AMD Radeon Instinct MI25 vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB Comparison

AMD
RADEON

AMD Radeon Instinct MI25

CORE STATE Vega 10
VRAM 16 GB
CLOCK SPEED 1500 MHz
TDP 300 W
BUS WIDTH 2048 bit
ARCHITECTURE GCN 5.0
nm
PROCESS 14 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2017
VS
NVIDIA
GEFORCE

Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB

CORE STATE GP100
VRAM 12 GB
CLOCK SPEED 1329 MHz
TDP 250 W
BUS WIDTH 3072 bit
ARCHITECTURE Pascal
nm
PROCESS 16 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2016

PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS

geekbench_opencl
68,562
79,396

Analysis: AMD Radeon Instinct MI25 vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB

The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB and the AMD Radeon Instinct MI25 are both end-of-life datacenter accelerators built for compute workloads, yet they deliver distinctly different levels of performance. Benchmark results from Geekbench OpenCL show a clear overall winner, but the underlying architectural and memory differences explain the gap and define where each card still holds relevance. The data shows the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB achieves an average benchmark score of 79,396, placing it in the 92nd percentile of all GPUs, while the AMD Radeon Instinct MI25 scores 68,562, landing in the 90th percentile. This 15.8% delta in favor of the NVIDIA card is the single head-to-head data point, but examining the specific hardware characteristics of both boards reveals why the performance margin exists and which workloads might still favor the AMD solution.

Head-to-Head Benchmarks

The only direct comparison available is the Geekbench OpenCL test, where the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB outscores the AMD Radeon Instinct MI25 by 15.8%. The P100's score of 79,396 versus the MI25's 68,562 is a substantial margin for a single benchmark, indicating that in general compute tasks, the NVIDIA architecture holds a decisive edge. This result is consistent with the P100's placement among its nearest rivals, which include the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB (a 0.3% higher score at 79,605), the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5090 (0.6% higher at 79,842), and the AMD Radeon Pro Vega 64X (1.9% higher at 80,959). The P100 sits just 0.6% behind the RTX 5090, a modern flagship, which underscores its sustained compute capability for a 2016-era product.

On the AMD side, the Radeon Instinct MI25's score of 68,562 places it 0.4% behind the Intel Arc A770 (68,809) and 0.6% behind the NVIDIA CMP 90HX (69,000). It trails the AMD Radeon Pro WX 8200 by 1.9% (69,870) and the NVIDIA Quadro P6000 by 2.0% (69,986). These deltas show the MI25 is competitive with a range of professional and consumer cards from its era, but it does not reach the performance tier occupied by the P100. The 15.8% head-to-head gap is the largest delta in either card's nearest-rival list, making it clear that the P100 is the stronger compute performer in this matchup. The MI25's higher theoretical FP32 throughput of 12.29 TFLOPS compared to the P100's 9.526 TFLOPS does not translate into a benchmark win, suggesting that raw shader count and clock speed are not the sole determinants of real-world OpenCL performance.

The Verdict

From the data alone, the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB is the superior choice for users seeking maximum compute performance in a single-slot dual-slot card. Its 15.8% OpenCL lead over the MI25 is decisive, and its 92nd percentile ranking versus the MI25's 90th percentile reinforces its higher standing across the entire GPU landscape. The P100 also achieves this performance with a lower thermal design power of 250 W compared to the MI25's 300 W, a notable efficiency advantage in dense server environments. For applications that are predominantly compute-bound—such as scientific simulation, deep learning inference, or rendering tasks that leverage OpenCL—the P100 is the clear pick.

The AMD Radeon Instinct MI25, however, is not without its merits. It offers 16 GB of HBM2 memory versus the P100's 12 GB, a 33% capacity increase that can be critical for large datasets that must reside in GPU memory. Its 4096 shading units and 256 texture mapping units outnumber the P100's 3584 and 224, respectively, and its higher boost clock of 1500 MHz versus 1329 MHz gives it a theoretical FP32 peak of 12.29 TFLOPS—29% higher than the P100's 9.526 TFLOPS. For workloads that are memory-capacity-bound or that can fully utilize its wider shader array, the MI25 might match or exceed the P100, despite losing the OpenCL benchmark. The MI25 also supports the same DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3 APIs as the P100, so software compatibility is not a differentiator. Ultimately, the P100 wins on measured performance and power efficiency, while the MI25 wins on memory capacity and raw compute headroom.

