AMD FirePro W4170M vs NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB Comparison

AMD
RADEON

AMD FirePro W4170M

CORE STATE Opal
VRAM 2 GB
CLOCK SPEED 900 MHz
TDP —
BUS WIDTH 128 bit
ARCHITECTURE GCN 1.0
nm
PROCESS 28 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2015
VS
NVIDIA
GEFORCE

GeForce RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB

CORE STATE GB206
VRAM 16 GB
CLOCK SPEED 2572 MHz
TDP 180 W
BUS WIDTH 128 bit
ARCHITECTURE Blackwell 2.0
nm
PROCESS 5 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2025

PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS

geekbench_opencl
5,034
N/A
3dmark_3dmark_steel_nomad_dx12
N/A
4,019
passmark_directx_10
N/A
144
passmark_directx_11
N/A
219
passmark_directx_12
N/A
89
passmark_directx_9
N/A
238
passmark_g2d
N/A
1,206
passmark_g3d
N/A
22,618
passmark_gpu_compute
N/A
11,224

Analysis: AMD FirePro W4170M vs NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB

The AMD FirePro W4170M and NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB represent two completely different eras of GPU design, separated by a decade of architectural evolution. The benchmark data shows a stark contrast: the FirePro W4170M scores 5034 in Geekbench OpenCL, while the RTX 5060 Ti delivers 22618 in Passmark G3D, 11224 in GPU Compute, and 4019 in 3DMark Steel Nomad DX12. The RTX 5060 Ti's average benchmark score of 4970 is dragged down by its lower Passmark scores, but its raw performance metrics tell a different story.

Head-to-Head Benchmarks

The most direct comparison comes from the Passmark suite, where the RTX 5060 Ti demonstrates overwhelming superiority. Its Passmark G3D score of 22618 dwarfs anything the FirePro W4170M can produce, though the FirePro lacks a comparable direct benchmark in the data. The RTX 5060 Ti also posts a Passmark GPU Compute score of 11224, indicating strong general-purpose compute performance. In contrast, the FirePro W4170M's only benchmark, Geekbench OpenCL at 5034, lands it in the 30th percentile of all GPUs, matching the RTX 5060 Ti's 29th percentile ranking.

The RTX 5060 Ti's 3DMark Steel Nomad DX12 score of 4019 reflects modern gaming workloads, while the FirePro W4170M has no equivalent data point. The older card's nearest rivals include the AMD Radeon R5 M430 (5018, 0.3% higher) and the AMD Radeon R7 M340 (5063, 0.6% lower), placing it in a performance class that is essentially obsolete. The RTX 5060 Ti's nearest rivals are similarly low-scoring, including the NVIDIA Quadro 4000 (4979, 0.2% higher) and AMD Radeon R7 Graphics (4998, 0.6% higher), which seems paradoxical given its high Passmark scores.

This discrepancy highlights a critical issue: the RTX 5060 Ti's average benchmark score of 4970 is misleadingly low because it includes Passmark DX9 (238), DX10 (144), DX11 (219), and DX12 (89) scores that are clearly outliers for a modern GPU. The Passmark G2D score of 1206 and G3D score of 22618 are more representative of its actual capability. The FirePro W4170M's single benchmark score of 5034, while higher than the RTX 5060 Ti's average, does not reflect the massive gap in real-world performance.

Where Each One Wins

The FirePro W4170M wins in one narrow regard: its Geekbench OpenCL score of 5034 exceeds the RTX 5060 Ti's average benchmark score of 4970 by roughly 1.3%. This is purely a statistical artifact, however, because the RTX 5060 Ti's average is depressed by its anomalous Passmark DX9-12 scores. In every meaningful workload, the RTX 5060 Ti dominates. Its Passmark G3D score of 22618 represents a 4.5x advantage over the FirePro's Geekbench OpenCL score when comparing raw compute output, and its 23.70 TFLOPS FP32 performance versus 691.2 GFLOPS for the FirePro shows a 34x difference in theoretical compute.

The RTX 5060 Ti also has exclusive capabilities that the FirePro cannot match. Its 36 RT cores enable hardware ray tracing, while the FirePro has none. Its 144 tensor cores accelerate AI workloads, a feature entirely absent from the FirePro. The RTX 5060 Ti supports DirectX 12 Ultimate (12_2), while the FirePro is limited to DirectX 12 (11_1). Vulkan support also differs, with the RTX 5060 Ti at 1.4 versus the FirePro's 1.2.170. For gaming, content creation, or any modern compute task, the RTX 5060 Ti is the clear winner, while the FirePro's only advantage is its legacy compatibility with older FirePro Mobile drivers.

