AMD Radeon Pro 575X vs NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB Comparison
AMD Radeon Pro 575X
Tesla M40 24 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Radeon Pro 575X vs NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The benchmark data presents a clear picture of performance hierarchy between these two workstation-oriented GPUs. In the Geekbench OpenCL test, the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB scores 37,439 against the AMD Radeon Pro 575X’s 34,773, giving NVIDIA a 7.7% lead. This is a meaningful margin in compute workloads, though not overwhelming. The gap widens substantially in the Vulkan test, where the Tesla M40 reaches 45,975 while the Radeon Pro 575X manages 37,919 — a 21.2% advantage for NVIDIA. That second result is the single largest delta across all head-to-head comparisons, and it suggests the Maxwell architecture handles Vulkan’s lower-level API overhead more efficiently than GCN 4.0 in this configuration.
Looking at aggregate scores, the Tesla M40 averages 41,707 across its two benchmark entries, while the Radeon Pro 575X averages 39,116 across three entries. The NVIDIA card lands in the 83rd percentile of all GPUs, barely ahead of the Radeon Pro 575X’s 82nd percentile. That one-point percentile difference masks a more significant performance gap in the head-to-head tests. The Radeon Pro 575X does have one benchmark the Tesla M40 lacks — a Geekbench Metal score of 44,655 — which boosts its average but also reflects a platform-specific API that the Tesla card cannot access due to its lack of display outputs.
The NVIDIA card’s nearest rivals include the non-24GB Tesla M40 at -0.5% delta, the GeForce RTX 3080 Ti at +1.3%, and the Radeon Pro 5300 at +2%. The AMD card’s closest competition includes the Radeon Pro 580X at +1.1%, the GeForce MX570 A at +1.1%, and the Radeon Pro 575 at -1.1%. These rival positions confirm that both cards sit in a similar performance tier overall, despite their architectural differences. The Tesla M40’s 21.2% Vulkan win is the outlier that pushes its average higher, while the Radeon Pro 575X’s Metal score provides a counterweight that keeps its percentile competitive.
The Verdict
The data dictates a straightforward conclusion for compute-heavy users: the NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB wins both head-to-head benchmarks, and wins them by margins that grow from moderate to substantial depending on the API. For OpenCL workloads, the 7.7% advantage is real but not transformative; for Vulkan workloads, the 21.2% lead is decisive. A user prioritizing raw compute performance in these two APIs should select the Tesla M40 without hesitation.
However, the Radeon Pro 575X has its own claim. Its 44,655 Metal score is a data point the Tesla M40 cannot match, because the NVIDIA card has no display outputs and thus cannot run Metal benchmarks in any practical sense. The Radeon Pro 575X also carries a lower 150 W TDP versus the Tesla M40’s 250 W, and it is an IGP form factor with no power connectors, making it suitable for portable or integrated systems. The Tesla M40 requires an 8-pin EPS connector and a 600 W suggested PSU, which constrains its deployment.
The verdict splits cleanly along use-case lines. A workstation with available power budget and PCIe slots, running OpenCL or Vulkan compute tasks, gets better performance from the Tesla M40. A Mac-based or portable system that relies on Metal, or a chassis with limited power delivery, should use the Radeon Pro 575X. The percentile difference (83 vs 82) is too small to override these practical considerations, but the head-to-head deltas are not.
Architecture Differences
The two GPUs come from fundamentally different design philosophies. The NVIDIA Tesla M40 uses the GM200 chip on the Maxwell 2.0 architecture, fabricated on a 28 nm process at TSMC. The AMD Radeon Pro 575X uses the Ellesmere chip on GCN 4.0, built on a 14 nm process at GlobalFoundries. The process node difference is stark: 28 nm versus 14 nm, which explains why the Tesla M40 has a 601 mm² die despite packing 8,000 million transistors, while the Radeon Pro 575X fits 5,700 million transistors into just 232 mm². Transistor density tells the story — the AMD card achieves 24.6 million transistors per square millimeter, nearly double the Tesla M40’s 13.3M / mm².
The shading unit counts differ significantly: the Tesla M40 has 3,072 shading units, 192 texture mapping units, and 96 ROPs. The Radeon Pro 575X has 2,048 shading units, 128 TMUs, and just 32 ROPs. This ROP disparity is notable — the Tesla M40 has three times the ROP count, which contributes to its 106.8 GPixel/s pixel rate versus the Radeon Pro 575X’s 35.07 GPixel/s. Texture rates also favor NVIDIA: 213.5 GTexel/s versus 140.3 GTexel/s. The FP32 compute figures follow suit: 6.832 TFLOPS for the Tesla M40 against 4.489 TFLOPS for the Radeon Pro 575X. Notably, the AMD card lists FP16 at 4.489 TFLOPS (1:1), while the NVIDIA card has no FP16 data in the pack.
API support differs at the margins. The Tesla M40 supports DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.4. The Radeon Pro 575X supports DirectX 12 (12_0), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3. The Vulkan version difference (1.4 vs 1.3) may partially explain the Tesla M40’s strong Vulkan benchmark showing. The NVIDIA card’s Maxwell 2.0 architecture is older in release timing but appears better optimized for the newer Vulkan revision in this data.
