AMD FirePro W4170M vs NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3080 12 GB Comparison
AMD FirePro W4170M
GeForce RTX 3080 12 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD FirePro W4170M vs NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3080 12 GB
The AMD FirePro W4170M and the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3080 12 GB represent two distant poles of the GPU spectrum, separated by nearly seven years of technological progress and entirely different design goals. The data confirms an overwhelming performance gulf, but the benchmark results also reveal a peculiar contextual twist. The RTX 3080 12 GB scores 4791 in the 3DMark Steel Nomad DX12 test, while the FirePro W4170M scores 5034 in Geekbench OpenCL. These are different workloads, and direct comparison is impossible, yet the percentile rankings show both cards near the bottom of the database: the FirePro sits at the 30th percentile and the RTX 3080 at the 28th. This indicates that the RTX 3080's score, while massive in absolute terms, is being measured against a benchmark suite where its modern architecture and immense resources do not translate to a dominant position, likely due to the specific nature of the test. The FirePro's nearest rivals, such as the AMD Radeon R7 M340, are within a 0.6% margin, confirming its position as a low-end mobile workstation part. The RTX 3080 12 GB, in contrast, is listed near the AMD Radeon R5 M255 (0.1% ahead) and the NVIDIA GeForce 940MX (1.1% behind) in this particular metric, which is an artifact of the benchmark's scoring, not a reflection of real-world capability.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The head-to-head benchmark table is empty, meaning no direct comparative test was run between these two cards. However, the individual benchmark scores provide the only quantitative basis for analysis. The AMD FirePro W4170M achieves 5034 points in Geekbench OpenCL, a synthetic test that measures compute performance across a range of workloads. This score places it just 0.3% above the AMD Radeon R5 M430 and 0.7% above the AMD Radeon R7 Graphics, showing it is competitive with other low-power mobile GPUs of its era. The NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3080 12 GB, on the other hand, posts 4791 points in 3DMark Steel Nomad DX12, a modern, DirectX 12-focused benchmark. This score is 0.8% higher than the AMD Radeon R5 M335 and 1.3% lower than the NVIDIA GeForce GTX 560M, a result that seems incongruous with the card's specifications but reflects the specific demands of the Steel Nomad test.
The raw specification gap is staggering. The RTX 3080 12 GB delivers 30.64 TFLOPS of FP32 compute, whereas the FirePro W4170M manages 691.2 GFLOPS. That is a 44-fold difference in theoretical floating-point throughput. The pixel rate tells a similar story: 164.2 GPixel/s for the NVIDIA card versus 7.200 GPixel/s for the AMD card. Texture rate is even more lopsided, with the RTX 3080 achieving 478.8 GTexel/s against the FirePro's 21.60 GTexel/s. These are not incremental improvements; they represent different classes of hardware. The RTX 3080 12 GB's memory bandwidth of 912.4 GB/s is over 14 times the FirePro's 64.00 GB/s. In any workload that scales with compute, memory bandwidth, or pixel throughput, the RTX 3080 12 GB would obliterate the FirePro W4170M, even though the single benchmark scores do not directly reflect this due to different testing methodologies.
Architecture Differences
The architectural divide is fundamental. The AMD FirePro W4170M is built on the GCN 1.0 architecture, using the Opal chip, fabricated on a 28 nm process at TSMC. It contains 950 million transistors on a 77 mm² die, yielding a transistor density of 12.3M per mm². This is a legacy mobile workstation GPU with 384 shading units, 24 texture mapping units, and 8 ROPs. It has no dedicated ray tracing or tensor cores, as those concepts did not exist in consumer hardware at its release. The memory subsystem is a 2 GB GDDR5 configuration on a 128-bit bus, running at an effective 4 Gbps. The card supports DirectX 12 (11_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.2.170. Its power delivery is minimal, requiring no external power connectors and using an MXM module slot, reflecting its mobile heritage.
The NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3080 12 GB is a completely different beast. It uses the GA102 chip on Samsung's 8 nm process, packing 28,300 million transistors into a 628 mm² die, which is a transistor density of 45.1M per mm². The architecture is Ampere, which introduces dedicated 70 ray tracing cores and 280 tensor cores alongside 8960 shading units, 280 TMUs, and 96 ROPs. The memory is 12 GB of GDDR6X on a 384-bit bus, running at an effective 19 Gbps. The APIs supported are more advanced, including DirectX 12 Ultimate (12_2) and Vulkan 1.4. This is a dual-slot desktop card requiring a 750 W power supply and a single 12-pin connector. The FirePro is a low-power embedded solution; the RTX 3080 is a high-performance desktop flagship. The process node difference alone, 28 nm versus 8 nm, explains a significant portion of the performance and efficiency gap.
Where Each One Wins
Given the benchmark data, the FirePro W4170M wins in the Geekbench OpenCL test, scoring 5034 versus the RTX 3080's 4791 in 3DMark Steel Nomad. However, this is not a meaningful victory in practical terms. The FirePro's win is in a legacy compute benchmark that is not representative of modern gaming or professional workloads. Its nearest rivals, all low-end mobile or entry-level desktop parts, confirm that it is best suited for basic tasks like portable CAD viewing, light 2D/3D design, or as a display output for a mobile workstation. It has no ray tracing capability, no tensor cores, and only 2 GB of VRAM, which severely limits its use with modern textures and datasets. The data suggests it is a competent chip for its time, but its 30th percentile ranking places it below the majority of GPUs in the database.
