AMD Radeon HD 8950M vs AMD Radeon Vega 11 Comparison

AMD
RADEON

AMD Radeon HD 8950M

CORE STATE Saturn
VRAM 2 GB
CLOCK SPEED —
TDP 100 W
BUS WIDTH 128 bit
ARCHITECTURE GCN 2.0
nm
PROCESS 28 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2013
VS
AMD
RADEON

Radeon Vega 11

CORE STATE Picasso
VRAM System Shared
CLOCK SPEED 1400 MHz
TDP 15 W
BUS WIDTH System Shared
ARCHITECTURE GCN 5.0
nm
PROCESS 12 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2019

PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS

geekbench_opencl
13,772
13,392
geekbench_vulkan
12,979
12,273
geekbench_metal
N/A
17,392

Analysis: AMD Radeon HD 8950M vs AMD Radeon Vega 11

The AMD Radeon Vega 11 and AMD Radeon HD 8950M are both end-of-life mobile graphics solutions from AMD, but they represent vastly different eras and design philosophies. The Vega 11 is a modern integrated graphics processor (IGP) built on a 12 nm process, while the HD 8950M is a dedicated discrete mobile GPU from an older 28 nm generation. Benchmark data shows a surprisingly close contest, with the HD 8950M edging out the Vega 11 in shared compute workloads, despite the Vega 11's newer architecture and significantly lower power envelope. The data reveals that architectural efficiency can partially offset raw hardware advantages, but dedicated memory and higher thermal headroom still matter in these specific tests.

FAQ

Q: Which GPU has the higher average benchmark score?

A: The AMD Radeon Vega 11 has a higher average benchmark score of 14352, compared to the AMD Radeon HD 8950M's 13376. This places the Vega 11 in the 56th percentile of all GPUs, while the HD 8950M sits in the 54th percentile.

Q: In the head-to-head Geekbench tests, which GPU wins?

A: The AMD Radeon HD 8950M wins both shared head-to-head benchmarks. It scores 13772 in Geekbench OpenCL versus the Vega 11's 13392 (a 2.8% difference), and 12979 in Geekbench Vulkan versus the Vega 11's 12273 (a 5.4% difference).

Q: How do their memory configurations differ?

A: The Vega 11 uses System Shared memory with a bandwidth that is System Dependent, while the HD 8950M has 2 GB of dedicated GDDR5 memory on a 128-bit bus, providing 88.00 GB/s of bandwidth.

Q: What is the difference in their transistor counts and process nodes?

A: The Vega 11 is built on a 12 nm process at GlobalFoundries with 4,940 million transistors on a 210 mm² die. The HD 8950M uses a 28 nm process at TSMC, containing 2,080 million transistors on a 160 mm² die.

Q: Which GPU has a higher pixel rate and texture rate?

A: The HD 8950M has a higher pixel rate at 17.20 GPixel/s, but the Vega 11 has a higher texture rate at 61.60 GTexel/s. The HD 8950M's texture rate is 51.60 GTexel/s.

Q: What are the TDPs of these two GPUs?

A: The Vega 11 has a TDP of 15 W, while the HD 8950M has a TDP of 100 W. This is a substantial difference in power consumption and thermal output.

Where Each One Wins

The AMD Radeon HD 8950M wins in the two benchmark tests where both were measured. In Geekbench OpenCL, it outperforms the Vega 11 by 2.8%, and in Geekbench Vulkan, the margin expands to 5.4%. This suggests that in raw compute throughput, the dedicated GPU with its 768 shading units and 16 ROPs holds an edge over the Vega 11's 704 shaders and 8 ROPs. The HD 8950M also offers a higher pixel rate, which could translate to better fill-rate-bound scenarios. Its dedicated 2 GB of GDDR5 memory with 88.00 GB/s bandwidth is a clear advantage over the system-shared memory of the Vega 11, which is dependent on the host system's RAM.

