.
Q: Which card has more Tensor Cores?
A: The Tesla V100 SXM2 16 GB has 640 Tensor Cores. The RTX A4500 Mobile has 184 Tensor Cores, but it also has 46 RT Cores, which are absent on the V100.
Q: Is the RTX A4500 Mobile faster in FP32 compute?
A: Yes, the RTX A4500 Mobile achieves 17.66 TFLOPS in FP32, while the Tesla V100 SXM2 16 GB achieves 15.67 TFLOPS. However, in FP16, the V100 is far ahead at 31.33 TFLOPS versus the A4500 Mobile's 17.66 TFLOPS.
The Verdict
The data presents a clear, albeit unconventional, verdict. For users whose primary workloads are built on the Vulkan API, the NVIDIA Tesla V100 SXM2 16 GB is the definitive choice. Its 83.6% performance advantage in that benchmark is overwhelming, and its higher average score and 95th percentile ranking confirm its elite status in that specific domain. The V100's massive 897.0 GB/s memory bandwidth and dedicated FP16 acceleration make it a specialized compute monster, particularly suited for high-performance computing and AI inference tasks that can exploit Vulkan.
For anyone needing a more balanced, efficient, and modern mobile GPU, the NVIDIA RTX A4500 Mobile is the better pick. Its 17% OpenCL lead is substantial, and its lower 140 W TDP makes it far more practical for a laptop form factor. The A4500 Mobile's support for DirectX 12 Ultimate, RT cores, and PCIe 4.0 gives it a feature-set advantage that the older V100 cannot match. Its performance is more consistent across the two tested APIs, even if its peak Vulkan score is far lower. The A4500 Mobile is the more versatile and forward-looking option, while the V100 is a specialized tool with a single, dominant strength.