AMD Radeon R5 Graphics vs AMD Radeon R5 M420 Comparison
AMD Radeon R5 Graphics
Radeon R5 M420
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Radeon R5 Graphics vs AMD Radeon R5 M420
The AMD Radeon R5 M420 and the AMD Radeon R5 Graphics are both end-of-life integrated-class parts from AMD, but they represent fundamentally different approaches to mobile graphics. The data shows a clear performance hierarchy, with the Radeon R5 Graphics holding a significant lead in the only shared benchmark, despite both parts occupying the same 23rd percentile among all GPUs. This analysis will dissect their architectural and specification differences to determine which is better suited for specific tasks.
The Verdict
Based strictly on the benchmark results, the AMD Radeon R5 Graphics is the superior choice for raw compute performance. In the Geekbench OpenCL test, it scores 5183, which is 23.7% higher than the M420's score of 3956. This is a substantial margin that indicates a real-world advantage in any workload that leverages general-purpose GPU compute, such as video encoding or image processing. The M420's only consolation is that its average score of 3956 places it in a dead heat with the NVIDIA GeForce 830M (3957), while the R5 Graphics’ average of 3883 is actually slightly lower than its OpenCL score, suggesting some inconsistency or that its Vulkan score of 2582 drags down its average.
However, the verdict is not a simple coronation. The M420 has a distinct advantage in memory configuration, featuring dedicated 4 GB of DDR3 with a 64-bit bus and a fixed 16.00 GB/s bandwidth. The R5 Graphics relies entirely on System Shared memory, making its performance highly dependent on the host system's RAM speed and architecture. For a user with a system that has slow or poorly configured memory, the R5 Graphics' advantage could shrink.
Therefore, the choice depends on the use case. For users who need consistent, predictable frame buffer performance in a system where the CPU's memory bandwidth is a bottleneck, the M420's dedicated memory is a safer bet. For users who want the highest possible raw compute throughput and have a system with fast dual-channel memory, the R5 Graphics is the clear winner. The data implies that the R5 Graphics is the more capable compute part, while the M420 is the more self-contained graphics solution.
Architecture Differences
The two GPUs come from different generations of AMD's Graphics Core Next (GCN) architecture, which explains their divergent performance characteristics. The Radeon R5 M420 is built on the Jet chip using the older GCN 1.0 architecture, produced on a 28 nm process at TSMC. In contrast, the Radeon R5 Graphics uses the Spectre SL chip with the more refined GCN 2.0 architecture, also on a 28 nm process but fabricated by GlobalFoundries. This generational leap is significant, as GCN 2.0 introduced architectural refinements that improve compute efficiency.
The chip sizes and transistor counts tell a compelling story. The M420's Jet chip is a small, efficient design with 690 million transistors on a 56 mm² die, yielding a high transistor density of 12.3M / mm². The R5 Graphics' Spectre SL chip is a much larger, monolithic die, housing 2,410 million transistors across 245 mm², with a lower density of 9.8M / mm². This massive difference in scale suggests the R5 Graphics is not just a GPU, but likely an APU die that also contains CPU cores, which explains its larger size and higher transistor count.
The memory subsystem is a major architectural divergence. The M420 is a discrete-style IGP with its own dedicated 4 GB DDR3 memory pool, a 64-bit bus, and a fixed bandwidth of 16.00 GB/s. The R5 Graphics, as a true integrated processor, has no dedicated VRAM; it uses System Shared memory with a bandwidth that is System Dependent. This fundamental difference means the M420's performance is stable, while the R5 Graphics' performance is at the mercy of the host system's memory. Both support DirectX 12, though the M420 is at feature level 11_1 while the R5 Graphics supports 12_0, and both support OpenGL 4.6 and Vulkan 1.2.170.
FAQ
Q: Which GPU has a higher raw compute performance in OpenCL?
A: The AMD Radeon R5 Graphics is significantly faster, scoring 5183 in Geekbench OpenCL compared to the Radeon R5 M420's 3956, a 23.7% lead.
Q: Does the Radeon R5 M420 have any performance advantage over the Radeon R5 Graphics?
A: The M420's primary advantage is not in raw speed but in memory architecture. It has a dedicated 4 GB DDR3 frame buffer with a fixed 16.00 GB/s bandwidth, whereas the R5 Graphics relies on System Shared memory, making its performance dependent on the host system.
