AMD Phenom II X6 1065T vs Intel Xeon W5590 Comparison
AMD Phenom II X6 1065T
Xeon W5590
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Phenom II X6 1065T vs Intel Xeon W5590
The data shows a remarkably tight contest between the AMD Phenom II X6 1065T and the Intel Xeon W5590. Across every benchmark recorded, the AMD processor wins by a margin of less than one percent, making this a photo finish rather than a knockout. However, the underlying architectural and market-segment differences tell a more interesting story than the near-identical scores suggest.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Phenom II X6 1065T claims victory in all five head-to-head comparisons, yet the margins are razor-thin. In the Cinebench R15 multicore test, the AMD scores 290 against Intel's 288, a 0.7% lead. That pattern repeats across Cinebench R20 and R23 multicore tests, where the AMD edges ahead by the same 0.7% margin. Even in single-core tests, the AMD wins with 0.6% to 0.7% advantages.
The practical interpretation is that the AMD Phenom II X6 1065T wins on every metric, but the wins are statistically negligible. For real-world workloads, these processors are effectively tied. The AMD's edge likely comes from its six physical cores versus Intel's four, but Intel's higher base and boost clocks compensate. The data indicates that users upgrading from either platform would see no measurable difference in Cinebench performance.
Where the Intel Xeon W5590 claims a structural win is in platform context. It is a server/workstation part with a triple-channel memory bus delivering 32.0 GB/s, compared to the AMD's dual-channel 21.3 GB/s. While no memory bandwidth benchmark is included, the 50% higher theoretical bandwidth suggests the Intel may be preferable for memory-bound server tasks. The AMD, with six cores and a desktop segment designation, is positioned for multi-threaded desktop workloads.
Architecture Differences
These are two fundamentally different designs from 45 nm era manufacturing. The AMD Phenom II X6 1065T uses the K10 architecture (Thuban codename) built by GlobalFoundries on a 346 mm² die containing 904 million transistors. It features six cores and six threads, with 128 KB L1 and 512 KB L2 per core, plus 6 MB of shared L3 cache. Its base clock is 2.90 GHz with a 3.40 GHz boost.
The Intel Xeon W5590 uses the Nehalem architecture (Gainestown codename) manufactured by Intel on a smaller 263 mm² die with 731 million transistors. It has four cores and eight threads, with 64 KB L1 and 256 KB L2 per core, but a larger 8 MB shared L3 cache. Its base clock is 3.33 GHz with a 3.60 GHz boost.
The core count disparity is the central difference: AMD offers 50% more physical cores, while Intel counters with Hyper-Threading to reach eight threads. The Intel also has a 15% higher base clock and 6% higher boost clock, which explains how it nearly matches the six-core AMD in multicore tests. The AMD has a larger L1 and L2 per core, but the Intel has a third more L3 cache. Both support ECC memory and PCIe Gen 2, but the Intel uses triple-channel DDR3 while the AMD supports both DDR2 and DDR3 in dual-channel configuration.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The most decisive result is also the smallest. In Cinebench R23 multicore, the AMD scores 2888 against the Intel's 2867 — a 0.7% difference of just 21 points. This is the largest absolute gap in the dataset, yet it would be imperceptible in real-world rendering. The single-core results are even closer: 407 to 404 in R23 (0.7%), and 170 to 169 in R20 (0.6%).
The Cinebench R15 and R20 multicore tests show identical 0.7% leads for the AMD, with scores of 290 vs 288 and 1212 vs 1204 respectively. These margins are consistent across all five benchmarks, suggesting a systematic but tiny advantage for the AMD. The data does not support a claim that either processor is meaningfully faster.
Comparing to their nearest rivals provides context. The AMD's average benchmark score of 993 places it in a dead heat with the Intel Core i7-965, Intel Core i7-960, and Intel Xeon W3565, all at 993 with 0% delta. The Intel Core i3-8130U is essentially tied at 994 with a -0.1% delta. The Intel Xeon W5590's average score of 986 places it 0.2% ahead of the Intel Core i7-875K and Core i3-4130T (both 984), and 0.3% ahead of the Intel Xeon X3470 and Core i3-4370T (both 983).
Both processors sit at the 27th percentile among all CPUs, meaning they are in the lower-middle range of performance according to the database. The benchmark results indicate these are legacy parts, now end-of-life, that still deliver usable multi-threaded performance but no longer compete with modern processors.
