AMD Instinct MI100 vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB Comparison
AMD Instinct MI100
Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Instinct MI100 vs NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The database records a single head-to-head benchmark between the AMD Instinct MI100 and the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB: Geekbench OpenCL. The results are decisive. The MI100 scores 139,035 points, while the P100 PCIe 12 GB scores 79,396 points. That is a delta of 75.1% in favor of the AMD part. In absolute terms, the MI100 delivers nearly 1.75 times the raw compute throughput of the older NVIDIA accelerator in this workload. The margin is so large that no other metric in the comparison is needed to establish a clear winner in raw OpenCL performance.
Contextualizing the MI100 score against its own nearest rivals reinforces its standing. The MI100 sits at the 96th percentile among all GPUs in the database. Its closest competitor is the NVIDIA Tesla V100 PCIe 16 GB, which averages 138,063 points, a gap of only 0.7%. The Tesla V100 SXM2 32 GB follows at 137,731 points, just 0.9% behind. Even the AMD Radeon PRO V620 (136,472 points, 1.9% behind) and the Radeon Pro W6800X Duo (135,774 points, 2.4% behind) are closely matched. The MI100 is not merely fast; it is at the very top of its immediate performance tier, separated from the pack by less than three percentage points.
The Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB, by contrast, holds a 92nd percentile ranking. Its nearest rivals tell a different story. The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 16 GB averages 79,605 points, a delta of negative 0.3%, meaning the 12 GB version is essentially identical in compute performance, within measurement noise. The GeForce RTX 5090 (79,842 points) trails by 0.6%, while the AMD Radeon RX 6850M XT (78,940 points) is 0.6% slower. The Radeon Pro Vega 64X (80,959 points) leads the P100 by 1.9%. The P100 is not a slow card by any stretch, but it occupies a crowded middle ground where single-digit percentage differences separate it from a wide range of contemporaries.
The head-to-head delta of 75.1% dwarfs any intra-tier variance. The MI100 is in a different performance league. To put it another way, the MI100's advantage over the P100 is more than 100 times larger than the P100's own gap to its closest rival. The benchmark data presents a clean, unambiguous outcome.
Where Each One Wins
The recorded benchmarks contain only one test: Geekbench OpenCL. Within that single workload, the AMD Instinct MI100 wins outright. It has a 75.1% higher score, a 96th percentile rank versus 92nd, and a raw score of 139,035 against 79,396. There are no benchmark categories in the database where the Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB comes out ahead. The wins tally confirms this: the MI100 has one win, the P100 has zero.
That does not mean the P100 is without merit in other dimensions, but those merits do not appear in the benchmark section. Looking at the specification data, the P100 operates at a higher base clock (1190 MHz vs 1000 MHz) and boost clock (1329 MHz vs 1502 MHz is actually higher for the MI100, so the P100 only wins on base). The P100 also has more ROPs (96 vs 64) and a higher pixel rate (127.6 GPixel/s vs 96.13 GPixel/s). If a workload were purely pixel-bound, the P100 might have an edge, but the database does not contain a test that isolates that. The P100 also supports DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3, whereas the MI100 reports N/A for all three APIs. For any graphics or compute task that relies on those APIs, the P100 has a functional advantage that the MI100 cannot claim.
For compute-heavy tasks, the MI100 leads in every relevant metric. It has more shading units (7680 vs 3584), more TMUs (480 vs 224), higher FP32 throughput (23.07 TFLOPS vs 9.526 TFLOPS), higher FP16 throughput (46.14 TFLOPS vs 19.05 TFLOPS), more memory (32 GB vs 12 GB), a wider memory bus (4096 bit vs 3072 bit), and far higher memory bandwidth (1.23 TB/s vs 549.1 GB/s). The MI100 is built for throughput, and the numbers confirm it.
The Verdict
The data points to a clear choice for most workloads. The AMD Instinct MI100 is the superior accelerator in raw compute performance as measured by Geekbench OpenCL. Its 75.1% lead over the Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB is substantial, and its 96th percentile ranking places it among the top accelerators in the database. For any task that stresses FP32 or FP16 compute, or that benefits from large memory capacity and bandwidth, the MI100 is the one to pick.
The Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB, however, is not obsolete. It holds a 92nd percentile ranking, which is still strong. Its nearest rivals are all within 2% of its score, meaning it is a stable, mid-tier performer. It also has a functional API advantage, supporting DirectX 12, OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3, while the MI100 supports none of those. If a deployment requires those APIs, the P100 is the only option between the two. Additionally, the P100 consumes less power (250 W vs 300 W) and requires a single 8-pin power connector versus two on the MI100, which could simplify installation in some systems.
The verdict depends on the workload. For pure compute density, the MI100 wins by a wide margin. For API compatibility and lower power draw, the P100 has its place. But based strictly on the recorded benchmark, the MI100 is the faster part, and the P100 is the more compatible part. Neither is a bad choice, but they serve different purposes.
FAQ
Q: How much faster is the AMD Instinct MI100 than the NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB in Geekbench OpenCL?
A: The MI100 scores 139,035 points, while the P100 scores 79,396 points. That is a 75.1% higher score for the MI100.
Q: What percentile does each GPU occupy in the database?
A: The MI100 is at the 96th percentile among all GPUs, while the P100 is at the 92nd percentile.
Q: Which GPU has more memory and bandwidth?
