AMD Radeon Pro 575 vs NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB Comparison
AMD Radeon Pro 575
Tesla M40 24 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Radeon Pro 575 vs NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB
The data presents a clear performance hierarchy between the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB and the AMD Radeon Pro 575, but the underlying architectures tell a more nuanced story about their respective strengths. The benchmark results, drawn from Geekbench compute tests, show the Tesla M40 leading in both shared workloads, yet the Radeon Pro 575 counters with a significant win in a Metal-specific test that the NVIDIA card cannot even participate in. This split reveals two very different design philosophies aimed at different computing environments.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The two GPUs share two benchmark tests, and in both, the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB emerges victorious. In Geekbench OpenCL, the Tesla M40 scores 37,439 against the Radeon Pro 575’s 34,596, a delta of 8.2%. This is a solid, if not overwhelming, margin that reflects the raw compute throughput differences between the two cards. The Tesla M40’s advantage becomes more pronounced in Geekbench Vulkan, where it scores 45,975 versus 37,878, a 21.4% lead. That is a substantial gap, suggesting the NVIDIA architecture handles Vulkan’s compute and graphics workloads with considerably more efficiency than the AMD part in this specific test.
However, the story does not end there. The AMD Radeon Pro 575 has a third benchmark result that is not shared with the Tesla M40: Geekbench Metal, where it scores 46,192. This is the Radeon Pro 575’s strongest showing, and it is notably higher than the Tesla M40’s Vulkan score. Since the Tesla M40 has no Metal benchmark listed, the head-to-head win count stands at 2-0 in favor of NVIDIA, but that Metal score is a critical piece of context. It indicates that in Apple-centric, Metal-accelerated environments, the Radeon Pro 575 is not just competitive but potentially superior, given that its Metal performance outpaces the NVIDIA card’s best listed result.
When placed against their respective peer groups, both cards hold up well. The Tesla M40’s average benchmark score is 41,707, placing it in the 83rd percentile of all GPUs. Its nearest rival, the NVIDIA Tesla M40 (the non-24GB variant), scores 41,897, a negligible 0.5% difference. The Tesla M40 24 GB also sits just 1.3% above the GeForce RTX 3080 Ti (41,187) and 2% above the Radeon Pro 5300 (40,870), though it trails the Radeon RX 7650 GRE by 2.4% (42,723). Meanwhile, the Radeon Pro 575 averages 39,555, landing in the 82nd percentile. It is essentially tied with the RTX A500 Mobile (39,568, 0% delta), 1.1% ahead of the Radeon Pro 575X (39,116), and trails the Radeon Pro WX 7100 (40,063) and Radeon Pro 580 (40,318) by 1.3% and 1.9%, respectively.
Architecture Differences
The performance delta between these two cards is rooted in starkly different hardware designs. The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB is built on the GM200 chip using the Maxwell 2.0 architecture, fabricated on a 28 nm process at TSMC. This is a massive chip, containing 8,000 million transistors on a 601 mm² die, yielding a transistor density of 13.3 million per mm². The AMD Radeon Pro 575, in contrast, uses the Ellesmere chip with GCN 4.0 architecture, produced on a 14 nm process at GlobalFoundries. It is a much smaller die at 232 mm², holding 5,700 million transistors, which translates to a higher density of 24.6 million per mm². The process node advantage is clear: AMD packed more transistors per area, but NVIDIA used its larger, older-node chip to deploy far more compute resources overall.
The compute resource disparity is significant. The Tesla M40 fields 3,072 shading units, 192 texture mapping units (TMUs), and 96 raster operations units (ROPs). The Radeon Pro 575 counters with 2,048 shading units, 128 TMUs, and just 32 ROPs. This is a 50% advantage in shaders and TMUs for NVIDIA, and a 3x advantage in ROPs. Consequently, the Tesla M40’s pixel rate is 106.8 GPixel/s versus 35.07 GPixel/s for the Radeon Pro 575, and its texture rate is 213.5 GTexel/s versus 140.3 GTexel/s. In raw FP32 compute, the Tesla M40 delivers 6.832 TFLOPS against 4.489 TFLOPS for the AMD card. Notably, the Radeon Pro 575 lists FP16 performance at 4.489 TFLOPS (1:1 ratio), while the Tesla M40 has no FP16 figure listed, implying it may not have dedicated FP16 throughput.
Memory configurations also diverge sharply. The Tesla M40 comes with 24 GB of GDDR5 on a 384-bit bus, providing 288.4 GB/s of bandwidth. The Radeon Pro 575 has only 4 GB of GDDR5 on a 256-bit bus, yielding 217.0 GB/s. The memory clocks differ, with the Tesla M40 running at 1502 MHz (6 Gbps effective) and the Radeon Pro 575 at 1695 MHz (6.8 Gbps effective), but the wider bus on the NVIDIA card more than compensates for its lower clock speed. The Tesla M40 also carries a 250 W TDP and requires dual-slot cooling with an 8-pin EPS connector, while the Radeon Pro 575 is a 150 W MXM module with no power connectors, designed for portable systems.