Q: What are the architectural generations of these two GPUs?
A: The Radeon R5 M420 is based on the older GCN 1.0 architecture, while the Radeon R5 Graphics uses the newer GCN 2.0 architecture. The R5 Graphics is also part of a larger chip, with 2,410 million transistors compared to the M420's 690 million.
Q: How do these GPUs compare to their nearest competitors?
A: The M420's average score of 3956 puts it within 0.1% of the NVIDIA GeForce 830M (3957) and 0.2% behind the NVIDIA Quadro K2000 (3964). The R5 Graphics' average score of 3883 is 1.3% ahead of the NVIDIA GeForce MX110 (3834).
Q: Which GPU has a higher pixel fill rate?
A: The Radeon R5 M420 has a significantly higher pixel rate of 6.800 GPixel/s compared to the Radeon R5 Graphics' 3.032 GPixel/s, despite the latter's higher overall compute score.
Q: What is the power consumption of each GPU?
A: The data shows a TDP of 15 W for the Radeon R5 Graphics. No TDP figure is listed for the Radeon R5 M420.
Specification Differences
The following table details the key specifications where the two GPUs differ, based exclusively on the provided data.
| Specification | AMD Radeon R5 M420 | AMD Radeon R5 Graphics |
| :--- | :--- | :--- |
| Architecture | GCN 1.0 | GCN 2.0 |
| Chip | Jet | Spectre SL |
| Foundry | TSMC | GlobalFoundries |
| Transistors | 690 million | 2,410 million |
| Die Size | 56 mm² | 245 mm² |
| Transistor Density | 12.3M / mm² | 9.8M / mm² |
| Base Clock | 780 MHz | null |
| Boost Clock | 850 MHz | null |
| Memory Clock | 1000 MHz (2 Gbps effective) | System Shared |
| Memory Size | 4 GB | System Shared |
| Memory Type | DDR3 | System Shared |
| Memory Bus Width | 64 bit | System Shared |
| Memory Bandwidth | 16.00 GB/s | System Dependent |
| Shading Units | 320 | 256 |
| TMUs | 20 | 16 |
| ROPs | 8 | 4 |
| Pixel Rate | 6.800 GPixel/s | 3.032 GPixel/s |
| Texture Rate | 17.00 GTexel/s | 12.13 GTexel/s |
| FP32 Performance | 544.0 GFLOPS | 388.1 GFLOPS |
| TDP | null | 15 W |
| Bus Interface | PCIe 3.0 x8 | IGP |
| Display Outputs | Portable Device Dependent | Motherboard Dependent |
| DirectX | 12 (11_1) | 12 (12_0) |
| Release Date | 2016-05-14 | 2014-09-16 |
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The only direct benchmark comparison available is the Geekbench OpenCL test, and it decisively favors the Radeon R5 Graphics. The R5 Graphics scores 5183, while the M420 scores 3956. This is a 23.7% difference, a substantial gap that clearly demonstrates the architectural superiority of the GCN 2.0 design in compute tasks. This single result is the most important data point for understanding the performance relationship between these two GPUs.
The M420, however, does have theoretical advantages in other areas. Its pixel rate of 6.800 GPixel/s is more than double that of the R5 Graphics' 3.032 GPixel/s. Similarly, its texture rate of 17.00 GTexel/s outpaces the R5 Graphics' 12.13 GTexel/s. In terms of raw shader throughput, the M420's FP32 performance of 544.0 GFLOPS is also higher than the R5 Graphics' 388.1 GFLOPS. These figures suggest that the M420 could be quicker at traditional rasterization and pixel-filling tasks, even though it loses in the OpenCL compute benchmark. This is a classic case of a dedicated, smaller GPU with higher clocks and a dedicated memory bus having an edge in fixed-function pipeline work, while a larger, newer architecture with more compute resources wins in general-purpose compute.
The R5 Graphics' win in the OpenCL benchmark is particularly notable given its lower theoretical FP32 rating. This implies that its GCN 2.0 architecture is far more efficient at executing the OpenCL workload than the M420's GCN 1.0 design. The R5 Graphics also has a Geekbench Vulkan score of 2582, a test the M420 does not have a recorded score for, indicating a potential advantage in modern graphics APIs. In the end, the head-to-head data shows a clear split: the R5 Graphics is the compute champion, while the M420 has the theoretical edge in traditional graphics throughput metrics.