The AMD Radeon Vega 11, despite losing the direct head-to-head, shows wins in other derived metrics. Its average benchmark score of 14352 is 7.3% higher than the HD 8950M's 13376, and it sits at a higher percentile (56th vs 54th). This is largely due to its superior score in the Geekbench Metal test, where it achieves 17392, a test the HD 8950M did not run. The Vega 11 also has a much higher texture rate (61.60 GTexel/s) and FP32 throughput (1.971 TFLOPS). The Vega 11's 12 nm process and GCN 5.0 architecture deliver these performance-per-clock and efficiency gains, making it a stronger choice for overall compute versatility in tests that utilize newer APIs or specific instruction sets.

Architecture Differences

The two GPUs are separated by two full generations of AMD's Graphics Core Next (GCN) architecture. The AMD Radeon Vega 11 is based on GCN 5.0, implemented on the Picasso chip, while the AMD Radeon HD 8950M uses the older GCN 2.0 architecture with the Saturn chip. This architectural gap is fundamental. GCN 5.0 brings improvements in instruction scheduling, cache hierarchy, and support for newer features that are not present in GCN 2.0.

The manufacturing process is another major differentiator. The Vega 11 is fabricated on a 12 nm process at GlobalFoundries, whereas the HD 8950M is built on a 28 nm process at TSMC. This process shrink allows the Vega 11 to pack 4,940 million transistors into a 210 mm² die, resulting in a transistor density of 23.5M / mm². In contrast, the HD 8950M has 2,080 million transistors on a larger 160 mm² die, yielding a density of just 13.0M / mm². This efficiency difference is stark and explains why the Vega 11 can achieve higher FP32 and texture rates despite having fewer shading units.

The Vega 11 also supports newer API versions, including DirectX 12 (12_1) and Vulkan 1.3, while the HD 8950M is limited to DirectX 12 (12_0) and Vulkan 1.2.170. The Vega 11 also supports FP16 computation at a 2:1 ratio, a feature absent from the HD 8950M's specifications. These architectural and API differences suggest the Vega 11 is better suited for modern workloads, even if its raw fillrate and memory bandwidth are lower.

Specification Differences

The most obvious difference is the form factor and power. The Vega 11 is an IGP with a 15 W TDP, while the HD 8950M is an MXM Module with a 100 W TDP. This represents a 6.7x difference in power consumption. The Vega 11 requires no power connectors and has no dedicated slot width, as it is integrated into the motherboard. The HD 8950M, as a discrete module, uses a PCIe 3.0 x16 bus interface.

Clock speeds are also a point of divergence. The Vega 11 has a defined base clock of 300 MHz and a boost clock of 1400 MHz. The HD 8950M does not list base or boost clocks, but its memory is clocked at 1375 MHz (5.5 Gbps effective). The Vega 11's memory clock is "System Shared," meaning it depends entirely on the host system's RAM speed.

In terms of core configuration, the HD 8950M has more shading units (768 vs 704) and more TMUs (48 vs 44), but the Vega 11 has significantly fewer ROPs (8 vs 16). The HD 8950M's memory setup is a clear spec sheet win: 2 GB of GDDR5 on a 128-bit bus with a fixed 88.00 GB/s bandwidth. The Vega 11's memory bandwidth is "System Dependent," which is a wildcard that can be either a bottleneck or a benefit depending on the platform's RAM. The HD 8950M also has a higher pixel rate (17.20 GPixel/s vs 11.20 GPixel/s), but the Vega 11 counters with a higher texture rate (61.60 GTexel/s vs 51.60 GTexel/s) and FP32 performance (1.971 TFLOPS vs 1.651 TFLOPS).

Head-to-Head Benchmarks

The two shared Geekbench tests paint a clear picture of the HD 8950M's advantage. In Geekbench OpenCL, the HD 8950M scores 13772 against the Vega 11's 13392. This 2.8% lead for the HD 8950M is modest, but it suggests that the extra shading units and dedicated memory provide a tangible benefit in OpenCL compute workloads, where memory latency and bandwidth are critical.

The Geekbench Vulkan test shows a wider gap. Here, the HD 8950M scores 12979, while the Vega 11 manages only 12273. This 5.4% delta is more substantial. Vulkan is a lower-level API that can expose hardware differences more directly. The HD 8950M's higher pixel rate and dedicated memory likely help it in these low-level graphics and compute tasks, while the Vega 11's shared memory architecture may introduce overhead that the newer API cannot fully compensate for.