The RTX 3080 12 GB, despite its lower percentile ranking in this specific benchmark, is the clear winner in any scenario that leverages its hardware. Its 70 RT cores enable hardware-accelerated ray tracing, a feature the FirePro lacks entirely. Its 280 tensor cores accelerate AI and deep learning workloads, which the FirePro cannot handle. The 12 GB of GDDR6X memory with 912.4 GB/s bandwidth is essential for high-resolution textures and large datasets. The card's 30.64 TFLOPS of FP32 and matching FP16 performance (30.64 TFLOPS 1:1) make it suitable for compute-intensive tasks like video rendering, scientific simulation, and machine learning training. The FirePro's FP32 of 691.2 GFLOPS is a rounding error in comparison. For gaming, the RTX 3080 12 GB would excel in DirectX 12 Ultimate titles, while the FirePro, with its DirectX 12 (11_1) support, would struggle with modern feature sets.
FAQ
Q: Is the AMD FirePro W4170M faster than the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3080 12 GB in any test?
A: Yes, in the Geekbench OpenCL test, the FirePro W4170M scores 5034, while the RTX 3080 12 GB scores 4791 in the 3DMark Steel Nomad DX12 test. However, these are different benchmarks, so this is not a direct comparison of performance.
Q: What is the memory capacity and type difference?
A: The FirePro W4170M has 2 GB of GDDR5 memory on a 128-bit bus with 64.00 GB/s bandwidth. The RTX 3080 12 GB has 12 GB of GDDR6X memory on a 384-bit bus with 912.4 GB/s bandwidth.
Q: Does the FirePro W4170M support ray tracing?
A: No. The FirePro W4170M has no ray tracing cores. The RTX 3080 12 GB has 70 dedicated ray tracing cores.
Q: What is the FP32 compute performance of each card?
A: The FirePro W4170M delivers 691.2 GFLOPS of FP32 performance. The RTX 3080 12 GB delivers 30.64 TFLOPS of FP32 performance.
Q: Which card has a higher transistor count?
A: The RTX 3080 12 GB has 28,300 million transistors, while the FirePro W4170M has 950 million transistors.
Q: What are the power requirements for the RTX 3080 12 GB?
A: The RTX 3080 12 GB has a TDP of 350 W, requires a single 12-pin power connector, and a suggested power supply of 750 W. The FirePro W4170M has no external power connectors and uses an MXM module slot.
The Verdict
The choice between these two cards is not a choice at all; it is a matter of era and use case. The data shows that the RTX 3080 12 GB is a modern, high-end desktop GPU designed for demanding tasks like 4K gaming, ray tracing, and AI workloads. Its specifications are an order of magnitude beyond the FirePro W4170M in every measurable category except the single Geekbench score. The FirePro W4170M is an end-of-life mobile workstation part from 2015, designed for portability and basic professional graphics. Its 2 GB memory and lack of modern features make it unsuitable for any current demanding application. The RTX 3080 12 GB, despite its lower percentile in the 3DMark test, is the only sensible pick for anyone needing real graphics performance. The FirePro W4170M should only be considered for legacy systems or specific tasks where its low power draw and MXM form factor are absolute requirements. The benchmark scores, while not directly comparable, do not change the fundamental conclusion: the RTX 3080 12 GB is the superior hardware by a wide margin.
Specification Differences
The following table outlines the key specification differences between the two GPUs, based solely on the provided data.
| Specification | AMD FirePro W4170M | NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3080 12 GB |
| :--- | :--- | :--- |
| Architecture | GCN 1.0 | Ampere |
| Process Node | 28 nm | 8 nm |
| Foundry | TSMC | Samsung |
| Transistors | 950 million | 28,300 million |
| Die Size | 77 mm² | 628 mm² |
| Base Clock | 825 MHz | 1260 MHz |
| Boost Clock | 900 MHz | 1710 MHz |
| Memory Size | 2 GB | 12 GB |
| Memory Type | GDDR5 | GDDR6X |
| Memory Bus | 128 bit | 384 bit |
| Memory Bandwidth | 64.00 GB/s | 912.4 GB/s |
| Shading Units | 384 | 8960 |
| TMUs | 24 | 280 |
| ROPs | 8 | 96 |
| RT Cores | None | 70 |
| Tensor Cores | None | 280 |
| Pixel Rate | 7.200 GPixel/s | 164.2 GPixel/s |
| Texture Rate | 21.60 GTexel/s | 478.8 GTexel/s |
| FP32 Performance | 691.2 GFLOPS | 30.64 TFLOPS |
| FP16 Performance | None | 30.64 TFLOPS (1:1) |
| TDP | None listed | 350 W |
| Slot Width | MXM Module | Dual-slot |
| Power Connectors | None | 1x 12-pin |
| Suggested PSU | None listed | 750 W |
| Bus Interface | PCIe 3.0 x8 | PCIe 4.0 x16 |
| DirectX Support | 12 (11_1) | 12 Ultimate (12_2) |
| Vulkan Support | 1.2.170 | 1.4 |
| Release Date | 2015-04-22 | 2022-01-10 |