AMD Radeon Instinct MI25 vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB Comparison
AMD Radeon Instinct MI25
Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Radeon Instinct MI25 vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB
The Verdict
The benchmark data positions the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB as the clear performance leader in this pairing, with a Geekbench OpenCL score of 79,605 against the AMD Radeon Instinct MI25’s 68,562. That is a 16.1% advantage in favor of the NVIDIA part, and it is the only head-to-head benchmark recorded between the two. The P100 also sits higher in the overall GPU landscape, ranking in the 92nd percentile of all GPUs, while the MI25 sits in the 90th percentile. Both cards are end-of-life products aimed at compute workloads, evidenced by their lack of display outputs, but the data suggests the P100 is the stronger choice for raw OpenCL compute performance. The MI25, however, offers a higher FP32 throughput on paper at 12.29 TFLOPS versus 9.526 TFLOPS, which complicates a purely score-based verdict. For buyers prioritizing the benchmark result, the P100 is the pick; for those whose workloads scale with theoretical FP32 or FP16 rates, the MI25 presents a compelling alternative despite its lower observed score.
Architecture Differences
The two accelerators come from different architectural lineages and process nodes. The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB is built on the Pascal architecture, specifically the GP100 chip, manufactured on a 16 nm process at TSMC. It packs 15,300 million transistors into a 610 mm² die, yielding a transistor density of 25.1 million per mm². In contrast, the AMD Radeon Instinct MI25 uses the GCN 5.0 architecture with the Vega 10 chip, fabricated on a 14 nm process at GlobalFoundries. The MI25 contains 12,500 million transistors on a 495 mm² die, with a slightly higher transistor density of 25.3 million per mm². Despite the smaller transistor count, the MI25 fields more shading units — 4,096 versus 3,584 — and more texture mapping units, 256 versus 224. The P100 counters with more ROPs, 96 versus 64, which impacts pixel throughput.
Memory subsystems differ substantially. Both cards use 16 GB of HBM2, but the P100 employs a 4096-bit bus width delivering 732.2 GB/s of bandwidth, while the MI25 uses a narrower 2048-bit bus yielding 436.2 GB/s. That is a 67.8% bandwidth advantage for the P100, which likely contributes to its benchmark lead. Clock speeds tell the opposite story: the MI25 runs at a base of 1400 MHz and boost of 1500 MHz, compared to the P100’s 1190 MHz base and 1329 MHz boost. The MI25’s memory clock is also higher at 852 MHz (1704 Mbps effective) versus the P100’s 715 MHz (1430 Mbps effective). Theoretical compute rates favor the MI25 in raw FLOPs: it delivers 12.29 TFLOPS FP32 and 24.58 TFLOPS FP16 (2:1), while the P100 delivers 9.526 TFLOPS FP32 and 19.05 TFLOPS FP16 (2:1). The MI25 achieves higher texture fill rate at 384.0 GTexel/s versus 297.7 GTexel/s, but the P100 wins on pixel rate, 127.6 GPixel/s versus 96.00 GPixel/s.
Power and physical characteristics also diverge. The MI25 has a 300 W TDP and requires two 8-pin power connectors, with a suggested 700 W PSU. The P100 is more efficient in this regard, drawing 250 W from a single 8-pin connector and needing a 600 W PSU. Both are dual-slot cards measuring 267 mm (10.5 inches) in length, but the MI25 adds a height dimension of 111 mm (4.4 inches), which the P100’s specs do not list. API support is identical, with DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3 on both. The P100 was released in June 2016 with a launch MSRP of 5,699 USD, while the MI25 came a year later in June 2017 with no launch MSRP listed.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The single recorded head-to-head benchmark is Geekbench OpenCL, where the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB scores 79,605 against the AMD Radeon Instinct MI25’s 68,562. The delta is 16.1% in favor of NVIDIA. This is a decisive margin, but it is important to contextualize it against the theoretical specs. The MI25’s higher FP32 and FP16 rates, along with its higher clock speeds, suggest that the benchmark may favor the P100’s memory bandwidth advantage (732.2 GB/s versus 436.2 GB/s) or its larger ROP count. The P100’s nearest rivals in the database are the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB (score 79,396, delta 0.3%), the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5090 (score 79,842, delta -0.3%), and the AMD Radeon RX 6850M XT (score 78,940, delta 0.8%). This places the P100 within a tight cluster of high-performance parts, with the AMD Radeon Pro Vega 64X leading it by 1.7% (score 80,959). The MI25’s nearest rivals are the Intel Arc A770 (score 68,809, delta -0.4%), NVIDIA CMP 90HX (score 69,000, delta -0.6%), AMD Radeon Pro WX 8200 (score 69,870, delta -1.9%), and NVIDIA Quadro P6000 (score 69,986, delta -2%). The MI25 trails all of these except the Arc A770, and the margin to the Quadro P6000 is a 2% deficit.
