AMD Radeon Pro 5300 vs NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB Comparison
AMD Radeon Pro 5300
Tesla M40 24 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Radeon Pro 5300 vs NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB
The data presents a clear split between two very different workstation GPUs. The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB is an older, high-capacity compute card built on a mature 28 nm process, while the AMD Radeon Pro 5300 is a newer, power-sipping part on 7 nm. Their average benchmark scores are close—41,707 for the NVIDIA and 40,870 for the AMD—putting them within 2% of each other overall, but their individual strengths could not be more different. The choice comes down to whether you need massive memory capacity or a more modern, efficient compute architecture.
The Verdict
Pick the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB if your workload demands 24 GB of VRAM. This is the card’s defining feature; the AMD Radeon Pro 5300 offers only 4 GB, a six-fold difference. The data indicates the Tesla wins the Vulkan benchmark decisively, scoring 45,975 against the AMD’s 35,793, a 28.4% advantage. It also sits at the 83rd percentile of all GPUs, one point higher than the AMD’s 82nd. This card is for datasets, models, or scenes that exceed 4 GB and need the extra headroom.
Pick the AMD Radeon Pro 5300 if your priority is compute efficiency and you work within a 4 GB memory budget. It wins the OpenCL benchmark, scoring 38,747 versus the Tesla’s 37,439, a 3.4% margin. It consumes just 85 W compared to the Tesla’s 250 W, requires no external power connectors, and is listed as an IGP (integrated graphics processor) form factor, making it far easier to integrate into compact systems. It also has a much higher boost clock at 1650 MHz versus the Tesla’s 1112 MHz, reflecting its modern design.
Neither card is a universal winner. The Tesla M40 24 GB is the choice for memory-bound tasks, while the Radeon Pro 5300 is the choice for balanced compute in a low-power envelope. Both are end-of-life products, so availability is the primary external factor.
Architecture Differences
The architectural gap is generational. The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB uses the GM200 chip based on Maxwell 2.0 architecture, built on a 28 nm process at TSMC. It packs 8,000 million transistors onto a 601 mm² die, yielding a transistor density of 13.3 million per square millimeter. In contrast, the AMD Radeon Pro 5300 uses the Navi 14 chip based on RDNA 1.0 architecture, also from TSMC but on a 7 nm process. It contains 6,400 million transistors on a much smaller 158 mm² die, achieving a density of 40.5 million per square millimeter—over three times the density of the NVIDIA chip.
The compute resources reflect these different design philosophies. The Tesla M40 24 GB has 3,072 shading units, 192 texture mapping units, and 96 ROPs. The Radeon Pro 5300 has 1,280 shading units, 80 TMUs, and 32 ROPs. Despite having fewer than half the shading units, the AMD card’s higher clocks—1650 MHz boost versus 1112 MHz boost—bring its FP32 throughput to 4.224 TFLOPS, compared to the NVIDIA’s 6.832 TFLOPS. The AMD card also supports FP16 at 8.448 TFLOPS with a 2:1 ratio, a feature the Tesla lacks entirely. The AMD’s memory is GDDR6 running at 14 Gbps effective, while the Tesla uses GDDR5 at 6 Gbps effective. The bus widths differ sharply: 128-bit for the AMD versus 384-bit for the NVIDIA, resulting in 224.0 GB/s bandwidth for the AMD and 288.4 GB/s for the Tesla.
Feature support is similar on paper. Both cards support DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.4. Neither has ray tracing or tensor cores. The critical differences are memory capacity, process node, power, and bus interface. The Tesla uses PCIe 3.0 x16, while the AMD uses PCIe 4.0 x8. The NVIDIA card is dual-slot with an 8-pin EPS connector and requires a 600 W power supply; the AMD card is an IGP with no power connectors and requires only a 250 W PSU.
Where Each One Wins
The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB wins in raw memory throughput and capacity. Its 384-bit bus and 288.4 GB/s bandwidth are superior to the AMD’s 128-bit bus and 224.0 GB/s. If a workload needs to move large datasets around, the Tesla has the advantage. The Vulkan benchmark result confirms this: the Tesla scores 45,975, which is 28.4% higher than the AMD’s 35,793. This suggests the Tesla is better suited for Vulkan-based compute or rendering tasks that can leverage its larger memory pool and wider bus. Its higher pixel rate (106.8 GPixel/s vs 52.80 GPixel/s) and texture rate (213.5 GTexel/s vs 132.0 GTexel/s) also point to stronger rasterization throughput on paper, driven by its 96 ROPs versus 32 ROPs.
The AMD Radeon Pro 5300 wins in efficiency and modern compute features. Its 7 nm process and 85 W TDP make it dramatically more power-efficient than the 250 W Tesla. It wins the OpenCL benchmark, scoring 38,747 versus 37,439, a 3.4% lead. The FP16 capability (8.448 TFLOPS) is a significant advantage for workloads that support mixed-precision math, as it doubles the throughput compared to FP32. Its 1650 MHz boost clock is considerably higher than the Tesla’s 1112 MHz, indicating better clock-for-clock performance. The AMD also has a Metal benchmark score of 48,070, which is notable for macOS environments, though the Tesla has no comparable Metal score in the data.
