NVIDIA GeForce GTX 580M vs NVIDIA RTX PRO 5000 72 GB Blackwell Comparison
NVIDIA GeForce GTX 580M
RTX PRO 5000 72 GB Blackwell
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 580M vs NVIDIA RTX PRO 5000 72 GB Blackwell
The NVIDIA RTX PRO 5000 72 GB Blackwell and the NVIDIA GeForce GTX 580M represent two extremes of the GPU timeline, separated by over a decade of architectural evolution. The data shows a stark contrast: the RTX PRO 5000 is an active, current-generation workstation part built on Blackwell 2.0, while the GTX 580M is an end-of-life mobile chip from the Fermi 2.0 era. Their average benchmark scores, however, tell a curious story of database normalization, placing them within 0.3% of each other in aggregate metrics, despite their vast differences in raw specifications and intended workloads.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The direct benchmark comparison is complicated by the fact that the two cards share no common test entries in the head-to-head data. The GTX 580M’s sole recorded benchmark is a Geekbench OpenCL score of 6389, while the RTX PRO 5000’s results span multiple PassMark and 3DMark tests. The database’s average benchmark score for the RTX PRO 5000 is 6407, which is a mere 0.3% higher than the GTX 580M’s 6389 average. This near-parity in aggregate scoring is the primary data point linking the two, but it masks the qualitative gulf between them.
Looking at the RTX PRO 5000’s individual results, it demonstrates overwhelming superiority in modern graphics workloads. In 3DMark Steel Nomad DX12, it scores 9579.5, a figure that dwarfs the GTX 580M’s capability in any comparable test—though the GTX 580M has no direct DX12 benchmark entry, its architecture only supports DirectX 12 (11_0), indicating a lack of full feature support. The PassMark G3D score of 24310 for the RTX PRO 5000 further illustrates its dominance in contemporary rendering tasks, while the GTX 580M’s absence from this test highlights its obsolescence in such measures.
The RTX PRO 5000 also shows substantial compute prowess with a PassMark GPU Compute score of 15667, versus the GTX 580M’s 6389 in OpenCL. This represents a 145% advantage in raw compute throughput, reflecting the RTX PRO 5000’s 66.94 TFLOPS FP32 performance against the GTX 580M’s 952.3 GFLOPS. In legacy DirectX tests, the RTX PRO 5000 scores 311 in PassMark DirectX 9 and 219 in DirectX 11, while the GTX 580M has no corresponding entries, suggesting the older card’s driver support and benchmark compatibility have lapsed.
The nearestRivals data places both cards in a similar percentile bracket—both at the 37th percentile of all GPUs—which explains their close average scores. However, this percentile ranking is misleading when viewed in isolation. The GTX 580M’s nearest rival is the NVIDIA GeForce GTX 460 SE with a delta of 0%, while the RTX PRO 5000’s closest competitor is the GTX 460 SE at 0.3% and the GTX 580M itself at 0.3%. This clustering indicates that the database’s average score metric is heavily influenced by the limited benchmark set for the older card, not by actual performance parity.
The Verdict
From the data, the RTX PRO 5000 72 GB Blackwell is the clear choice for any modern workload involving DirectX 12 Ultimate, ray tracing, or high-end compute. Its 3DMark Steel Nomad score of 9579.5 demonstrates capability in current-generation gaming and professional visualization that the GTX 580M cannot approach, as the latter lacks RT cores and tensor cores entirely. The RTX PRO 5000’s 72 GB of GDDR7 memory with 1.34 TB/s bandwidth versus the GTX 580M’s 2 GB GDDR5 at 96 GB/s makes the older card unusable for large datasets or high-resolution textures.
The GTX 580M, however, holds a niche in the database’s aggregate scoring due to its single Geekbench OpenCL result of 6389, which is statistically indistinguishable from the RTX PRO 5000’s 6407 average. This does not mean the cards perform equally; rather, it reflects the GTX 580M’s lack of diverse benchmark data, inflating its relative standing. For legacy application compatibility, the GTX 580M supports OpenGL 4.6, matching the RTX PRO 5000, but it lacks Vulkan support entirely, whereas the RTX PRO 5000 supports Vulkan 1.4.
The verdict is unambiguous: the RTX PRO 5000 is the superior hardware by every objective specification and modern benchmark metric. The GTX 580M’s only advantage is its lower 100 W TDP versus 300 W, making it more power-efficient on paper, but this is irrelevant given its lack of performance. The data does not support any scenario where the GTX 580M outperforms the RTX PRO 5000 in a meaningful task.
