AMD Radeon VII vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB Comparison
AMD Radeon VII
Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Radeon VII vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB
The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB and the AMD Radeon VII are two 16 GB HBM2 graphics cards from different eras, targeting different use cases. The data shows a clear split: the Radeon VII delivers substantially higher raw compute throughput and wins the available head-to-head benchmark, while the Tesla P100 holds a higher percentile ranking among all GPUs based on its average score. This analysis walks through the architectural, benchmark, and specification differences to determine where each card excels.
FAQ
Q: Which card has the higher average benchmark score?
A: The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB has an average benchmark score of 79,605, which places it in the 92nd percentile among all GPUs. The AMD Radeon VII has a lower average score of 66,004, placing it in the 90th percentile.
Q: How do the two cards compare in the Geekbench OpenCL benchmark?
A: The AMD Radeon VII wins the head-to-head Geekbench OpenCL test with a score of 91,947, which is 13.4% higher than the Tesla P100's score of 79,605. This is the only direct benchmark comparison available in the data.
Q: What are the nearest rivals for each card based on average score?
A: The Tesla P100's closest rivals include the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB (0.3% lower score), the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5090 (0.3% higher score), and the AMD Radeon RX 6850M XT (0.8% lower score). The Radeon VII's closest rivals include the NVIDIA Tesla T4 (1.1% lower score), the NVIDIA Tesla P40 (1.4% higher score), and the AMD Radeon Pro WX 9100 (2.8% higher score).
Q: Which card has a higher transistor density?
A: The AMD Radeon VII, built on a 7 nm process, achieves a transistor density of 40.0M per mm². The NVIDIA Tesla P100, built on a 16 nm process, has a lower density of 25.1M per mm².
Q: Do both cards support the same graphics APIs?
A: Yes, both cards support DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3. However, the Radeon VII also has a Geekbench Metal score of 77,975, indicating macOS compatibility, while the Tesla P100 has no display outputs.
Q: What is the memory bandwidth difference between the two cards?
A: The AMD Radeon VII has a memory bandwidth of 1.02 TB/s, which is significantly higher than the NVIDIA Tesla P100's 732.2 GB/s. Both cards use 16 GB of HBM2 memory with a 4096-bit bus width.
Architecture Differences
The architectural gap between these two cards is substantial, reflecting their different release timelines and design goals. The NVIDIA Tesla P100 is built on the Pascal architecture using the GP100 chip, manufactured on a 16 nm process at TSMC. It packs 15,300 million transistors onto a 610 mm² die, resulting in a transistor density of 25.1M per mm². In contrast, the AMD Radeon VII uses the Vega 20 chip with the GCN 5.1 architecture, fabricated on a much more advanced 7 nm process. This allows AMD to fit 13,230 million transistors onto a smaller 331 mm² die, achieving a significantly higher density of 40.0M per mm².
The compute configurations differ as well. The Radeon VII has 3,840 shading units, 240 texture mapping units, and 64 ROPs. The Tesla P100 has fewer shading units at 3,584, fewer TMUs at 224, but more ROPs at 96. Neither card features dedicated ray tracing or tensor cores, as both predate those hardware additions. The Pascal architecture in the Tesla P100 is older, belonging to the Tesla Pascal generation with a predecessor of Tesla Maxwell and a successor of Tesla Volta. The Radeon VII belongs to the Vega II generation, succeeding Vega and preceding Navi.
Power delivery and physical design also differ. The Tesla P100 has a TDP of 250 W and requires a single 8-pin power connector, while the Radeon VII draws more power at 295 W and needs two 8-pin connectors. Both are dual-slot cards with a PCIe 3.0 x16 interface. The Tesla P100 is longer at 267 mm (10.5 inches) but has no display outputs, whereas the Radeon VII is 280 mm (11 inches) long, 125 mm tall, and 40 mm wide, offering 1x HDMI 2.0b and 3x DisplayPort 1.4a outputs.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The only direct head-to-head benchmark available is Geekbench OpenCL, and the results show a decisive win for the AMD Radeon VII. The Radeon VII scores 91,947, while the NVIDIA Tesla P100 scores 79,605, giving AMD a 13.4% advantage. This is a meaningful gap in raw compute performance, consistent with the Radeon VII's higher peak FP32 throughput of 13.44 TFLOPS compared to the Tesla P100's 9.526 TFLOPS.
However, the average benchmark scores tell a different story. The Tesla P100's average score of 79,605 is higher than the Radeon VII's average of 66,004. This discrepancy arises because the Radeon VII's average includes multiple benchmark results, including a 3DMark Steel Nomad DX12 score of 2,304, a Geekbench Metal score of 77,975, and a Geekbench Vulkan score of 91,788. The Metal and Vulkan scores are close to the OpenCL result, but the low 3DMark score drags the average down.
