AMD FirePro W4170M vs AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT 16 GB Comparison
AMD FirePro W4170M
Radeon RX 9060 XT 16 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD FirePro W4170M vs AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT 16 GB
The AMD FirePro W4170M and the AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT 16 GB represent two vastly different eras of GPU design, and the benchmark data reflects a complete generational overhaul. The FirePro W4170M is an end-of-life mobile workstation part from 2015, while the RX 9060 XT is an active, high-end desktop gaming card from 2025. The data shows a decisive victory for the newer card in raw performance, but the older card’s niche strengths and the newer card's specific benchmark results create a more nuanced picture than a simple spec-sheet comparison might suggest.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The most striking difference between these two GPUs is the sheer scale of their performance disparity. The AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT 16 GB absolutely dominates in every available computational benchmark. Its Passmark G3D score is an overwhelming 20099, which places it far beyond the older card's capability. The FirePro W4170M's only direct benchmark is a Geekbench OpenCL score of 5034. While the RX 9060 XT does not have a Geekbench OpenCL score in the data, its Passmark GPU Compute score of 11234 demonstrates a massive advantage in general-purpose compute workloads. This indicates that for any modern gaming, rendering, or compute task, the RX 9060 XT is in a completely different performance class.
The RX 9060 XT's dominance is further highlighted by its advanced API support. It scores 305 in the Passmark DirectX 9 test, 185 in DirectX 11, and 116 in DirectX 10. These are legacy API scores, but even in these older workloads, the newer card's raw throughput is evident. The FirePro W4170M, with its older GCN 1.0 architecture, is limited to DirectX 12 (11_1) and lacks the hardware features to compete in modern ray-traced or heavily tessellated workloads. The RX 9060 XT's support for DirectX 12 Ultimate (12_2) and its dedicated 32 ray accelerators give it a functional advantage in games that use these features, while the FirePro W4170M has no such hardware.
Interestingly, the average benchmark scores tell a different story about market positioning. The RX 9060 XT has an average benchmark score of 4657, while the FirePro W4170M has an average of 5034. This is because the RX 9060 XT's average is dragged down by its low scores in specific legacy Passmark tests. For example, its Passmark DirectX 12 score is only 57, and its DirectX 10 score is 116. These low scores are not indicative of real-world performance but rather reflect the limitations of these older test suites on a modern architecture optimized for different workloads. The FirePro W4170M's single Geekbench OpenCL score of 5034 is actually higher than the RX 9060 XT's own average, a statistical quirk that highlights why single-point comparisons can be misleading.
The data also reveals that neither GPU is a top-tier performer in the current market. The FirePro W4170M's percentile rank is 30, placing it in the lower third of all GPUs. Its nearest rivals are the AMD Radeon R5 M430, which scores 5018 (a 0.3% difference), and the AMD Radeon R7 M340, which scores 5063 (a -0.6% difference). This shows the FirePro W4170M is firmly in entry-level territory. The RX 9060 XT, despite its enormous performance, has a percentile rank of just 27, even lower than the FirePro. This is because the Passmark suite's legacy tests penalize it heavily, placing it near the AMD Radeon R5 M320 with a score of 4657 and a 0% delta, and the NVIDIA Quadro P400 with a score of 4684 and a -0.6% delta. This data suggests that the RX 9060 XT's benchmark profile is highly specialized, excelling massively in modern compute and graphics tasks while being poorly represented by these older, standardized tests.
The Verdict
From a sheer performance standpoint, the choice is clear: the AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT 16 GB is the superior product. Its 25.64 TFLOPS of FP32 compute power is a generational leap over the FirePro W4170M's 691.2 GFLOPS. The RX 9060 XT boasts 2048 shading units compared to the FirePro's 384, and its 64 ROPs and 128 TMUs dwarf the older card's 8 and 24, respectively. For any task that requires modern graphics rendering, gaming, or GPU-accelerated compute, the RX 9060 XT is the only viable option. Its memory configuration alone — 16 GB of GDDR6 with a 322.3 GB/s bandwidth versus the FirePro's 2 GB of GDDR5 with a 64.00 GB/s bandwidth — makes it a non-contest.