A: The MI100 has 32 GB of HBM2 with a 4096-bit bus and 1.23 TB/s bandwidth. The P100 has 12 GB of HBM2 with a 3072-bit bus and 549.1 GB/s bandwidth.
Q: Does the P100 support any graphics APIs that the MI100 does not?
A: Yes. The P100 supports DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3. The MI100 reports N/A for all three.
Q: What is the power draw difference?
A: The MI100 has a 300 W TDP and requires two 8-pin power connectors. The P100 has a 250 W TDP and requires a single 8-pin connector.
Q: How does the P100 compare to its nearest rival, the P100 PCIe 16 GB?
A: The P100 PCIe 12 GB scores 79,396 points, while the P100 PCIe 16 GB scores 79,605 points. The 12 GB version is 0.3% slower, which is effectively a tie.
Architecture Differences
The two accelerators come from different eras and designs. The AMD Instinct MI100 uses the Arcturus chip, built on the CDNA 1.0 architecture, fabricated on a 7 nm process at TSMC. It packs 25,600 million transistors into a 750 mm² die, yielding a transistor density of 34.1 million per square millimeter. The NVIDIA Tesla P100 PCIe 12 GB uses the GP100 chip, based on the Pascal architecture, fabricated on a 16 nm process, also at TSMC. It contains 15,300 million transistors on a 610 mm² die, for a density of 25.1 million per square millimeter.
The MI100 is a compute-only design. It has no display outputs, no DirectX, OpenGL, or Vulkan support, and no RT or tensor cores (the database lists null for those fields). It is a pure stream processor with 7680 shading units, 480 TMUs, and 64 ROPs. Its memory subsystem is built around 32 GB of HBM2 on a 4096-bit bus. The P100, by contrast, also has no display outputs, but it does support DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3. It has 3584 shading units, 224 TMUs, and 96 ROPs. Its memory is 12 GB of HBM2 on a 3072-bit bus.
The process node difference is stark: 7 nm versus 16 nm. That explains the MI100's higher transistor count and density despite a larger die. The MI100 also uses a newer PCIe interface, PCIe 4.0 x16, versus PCIe 3.0 x16 on the P100. The MI100's boost clock is higher (1502 MHz vs 1329 MHz), and its memory clock is faster (1200 MHz, 2.4 Gbps effective) versus the P100's 715 MHz, 1430 Mbps effective. The MI100 is a second-generation compute architecture (CDNA 1.0) whereas the P100 is a first-generation Pascal design. The MI100's release date is 2020-11-15, while the P100 dates to 2016-06-19, a gap of over four years. The MI100's predecessor is Radeon Instinct, while the P100's predecessor is Tesla Maxwell and its successor is Tesla Volta.
Specification Differences
The two cards differ across nearly every specification field. Here are the key differences:
- Process node: MI100 is 7 nm; P100 is 16 nm.
- Transistors: MI100 has 25,600 million; P100 has 15,300 million.
- Die size: MI100 is 750 mm²; P100 is 610 mm².
- Transistor density: MI100 is 34.1M / mm²; P100 is 25.1M / mm².
- Base clock: MI100 is 1000 MHz; P100 is 1190 MHz.
- Boost clock: MI100 is 1502 MHz; P100 is 1329 MHz.
- Memory clock: MI100 is 1200 MHz, 2.4 Gbps effective; P100 is 715 MHz, 1430 Mbps effective.
- Memory size: MI100 is 32 GB; P100 is 12 GB.
- Memory bus width: MI100 is 4096 bit; P100 is 3072 bit.
- Memory bandwidth: MI100 is 1.23 TB/s; P100 is 549.1 GB/s.
- Shading units: MI100 has 7680; P100 has 3584.
- TMUs: MI100 has 480; P100 has 224.
- ROPs: MI100 has 64; P100 has 96.
- Pixel rate: MI100 is 96.13 GPixel/s; P100 is 127.6 GPixel/s.
- Texture rate: MI100 is 721.0 GTexel/s; P100 is 297.7 GTexel/s.
- FP32 performance: MI100 is 23.07 TFLOPS; P100 is 9.526 TFLOPS.
- FP16 performance: MI100 is 46.14 TFLOPS (2:1); P100 is 19.05 TFLOPS (2:1).
- TDP: MI100 is 300 W; P100 is 250 W.
- Power connectors: MI100 uses 2x 8-pin; P100 uses 1x 8-pin.
- Suggested PSU: MI100 is 700 W; P100 is 600 W.
- Bus interface: MI100 is PCIe 4.0 x16; P100 is PCIe 3.0 x16.
- API support: MI100 reports N/A for DirectX, OpenGL, and Vulkan; P100 supports DirectX 12 (12_1), OpenGL 4.6, and Vulkan 1.3.
- Release date: MI100 is 2020-11-15; P100 is 2016-06-19.
- Predecessor: MI100 is Radeon Instinct; P100 is Tesla Maxwell.
- Successor: MI100 has none listed; P100 is Tesla Volta.
- Launch MSRP: P100 is 4,599 USD; MI100 has no listed launch MSRP.
The MI100 wins on compute, memory, and bandwidth. The P100 wins on pixel rate, API support, and power efficiency per watt (250 W vs 300 W for a much lower performance level). The specification differences align perfectly with the benchmark outcome: the MI100 is a newer, denser, faster part, while the P100 is an older, lighter part with broader software compatibility.