AMD Radeon PRO W6400 vs NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB Comparison
AMD Radeon PRO W6400
Tesla M40 24 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Radeon PRO W6400 vs NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB
The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB and the AMD Radeon PRO W6400 represent two distinct approaches to professional graphics, separated by over six years of architectural evolution. The data shows a clear, albeit nuanced, performance hierarchy, with the older Tesla M40 taking the overall benchmark crown while the newer Radeon PRO W6400 counters with superior efficiency and modern feature support. This analysis breaks down the head-to-head results, architectural philosophies, and where each card stands in the current landscape.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The benchmark results are unequivocal in favor of the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB, which secures victories in both available tests. In the Geekbench OpenCL workload, the Tesla M40 scores 37,439 points against the Radeon PRO W6400's 35,027 points, resulting in a 6.9% lead for the NVIDIA card. This advantage expands significantly in the Vulkan API test, where the Tesla M40 achieves 45,975 points compared to the W6400's 39,286 points, a substantial 17% delta. The average benchmark score across both tests reinforces this pattern, with the Tesla M40 averaging 41,707 points versus the W6400's 37,157 points.
To contextualize the Tesla M40's performance, its average score of 41,707 places it in the 83rd percentile of all GPUs. Its nearest rivals in the database include the NVIDIA Tesla M40 (non-24GB variant) with an average score of 41,897, a negligible -0.5% difference, and the AMD Radeon RX 7650 GRE at 42,723, which is 2.4% faster. Even the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3080 Ti, a formidable consumer card, sits just 1.3% behind the Tesla M40 in this metric, with a score of 41,187. This indicates that despite its age, the Tesla M40's raw compute power remains highly competitive.
Conversely, the Radeon PRO W6400's average score of 37,157 places it in the 80th percentile. Its rival set is equally revealing: the AMD Radeon RX Vega 56 scores 37,507 (-0.9%), the NVIDIA Tesla P4 scores 37,628 (-1.3%), and the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4070 scores 37,648 (-1.3%). The only rival it beats is the NVIDIA GeForce GTX TITAN X, which scores 36,530, a 1.7% deficit. The tight clustering of scores around the W6400 suggests it delivers consistent, mid-range performance that is only marginally differentiated from its closest competitors.
In the specific head-to-head comparison, the Tesla M40's Vulkan win is particularly noteworthy. A 17% delta in Vulkan indicates the NVIDIA architecture handles this modern API's command and memory management patterns more efficiently, or that its larger memory subsystem provides a distinct advantage in the test's workload. The OpenCL gap of 6.9% is more modest, but still decisive. Overall, the data shows the Tesla M40 winning both tests, for a 2-0 win count, with the average delta across the two tests being approximately 12%.
The Verdict
Based strictly on the benchmark data, the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB is the superior performer. It wins both synthetic tests with margins ranging from 6.9% to 17%, and its average score places it in a higher performance tier relative to the rest of the database. The Radeon PRO W6400, while competitive within its own peer group, simply cannot match the raw compute throughput of the Tesla M40.
The choice between these two cards, however, is not solely about benchmark scores. The data reveals that the Tesla M40 achieves its performance with a 250W TDP, while the W6400 sips power at just 50W. This is a five-fold difference in power consumption. For a workstation or server environment where power density and cooling are primary constraints, the W6400's efficiency is a compelling operational advantage. The Tesla M40 also requires a dual-slot form factor and an 8-pin EPS power connector, whereas the W6400 is a single-slot card with no external power connectors, making it far easier to install in a wider range of chassis.
Therefore, the verdict is split by use case. The data indicates that users who prioritize maximum compute performance and have the power and cooling headroom should select the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB. Conversely, users who require a low-power, single-slot solution that is easy to deploy, and who can accept a 17% or less performance deficit in the tested workloads, would find the AMD Radeon PRO W6400 to be the more practical choice. The W6400's modern architecture also brings features to the table that the Tesla M40 lacks, which are critical for certain software environments.
FAQ
Q: Which GPU has the higher average benchmark score?
A: The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB has a higher average benchmark score of 41,707, compared to the AMD Radeon PRO W6400's average of 37,157.
Q: By how much does the Tesla M40 win the Vulkan benchmark?
A: The Tesla M40 wins the Geekbench Vulkan test with a score of 45,975 against the W6400's 39,286, a difference of 17%.
Q: What is the performance delta in the OpenCL benchmark?
A: The Tesla M40 leads the OpenCL test with 37,439 points versus 35,027 for the W6400, resulting in a 6.9% advantage.
Q: How does the Tesla M40 compare to the GeForce RTX 3080 Ti?
A: The Tesla M40's average score of 41,707 is 1.3% higher than the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3080 Ti's average score of 41,187.
Q: Is the Radeon PRO W6400 faster than the GeForce GTX TITAN X?
A: Yes, the W6400's average score of 37,157 is 1.7% higher than the GeForce GTX TITAN X's average score of 36,530.
Q: What is the power consumption difference between the two cards?