Where Each One Wins
Based strictly on the benchmark data, the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB wins in OpenCL and Vulkan compute workloads. Its 21.4% Vulkan lead suggests that applications leveraging Vulkan’s low-level API will see substantially better performance on the NVIDIA card. The OpenCL advantage, while smaller at 8.2%, still indicates a consistent edge in general-purpose GPU compute. The Tesla M40’s massive 24 GB memory pool also makes it the obvious choice for workloads that require large datasets to reside in VRAM, such as machine learning inference or rendering scenes with massive texture sets, though this is a qualitative inference from the memory size rather than a tested benchmark.
The AMD Radeon Pro 575 wins in the Metal environment, as evidenced by its 46,192 score. This is its only listed benchmark win, but it is an important one. For users operating within Apple’s ecosystem—where Metal is the primary graphics and compute API—the Radeon Pro 575 appears to be the stronger performer. Its 4 GB memory and 150 W power envelope also make it suitable for portable, power-constrained systems, as indicated by its MXM Module form factor and lack of external power connectors. The Tesla M40, with its 250 W TDP and dual-slot design, has no display outputs, making it a pure compute accelerator for servers, whereas the Radeon Pro 575’s outputs are listed as "Portable Device Dependent," implying it is meant for laptops or all-in-one systems.
The Verdict
The data points to a clear split based on use case. For pure compute performance in OpenCL and Vulkan, the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB is the superior card, delivering 8.2% and 21.4% higher scores, respectively. Its 24 GB memory capacity is a decisive advantage for memory-bound workloads, and its higher pixel and texture rates (106.8 GPixel/s and 213.5 GTexel/s vs. 35.07 and 140.3) make it more capable of handling high-resolution rendering tasks. The Tesla M40 also edges out the Radeon Pro 575 in overall average benchmark score, 41,707 vs. 39,555, and holds a slightly higher percentile ranking at 83 versus 82.
However, the Radeon Pro 575 is not without its merits. Its Metal score of 46,192 is the highest single benchmark result between the two cards, surpassing the Tesla M40’s best score of 45,975 in Vulkan. This suggests that in Metal-accelerated applications, the Radeon Pro 575 would outperform the Tesla M40, despite the latter’s raw compute advantages. The AMD card also does so at a much lower power draw (150 W vs. 250 W) and in a smaller form factor, making it the only viable option for portable systems. For users building a Mac-based workstation, the Radeon Pro 575 is the logical choice. For server-side compute, deep learning, or any Vulkan/OpenCL-centric workload where power and space are not constraints, the Tesla M40 24 GB is the clear winner.
FAQ
Q: Which GPU has the higher average benchmark score?
A: The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB has an average benchmark score of 41,707, while the AMD Radeon Pro 575 averages 39,555.
Q: How much faster is the Tesla M40 in Vulkan?
A: The Tesla M40 scores 45,975 in Geekbench Vulkan, which is 21.4% higher than the Radeon Pro 575’s 37,878.
Q: Does the Radeon Pro 575 win any benchmark tests?
A: Yes, the Radeon Pro 575 scores 46,192 in Geekbench Metal, which is its only listed benchmark win, though the Tesla M40 has no Metal result to compare against.
Q: What is the memory capacity difference?
A: The Tesla M40 has 24 GB of GDDR5 memory on a 384-bit bus, while the Radeon Pro 575 has 4 GB of GDDR5 on a 256-bit bus.
Q: Which card has a higher transistor density?
A: The AMD Radeon Pro 575 has a higher transistor density at 24.6M per mm², compared to the Tesla M40’s 13.3M per mm², due to its smaller 232 mm² die on a 14 nm process versus the Tesla’s 601 mm² die on 28 nm.
Q: Are both cards still in production?
A: No, both the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB and the AMD Radeon Pro 575 are listed as end-of-life products.
Specification Differences
| Specification | NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB | AMD Radeon Pro 575 |
|---|---|---|
| Architecture | Maxwell 2.0 | GCN 4.0 |
| Process Node | 28 nm | 14 nm |
| Foundry | TSMC | GlobalFoundries |
| Transistors | 8,000 million | 5,700 million |
| Die Size | 601 mm² | 232 mm² |
| Transistor Density | 13.3M / mm² | 24.6M / mm² |
| Memory Size | 24 GB | 4 GB |
| Memory Bus Width | 384 bit | 256 bit |
| Memory Bandwidth | 288.4 GB/s | 217.0 GB/s |
| Shading Units | 3072 | 2048 |
| TMUs | 192 | 128 |
| ROPs | 96 | 32 |
| Pixel Rate | 106.8 GPixel/s | 35.07 GPixel/s |
| Texture Rate | 213.5 GTexel/s | 140.3 GTexel/s |
| FP32 Performance | 6.832 TFLOPS | 4.489 TFLOPS |
| FP16 Performance | Not listed | 4.489 TFLOPS (1:1) |
| TDP | 250 W | 150 W |
| Slot Width | Dual-slot | MXM Module |
| Power Connectors | 8-pin EPS | None |
| Display Outputs | No outputs | Portable Device Dependent |
| DirectX Support | 12 (12_1) | 12 (12_0) |
| Vulkan Support | 1.4 | 1.3 |
| Release Date | 2015-11-09 | 2017-06-04 |