Where Each One Wins
The RTX PRO 5000 wins decisively in all compute and rendering benchmarks present in the FACT PACK. Its PassMark G3D score of 24310 and GPU Compute score of 15667 are the standout figures, indicating dominance in both graphics and general-purpose compute. The 3DMark Steel Nomad result of 9579.5 confirms its strength in DX12 workloads, which is expected given its DirectX 12 Ultimate (12_2) support versus the GTX 580M’s limited DirectX 12 (11_0). The RTX PRO 5000 also wins on memory capacity and bandwidth by factors of 36x and 14x respectively, making it the only viable option for large-scale data processing.
The GTX 580M’s sole benchmark win, if it can be called that, is its Geekbench OpenCL score of 6389, which is the only data point keeping its average score competitive. This does not represent a real-world win but rather a statistical artifact of the database’s limited test coverage for this card. In terms of physical attributes, the GTX 580M’s MXM Module form factor and lack of power connectors make it suitable for older portable devices, whereas the RTX PRO 5000 requires a dual-slot PCIe 5.0 x16 slot and a 16-pin connector. For users maintaining legacy laptops, the GTX 580M is the only option, but this is a compatibility win, not a performance one.
FAQ
Q: Which card has a higher average benchmark score?
A: The NVIDIA RTX PRO 5000 72 GB Blackwell has an average benchmark score of 6407, which is 0.3% higher than the NVIDIA GeForce GTX 580M’s 6389.
Q: Does the GTX 580M support ray tracing or tensor cores?
A: No, the GTX 580M has null values for both RT cores and tensor cores, while the RTX PRO 5000 has 110 RT cores and 440 tensor cores.
Q: What is the memory configuration difference?
A: The RTX PRO 5000 features 72 GB of GDDR7 memory on a 384-bit bus with 1.34 TB/s bandwidth, while the GTX 580M has 2 GB of GDDR5 on a 256-bit bus with 96.00 GB/s bandwidth.
Q: Are these cards in the same performance percentile?
A: Yes, both are at the 37th percentile of all GPUs, despite their vastly different specifications and release dates.
Q: Which card has better API support?
A: The RTX PRO 5000 supports DirectX 12 Ultimate (12_2), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.4, whereas the GTX 580M supports DirectX 12 (11_0) and OpenGL 4.6 but has no Vulkan support.
Q: What is the production status of each card?
A: The RTX PRO 5000 is listed as "Active" with a release date of 2025-10-20, while the GTX 580M is "End-of-life" with a release date of 2011-06-27.
Architecture Differences
The architectural gap between the two GPUs is profound. The RTX PRO 5000 uses the GB202 chip built on a 5 nm process at TSMC, containing 92,200 million transistors on a 750 mm² die, yielding a transistor density of 122.9 million per mm². In contrast, the GTX 580M uses the GF114 chip on a 40 nm process, with 1,950 million transistors on a 332 mm² die, giving a density of 5.9 million per mm². This represents a 47x increase in transistor count and a 20x increase in density, enabling the RTX PRO 5000’s massive compute resources.
The RTX PRO 5000 features 14,080 shading units, 440 TMUs, and 160 ROPs, alongside 110 RT cores and 440 tensor cores. The GTX 580M has 384 shading units, 64 TMUs, and 32 ROPs, with no RT or tensor cores. This translates to pixel rates of 380.3 GPixel/s and texture rates of 1,045.9 GTexel/s for the RTX PRO 5000, versus 9.920 GPixel/s and 39.68 GTexel/s for the GTX 580M. The FP32 compute is 66.94 TFLOPS for the RTX PRO 5000, with FP16 at a 1:1 ratio, while the GTX 580M manages 952.3 GFLOPS with no FP16 capability listed.
Clock speeds differ significantly: the RTX PRO 5000 runs at a base of 1740 MHz and boost of 2377 MHz, with memory at 1750 MHz (28 Gbps effective). The GTX 580M has no base or boost clock listed, only a memory clock of 750 MHz (3 Gbps effective). The RTX PRO 5000’s memory bandwidth of 1.34 TB/s is 14x higher than the GTX 580M’s 96 GB/s. Power consumption is 300 W for the RTX PRO 5000 with a 700 W suggested PSU, versus 100 W for the GTX 580M with no PSU recommendation. The RTX PRO 5000 is a dual-slot PCIe 5.0 x16 card with 4x DisplayPort 2.1b outputs, while the GTX 580M is an MXM Module with MXM-B (3.0) interface and portable-device-dependent outputs. The production statuses reflect their eras: the RTX PRO 5000 is active with a 2025 release, while the GTX 580M is end-of-life from 2011.