Architecture Differences

The architectural gap between these two GPUs is enormous. The FirePro W4170M uses GCN 1.0 architecture on a 28 nm process node from TSMC, packing 950 million transistors into a 77 mm² die. The RTX 5060 Ti uses Blackwell 2.0 architecture on a 5 nm process, also from TSMC, with 21,900 million transistors in a 181 mm² die. This represents a 23x increase in transistor count and a 16x increase in die size, while the process node shrink from 28 nm to 5 nm enables a transistor density jump from 12.3M per mm² to 121.0M per mm².

The compute resources differ dramatically. The FirePro has 384 shading units, 24 TMUs, and 8 ROPs, while the RTX 5060 Ti has 4608 shading units, 144 TMUs, and 48 ROPs. That is 12x more shading units, 6x more TMUs, and 6x more ROPs. The RTX 5060 Ti also adds 36 RT cores and 144 tensor cores, features that simply do not exist on the FirePro. Clock speeds have improved as well, from a base of 825 MHz and boost of 900 MHz on the FirePro to 2407 MHz base and 2572 MHz boost on the RTX 5060 Ti.

Memory is another major differentiator. The FirePro uses 2 GB of GDDR5 on a 128-bit bus with 64.00 GB/s bandwidth and a 1000 MHz memory clock (4 Gbps effective). The RTX 5060 Ti uses 16 GB of GDDR7 on the same 128-bit bus but achieves 448.0 GB/s bandwidth with a 1750 MHz memory clock (28 Gbps effective). That is 8x more memory and 7x more bandwidth. The RTX 5060 Ti also features a PCIe 5.0 x8 interface versus the FirePro's PCIe 3.0 x8, providing much higher host bandwidth for data transfers.

The Verdict

The data is unambiguous: the RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB is the superior GPU by every meaningful metric. Its 23.70 TFLOPS FP32 performance versus 691.2 GFLOPS for the FirePro W4170M is a 34x advantage. Its 16 GB of GDDR7 memory with 448.0 GB/s bandwidth versus 2 GB GDDR5 with 64.00 GB/s is essential for modern workloads. The RTX 5060 Ti's 36 RT cores and 144 tensor cores enable features the FirePro cannot physically support. The RTX 5060 Ti is an active product with a launch MSRP of 429 USD, while the FirePro is end-of-life from 2015.

Who should pick the FirePro W4170M? Only someone specifically needing a legacy MXM module with 64.00 GB/s bandwidth and no external power connector, likely for a specialized industrial or embedded system. The FirePro's 28 nm process and GCN 1.0 architecture are from a different era, and its 30th percentile ranking places it among the weakest GPUs in the database. The FirePro's 5034 Geekbench OpenCL score is competitive only with other decade-old mobile parts.

Who should pick the RTX 5060 Ti? Anyone building a modern desktop system needs the 16 GB GDDR7 memory, the 448.0 GB/s bandwidth, and the 23.70 TFLOPS of FP32 compute. The 180 W TDP with a 450 W suggested PSU is manageable for most systems. The PCIe 5.0 x8 interface, DirectX 12 Ultimate support, and Vulkan 1.4 compatibility ensure it will handle current and near-future software. Its 29th percentile ranking is misleading due to the anomalous Passmark scores, but the G3D score of 22618 and 3DMark Steel Nomad score of 4019 demonstrate real capability. The 5 nm process, 121.0M transistors per mm², and 2,572 MHz boost clock represent the state of the art.

FAQ

Q: Which GPU has higher raw compute performance?

A: The RTX 5060 Ti has 23.70 TFLOPS FP32 versus 691.2 GFLOPS for the FirePro W4170M, a 34x advantage. The RTX 5060 Ti also delivers 23.70 TFLOPS FP16, while the FirePro has no FP16 specification.

Q: How does memory capacity compare?

A: The RTX 5060 Ti has 16 GB of GDDR7, which is 8x the FirePro W4170M's 2 GB of GDDR5. Both use a 128-bit bus, but the RTX 5060 Ti achieves 448.0 GB/s bandwidth versus 64.00 GB/s for the FirePro.

Q: Does the FirePro support ray tracing?

A: No. The FirePro W4170M has no RT cores, while the RTX 5060 Ti includes 36 RT cores. The RTX 5060 Ti also has 144 tensor cores for AI workloads, which the FirePro lacks entirely.

Q: What is the release date difference?

A: The FirePro W4170M was released on 2015-04-22 and is end-of-life, while the RTX 5060 Ti was released on 2025-04-15 and is active. That is roughly a decade between generations.

Q: Which GPU has better API support?

A: The RTX 5060 Ti supports DirectX 12 Ultimate (12_2) and Vulkan 1.4, while the FirePro supports DirectX 12 (11_1) and Vulkan 1.2.170. Both support OpenGL 4.6.

Q: Are the benchmark scores directly comparable?

A: No. The FirePro has a Geekbench OpenCL score of 5034, while the RTX 5060 Ti has Passmark G3D (22618), GPU Compute (11224), and 3DMark Steel Nomad (4019) scores. The RTX 5060 Ti's average score of 4970 is skewed by low Passmark DX9-12 scores.

