AMD Radeon Pro Vega 56 vs AMD Radeon Vega Frontier Edition Comparison
AMD Radeon Pro Vega 56
Radeon Vega Frontier Edition
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Radeon Pro Vega 56 vs AMD Radeon Vega Frontier Edition
AMD Radeon Vega Frontier Edition and AMD Radeon Pro Vega 56 are both 14 nm Vega 10 parts from AMD’s GCN 5.0 architecture, but they target different corners of the pro market. The Frontier Edition is a 300 W dual-slot board with 16 GB of HBM2, while the Pro Vega 56 is a 210 W IGP (integrated graphics processor) design with 8 GB. Benchmark data shows the Frontier Edition winning all three head-to-head tests, with margins ranging from 9% to 22.9%. That gap is consistent with its higher shader count, clocks, and memory bandwidth, though the Pro Vega 56’s lower power draw and slotless form factor make it a distinct option for specific chassis. Below is a breakdown of what the numbers actually mean for a buyer choosing between these two end-of-life cards.
FAQ
Q: Which card has the higher average benchmark score?
A: The AMD Radeon Vega Frontier Edition averages 73370 across all benchmarks, while the AMD Radeon Pro Vega 56 averages 63693. That is a 15.2% difference in the Frontier Edition’s favor, based on the delta between the two averages.
Q: How does the Frontier Edition compare to its nearest rivals?
A: The Frontier Edition’s average score of 73370 places it 1.4% ahead of the AMD Radeon Pro Vega 64 (72379), 1.8% ahead of the NVIDIA TITAN X Pascal (72098), and 2.2% ahead of the AMD Radeon RX 6650M (71768). It ranks in the 91st percentile of all GPUs.
Q: What is the Pro Vega 56’s standing relative to other cards?
A: The Pro Vega 56 sits at the 89th percentile with an average score of 63693. Its closest rival is the AMD Radeon RX 7600M (63775), which edges it out by 0.1%, followed by the AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT LP (63830) at 0.2% ahead and the NVIDIA CMP 30HX (63842) at 0.2% ahead.
Q: In which specific test does the Frontier Edition have its largest win?
A: The biggest margin is in Geekbench OpenCL, where the Frontier Edition scores 76111 versus the Pro Vega 56’s 61930 — a 22.9% advantage. The smallest win is in Geekbench Vulkan, at 9% (71937 vs 66004).
Q: Does the Pro Vega 56 win any benchmark against the Frontier Edition?
A: No. The head-to-head data shows three wins for the Frontier Edition (Geekbench Metal, OpenCL, and Vulkan) and zero wins for the Pro Vega 56. The Pro Vega 56’s only competitive edge is in power consumption and physical design, not raw performance.
Q: Are these cards the same physical size?
A: No. The Frontier Edition is a dual-slot card measuring 267 mm (10.5 inches) in length and 111 mm (4.4 inches) in height, requiring two 8-pin power connectors. The Pro Vega 56 is an IGP with no listed dimensions and no power connectors, meaning it is designed for a different mounting scenario.
Architecture Differences
Both cards use the same Vega 10 chip on a 14 nm process from GlobalFoundries, with 12,500 million transistors on a 495 mm² die and a transistor density of 25.3M per mm². The architecture is GCN 5.0 for both, and they share the same API support: DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3. Neither card has ray tracing cores or tensor cores.
The key architectural split comes down to execution resources. The Frontier Edition has 4096 shading units, 256 texture mapping units, and 64 ROPs. The Pro Vega 56 reduces that to 3584 shading units and 224 TMUs, while keeping 64 ROPs. That is a 12.5% cut in shaders and a 12.5% cut in TMUs, which directly explains the compute throughput differences.
Clock speeds also diverge significantly. The Frontier Edition runs at a 1382 MHz base and 1600 MHz boost. The Pro Vega 56 drops to 1138 MHz base and 1250 MHz boost. That is a 17.7% lower base clock and a 21.9% lower boost clock. Combined with fewer shaders, the Frontier Edition reaches 13.11 TFLOPS FP32 and 26.21 TFLOPS FP16 (2:1), while the Pro Vega 56 manages 8.960 TFLOPS FP32 and 17.92 TFLOPS FP16 (2:1).
