AMD Radeon Pro 580X vs NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB Comparison

AMD
RADEON

AMD Radeon Pro 580X

CORE STATE Ellesmere
VRAM 8 GB
CLOCK SPEED 1200 MHz
TDP 185 W
BUS WIDTH 256 bit
ARCHITECTURE GCN 4.0
nm
PROCESS 14 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2019
VS
NVIDIA
GEFORCE

Tesla M40 24 GB

CORE STATE GM200
VRAM 24 GB
CLOCK SPEED 1112 MHz
TDP 250 W
BUS WIDTH 384 bit
ARCHITECTURE Maxwell 2.0
nm
PROCESS 28 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2015

PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS

geekbench_metal
39,577
N/A
geekbench_opencl
36,426
37,439
geekbench_vulkan
40,115
45,975

Analysis: AMD Radeon Pro 580X vs NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB

The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB and AMD Radeon Pro 580X are both end-of-life workstation-adjacent GPUs, but they approach their roles from opposite directions. The Tesla M40 is a dual-slot, 250 W data-center card with no display outputs, built on TSMC’s 28 nm process and the Maxwell 2.0 architecture. The Radeon Pro 580X is a 185 W integrated graphics processor (IGP) for Apple’s MPX bus, built on GlobalFoundries’ 14 nm process with GCN 4.0. Benchmark results place them within 7.8% of each other in average score (41707 vs 38706), yet their architectural and feature-set differences create a clear split in use cases.

Where Each One Wins

The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB wins every head-to-head benchmark in the data: both Geekbench OpenCL and Geekbench Vulkan. Its average benchmark score of 41707 is 7.8% higher than the Radeon Pro 580X’s 38706, and it holds a higher percentile rank among all GPUs (83rd vs 82nd). The M40’s wins are decisive in Vulkan, where it scores 45975 against 40115, a 14.6% margin. In OpenCL, the lead shrinks to 2.8% (37439 vs 36426), but it is still a win.

Where the Radeon Pro 580X wins is in platform integration and connectivity. It is an IGP designed for Apple’s MPX bus, featuring 2x HDMI 2.0b outputs, making it a functional display adapter out of the box. The Tesla M40 has no display outputs, meaning any visual output requires a secondary GPU or a headless compute setup. The Radeon Pro 580X also offers a 1:1 FP16 rate (5.530 TFLOPS), a capability the Tesla M40 lacks entirely (FP16 is null in its spec). For workloads that leverage FP16 compute, the Radeon Pro 580X is the only one of the two with that path.

The use-case split is therefore: the Tesla M40 is the compute-oriented card for Vulkan-heavy or OpenCL-heavy tasks where raw score matters and display output is irrelevant; the Radeon Pro 580X is the integrated solution for Mac Pro systems needing both compute and display output, with FP16 support as a secondary benefit.

Architecture Differences

The most glaring architectural difference is the process node and die size. The Tesla M40 uses TSMC’s 28 nm process with a massive 601 mm² die containing 8,000 million transistors, yielding a transistor density of 13.3M / mm². The Radeon Pro 580X uses GlobalFoundries’ 14 nm process with a 232 mm² die containing 5,700 million transistors, yielding a density of 24.6M / mm² — nearly double the density. This explains the power envelope difference: the M40 draws 250 W, the Radeon Pro 580X draws 185 W, despite the latter having a smaller die.

Core configurations differ substantially. The Tesla M40 has 3072 shading units, 192 TMUs, and 96 ROPs. The Radeon Pro 580X has 2304 shading units, 144 TMUs, and only 32 ROPs. The M40’s ROP count is triple that of the Radeon Pro 580X, which directly explains its much higher pixel rate: 106.8 GPixel/s vs 38.40 GPixel/s. Texture rate also favors the M40 (213.5 GTexel/s vs 172.8 GTexel/s), though the gap is smaller.

Memory subsystems also diverge. The Tesla M40 offers 24 GB of GDDR5 on a 384-bit bus, delivering 288.4 GB/s of bandwidth. The Radeon Pro 580X offers 8 GB of GDDR5 on a 256-bit bus, delivering 218.9 GB/s. The M40 has three times the memory capacity and 31.7% more bandwidth. Clock speeds are higher on the Radeon Pro 580X (base 1100 MHz, boost 1200 MHz vs 948 MHz base, 1112 MHz boost), but the M40’s wider memory bus and larger core compensate.

API support also differs: the Tesla M40 supports DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.4; the Radeon Pro 580X supports DirectX 12 (12_0), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3. The M40 has a higher DirectX feature level and a newer Vulkan version. Neither has ray tracing cores or tensor cores.