The Tesla P100's nearest rival data shows it is tightly clustered with the RTX 5090, which scores 79,842 (0.3% higher), and the Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB, which scores 79,396 (0.3% lower). This indicates the 16 GB Tesla P100 sits right at the top of its immediate performance tier. The Radeon VII, meanwhile, sits in a lower tier, with its nearest rival the Tesla T4 scoring 66,733 (1.1% lower) and the Tesla P40 scoring 65,095 (1.4% higher).
Specification Differences
The two cards differ across several key specification fields. The manufacturing process is a major differentiator: the Tesla P100 uses 16 nm, while the Radeon VII uses 7 nm. This leads to differences in die size (610 mm² for NVIDIA vs 331 mm² for AMD) and transistor density (25.1M vs 40.0M per mm²), though the Tesla P100 has more total transistors at 15,300 million versus 13,230 million.
Clock speeds also favor the Radeon VII. Its base clock is 1400 MHz with a boost clock of 1750 MHz, while the Tesla P100 runs at 1190 MHz base and 1329 MHz boost. Memory clocks differ as well, with the Radeon VII running at 1000 MHz (2 Gbps effective) versus the Tesla P100's 715 MHz (1430 Mbps effective). This contributes to the bandwidth gap: 1.02 TB/s for AMD versus 732.2 GB/s for NVIDIA.
Compute unit counts vary: the Radeon VII has 3,840 shading units, 240 TMUs, and 64 ROPs, while the Tesla P100 has 3,584 shading units, 224 TMUs, and 96 ROPs. The pixel rate is higher on the Tesla P100 at 127.6 GPixel/s versus 112.0 GPixel/s, but the texture rate is higher on the Radeon VII at 420.0 GTexel/s versus 297.7 GTexel/s. FP32 and FP16 performance both favor AMD: 13.44 TFLOPS vs 9.526 TFLOPS and 26.88 TFLOPS vs 19.05 TFLOPS, respectively.
Power specs differ: the Tesla P100 has a 250 W TDP with a single 8-pin connector, while the Radeon VII has a 295 W TDP with dual 8-pin connectors. Both recommend a 600 W PSU. Physical dimensions and display outputs also differ, with the Radeon VII offering full video outputs while the Tesla P100 has none. Release dates are far apart, with the Tesla P100 launching on June 19, 2016, and the Radeon VII on February 6, 2019.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Radeon VII wins decisively in raw compute performance. Its 13.44 TFLOPS FP32 and 26.88 TFLOPS FP16 figures are 41% and 41% higher than the Tesla P100's respective numbers. The 13.4% lead in Geekbench OpenCL confirms this advantage in real-world compute workloads. The Radeon VII also wins on memory bandwidth with 1.02 TB/s, a 39% improvement over the Tesla P100's 732.2 GB/s. For tasks that are memory-bandwidth bound or rely heavily on FP32/FP16 throughput, the Radeon VII is the clear choice. It also has the advantage of display outputs, making it usable in a workstation with monitors attached.
The NVIDIA Tesla P100 wins on several other fronts. Its average benchmark score of 79,605 is 20.6% higher than the Radeon VII's 66,004, placing it in the 92nd percentile versus the 90th. This suggests that across a broader range of workloads not covered by the limited head-to-head test, the Tesla P100 maintains a higher overall performance level. It also has a higher pixel rate (127.6 GPixel/s vs 112.0 GPixel/s) and more ROPs (96 vs 64), which could favor certain rasterization-heavy tasks. The Tesla P100's lower TDP of 250 W versus 295 W means it draws less power, and its single 8-pin connector simplifies installation. For a data center or compute server environment where display output is irrelevant and power efficiency matters, the Tesla P100 holds advantages.
The Verdict
The choice between these two cards depends entirely on the workload. If the primary application is compute-heavy, particularly involving FP32 or FP16 math, the AMD Radeon VII is the superior option based on the data. It delivers 41% higher FP32 throughput, 41% higher FP16 throughput, 39% more memory bandwidth, and wins the only available head-to-head benchmark by 13.4%. The Radeon VII also has the flexibility of display outputs, making it suitable for a workstation that needs both compute and visual output.
If the workload is diverse or favors higher pixel throughput, the NVIDIA Tesla P100 is the better pick. Its higher average benchmark score of 79,605 versus 66,004 indicates it maintains stronger performance across a broader benchmark suite. The 92nd percentile ranking versus the 90th suggests it sits higher in the overall GPU hierarchy. The Tesla P100 also consumes less power (250 W vs 295 W) and requires only a single 8-pin power connector, which may simplify deployment in power-constrained environments.
The launch MSRP of the Tesla P100 was 5,699 USD, while the Radeon VII launched at 699 USD. This price difference is substantial, but the performance data shows the Radeon VII offers far higher compute performance per dollar. However, the Tesla P100's higher average score and percentile ranking indicate it may be more consistent across varied tasks. Ultimately, the Radeon VII is the compute specialist, while the Tesla P100 is the more balanced, all-around performer.