Memory configurations differ as well. The Frontier Edition packs 16 GB of HBM2 on a 2048-bit bus, running at 945 MHz (1890 Mbps effective) for 483.8 GB/s of bandwidth. The Pro Vega 56 has 8 GB of HBM2 on the same 2048-bit bus, but at 786 MHz (1572 Mbps effective), yielding 402.4 GB/s. So the Frontier Edition has double the capacity and 20.2% more bandwidth.
Pixel and texture rates follow the same pattern. The Frontier Edition outputs 102.4 GPixel/s and 409.6 GTexel/s. The Pro Vega 56 delivers 80.00 GPixel/s and 280.0 GTexel/s. The pixel rate gap (28% in favor of Frontier) is smaller than the texture rate gap (46.3% in favor), because ROPs are equal but TMUs and clocks differ.
Power delivery is another fundamental difference. The Frontier Edition has a 300 W TDP and requires two 8-pin connectors, with a suggested PSU of 700 W. The Pro Vega 56 has a 210 W TDP and no power connectors, reflecting its IGP design. The Pro Vega 56 also has no listed dimensions, indicating it is not a standard add-in card.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The three Geekbench tests tell a consistent story, but the margins vary by workload. In Geekbench Metal, the Frontier Edition scores 72061 against the Pro Vega 56’s 63145, a 14.1% win. Metal is Apple’s graphics API, and the Frontier Edition’s higher shader count and clocks give it a clear edge in that compute-heavy environment.
Geekbench OpenCL shows the largest divergence. The Frontier Edition hits 76111, while the Pro Vega 56 trails at 61930 — a 22.9% gap. OpenCL is sensitive to raw FP32 throughput and memory bandwidth, both of which favor the Frontier Edition by wide margins. The Pro Vega 56’s 8.960 TFLOPS simply cannot keep pace with 13.11 TFLOPS in this test.
Geekbench Vulkan narrows the gap considerably. The Frontier Edition scores 71937, and the Pro Vega 56 reaches 66004. That is a 9% difference, the smallest of the three. Vulkan’s lower-level overhead appears to let the Pro Vega 56 use its resources more efficiently, but it still loses. The Pro Vega 56’s Vulkan score of 66004 is actually its best result across all three tests, while the Frontier Edition’s Vulkan score (71937) is its weakest.
The overall pattern shows that the Frontier Edition’s advantage grows with compute intensity. In Metal, it leads by 14.1%; in OpenCL, by 22.9%; in Vulkan, by just 9%. This suggests the Pro Vega 56’s memory bandwidth and ROP count keep it competitive in lighter workloads, but the shader and clock deficits become decisive when the GPU is fully saturated.
For context, the Frontier Edition’s average score of 73370 puts it in the 91st percentile, while the Pro Vega 56’s 63693 lands in the 89th. The Frontier Edition’s nearest rival, the AMD Radeon Pro Vega 64, scores 72379 — just 1.4% lower. The Pro Vega 56’s nearest rival, the AMD Radeon RX 7600M, scores 63775, which is 0.1% higher than the Pro Vega 56. So while the two cards are separated by roughly 15% in average score, the Pro Vega 56 is actually slightly below its own closest competitor, whereas the Frontier Edition sits slightly above its nearest rival.
Specification Differences
The two cards share the same chip, process node, foundry, transistor count, die size, transistor density, ROP count, bus interface (PCIe 3.0 x16), and display outputs (1x HDMI 2.0b, 3x DisplayPort 1.4a). They also have identical API support and both use HBM2 memory with a 2048-bit bus.