A: The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB has a TDP of 250 W, while the AMD Radeon PRO W6400 has a TDP of just 50 W.
Specification Differences
The specification sheets reveal stark contrasts that explain the benchmark results. The most obvious difference is memory: the Tesla M40 is equipped with 24 GB of GDDR5 memory on a 384-bit bus, providing a bandwidth of 288.4 GB/s. In contrast, the W6400 has only 4 GB of GDDR6 memory on a 64-bit bus, yielding a bandwidth of 128.0 GB/s. The Tesla M40's memory bandwidth is more than double that of the W6400, a significant factor in compute-heavy workloads.
Core configurations also diverge dramatically. The Tesla M40 features 3,072 shading units, 192 texture mapping units (TMUs), and 96 render output units (ROPs). The W6400 is far more modest, with 768 shading units, 48 TMUs, and 32 ROPs. This explains the Tesla M40's higher pixel rate of 106.8 GPixel/s and texture rate of 213.5 GTexel/s, compared to the W6400's 74.27 GPixel/s and 111.4 GTexel/s, respectively. In terms of raw FP32 compute, the Tesla M40 delivers 6.832 TFLOPS, while the W6400 offers 3.565 TFLOPS.
Clock speeds, however, are where the newer card excels. The W6400 has a base clock of 2039 MHz and a boost clock of 2321 MHz, far exceeding the Tesla M40's 948 MHz base and 1112 MHz boost. This high clock speed is a hallmark of the newer manufacturing process. The memory clocks also differ, with the W6400 running at 2000 MHz (16 Gbps effective) versus the Tesla M40's 1502 MHz (6 Gbps effective). Power consumption is another major differentiator: the Tesla M40 is rated at 250 W with a suggested 600 W PSU, while the W6400 is rated at just 50 W with a suggested 250 W PSU. Finally, the bus interfaces differ, with the Tesla M40 using PCIe 3.0 x16 and the W6400 using PCIe 4.0 x4.
Architecture Differences
The architectural chasm between these two GPUs is vast, reflecting their different eras and design goals. The NVIDIA Tesla M40 is built on the Maxwell 2.0 architecture, using the GM200 chip fabricated on a 28 nm process at TSMC. This chip contains 8,000 million transistors on a large 601 mm² die, resulting in a transistor density of 13.3M / mm². It is a compute-optimized design from the Tesla Maxwell generation, with no dedicated ray tracing or tensor cores.
The AMD Radeon PRO W6400, on the other hand, is based on the RDNA 2.0 architecture, using the Navi 24 chip manufactured on a 6 nm process, also at TSMC. This process is significantly more advanced, allowing AMD to pack 5,400 million transistors into a tiny 107 mm² die, achieving a transistor density of 50.5M / mm². This is nearly four times denser than the Tesla M40. The RDNA 2.0 architecture brings modern features to the table, including 12 dedicated ray tracing cores. It also supports FP16 computation at a 2:1 rate, delivering 7.130 TFLOPS, a feature the Tesla M40 lacks entirely.
The API support also differentiates the two. The W6400 supports DirectX 12 Ultimate (12_2), which includes features like mesh shaders and variable rate shading, while the Tesla M40 is limited to DirectX 12 (12_1). Both support OpenGL 4.6 and Vulkan 1.4. The display outputs are another key difference: the W6400 has 2x DisplayPort 1.4a outputs, while the Tesla M40 has no display outputs at all, underscoring its purpose as a compute or server accelerator. The Tesla M40's predecessor is listed as Tesla Kepler, with a successor in Tesla Pascal, while the W6400's predecessor is the Radeon Pro Vega, with no successor listed.
Where Each One Wins
Based on the data, the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB is the clear winner in scenarios demanding maximum raw compute throughput and memory capacity. Its 24 GB frame buffer and 288.4 GB/s bandwidth make it suitable for large dataset processing, deep learning inference, or rendering tasks that require massive memory residency. The benchmark data shows it is particularly strong in Vulkan workloads, where its 17% lead indicates a robust driver and architecture for that API. Its performance percentile of 83 and its closeness to cards like the RTX 3080 Ti suggest it can handle demanding professional applications that are not bound by power constraints. It is the choice for users who need the absolute highest compute performance in this comparison.
The AMD Radeon PRO W6400 wins in scenarios where efficiency, physical footprint, and modern feature support are paramount. Its 50 W TDP, single-slot design, and lack of external power connectors make it ideal for dense, multi-GPU workstations, low-profile systems, or environments with limited airflow and power budgets. The presence of ray tracing cores and DirectX 12 Ultimate support means it is better positioned for applications that leverage these modern graphics APIs, even if its overall FP32 performance is lower. Its PCIe 4.0 x4 interface, while narrower, is newer and offers higher per-lane bandwidth than the Tesla M40's PCIe 3.0 x16. For a professional user whose software stack utilizes ray tracing or who requires a silent, low-power solution, the W6400 is the data-supported choice, despite losing the synthetic benchmark battle.