NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB vs NVIDIA Quadro K5200 Comparison
NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB
Quadro K5200
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB vs NVIDIA Quadro K5200
The NVIDIA Quadro K5200 and the NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB represent two distinct philosophies from the same manufacturer, separated by two years of architectural evolution. The K5200 is a professional Kepler-generation workstation card from 2014, while the GTX 1060 3 GB is a Pascal-generation consumer card from 2016. The benchmark data shows a fascinating split: the GTX 1060 dominates in OpenCL compute workloads, while the K5200 counters with a significant Vulkan advantage. With each card winning exactly one head-to-head benchmark, the choice between them depends entirely on the target application workload.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The most striking result in the head-to-head comparison is the GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB's decisive victory in Geekbench OpenCL. The GTX 1060 scores 27,001 points, while the Quadro K5200 manages only 19,024 points. This represents a 29.5% deficit for the K5200, a massive gap that highlights the generational leap in compute efficiency between Kepler and Pascal architectures. The GTX 1060 achieves this despite having roughly half the shading units of the K5200 — 1,152 versus 2,304 — which demonstrates how much more efficiently each Pascal core executes compute instructions compared to its Kepler predecessor.
However, the story reverses completely in the Geekbench Vulkan test. Here, the Quadro K5200 takes the lead with a score of 20,180, outperforming the GTX 1060's 17,475 by 15.5%. This is a substantial margin that suggests the K5200's driver stack or hardware design handles Vulkan's low-level GPU access patterns more effectively, despite the older architecture. The K5200's Vulkan support is listed as version 1.2.175, while the GTX 1060 supports Vulkan 1.4, so the advantage is not simply a matter of newer API support.
When compared to their nearest rivals, both cards sit in remarkably similar performance territory. The K5200's average benchmark score of 19,602 places it just 0.2% behind the AMD FirePro D300 (19,637) and 0.8% behind the AMD Radeon RX 6650 XT (19,765), yet 1% ahead of the AMD Radeon RX 7900 XTX (19,410). The GTX 1060 3 GB's average score of 19,334 puts it 0.4% behind the RX 7900 XTX, 0.8% ahead of the NVIDIA TITAN Xp (19,177), and 1.3% ahead of the NVIDIA Tesla K20m (19,089). Both cards occupy the same percentile ranking of 64 among all GPUs, confirming that their overall performance is essentially equivalent despite their very different architectural approaches.
Architecture Differences
The fundamental architectural divide between these two cards is substantial. The Quadro K5200 uses the GK110B chip built on TSMC's 28 nm process, featuring 7,080 million transistors on a massive 561 mm² die. The GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB, by contrast, uses the GP106 chip fabricated on a more advanced 16 nm process, packing 4,400 million transistors onto a much smaller 200 mm² die. This process shrink allows the GTX 1060 to achieve a transistor density of 22.0 million transistors per square millimeter, nearly double the K5200's 12.6 million per square millimeter.
Clock speeds tell a similarly dramatic story. The K5200 operates at a base clock of 667 MHz with a boost clock of 771 MHz, while the GTX 1060 runs at a base of 1,506 MHz and boosts to 1,708 MHz. This more than doubling of clock speed is the primary reason the GTX 1060 can match or exceed the K5200's compute performance despite having fewer processing units. The K5200 does field more raw hardware: 2,304 shading units, 192 texture mapping units, and 48 raster output units, versus the GTX 1060's 1,152 shading units, 72 TMUs, and 48 ROPs.
Memory configurations differ considerably. The K5200 ships with 8 GB of GDDR5 memory on a 256-bit bus, delivering 192.3 GB/s of bandwidth. The GTX 1060 offers only 3 GB of GDDR5 on a narrower 192-bit bus, yet achieves nearly identical bandwidth at 192.2 GB/s thanks to its faster 8 Gbps effective memory speed versus the K5200's 6 Gbps. The memory clock difference is stark: the GTX 1060 runs at 2,002 MHz compared to the K5200's 1,502 MHz.
Power consumption heavily favors the newer card. The GTX 1060 has a TDP of 120 W with a suggested power supply of 300 W, while the K5200 draws 150 W and recommends a 450 W supply. Both cards use a single 6-pin power connector and occupy dual-slot widths. The GTX 1060 is also shorter at 250 mm (9.8 inches) versus the K5200's 267 mm (10.5 inches).