However, the Vega 11's overall average score is propped up by its Geekbench Metal result of 17392. This is a significant score, and while it is not a direct head-to-head comparison (the HD 8950M has no Metal score), it indicates that the Vega 11's GCN 5.0 architecture is particularly efficient in Apple's Metal API. When considering the average of all available benchmarks, the Vega 11's 14352 average is 976 points higher than the HD 8950M's 13376, a 7.3% advantage. This suggests that the Vega 11's newer architecture is more versatile across different test suites, even if it loses in the specific OpenCL and Vulkan tests shared by both.

The Verdict

The data presents a nuanced verdict. The AMD Radeon HD 8950M is the clear winner in the direct head-to-head benchmarks, taking both OpenCL and Vulkan tests. For users whose workloads are specifically reliant on OpenCL or Vulkan performance, the HD 8950M's dedicated memory and higher pixel rate make it the better choice. Its 2 GB of GDDR5 memory also provides a level of consistency that the Vega 11 cannot match, as the latter's performance is at the mercy of the system's RAM speed and configuration.

However, the AMD Radeon Vega 11 should be the pick for those looking at overall compute versatility and efficiency. Its higher average benchmark score, driven by a strong Metal showing, and its significantly lower 15 W TDP make it a superior option for thin-and-light systems where battery life and thermals are paramount. The Vega 11's newer GCN 5.0 architecture, support for Vulkan 1.3, and FP16 capabilities point to better driver optimization and future-proofing for modern software. The HD 8950M, with its 100 W TDP, is a power-hungry relic suited for older, larger laptops where raw fillrate in specific APIs is the only concern. In summary, choose the HD 8950M for immediate OpenCL/Vulkan compute wins, but choose the Vega 11 for a more balanced, efficient, and forward-looking integrated solution.

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS

SPECIFICATION
HD 8950M
Vega 11
Core Specs
Shading Units
768
704 -8.3%
Shaders
768
704 -8.3%
TMUs
48
44 -8.3%
ROPs
16
8 -50.0%
Compute Units
12
11 -8.3%
Clocks
Base Clock
—
300 MHz
Boost Clock
—
1400 MHz
GPU Clock
1075 MHz
—
Memory Clock
1375 MHz 5.5 Gbps effective
System Shared
Memory
Memory Size
2 GB
System Shared
VRAM (MB)
2,048
—
Memory Type
GDDR5
System Shared
Memory Bus
128 bit
System Shared
Bandwidth
88.00 GB/s
System Dependent
Cache
L1 Cache
16 KB (per CU)
—
L2 Cache
256 KB
—
Performance
Pixel Rate
17.20 GPixel/s
11.20 GPixel/s
Texture Rate
51.60 GTexel/s
61.60 GTexel/s
FP32 (TFLOPS)
1.651 TFLOPS
1.971 TFLOPS
FP64 (TFLOPS)
103.2 GFLOPS (1:16)
123.2 GFLOPS (1:16)
FP16 (TFLOPS)
—
3.942 TFLOPS (2:1)
Power
TDP
100 W
15 W
TDP (W)
100
15 -85.0%
Power Connectors
—
None
Architecture
Architecture
GCN 2.0
GCN 5.0
GPU Name
Saturn
Picasso
Generation
Solar System (HD 8900M)
Vega IGP (Picasso)
Process Size
28 nm
12 nm
Transistors
2,080 million
4,940 million
Die Size
160 mm²
210 mm²
Foundry
TSMC
GlobalFoundries
Density
13.0M / mm²
23.5M / mm²
API Support
DirectX
12 (12_0)
12 (12_1)
OpenGL
4.6
4.6
Vulkan
1.2.170
1.3
OpenCL
2.1
2.1
Shader Model
6.5
6.7
Physical
Slot Width
MXM Module
IGP
Outputs
Portable Device Dependent
Motherboard Dependent
Bus Interface
PCIe 3.0 x16
IGP
Other
Production
End-of-life
End-of-life
Predecessor
London
GCN 3.0 IGP
Successor
Gem System
Vega II IGP
View Radeon HD 8950M Details View Radeon Vega 11 Details