Head-to-Head Benchmarks

The two Geekbench tests in the head-to-head data show a consistent but uneven NVIDIA advantage. In Geekbench Vulkan, the Tesla M40 scores 45975 against the Radeon Pro 580X’s 40115, a 14.6% delta. This is the largest single margin in the comparison and suggests the M40’s Maxwell architecture handles Vulkan workloads more efficiently, despite the Radeon Pro 580X having a higher boost clock (1200 MHz vs 1112 MHz). The M40’s 384-bit memory bus and 288.4 GB/s bandwidth likely contribute to this Vulkan lead, as Vulkan workloads often stress memory throughput.

In Geekbench OpenCL, the margin narrows to 2.8%: 37439 for the M40 vs 36426 for the Radeon Pro 580X. This is a modest win, and the data suggests that OpenCL performance is more balanced between the two architectures. Notably, the Radeon Pro 580X also has a Geekbench Metal score of 39577, a test the Tesla M40 does not participate in (Metal is not listed among its APIs). If Metal is a target workload, the Radeon Pro 580X has a dedicated score, while the M40 has no equivalent data point.

Looking at nearest rivals, the Tesla M40’s average score of 41707 places it 1.3% ahead of a GeForce RTX 3080 Ti (41187) and 2% ahead of a Radeon Pro 5300 (40870), but 2.4% behind a Radeon RX 7650 GRE (42723). The Radeon Pro 580X’s average score of 38706 is essentially tied with a GeForce MX570 A (38691, 0% delta) and a GeForce RTX 5080 Mobile (38349, 0.9% delta), and it is 1% ahead of a Radeon Pro 575X (39116, -1% delta). These rival comparisons reinforce that the Tesla M40 competes in a higher performance tier, while the Radeon Pro 580X sits in the mid-range.

FAQ

Q: Which GPU has the higher average benchmark score?

A: The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB, with an average benchmark score of 41707, is 7.8% higher than the AMD Radeon Pro 580X’s 38706.

Q: Does the Tesla M40 win every head-to-head test?

A: Yes. It wins Geekbench OpenCL (37439 vs 36426, +2.8%) and Geekbench Vulkan (45975 vs 40115, +14.6%) for a total of 2 wins against 0 for the Radeon Pro 580X.

Q: What is the largest performance gap between the two?

A: The largest gap is in Geekbench Vulkan, where the Tesla M40 leads by 14.6% (45975 vs 40115).

Q: Can either GPU output video?

A: Only the AMD Radeon Pro 580X has display outputs, listed as 2x HDMI 2.0b. The NVIDIA Tesla M40 has no display outputs.

Q: Which GPU supports FP16 compute?

A: The AMD Radeon Pro 580X supports FP16 at a 1:1 ratio (5.530 TFLOPS). The NVIDIA Tesla M40 has no FP16 specification listed.

Q: How do the memory capacities compare?

A: The NVIDIA Tesla M40 has 24 GB of GDDR5 on a 384-bit bus with 288.4 GB/s bandwidth. The AMD Radeon Pro 580X has 8 GB of GDDR5 on a 256-bit bus with 218.9 GB/s bandwidth.

The Verdict

The data points to a clear choice for compute-heavy, display-less workloads: the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB. It wins both head-to-head benchmarks, offers triple the memory capacity (24 GB vs 8 GB), significantly higher pixel rate (106.8 GPixel/s vs 38.40 GPixel/s), and a higher average score (41707 vs 38706). Its 96 ROPs versus 32 ROPs and 384-bit versus 256-bit memory bus are structural advantages that no clock speed difference can overcome. For Vulkan workloads specifically, the 14.6% lead is decisive.

The AMD Radeon Pro 580X is the pick for systems that need an integrated GPU with display output. Its 2x HDMI 2.0b ports and Apple MPX bus interface make it a drop-in component for Mac Pro systems, a role the Tesla M40 cannot fill due to its lack of outputs. The Radeon Pro 580X also offers FP16 capability at 5.530 TFLOPS, which the M40 lacks entirely, and it does so at a lower power draw (185 W vs 250 W). Its smaller die (232 mm² vs 601 mm²) and newer 14 nm process translate to better transistor density (24.6M / mm² vs 13.3M / mm²), which is relevant for thermal and power-constrained environments.

For raw compute performance, the Tesla M40 is the superior card. For a functional workstation GPU that can drive displays and handle FP16, the Radeon Pro 580X is the only option between the two. The choice hinges entirely on whether display output and FP16 are required, because in every measured compute benchmark, the Tesla M40 wins.