Architecture Differences

The two accelerators are built on fundamentally different architectures and manufacturing processes. The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB uses the GP100 chip based on the Pascal architecture, fabricated on a 16 nm process at TSMC. This chip contains 15,300 million transistors on a 610 mm² die, yielding a transistor density of 25.1 million per square millimeter. The AMD Radeon Instinct MI25, in contrast, uses the Vega 10 chip based on the GCN 5.0 architecture, produced on a 14 nm process at GlobalFoundries. Vega 10 packs 12,500 million transistors into a 495 mm² die, achieving a nearly identical density of 25.3 million per square millimeter. The P100's larger die and higher transistor count suggest a more complex design, but the MI25's marginally higher density indicates efficient use of its smaller area.

Memory subsystems differ significantly. The P100 features 12 GB of HBM2 across a 3072-bit bus, delivering 549.1 GB/s of bandwidth. The MI25 offers 16 GB of HBM2 on a narrower 2048-bit bus, resulting in 436.2 GB/s of bandwidth—20.6% less than the P100. The P100's wider memory bus is a key factor in its OpenCL victory, as memory bandwidth often limits compute throughput in data-intensive tasks. Clock speeds also favor the MI25 in raw terms: it runs at a base of 1400 MHz and boosts to 1500 MHz, while the P100 operates at 1190 MHz base and 1329 MHz boost. The MI25's memory clock of 852 MHz (1704 Mbps effective) is higher than the P100's 715 MHz (1430 Mbps effective), yet the P100's wider bus still provides superior bandwidth.

Compute resources are distributed differently. The MI25 has more shading units (4096 versus 3584) and more TMUs (256 versus 224), but fewer ROPs (64 versus 96). This results in a higher texture rate for the MI25 at 384.0 GTexel/s versus 297.7 GTexel/s for the P100, but a lower pixel rate at 96.00 GPixel/s versus 127.6 GPixel/s. The P100 also has a lower FP16 throughput of 19.05 TFLOPS (2:1) compared to the MI25's 24.58 TFLOPS (2:1), yet this does not help the MI25 in the FP32-focused OpenCL benchmark. Both cards lack dedicated ray tracing and tensor cores, as neither architecture includes such hardware. Physical dimensions are similar—both are dual-slot, 267 mm (10.5 inches) long—but the MI25 adds a specified height of 111 mm (4.4 inches). Power delivery differs, with the P100 requiring a single 8-pin connector and a 600 W suggested PSU, while the MI25 demands two 8-pin connectors and a 700 W suggested PSU.

FAQ

Q: Which card has higher memory bandwidth?

A: The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB, with 549.1 GB/s across a 3072-bit HBM2 bus, versus 436.2 GB/s on a 2048-bit bus for the AMD Radeon Instinct MI25.

Q: What is the performance difference in the Geekbench OpenCL test?

A: The P100 scores 79,396 compared to the MI25's 68,562, a 15.8% advantage for the NVIDIA card.

Q: Which card has more memory capacity?

A: The AMD Radeon Instinct MI25, with 16 GB of HBM2, versus 12 GB on the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB.

Q: How do the FP32 compute ratings compare?

A: The MI25 has a higher FP32 rating at 12.29 TFLOPS, while the P100 is rated at 9.526 TFLOPS.

Q: What are the power consumption requirements?

A: The P100 has a TDP of 250 W and needs a single 8-pin connector with a 600 W suggested PSU; the MI25 has a 300 W TDP, requires two 8-pin connectors, and a 700 W suggested PSU.

Q: Do either of these cards support ray tracing or tensor cores?

A: No, both the P100 and MI25 lack dedicated RT cores and tensor cores, as neither Pascal nor GCN 5.0 include such hardware.