The FirePro W4170M's only potential advantage is in its physical form factor. As an MXM Module, it is designed for mobile workstations. However, its performance is so limited that it is only suitable for the most basic 2D workload or as a legacy compatibility part. Its single benchmark score of 5034 is competitive with the RX 9060 XT's average of 4657, but this is an artifact of the different test suites used. The RX 9060 XT's Passmark G3D score of 20099 is the definitive measure of its 3D rendering capability, a metric the FirePro W4170M simply cannot approach.
For a user choosing between these two, the decision is based on era and use case. The RX 9060 XT is for anyone who needs a powerful, modern GPU for gaming, content creation, or AI workloads. The FirePro W4170M is a legacy part that should only be considered if there is a specific need for a low-profile, mobile MXM card with extremely low power requirements, as its power connectors are listed as "None" and it has no TDP figure. Otherwise, the data unequivocally points to the RX 9060 XT as the superior choice.
FAQ
Q: Which GPU has a higher average benchmark score?
A: The AMD FirePro W4170M has a higher average benchmark score of 5034 compared to the AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT 16 GB's average of 4657. This is due to the RX 9060 XT's low scores in legacy Passmark tests, despite its vastly superior raw performance.
Q: What is the most significant performance gap between the two cards?
A: The most significant gap is in 3D rendering performance. The RX 9060 XT scores 20099 in the Passmark G3D test, while the FirePro W4170M has no comparable score. Additionally, the RX 9060 XT's FP32 compute power of 25.64 TFLOPS is over 37 times higher than the FirePro's 691.2 GFLOPS.
Q: Does the AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT support ray tracing?
A: Yes, the RX 9060 XT is equipped with 32 RT cores and supports DirectX 12 Ultimate (12_2), which includes hardware-accelerated ray tracing. The FirePro W4170M does not have any RT cores and only supports DirectX 12 (11_1).
Q: How much memory does each card have?
A: The AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT 16 GB has 16 GB of GDDR6 memory on a 128-bit bus, providing a bandwidth of 322.3 GB/s. The AMD FirePro W4170M has 2 GB of GDDR5 memory on a 128-bit bus, with a bandwidth of 64.00 GB/s.
Q: What is the manufacturing process for each GPU?
A: The AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT is built on a 4 nm process at TSMC, while the AMD FirePro W4170M uses a much older 28 nm process. This contributes to the RX 9060 XT's higher transistor density of 149.2M / mm² versus 12.3M / mm² for the FirePro.
Q: Which card is better for modern gaming?
A: The AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT is unequivocally better for modern gaming. It offers a massive 20099 Passmark G3D score, 16 GB of VRAM, and support for DirectX 12 Ultimate, making it capable of handling current and future titles. The FirePro W4170M is a legacy mobile part with only 2 GB of VRAM and is unsuitable for modern gaming.
Specification Differences
The specification sheets for these two GPUs reveal a fundamental evolution in hardware design. The most obvious difference is in their core compute resources. The Radeon RX 9060 XT features 2048 shading units, 128 texture mapping units, and 64 render output units. In contrast, the FirePro W4170M has only 384 shading units, 24 TMUs, and 8 ROPs. This 5x, 5.3x, and 8x difference in core counts, respectively, directly translates to the massive performance gap seen in the benchmarks.
Memory configuration is another major point of divergence. The RX 9060 XT comes with 16 GB of GDDR6 memory running at 2518 MHz (effectively 20.1 Gbps), which provides a bandwidth of 322.3 GB/s over a 128-bit bus. The FirePro W4170M is limited to 2 GB of GDDR5 memory at 1000 MHz (4 Gbps effective), yielding a bandwidth of 64.00 GB/s on the same 128-bit bus. This represents an 8x increase in memory capacity and a 5x increase in bandwidth for the newer card.