The wins tally reflects this: the P100 wins 1 benchmark, the MI25 wins 0. That is the entirety of the empirical comparison. The 16.1% delta is significant in the context of compute accelerators, where even small percentage differences can translate to meaningful runtime reductions in large-scale workloads. The P100’s score also places it above its 12 GB sibling by a slim 0.3%, indicating that the extra memory capacity does not dramatically alter performance in this test. The MI25’s deficit to the Quadro P6000 (2%) and Radeon Pro WX 8200 (1.9%) suggests it sits in a lower performance tier, though its 90th percentile ranking still places it above the vast majority of GPUs.
FAQ
Q: Which card has the higher Geekbench OpenCL score?
A: The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB scores 79,605, which is 16.1% higher than the AMD Radeon Instinct MI25’s 68,562.
Q: Does the AMD card have any theoretical compute advantage?
A: Yes, the MI25 lists higher FP32 throughput at 12.29 TFLOPS versus 9.526 TFLOPS for the P100, and higher FP16 at 24.58 TFLOPS versus 19.05 TFLOPS, both at a 2:1 ratio.
Q: How do the memory bandwidth figures compare?
A: The P100 has a 4096-bit bus with 732.2 GB/s bandwidth, while the MI25 has a 2048-bit bus with 436.2 GB/s. The P100’s bandwidth is roughly 67.8% higher.
Q: What are the power requirements for each card?
A: The P100 has a 250 W TDP with a single 8-pin connector and a suggested 600 W PSU. The MI25 has a 300 W TDP with two 8-pin connectors and a suggested 700 W PSU.
Q: Are there any display outputs on either card?
A: No, both the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB and the AMD Radeon Instinct MI25 have no display outputs, indicating they are intended for compute-only workloads.
Q: How does each card rank against all GPUs?
A: The P100 is in the 92nd percentile of all GPUs, while the MI25 is in the 90th percentile.
Where Each One Wins
The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB wins the only empirical benchmark available, and it does so by a commanding 16.1% margin. This makes it the default choice for any workload that closely mirrors the Geekbench OpenCL test pattern. Its memory bandwidth of 732.2 GB/s, achieved via a 4096-bit HBM2 interface, is a likely factor in this victory, as memory-bound compute tasks would benefit disproportionately. The P100 also wins on pixel rate (127.6 GPixel/s versus 96.00 GPixel/s) and power efficiency, drawing 250 W versus 300 W for the MI25. Its higher ROP count (96 versus 64) further supports rasterization-adjacent workloads. The P100’s percentile ranking of 92 versus the MI25’s 90 reinforces its position as the higher-performing part in the database’s overall hierarchy.
The AMD Radeon Instinct MI25 wins on paper in several theoretical metrics. Its FP32 throughput of 12.29 TFLOPS is 29% higher than the P100’s 9.526 TFLOPS, and its FP16 rate of 24.58 TFLOPS is 29% higher than the P100’s 19.05 TFLOPS. For workloads that are compute-bound and scale linearly with FLOPs — such as certain dense matrix operations or neural network inference — the MI25 could potentially outperform the P100 despite the benchmark result. It also has more shading units (4,096 versus 3,584) and more TMUs (256 versus 224), which could benefit texture-heavy compute shaders. The MI25’s higher clock speeds (1500 MHz boost versus 1329 MHz boost) and higher memory clock (852 MHz versus 715 MHz) suggest it can sustain higher instruction issue rates. Its texture rate of 384.0 GTexel/s is 29% higher than the P100’s 297.7 GTexel/s.
The practical split is clear: the P100 is the safer choice based on measured performance and lower power draw, while the MI25 offers a theoretical compute ceiling that might be unlocked in specific, FLOP-dominated workloads. The P100’s launch MSRP of 5,699 USD provides a reference point, but the MI25 has no such listed price. Both cards are end-of-life, so availability and driver maturity are considerations that the data does not address, but for raw OpenCL performance, the P100 is the winner in every recorded metric. The MI25’s higher FP32 and FP16 rates remain the only quantitative arguments in its favor, and they are contradicted by the 16.1% benchmark deficit.