FAQ
Q: Which card has more VRAM?
A: The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB has 24 GB of GDDR5 memory, while the AMD Radeon Pro 5300 has 4 GB of GDDR6 memory.
Q: Why is the AMD card more power-efficient?
A: The AMD Radeon Pro 5300 has a TDP of 85 W and requires no power connectors, whereas the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB has a TDP of 250 W and needs an 8-pin EPS connector. The AMD’s 7 nm process node contributes to this efficiency.
Q: Which card performs better in Vulkan?
A: The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB performs better, scoring 45,975 in Geekbench Vulkan compared to the AMD Radeon Pro 5300’s 35,793, a 28.4% difference.
Q: Which card performs better in OpenCL?
A: The AMD Radeon Pro 5300 performs better, scoring 38,747 in Geekbench OpenCL versus the NVIDIA’s 37,439, a 3.4% margin.
Q: Do both cards support the same APIs?
A: Yes, both support DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.4.
Q: What are the physical form factor differences?
A: The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB is a dual-slot card measuring 267 mm (10.5 inches) in length, while the AMD Radeon Pro 5300 is listed as an IGP with no dimensions provided.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The two available head-to-head benchmarks show a clean split. In Geekbench OpenCL, the AMD Radeon Pro 5300 takes the win with a score of 38,747, beating the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB’s 37,439 by 3.4%. This is a modest but consistent margin, suggesting the AMD’s newer architecture and higher boost clock (1650 MHz vs 1112 MHz) translate into better compute throughput in this API. The Tesla’s larger shading unit count (3,072 vs 1,280) is not enough to overcome its lower clocks and older Maxwell design in this test.
In Geekbench Vulkan, the tables turn dramatically. The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB scores 45,975, which is 28.4% higher than the AMD’s 35,793. This is a substantial gap, likely driven by the Tesla’s much larger memory bandwidth (288.4 GB/s vs 224.0 GB/s) and its 384-bit bus. Vulkan workloads often stress memory subsystems, and the Tesla’s advantage there is decisive. The AMD card’s 4 GB memory capacity may also be a limiting factor in Vulkan tests that allocate larger buffers.
Looking at the broader benchmark context, the average scores are nearly identical. The Tesla M40 24 GB averages 41,707, while the AMD Radeon Pro 5300 averages 40,870. The Tesla’s nearest rival is the NVIDIA Tesla M40 (non-24GB) at 41,897, a 0.5% difference, and the AMD Radeon Pro 5300 sits at 2% below the Tesla in that comparison. The AMD’s nearest rival is the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3080 Ti at 41,187, which is 0.8% ahead of the AMD, and the AMD Radeon Pro 580 at 40,318, which is 1.4% behind. These figures place both cards in the same performance tier despite their architectural differences.
Specification Differences
The specifications that differ between the two cards are numerous and central to their character.
- Chip and Architecture: NVIDIA uses GM200 with Maxwell 2.0; AMD uses Navi 14 with RDNA 1.0.
- Process Node: NVIDIA is on 28 nm; AMD is on 7 nm.
- Transistors: NVIDIA has 8,000 million; AMD has 6,400 million.
- Die Size: NVIDIA is 601 mm²; AMD is 158 mm².
- Transistor Density: NVIDIA is 13.3M / mm²; AMD is 40.5M / mm².
- Base Clock: NVIDIA is 948 MHz; AMD is 1000 MHz.
- Boost Clock: NVIDIA is 1112 MHz; AMD is 1650 MHz.
- Memory Speed: NVIDIA is 1502 MHz (6 Gbps effective); AMD is 1750 MHz (14 Gbps effective).
- Memory Size: NVIDIA is 24 GB; AMD is 4 GB.
- Memory Type: NVIDIA is GDDR5; AMD is GDDR6.
- Memory Bus Width: NVIDIA is 384 bit; AMD is 128 bit.
- Memory Bandwidth: NVIDIA is 288.4 GB/s; AMD is 224.0 GB/s.
- Shading Units: NVIDIA is 3072; AMD is 1280.
- TMUs: NVIDIA is 192; AMD is 80.
- ROPs: NVIDIA is 96; AMD is 32.
- Pixel Rate: NVIDIA is 106.8 GPixel/s; AMD is 52.80 GPixel/s.
- Texture Rate: NVIDIA is 213.5 GTexel/s; AMD is 132.0 GTexel/s.
- FP32 Performance: NVIDIA is 6.832 TFLOPS; AMD is 4.224 TFLOPS.
- FP16 Performance: NVIDIA has none; AMD is 8.448 TFLOPS (2:1).
- TDP: NVIDIA is 250 W; AMD is 85 W.
- Slot Width: NVIDIA is dual-slot; AMD is IGP.
- Power Connectors: NVIDIA is 8-pin EPS; AMD is none.
- Suggested PSU: NVIDIA is 600 W; AMD is 250 W.
- Bus Interface: NVIDIA is PCIe 3.0 x16; AMD is PCIe 4.0 x8.
- Dimensions: NVIDIA is 267 mm (10.5 inches); AMD has no listed dimensions.
- Release Date: NVIDIA is 2015-11-09; AMD is 2020-08-03.