Where Each One Wins

The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB wins in any scenario where measured compute performance is the primary criterion. Its 15.8% OpenCL lead over the MI25, combined with its higher 92nd percentile ranking, makes it the default choice for general-purpose compute tasks such as HPC simulations, AI inference, or any workload that relies on OpenCL acceleration. The P100's superior memory bandwidth of 549.1 GB/s is also an advantage for memory-bound algorithms that stream large datasets, and its lower 250 W TDP makes it easier to cool and power in multi-GPU servers. The P100's narrower 12 GB memory capacity could be a limitation for very large models, but its overall benchmark dominance suggests it handles typical compute loads more efficiently.

The AMD Radeon Instinct MI25 wins in the specific niche of memory capacity and raw shader throughput. Its 16 GB of HBM2 provides 33% more on-board memory, which is critical for workloads that must hold large matrices, point clouds, or simulation grids without spilling to host memory. Its higher FP32 rating of 12.29 TFLOPS and texture rate of 384.0 GTexel/s suggest that peak-throughput scenarios—such as dense linear algebra or texture-heavy rendering—could see the MI25 outperform the P100, even if the OpenCL benchmark does not reflect this. The MI25's 4096 shading units and 256 TMUs offer more parallel execution resources, which may benefit workloads that are shader-bound rather than bandwidth-bound. For users who prioritize memory capacity over measured benchmark score, the MI25 remains a viable option, especially given its 90th percentile standing. However, the data is unambiguous: the P100 is the faster card in the majority of compute scenarios, and the MI25's advantages are confined to specific hardware characteristics rather than overall performance.

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS

SPECIFICATION
Instinct MI25
Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB
Core Specs
Shading Units
4,096
3,584 -12.5%
Shaders
4,096
3,584 -12.5%
TMUs
256
224 -12.5%
ROPs
64
96 +50.0%
Compute Units
64
—
SM Count
—
56
Clocks
Base Clock
1400 MHz
1190 MHz
Boost Clock
1500 MHz
1329 MHz
Memory Clock
852 MHz 1704 Mbps effective
715 MHz 1430 Mbps effective
Memory
Memory Size
16 GB
12 GB
VRAM (MB)
16,384
12,288 -25.0%
Memory Type
HBM2
HBM2
Memory Bus
2048 bit
3072 bit
Bandwidth
436.2 GB/s
549.1 GB/s
Cache
L1 Cache
16 KB (per CU)
24 KB (per SM)
L2 Cache
4 MB
3 MB
Performance
Pixel Rate
96.00 GPixel/s
127.6 GPixel/s
Texture Rate
384.0 GTexel/s
297.7 GTexel/s
FP32 (TFLOPS)
12.29 TFLOPS
9.526 TFLOPS
FP64 (TFLOPS)
768.0 GFLOPS (1:16)
4.763 TFLOPS (1:2)
FP16 (TFLOPS)
24.58 TFLOPS (2:1)
19.05 TFLOPS (2:1)
Power
TDP
300 W
250 W
TDP (W)
300
250 -16.7%
Suggested PSU
700 W
600 W
Power Connectors
2x 8-pin
1x 8-pin
Architecture
Architecture
GCN 5.0
Pascal
GPU Name
Vega 10
GP100
Generation
Radeon Instinct (MIx)
Tesla Pascal (Pxx)
Process Size
14 nm
16 nm
Transistors
12,500 million
15,300 million
Die Size
495 mm²
610 mm²
Foundry
GlobalFoundries
TSMC
Density
25.3M / mm²
25.1M / mm²
API Support
DirectX
12 (12_1)
12 (12_1)
OpenGL
4.6
4.6
Vulkan
1.3
1.3
OpenCL
2.1
3.0
CUDA
—
6.0
Shader Model
6.7
6.0
Physical
Slot Width
Dual-slot
Dual-slot
Length
267 mm 10.5 inches
267 mm 10.5 inches
Height
111 mm 4.4 inches
—
Outputs
No outputs
No outputs
Bus Interface
PCIe 3.0 x16
PCIe 3.0 x16
Other
Launch Price
—
4,599 USD
Production
End-of-life
End-of-life
Predecessor
FirePro Data Center
Tesla Maxwell
Successor
—
Tesla Volta
View Radeon Instinct MI25 Details View Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB Details