FAQ
Q: Which processor is faster in single-core performance?
A: The AMD Phenom II X6 1065T wins both single-core tests, scoring 170 vs 169 in Cinebench R20 (0.6% lead) and 407 vs 404 in Cinebench R23 (0.7% lead). The Intel's higher 3.60 GHz boost clock nearly cancels out the AMD's architectural advantages.
Q: Does the Intel's higher clock speed make up for its fewer cores?
A: Yes, almost exactly. The Intel Xeon W5590 has a 3.33 GHz base and 3.60 GHz boost, versus 2.90 GHz and 3.40 GHz on the AMD. This higher frequency allows the four-core/ eight-thread Intel to trail the six-core AMD by only 0.7% in multicore tests.
Q: Which processor has better memory bandwidth?
A: The Intel Xeon W5590 has a significant advantage with a triple-channel memory bus delivering 32.0 GB/s, compared to the AMD's dual-channel 21.3 GB/s. This is a 50% higher theoretical bandwidth, though no memory benchmarks are included in the data.
Q: What are the thread counts for each processor?
A: The AMD has 6 cores and 6 threads (no simultaneous multithreading), while the Intel has 4 cores and 8 threads thanks to Hyper-Threading. This means the Intel processes the same number of threads as the AMD despite having two fewer physical cores.
Q: Which processor has more cache?
A: The Intel has 8 MB of shared L3 cache versus 6 MB on the AMD, a 33% advantage. However, the AMD has larger per-core L1 (128 KB vs 64 KB) and L2 (512 KB vs 256 KB) caches.
Q: Are these processors comparable in overall benchmark scores?
A: Yes. The AMD's average benchmark score is 993, while the Intel's is 986, a difference of 0.7%. Both are at the 27th percentile of all CPUs, and the AMD's closest rivals include the Intel Core i7-965 and i7-960 at identical 993 scores.
The Verdict
The data presents a clear conclusion: these processors are performance twins. The AMD Phenom II X6 1065T wins every benchmark in the head-to-head comparison, but with margins between 0.6% and 0.7%, the results are functionally identical. A user choosing between them based on Cinebench scores alone would find no practical difference.
The choice should instead be guided by platform and workload characteristics. The AMD offers six physical cores, which may be preferable for workloads that scale with core count and do not benefit from Hyper-Threading. It supports both DDR2 and DDR3 memory, offering flexibility for older motherboards. The Intel Xeon W5590, with its triple-channel memory bus and 32.0 GB/s bandwidth, is positioned for server and workstation environments where memory throughput is critical. Its higher base clock of 3.33 GHz gives it an edge in lightly threaded tasks that do not boost well.
The Intel also carries a notable launch MSRP of $1600, while the AMD has no recorded launch MSRP. Both are end-of-life products, so current pricing is not a factor. For a desktop user with an AMD Socket AM3 motherboard, the Phenom II X6 1065T is the obvious choice. For a workstation build on Intel Socket 1366 with triple-channel memory, the Xeon W5590 makes more sense. The data does not justify switching platforms to obtain a 0.7% performance difference.
Specification Differences
| Specification | AMD Phenom II X6 1065T | Intel Xeon W5590 |
|---|---|---|
| Cores | 6 | 4 |
| Threads | 6 | 8 |
| Base Clock | 2.90 GHz | 3.33 GHz |
| Boost Clock | 3.40 GHz | 3.60 GHz |
| TDP | 125 W | 130 W |
| Socket | AMD Socket AM3 | Intel Socket 1366 |
| Architecture | K10 | Nehalem |
| Codename | Thuban | Gainestown |
| Process Node | 45 nm | 45 nm |
| Transistors | 904 million | 731 million |
| Die Size | 346 mm² | 263 mm² |
| L1 Cache | 128 KB (per core) | 64 KB (per core) |
| L2 Cache | 512 KB (per core) | 256 KB (per core) |
| L3 Cache | 6 MB (shared) | 8 MB (shared) |
| Memory Support | DDR2, DDR3 | DDR3 |
| Memory Bus | Dual-channel | Triple-channel |
| Memory Bandwidth | 21.3 GB/s | 32.0 GB/s |
| Market Segment | Desktop | Server/Workstation |
| Release Date | 2010-12-06 | 2009-08-08 |
| Launch MSRP | Not available | $1600 |