The cards also differ in their physical and interface specifications. The RX 9060 XT has a TDP of 160 W, uses a dual-slot design, and requires a single 8-pin power connector. It also recommends a 450 W power supply. The FirePro W4170M is an MXM Module with no power connectors. The bus interface has also been upgraded, with the RX 9060 XT using PCIe 5.0 x16 compared to the FirePro's PCIe 3.0 x8. Finally, the RX 9060 XT's display outputs are 1x HDMI 2.1b and 2x DisplayPort 2.1a, while the FirePro's outputs are listed as "Portable Device Dependent," reflecting its mobile nature.
Architecture Differences
The architectural chasm between these two GPUs is the primary driver of their performance disparity. The FirePro W4170M is built on the GCN 1.0 architecture, using the "Opal" chip, and is part of the FirePro Mobile (Wx100M) generation. It is fabricated on a 28 nm process at TSMC, containing 950 million transistors on a 77 mm² die. This results in a transistor density of 12.3M / mm². Its architecture is limited to DirectX 12 (11_1) and Vulkan 1.2.170.
In stark contrast, the Radeon RX 9060 XT utilizes the modern RDNA 4.0 architecture with the "Navi 44" chip, belonging to the Navi IV (RX 9000) generation. It is manufactured on a state-of-the-art 4 nm process, also at TSMC, but packs a staggering 29,700 million transistors into a 199 mm² die. This yields a transistor density of 149.2M / mm², a 12x improvement over the older part. The RDNA 4.0 architecture brings support for DirectX 12 Ultimate (12_2) and Vulkan 1.4, along with dedicated 32 RT cores for hardware ray tracing.
The clock speeds also tell a story of architectural efficiency. The RX 9060 XT has a base clock of 1700 MHz, a game clock of 2530 MHz, and a boost clock of 3130 MHz. The FirePro W4170M, by comparison, has a base clock of 825 MHz and a boost of 900 MHz. This difference, combined with the architectural improvements, allows the RX 9060 XT to achieve a pixel rate of 200.3 GPixel/s and a texture rate of 400.6 GTexel/s, compared to the FirePro's 7.200 GPixel/s and 21.60 GTexel/s. The RX 9060 XT also supports FP16 compute at a 1:1 ratio with 25.64 TFLOPS, a feature completely absent in the FirePro's spec sheet.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT 16 GB wins in virtually every measurable category involving modern performance. It is the clear choice for gaming, with a Passmark G3D score of 20099 that is orders of magnitude beyond the FirePro's capability. Its 16 GB of VRAM makes it suitable for high-resolution textures and modern game assets, while its 32 RT cores enable hardware-accelerated ray tracing, a feature the FirePro completely lacks. For content creation, 3D rendering, and GPU compute tasks, the RX 9060 XT's 25.64 TFLOPS of FP32 and FP16 performance, coupled with its massive memory bandwidth of 322.3 GB/s, makes it a highly capable workstation tool.
The AMD FirePro W4170M's wins are almost entirely contextual and related to its legacy status. Its only benchmark score, 5034 in Geekbench OpenCL, is higher than the RX 9060 XT's average score of 4657, indicating that in this specific test, it performs adequately. Its primary advantage is its form factor as an MXM Module with no power connectors, making it potentially useful for upgrading or repairing older, specialized mobile workstations where a modern dual-slot card cannot physically fit. Its 28 nm GCN 1.0 architecture and support for older APIs like DirectX 11_1 could also be relevant for running specific legacy professional software that has not been updated for modern hardware. However, these are niche scenarios. For any general-purpose or modern task, the RX 9060 XT is the definitive winner, as the data shows a performance gulf that cannot be bridged by the older card's single benchmark score.