Specification Differences

| Specification | NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB | AMD Radeon Pro 580X |

|---|---|---|

| Architecture | Maxwell 2.0 | GCN 4.0 |

| Process Node | 28 nm | 14 nm |

| Foundry | TSMC | GlobalFoundries |

| Transistors | 8,000 million | 5,700 million |

| Die Size | 601 mm² | 232 mm² |

| Transistor Density | 13.3M / mm² | 24.6M / mm² |

| Base Clock | 948 MHz | 1100 MHz |

| Boost Clock | 1112 MHz | 1200 MHz |

| Memory Clock | 1502 MHz (6 Gbps effective) | 1710 MHz (6.8 Gbps effective) |

| Memory Size | 24 GB | 8 GB |

| Memory Bus Width | 384 bit | 256 bit |

| Memory Bandwidth | 288.4 GB/s | 218.9 GB/s |

| Shading Units | 3072 | 2304 |

| TMUs | 192 | 144 |

| ROPs | 96 | 32 |

| Pixel Rate | 106.8 GPixel/s | 38.40 GPixel/s |

| Texture Rate | 213.5 GTexel/s | 172.8 GTexel/s |

| FP32 | 6.832 TFLOPS | 5.530 TFLOPS |

| FP16 | null | 5.530 TFLOPS (1:1) |

| TDP | 250 W | 185 W |

| Slot Width | Dual-slot | IGP |

| Power Connectors | 8-pin EPS | null |

| Suggested PSU | 600 W | null |

| Bus Interface | PCIe 3.0 x16 | Apple MPX |

| Display Outputs | No outputs | 2x HDMI 2.0b |

| DirectX | 12 (12_1) | 12 (12_0) |

| OpenGL | 4.6 | 4.6 |

| Vulkan | 1.4 | 1.3 |

| Dimensions | 267 mm (10.5 inches) | null |

| Release Date | 2015-11-09 | 2019-03-17 |

| Predecessor | Tesla Kepler | null |

| Successor | Tesla Pascal | null |

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS

SPECIFICATION
Pro 580X
Tesla M40 24 GB
Core Specs
Shading Units
2,304
3,072 +33.3%
Shaders
2,304
3,072 +33.3%
TMUs
144
192 +33.3%
ROPs
32
96 +200.0%
Compute Units
36
—
Clocks
Base Clock
1100 MHz
948 MHz
Boost Clock
1200 MHz
1112 MHz
Memory Clock
1710 MHz 6.8 Gbps effective
1502 MHz 6 Gbps effective
Memory
Memory Size
8 GB
24 GB
VRAM (MB)
8,192
24,576 +200.0%
Memory Type
GDDR5
GDDR5
Memory Bus
256 bit
384 bit
Bandwidth
218.9 GB/s
288.4 GB/s
Cache
L1 Cache
16 KB (per CU)
48 KB (per SMM)
L2 Cache
2 MB
3 MB
Performance
Pixel Rate
38.40 GPixel/s
106.8 GPixel/s
Texture Rate
172.8 GTexel/s
213.5 GTexel/s
FP32 (TFLOPS)
5.530 TFLOPS
6.832 TFLOPS
FP64 (TFLOPS)
345.6 GFLOPS (1:16)
213.5 GFLOPS (1:32)
FP16 (TFLOPS)
5.530 TFLOPS (1:1)
—
Power
TDP
185 W
250 W
TDP (W)
185
250 +35.1%
Suggested PSU
—
600 W
Power Connectors
—
8-pin EPS
Architecture
Architecture
GCN 4.0
Maxwell 2.0
GPU Name
Ellesmere
GM200
Generation
Radeon Pro Mac (500X Series)
Tesla Maxwell (Mxx)
Process Size
14 nm
28 nm
Transistors
5,700 million
8,000 million
Die Size
232 mm²
601 mm²
Foundry
GlobalFoundries
TSMC
Density
24.6M / mm²
13.3M / mm²
API Support
DirectX
12 (12_0)
12 (12_1)
OpenGL
4.6
4.6
Vulkan
1.3
1.4
OpenCL
2.1
3.0
CUDA
—
5.2
Shader Model
6.7
6.8
Physical
Slot Width
IGP
Dual-slot
Length
—
267 mm 10.5 inches
Outputs
2x HDMI 2.0b
No outputs
Bus Interface
Apple MPX
PCIe 3.0 x16
Other
Production
End-of-life
End-of-life
Predecessor
—
Tesla Kepler
Successor
—
Tesla Pascal
View Radeon Pro 580X Details View Tesla M40 24 GB Details