NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB vs NVIDIA Quadro M4000M Comparison
NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB
Quadro M4000M
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB vs NVIDIA Quadro M4000M
The NVIDIA Quadro M4000M and the NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB represent two distinct philosophies from the same manufacturer: one aimed at professional workflows, the other at consumer gaming. The benchmark data reveals a fascinating split, where the older Maxwell-based professional card wins in one modern API test, while the newer Pascal-based consumer card dominates in another. This head-to-head comparison is not a clean sweep for either side, forcing a nuanced look at what each GPU prioritizes.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The two available benchmark results show a clear division of labor. In the Geekbench OpenCL test, the GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB delivers a decisive victory, scoring 27001 compared to the Quadro M4000M's 19989. This represents a 26% advantage for the GTX 1060, a substantial margin that highlights the raw compute power of the Pascal architecture. The GTX 1060's higher shading unit count and significantly higher clock speeds contribute to this lead, making it the clear choice for compute-heavy OpenCL workloads.
However, the tables turn completely in the Geekbench Vulkan test. Here, the Quadro M4000M scores 20971, while the GTX 1060 3 GB trails at 17475. This is a 20% win for the Quadro, a surprising result given the GTX 1060's newer architecture. The Quadro's victory in Vulkan is particularly noteworthy because it suggests that the professional card's driver optimizations or memory subsystem design—featuring a 256-bit bus and 4 GB of VRAM—provide tangible benefits in this low-level graphics API, even against a faster chip on paper.
The overall average benchmark scores tell a similar story of close competition. The Quadro M4000M has an average benchmark score of 20480, while the GTX 1060 3 GB sits at 19334. This puts the Quadro slightly ahead, a delta of about 5.9%. Yet, the percentile rankings are nearly identical, with the Quadro in the 65th percentile and the GTX 1060 in the 64th percentile of all GPUs. The data suggests that while the GTX 1060 has a higher peak in OpenCL, the Quadro is more consistent across the test suite, leading to a higher aggregate score.
FAQ
Q: Which GPU has the higher average benchmark score?
A: The NVIDIA Quadro M4000M has a higher average benchmark score of 20480, compared to the GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB's 19334. This places the Quadro in the 65th percentile, slightly above the GTX 1060's 64th percentile.
Q: How does the GTX 1060 perform in OpenCL compared to the Quadro?
A: The GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB is significantly faster in OpenCL, scoring 27001 against the Quadro's 19989. This translates to a 26% performance advantage for the GTX 1060 in this specific compute workload.
Q: Is there any test where the Quadro M4000M wins?
A: Yes, the Quadro M4000M wins the Geekbench Vulkan test decisively. It scores 20971, while the GTX 1060 3 GB scores 17475, giving the Quadro a 20% lead in this API.
Q: How close are these GPUs in overall performance?
A: Based on the average benchmark scores, they are quite close. The Quadro's average score is 20480, and the GTX 1060's is 19334. The nearest rival data shows the Quadro is only 0.3% behind the RTX 3070 Mobile and 0.9% behind the R9 M390X, while the GTX 1060 is 0.8% ahead of the TITAN Xp.
Q: What is the transistor density difference between the two chips?
A: The GTX 1060's GP106 chip has a much higher transistor density at 22.0M / mm². The Quadro's GM204 chip has a density of 13.1M / mm², despite having more total transistors (5,200 million vs 4,400 million).
Q: Which GPU was released later?
A: The NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB was released on 2016-08-17, exactly one year after the Quadro M4000M, which was released on 2015-08-17.
Where Each One Wins
The GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB is the clear winner for raw compute performance in OpenCL. Its 26% lead in this test indicates that for applications leveraging OpenCL for general-purpose computing, rendering, or physics simulation, the GTX 1060 is the superior choice. The card's higher FP32 performance of 3.935 TFLOPS, compared to the Quadro's 2.593 TFLOPS, reinforces this position. The GTX 1060 also has a higher pixel rate (81.98 GPixel/s vs 64.83 GPixel/s) and texture rate (123.0 GTexel/s vs 81.04 GTexel/s), making it better suited for rasterization-heavy tasks.
Conversely, the Quadro M4000M wins in the Vulkan API, a modern low-level graphics standard. This win is particularly significant for professional applications that have adopted Vulkan for visualization or CAD work. The Quadro's 4 GB of VRAM, compared to the GTX 1060's 3 GB, could also be a deciding factor in workloads with larger texture sets or data buffers, even if the GTX 1060's memory bandwidth is slightly higher (192.2 GB/s vs 160.4 GB/s). Its higher average benchmark score also suggests it may be a more balanced performer across a wider variety of tasks.
Specification Differences
The two GPUs differ substantially in their core specifications. The GTX 1060 3 GB has a higher base clock of 1506 MHz and a boost clock of 1708 MHz, compared to the Quadro's 975 MHz base and 1013 MHz boost. Memory configurations also diverge: the Quadro offers 4 GB of GDDR5 on a 256-bit bus with 160.4 GB/s bandwidth, while the GTX 1060 provides 3 GB on a 192-bit bus with higher bandwidth of 192.2 GB/s. The GTX 1060 features more shading units (1152 vs 1280) and TMUs (72 vs 80), but fewer ROPs (48 vs 64). The GTX 1060's FP32 performance is significantly higher at 3.935 TFLOPS versus 2.593 TFLOPS, and its FP16 performance is 61.49 GFLOPS (1:64). The TDP also differs, with the GTX 1060 rated at 120 W and the Quadro at 100 W, reflecting the GTX 1060's higher clocks.
Architecture Differences
The fundamental architecture gap is the defining difference. The Quadro M4000M is built on NVIDIA's Maxwell 2.0 architecture, using the GM204 chip fabricated on a 28 nm process at TSMC. The GTX 1060 3 GB utilizes the newer Pascal architecture with the GP106 chip on a more advanced 16 nm process. This process shrink allows for a significantly smaller die size (200 mm² vs 398 mm²) and higher transistor density (22.0M / mm² vs 13.1M / mm²). Despite having fewer total transistors (4,400 million vs 5,200 million), the GTX 1060 achieves higher performance due to architectural improvements and clock speeds. The GTX 1060 also has a predecessor of "GeForce 900" and a successor of "GeForce 20", while the Quadro's lineage is "Quadro Kepler-M" to "Quadro Pascal-M".
The Verdict
The data presents a clear choice based on workload priorities. For users whose primary applications rely on OpenCL compute, the GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB is the definitive choice. Its 26% lead in that benchmark, combined with higher pixel and texture rates, makes it the more powerful raw compute engine. The GTX 1060's higher clocks and FP32 throughput are undeniable advantages in these scenarios.
Conversely, the Quadro M4000M is the better option for Vulkan-based workloads, where it leads by 20%. Its larger memory pool of 4 GB, while having lower bandwidth, offers more capacity for professional datasets. Its higher average benchmark score and slightly better percentile ranking also indicate more consistent performance across the tested APIs. The Quadro's lower TDP of 100 W and MXM module form factor also make it a more suitable choice for certain mobile workstation environments. Ultimately, the choice hinges on whether the priority is OpenCL compute (GTX 1060) or Vulkan graphics and memory capacity (Quadro M4000M).