AMD Radeon VII vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB Comparison
AMD Radeon VII
Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Radeon VII vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB
The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB and the AMD Radeon VII are two end-of-life accelerators from different design philosophies. The data shows a clear performance divide in the single shared benchmark, but the specifications reveal why each card was built for a distinct purpose. The Tesla P100, a 2016 compute card, relies on a larger die and older process, while the 2019 Radeon VII uses a denser, newer node to deliver higher raw throughput.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The only direct benchmark comparison available is the Geekbench OpenCL test. In this test, the AMD Radeon VII scores 91,947 points, while the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB scores 79,396 points. The delta is -13.7% in favor of the Radeon VII. This means the Radeon VII is roughly 15.8% faster than the Tesla P100 in this synthetic compute workload, a substantial lead for a single test. The Tesla P100’s score places it in the 92nd percentile of all GPUs, while the Radeon VII sits slightly lower at the 90th percentile, yet the Radeon still wins the head-to-head.
Looking at the broader context, the Tesla P100’s average benchmark score is 79,396, which is nearly identical to its OpenCL result. Its closest rival, the Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB, scores 79,605, a mere -0.3% difference, indicating that the 12 GB version is essentially on par with its higher-capacity sibling. The Radeon VII’s average score is 66,004, pulled down by other tests, but its OpenCL score of 91,947 is its strongest result. In that specific test, the Radeon VII outperforms the Tesla P100 by a clear margin, even though the Tesla’s percentile ranking is higher overall.
The Radeon VII also demonstrates versatility with multiple benchmark entries: it scores 77,975 in Geekbench Metal, 91,788 in Geekbench Vulkan, and 2,304 in 3DMark Steel Nomad DX12. These scores show a strong cross-API performance profile, whereas the Tesla P100 only has a single OpenCL result in the data. The lack of a second benchmark for the Tesla makes direct comparisons limited, but the OpenCL result is decisive: the Radeon VII wins the only head-to-head test.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Radeon VII wins the sole head-to-head benchmark, the Geekbench OpenCL test, with a -13.7% delta over the Tesla P100. This suggests that in raw compute tasks leveraging OpenCL, the Radeon VII holds a significant advantage. Its higher FP32 throughput of 13.44 TFLOPS versus the Tesla’s 9.526 TFLOPS supports this result, indicating that the Radeon VII is better suited for general-purpose compute workloads that rely on single-precision floating-point math.
The NVIDIA Tesla P100, however, wins in terms of relative standing. Its 92nd percentile versus the Radeon VII’s 90th percentile indicates that, across all GPUs in the database, the Tesla scores higher relative to its peers. This is likely because the Tesla’s single score is consistent, while the Radeon VII’s average is diluted by weaker results in other tests (e.g., Metal and Vulkan scores are lower than its OpenCL). The Tesla also has a higher pixel rate of 127.6 GPixel/s versus the Radeon VII’s 112.0 GPixel/s, suggesting that the Tesla may excel in rasterization-bound tasks, despite having fewer ROPs (96 vs 64).
For memory-bound workloads, the Radeon VII is the clear winner. It offers 16 GB of HBM2 memory with a 1.02 TB/s bandwidth, while the Tesla P100 provides 12 GB with 549.1 GB/s. This nearly doubles the memory bandwidth, which is critical for large datasets and high-resolution workloads. The Radeon VII also has a wider 4096-bit bus versus the Tesla’s 3072-bit bus, reinforcing its advantage in data-intensive scenarios.
Architecture Differences
The two cards are built on fundamentally different architectures. The Tesla P100 uses the GP100 chip with NVIDIA’s Pascal architecture on a 16 nm process from TSMC. It packs 15,300 million transistors on a 610 mm² die, resulting in a transistor density of 25.1M / mm². The Radeon VII uses the Vega 20 chip with AMD’s GCN 5.1 architecture on a 7 nm process, also from TSMC. It has 13,230 million transistors on a much smaller 331 mm² die, achieving a density of 40.0M / mm². The newer node allows AMD to fit fewer transistors in a smaller area, but with higher density.
The shader configurations differ notably. The Tesla P100 has 3,584 shading units, 224 texture mapping units (TMUs), and 96 raster output units (ROPs). The Radeon VII has more shading units at 3,840, more TMUs at 240, but significantly fewer ROPs at 64. This explains the Tesla’s higher pixel rate despite the Radeon’s higher texture rate (420.0 GTexel/s vs 297.7 GTexel/s). The Radeon VII’s extra shading units and TMUs contribute to its higher FP32 and FP16 throughput, which are 13.44 TFLOPS and 26.88 TFLOPS respectively, versus the Tesla’s 9.526 TFLOPS and 19.05 TFLOPS.