The differences are as follows:
- Shading Units: Frontier Edition 4096 vs Pro Vega 56 3584
- TMUs: Frontier Edition 256 vs Pro Vega 56 224
- Base Clock: Frontier Edition 1382 MHz vs Pro Vega 56 1138 MHz
- Boost Clock: Frontier Edition 1600 MHz vs Pro Vega 56 1250 MHz
- Memory Clock: Frontier Edition 945 MHz (1890 Mbps effective) vs Pro Vega 56 786 MHz (1572 Mbps effective)
- Memory Size: Frontier Edition 16 GB vs Pro Vega 56 8 GB
- Memory Bandwidth: Frontier Edition 483.8 GB/s vs Pro Vega 56 402.4 GB/s
- Pixel Rate: Frontier Edition 102.4 GPixel/s vs Pro Vega 56 80.00 GPixel/s
- Texture Rate: Frontier Edition 409.6 GTexel/s vs Pro Vega 56 280.0 GTexel/s
- FP32: Frontier Edition 13.11 TFLOPS vs Pro Vega 56 8.960 TFLOPS
- FP16: Frontier Edition 26.21 TFLOPS vs Pro Vega 56 17.92 TFLOPS
- TDP: Frontier Edition 300 W vs Pro Vega 56 210 W
- Slot Width: Frontier Edition Dual-slot vs Pro Vega 56 IGP
- Power Connectors: Frontier Edition 2x 8-pin vs Pro Vega 56 None
- Suggested PSU: Frontier Edition 700 W vs Pro Vega 56 None
- Dimensions: Frontier Edition 267 mm x 111 mm vs Pro Vega 56 Not listed
- Release Date: Frontier Edition 2017-06-26 vs Pro Vega 56 2017-08-13
- Generation: Frontier Edition "Radeon Pro Vega (Vega Series)" vs Pro Vega 56 "Radeon Pro Mac (Vega Series)"
- Launch MSRP: Frontier Edition 999 USD vs Pro Vega 56 None
Where Each One Wins
The Frontier Edition wins every benchmark in the head-to-head comparison, so the performance case is unambiguous. If the task is compute-heavy — OpenCL workloads, FP32 or FP16 processing, or any application that can use 16 GB of HBM2 — the Frontier Edition is the stronger pick. Its 22.9% OpenCL lead and 14.1% Metal lead show that it scales better with demanding shader workloads. The 16 GB memory capacity is also a clear advantage for large datasets or multi-application workflows, doubling the Pro Vega 56’s 8 GB.
The Pro Vega 56’s wins are not in performance but in physical and power characteristics. As an IGP with no power connectors and a 210 W TDP, it fits in systems where a dual-slot, 300 W card with two 8-pin connectors is not an option. The lack of listed dimensions suggests it was designed for a proprietary or compact chassis, making it the only choice if the host system cannot accommodate a standard add-in card. Its 9% Vulkan deficit also shows that in lower-overhead graphics APIs, it stays closer to the Frontier Edition than in compute-heavy tests, so for graphics-only workloads the gap narrows.
For a builder with a standard PC case and a 700 W PSU, the Frontier Edition is the obvious performer. For someone integrating into a Mac-specific or IGP-based system with no external power, the Pro Vega 56 is the only one of the two that physically works. The Pro Vega 56’s 210 W TDP also means less heat and lower system power draw, though no efficiency metric is provided in the data.
The Verdict
The data supports a clear split. If raw performance is the priority, the AMD Radeon Vega Frontier Edition is the choice. It wins all three head-to-head benchmarks, has double the memory (16 GB vs 8 GB), higher bandwidth (483.8 GB/s vs 402.4 GB/s), and significantly more compute throughput (13.11 TFLOPS vs 8.960 TFLOPS FP32). Its average score of 73370 places it in the 91st percentile, and it sits above its nearest rival, the AMD Radeon Pro Vega 64, by 1.4%. The 999 USD launch MSRP reflects that positioning, though both cards are now end-of-life.
The AMD Radeon Pro Vega 56 is for a narrower niche. It does not win a single benchmark and its average score of 63693 puts it below its nearest rival, the AMD Radeon RX 7600M, by 0.1%. However, its IGP form factor, 210 W TDP, and lack of power connectors make it the only viable option for systems that cannot physically support a dual-slot card. Its best result is a 9% loss in Vulkan, showing it can hold its own in graphics-oriented APIs, but it is not a competitor for compute-heavy tasks.
The verdict is straightforward: buyers with a standard PCIe slot and power delivery should take the Frontier Edition for its 14.1% to 22.9% benchmark wins and 16 GB memory buffer. Buyers constrained to an IGP chassis with no external power have only one option, and that is the Pro Vega 56 — but they should expect roughly 15% lower average performance and half the memory capacity. There is no scenario in the data where the Pro Vega 56 outperforms the Frontier Edition, so the decision hinges entirely on physical compatibility and power budget.