Specification Differences

| Specification | AMD FirePro W4170M | NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB |

|---|---|---|

| Architecture | GCN 1.0 | Blackwell 2.0 |

| Process Node | 28 nm | 5 nm |

| Transistors | 950 million | 21,900 million |

| Die Size | 77 mm² | 181 mm² |

| Transistor Density | 12.3M / mm² | 121.0M / mm² |

| Base Clock | 825 MHz | 2407 MHz |

| Boost Clock | 900 MHz | 2572 MHz |

| Memory Size | 2 GB | 16 GB |

| Memory Type | GDDR5 | GDDR7 |

| Memory Clock | 1000 MHz (4 Gbps) | 1750 MHz (28 Gbps) |

| Bandwidth | 64.00 GB/s | 448.0 GB/s |

| Shading Units | 384 | 4608 |

| TMUs | 24 | 144 |

| ROPs | 8 | 48 |

| RT Cores | None | 36 |

| Tensor Cores | None | 144 |

| Pixel Rate | 7.200 GPixel/s | 123.5 GPixel/s |

| Texture Rate | 21.60 GTexel/s | 370.4 GTexel/s |

| FP32 | 691.2 GFLOPS | 23.70 TFLOPS |

| FP16 | None | 23.70 TFLOPS (1:1) |

| TDP | Not specified | 180 W |

| Slot Width | MXM Module | Dual-slot |

| Power Connectors | None | 1x 8-pin |

| Suggested PSU | Not specified | 450 W |

| Bus Interface | PCIe 3.0 x8 | PCIe 5.0 x8 |

| Display Outputs | Portable Device Dependent | 1x HDMI 2.1b, 3x DisplayPort 2.1b |

| DirectX | 12 (11_1) | 12 Ultimate (12_2) |

| Vulkan | 1.2.170 | 1.4 |

| Production Status | End-of-life | Active |

| Release Date | 2015-04-22 | 2025-04-15 |

| Launch MSRP | None | 429 USD |

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS

SPECIFICATION
FirePro W4170M
RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB
Core Specs
Shading Units
384
4,608 +1100.0%
Shaders
384
4,608 +1100.0%
TMUs
24
144 +500.0%
ROPs
8
48 +500.0%
Compute Units
6
—
SM Count
—
36
Clocks
Base Clock
825 MHz
2407 MHz
Boost Clock
900 MHz
2572 MHz
Memory Clock
1000 MHz 4 Gbps effective
1750 MHz 28 Gbps effective
Memory
Memory Size
2 GB
16 GB
VRAM (MB)
2,048
16,384 +700.0%
Memory Type
GDDR5
GDDR7
Memory Bus
128 bit
128 bit
Bandwidth
64.00 GB/s
448.0 GB/s
Cache
L1 Cache
16 KB (per CU)
128 KB (per SM)
L2 Cache
256 KB
32 MB
Performance
Pixel Rate
7.200 GPixel/s
123.5 GPixel/s
Texture Rate
21.60 GTexel/s
370.4 GTexel/s
FP32 (TFLOPS)
691.2 GFLOPS
23.70 TFLOPS
FP64 (TFLOPS)
43.20 GFLOPS (1:16)
370.4 GFLOPS (1:64)
FP16 (TFLOPS)
—
23.70 TFLOPS (1:1)
AI/RT
RT Cores
—
36
Tensor Cores
—
144
Power
TDP
—
180 W
TDP (W)
—
180
Suggested PSU
—
450 W
Power Connectors
None
1x 8-pin
Architecture
Architecture
GCN 1.0
Blackwell 2.0
GPU Name
Opal
GB206
Generation
FirePro Mobile (Wx100M)
GeForce 50
Process Size
28 nm
5 nm
Transistors
950 million
21,900 million
Die Size
77 mm²
181 mm²
Foundry
TSMC
TSMC
Density
12.3M / mm²
121.0M / mm²
API Support
DirectX
12 (11_1)
12 Ultimate (12_2)
OpenGL
4.6
4.6
Vulkan
1.2.170
1.4
OpenCL
2.1 (1.2)
3.0
CUDA
—
12.0
Shader Model
6.5 (5.1)
6.9
Physical
Slot Width
MXM Module
Dual-slot
Length
—
241 mm 9.5 inches
Height
—
111 mm 4.4 inches
Outputs
Portable Device Dependent
1x HDMI 2.1b3x DisplayPort 2.1b
Bus Interface
PCIe 3.0 x8
PCIe 5.0 x8
Other
Launch Price
—
429 USD
Production
End-of-life
Active
Predecessor
FirePro Mobility
GeForce 40
Successor
Radeon Pro Mobile
GeForce 60
View FirePro W4170M Details View GeForce RTX 5060 Ti 16 GB Details