The K5200 offers 2x DVI and 2x DisplayPort 1.2 outputs, while the GTX 1060 provides 1x DVI, 1x HDMI 2.0, and 3x DisplayPort 1.4a. In terms of API support, the K5200 supports DirectX 12 (11_1) and OpenGL 4.6, while the GTX 1060 supports DirectX 12 (12_1) and OpenGL 4.6. The K5200's FP32 throughput is 3.553 TFLOPS, slightly lower than the GTX 1060's 3.935 TFLOPS, and the GTX 1060 additionally offers FP16 capability at 61.49 GFLOPS (1:64 ratio), which the K5200 lacks entirely.
The Verdict
The data presents a clear picture of two cards with equal overall standing but opposing strengths. The Quadro K5200 wins the Vulkan benchmark decisively, outperforming the GTX 1060 by 15.5%, which suggests it remains a viable choice for Vulkan-based workloads. Its 8 GB memory capacity also gives it a substantial advantage for memory-intensive tasks, even though its bandwidth is virtually identical to the GTX 1060's.
The GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB is the clear winner for OpenCL compute, with a 29.5% advantage that cannot be ignored. Its higher clock speeds and newer architecture deliver superior raw compute performance in that API, despite having fewer shading units. The GTX 1060 also consumes 30 W less power and requires a smaller power supply, making it a more efficient choice for most users.
Neither card offers a universal advantage, as their head-to-head record stands at one win apiece. The K5200's professional pedigree does not translate into benchmark superiority, and the GTX 1060's consumer positioning does not hold it back in compute tasks. For users prioritizing Vulkan performance or requiring more than 3 GB of memory, the K5200 is the data-supported choice. For those focused on OpenCL workloads or wanting lower power draw, the GTX 1060 3 GB is clearly superior.
FAQ
Q: Which card has the higher average benchmark score?
A: The Quadro K5200 has a slightly higher average benchmark score of 19,602, compared to the GTX 1060 3 GB's 19,334, a difference of approximately 1.4%.
Q: How do the two cards compare in Geekbench Vulkan?
A: The Quadro K5200 wins the Vulkan test with a score of 20,180, beating the GTX 1060 3 GB's 17,475 by 15.5%.
Q: What is the memory capacity difference between these cards?
A: The Quadro K5200 has 8 GB of GDDR5 memory, while the GTX 1060 3 GB has only 3 GB, although both deliver nearly identical bandwidth at approximately 192 GB/s.
Q: Which card has a higher boost clock speed?
A: The GTX 1060 3 GB has a boost clock of 1,708 MHz, more than double the K5200's boost clock of 771 MHz.
Q: How does the transistor density compare between the two architectures?
A: The GTX 1060 3 GB's 16 nm process achieves 22.0 million transistors per square millimeter, while the K5200's 28 nm process achieves 12.6 million per square millimeter.
Q: What is the power consumption difference?
A: The GTX 1060 3 GB has a TDP of 120 W with a 300 W suggested power supply, while the K5200 has a TDP of 150 W and recommends a 450 W power supply.
Where Each One Wins
The Quadro K5200 is the better choice for Vulkan-based rendering workloads. Its 15.5% Vulkan benchmark advantage over the GTX 1060 3 GB makes it the data-supported option for applications that leverage this API, such as modern game engines or compute frameworks that use Vulkan's low-level GPU access. The K5200's 8 GB memory capacity also provides a significant practical advantage for large datasets or high-resolution textures, even if the bandwidth is identical to the GTX 1060. Its higher average benchmark score of 19,602 versus 19,334 also makes it nominally the stronger overall performer.
The GeForce GTX 1060 3 GB is the clear winner for OpenCL workloads. Its 29.5% OpenCL benchmark advantage is the largest margin in any comparison between these two cards, making it the obvious choice for general-purpose GPU computing that targets OpenCL. The GTX 1060 also wins on efficiency, drawing 30 W less power and requiring a 300 W power supply instead of 450 W, which makes it easier to integrate into existing systems. Its higher FP32 throughput of 3.935 TFLOPS versus 3.553 TFLOPS further supports its compute superiority, and its shorter length of 250 mm versus 267 mm makes it more compatible with compact cases. For users who need both OpenCL performance and lower power consumption, the GTX 1060 3 GB is the unequivocal choice.