Memory architecture also diverges. The Tesla P100 uses 12 GB of HBM2 with a 3072-bit bus and 549.1 GB/s bandwidth, clocked at 715 MHz (effective 1430 Mbps). The Radeon VII uses 16 GB of HBM2 with a 4096-bit bus and 1.02 TB/s bandwidth, clocked at 1000 MHz (effective 2 Gbps). Both support DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3, but the Radeon VII adds display outputs (1x HDMI 2.0b and 3x DisplayPort 1.4a), while the Tesla has no outputs. The Tesla’s power draw is lower at 250 W versus the Radeon’s 295 W, with a single 8-pin connector versus dual 8-pin.
FAQ
Q: Which GPU has higher memory bandwidth?
A: The AMD Radeon VII has a bandwidth of 1.02 TB/s, which is nearly double the Tesla P100’s 549.1 GB/s. The Radeon VII also has a wider 4096-bit bus versus the Tesla’s 3072-bit bus.
Q: Does the Radeon VII have more shading units than the Tesla P100?
A: Yes, the Radeon VII has 3,840 shading units, while the Tesla P100 has 3,584. The Radeon VII also has more TMUs (240 vs 224), but fewer ROPs (64 vs 96).
Q: What is the performance delta in the Geekbench OpenCL test?
A: The AMD Radeon VII scores 91,947 versus the Tesla P100’s 79,396, resulting in a -13.7% delta in favor of the Radeon VII. This means the Radeon VII is about 15.8% faster in that specific test.
Q: Which card has a higher transistor density?
A: The Radeon VII has a transistor density of 40.0M / mm² on its 7 nm process, while the Tesla P100 has 25.1M / mm² on its 16 nm process. The Radeon VII’s die is also smaller at 331 mm² versus 610 mm².
Q: Can the Tesla P100 output video to a display?
A: No, the Tesla P100 has no display outputs. The Radeon VII includes 1x HDMI 2.0b and 3x DisplayPort 1.4a outputs.
Q: How do their percentile rankings compare?
A: The Tesla P100 is in the 92nd percentile of all GPUs, while the Radeon VII is in the 90th percentile. Despite the Radeon VII winning the OpenCL test, the Tesla ranks higher overall.
The Verdict
The data points to the AMD Radeon VII as the stronger choice for general compute performance. It wins the only head-to-head benchmark with a -13.7% delta, offers 13.44 TFLOPS of FP32 performance versus the Tesla’s 9.526 TFLOPS, and has double the memory bandwidth at 1.02 TB/s. For workloads like machine learning inference or data processing that rely on OpenCL and large memory pools, the Radeon VII’s 16 GB capacity and higher throughput make it the better pick. Its additional display outputs also add flexibility for mixed-use environments.
The NVIDIA Tesla P100, however, holds advantages in specific areas. Its higher pixel rate of 127.6 GPixel/s and more ROPs (96 vs 64) suggest it may be better for certain graphics or rasterization tasks, despite its older architecture. Its lower power draw of 250 W versus 295 W and single 8-pin connector make it easier to integrate into existing power envelopes. The Tesla also has a higher percentile ranking (92nd vs 90th), indicating it performs better relative to its peers in the database.
Choosing between them depends on the workload. For raw compute throughput and memory capacity, the Radeon VII is the data-driven winner. For rasterization-bound tasks or power-constrained deployments, the Tesla P100’s architecture and efficiency make it a viable alternative, even if its raw scores lag.
Specification Differences
| Specification | NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB | AMD Radeon VII |
|----------------|-------------------------------|-----------------|
| Chip | GP100 | Vega 20 |
| Architecture | Pascal | GCN 5.1 |
| Process Node | 16 nm | 7 nm |
| Transistors | 15,300 million | 13,230 million |
| Die Size | 610 mm² | 331 mm² |
| Transistor Density | 25.1M / mm² | 40.0M / mm² |
| Base Clock | 1190 MHz | 1400 MHz |
| Boost Clock | 1329 MHz | 1750 MHz |
| Memory Clock | 715 MHz / 1430 Mbps effective | 1000 MHz / 2 Gbps effective |
| Memory Size | 12 GB | 16 GB |
| Memory Bus Width | 3072 bit | 4096 bit |
| Memory Bandwidth | 549.1 GB/s | 1.02 TB/s |
| Shading Units | 3584 | 3840 |
| TMUs | 224 | 240 |
| ROPs | 96 | 64 |
| Pixel Rate | 127.6 GPixel/s | 112.0 GPixel/s |
| Texture Rate | 297.7 GTexel/s | 420.0 GTexel/s |
| FP32 Performance | 9.526 TFLOPS | 13.44 TFLOPS |
| FP16 Performance | 19.05 TFLOPS (2:1) | 26.88 TFLOPS (2:1) |
| TDP | 250 W | 295 W |
| Power Connectors | 1x 8-pin | 2x 8-pin |
| Display Outputs | No outputs | 1x HDMI 2.0b, 3x DisplayPort 1.4a |
| Length | 267 mm (10.5 inches) | 280 mm (11 inches) |
| Height | Not specified | 125 mm (4.9 inches) |
| Width | Not specified | 40 mm (1.6 inches) |
| Launch MSRP | 4,599 USD | 699 USD |