Specification Differences
Memory configuration is a major differentiator. The Tesla M40 carries 24 GB of GDDR5 on a 384-bit bus, yielding 288.4 GB/s of bandwidth. The Radeon Pro 575X has 4 GB of GDDR5 on a 256-bit bus, producing 217.0 GB/s. The memory clock speeds reflect the architecture generation: the Tesla M40 runs at 1502 MHz (6 Gbps effective), while the Radeon Pro 575X runs at 1695 MHz (6.8 Gbps effective). Despite the AMD card’s higher memory clock, its narrower bus limits total bandwidth to about 75% of the NVIDIA card’s throughput.
Clock speeds for the computing cores are listed only for the Tesla M40: 948 MHz base and 1112 MHz boost. The Radeon Pro 575X has no base or boost clock figures in the pack. Power requirements diverge sharply: the Tesla M40 draws 250 W TDP and needs an 8-pin EPS connector with a 600 W suggested PSU, while the Radeon Pro 575X draws 150 W TDP with no power connectors and no suggested PSU listed. The form factors differ completely — the Tesla M40 is a dual-slot card measuring 267 mm (10.5 inches) in length, while the Radeon Pro 575X is an IGP (integrated graphics processor) with no dimensions listed.
Display outputs are another binary split. The Tesla M40 has no outputs whatsoever, making it a pure compute accelerator. The Radeon Pro 575X has “Portable Device Dependent” outputs, meaning it can drive displays in the portable systems where it is deployed. The bus interface is PCIe 3.0 x16 for both. Production status is end-of-life for both cards, but release dates differ: the Tesla M40 launched in November 2015, while the Radeon Pro 575X launched in March 2019. Neither card has a launch MSRP in the data.
FAQ
Q: Which GPU has higher raw compute performance in FP32?
A: The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB achieves 6.832 TFLOPS FP32, which is 52% higher than the AMD Radeon Pro 575X’s 4.489 TFLOPS.
Q: Does the Radeon Pro 575X support any API that the Tesla M40 cannot use?
A: Yes, the Radeon Pro 575X has a Geekbench Metal score of 44,655, and the Tesla M40 has no display outputs, making Metal benchmarking impractical on that card.
Q: What is the memory bandwidth difference between the two cards?
A: The Tesla M40 provides 288.4 GB/s over a 384-bit bus, while the Radeon Pro 575X provides 217.0 GB/s over a 256-bit bus — a 32.9% advantage for the NVIDIA card.
Q: Which GPU requires less power and is easier to install?
A: The Radeon Pro 575X draws 150 W TDP, has no power connectors, and is an IGP form factor. The Tesla M40 draws 250 W TDP, requires an 8-pin EPS connector and a 600 W suggested PSU, and is a dual-slot card.
Q: How do the two cards compare in Vulkan performance?
A: The Tesla M40 scores 45,975 in Geekbench Vulkan, which is 21.2% higher than the Radeon Pro 575X’s 37,919.
Q: What are the transistor density figures for each chip?
A: The Tesla M40’s GM200 chip has 13.3 million transistors per mm², while the Radeon Pro 575X’s Ellesmere chip has 24.6 million transistors per mm².
Where Each One Wins
The NVIDIA Tesla M40 24 GB wins in OpenCL compute, posting 37,439 against the Radeon Pro 575X’s 34,773. It wins more decisively in Vulkan, with a 45,975 score that beats the AMD card by 21.2%. The Tesla M40 also dominates in memory capacity (24 GB vs 4 GB), memory bandwidth (288.4 GB/s vs 217.0 GB/s), pixel rate (106.8 GPixel/s vs 35.07 GPixel/s), texture rate (213.5 GTexel/s vs 140.3 GTexel/s), and FP32 compute (6.832 TFLOPS vs 4.489 TFLOPS). Its shading unit count of 3,072 exceeds the Radeon Pro 575X’s 2,048, and its 96 ROPs triple the AMD card’s 32. For any workload that stresses compute, memory capacity, or pixel throughput, the Tesla M40 is the clear choice.
The AMD Radeon Pro 575X wins in the Metal benchmark, where it scores 44,655 — a test category the Tesla M40 cannot participate in due to having no display outputs. The Radeon Pro 575X also wins on power efficiency as measured by TDP: 150 W versus 250 W, a 40% reduction. Its 14 nm process node offers higher transistor density (24.6M / mm² vs 13.3M / mm²), and its memory clock runs faster at 1695 MHz (6.8 Gbps effective) versus the Tesla M40’s 1502 MHz (6 Gbps effective). For portable systems, integrated graphics deployments, or Metal-based macOS workflows, the Radeon Pro 575X is the appropriate selection. The AMD card also supports DirectX 12 (12_0) and Vulkan 1.3, while the Tesla M40 supports DirectX 12 (12_1) and Vulkan 1.4, so the NVIDIA card edges ahead on API version coverage.