Intel Xeon Gold 5317 vs Intel Xeon Gold 6154 Comparison

Intel
INTEL

Intel Xeon Gold 5317

CORE STATE Ice Lake-SP
CORE SPECS 12 Cores / 24 Threads
CLOCK SPEED 3 Base / 3.6 GHz Turbo
CACHE 18 MB (shared)
MAX TDP 150W
ARCHITECTURE Ice Lake
nm
PROCESS 10 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2021
VS
Intel
INTEL

Xeon Gold 6154

CORE STATE Skylake-SP
CORE SPECS 18 Cores / 36 Threads
CLOCK SPEED 3 Base / 3.7 GHz Turbo
CACHE 24.75 MB (shared)
MAX TDP 200W
ARCHITECTURE Skylake
nm
PROCESS 14 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2017

PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS

cinebench_cinebench_r15_multicore
2,338
2,370
cinebench_cinebench_r15_singlecore
330
334
cinebench_cinebench_r20_multicore
9,743
9,878
cinebench_cinebench_r20_singlecore
1,375
1,394
cinebench_cinebench_r23_multicore
23,199
23,521
cinebench_cinebench_r23_singlecore
3,275
3,320

Analysis: Intel Xeon Gold 5317 vs Intel Xeon Gold 6154

The Intel Xeon Gold 6154 and Intel Xeon Gold 5317 are both server/workstation processors from Intel, yet they represent distinct generations and design philosophies. The benchmark data provided shows a consistent, albeit narrow, victory for the older Gold 6154 across every single test in the Cinebench suite. However, the story is more nuanced than a simple win/loss tally, as the differences in core counts, memory support, and platform connectivity point to different deployment scenarios. The data indicates the Gold 6154 wins six out of six head-to-head benchmarks, but the margins are consistently small, hovering around 1.4% in most tests. This analysis breaks down where each processor holds an advantage and what the architectural specifications reveal about their intended use cases.

Where Each One Wins

Based strictly on the benchmark results, the Intel Xeon Gold 6154 is the outright winner in every measured category. It leads in all three generations of Cinebench tests (R15, R20, and R23), and it wins in both single-core and multi-core workloads. The largest margin of victory is a 1.4% advantage in multi-core tests such as Cinebench R15 (2370 vs 2338), R20 (9878 vs 9743), and R23 (23521 vs 23199). It also edges out the Gold 5317 in single-core tests, with a 1.2% lead in R15 (334 vs 330) and a 1.4% lead in both R20 (1394 vs 1375) and R23 (3320 vs 3275).

The Gold 5317, while losing all six benchmarks, does not lose by a large margin. Its scores are within 1.4% of the Gold 6154 in every test, which suggests that the newer processor is highly competitive in raw compute performance despite having fewer cores. The data shows that the Gold 5317 does not have a single benchmark win, but its performance profile is close enough that the choice between the two may come down to platform features rather than raw speed. The Gold 6154’s wins are consistent, but they are not dominant; the Gold 5317 is never more than 35 points behind in multi-core R15 or 322 points behind in multi-core R23.

Architecture Differences

The most significant architectural difference is the manufacturing process and core design. The Intel Xeon Gold 6154 is built on a 14 nm process using the Skylake-SP architecture, released on 2017-07-10. It features 18 cores and 36 threads. The Intel Xeon Gold 5317, in contrast, uses a 10 nm process with the Ice Lake-SP architecture, released on 2021-04-05, and it has 12 cores and 24 threads. The newer 10 nm node allows the Gold 5317 to pack fewer cores into a lower thermal envelope, with a TDP of 150 compared to the Gold 6154’s 200.

The cache hierarchy also differs. Both share the same L1 cache per core (64 KB) and the same L2 cache per core (1 MB), but the shared L3 cache is larger on the Gold 6154 at 24.75 MB versus 18 MB on the Gold 5317. This is a substantial difference, given that the Gold 6154 has more cores to feed. The Gold 5317 compensates with a more modern memory subsystem, offering eight-channel memory support and a memory bandwidth of 187.7 GB/s, while the Gold 6154’s memory bus and bandwidth are not specified in the data. The Gold 5317 also supports PCIe Gen 4 with 64 lanes (CPU only), whereas the Gold 6154’s PCIe configuration is not listed.

Both processors support DDR4 memory and ECC memory, which is expected for server parts. The Gold 6154’s transistor count is listed at 8,000 million, while the Gold 5317’s transistor count is not provided. The sockets differ as well: the Gold 6154 uses Intel Socket 3647, while the Gold 5317 uses Intel Socket 4189. This means they are not drop-in compatible, requiring different motherboards.

Head-to-Head Benchmarks

The head-to-head data shows a clear pattern: the Gold 6154 wins every test, but the margins are tight and remarkably consistent. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the Gold 6154 scores 2370 against the Gold 5317’s 2338, a 1.4% difference. The single-core R15 test shows a 1.2% lead (334 vs 330). Moving to Cinebench R20, the multi-core scores are 9878 for the Gold 6154 and 9743 for the Gold 5317, again a 1.4% delta. Single-core R20 follows suit with 1394 vs 1375, also a 1.4% delta.

The biggest absolute gap is in Cinebench R23 multi-core, where the Gold 6154 scores 23521 and the Gold 5317 scores 23199. That 322-point gap represents a 1.4% advantage. In R23 single-core, the Gold 6154 leads 3320 to 3275, a 1.4% delta. The consistency of the 1.4% delta across nearly all tests suggests that the Gold 6154’s advantage is not workload-specific but rather a general throughput edge, likely stemming from its six additional cores. The Gold 5317’s higher clock speed (3.60 GHz boost vs 3.70 GHz boost for the Gold 6154) is not enough to overcome the core deficit, as the Gold 6154 actually has a higher boost clock of 3.70 GHz.

Both processors have the same base clock of 3.00 GHz, but the Gold 6154 boosts to 3.70 GHz while the Gold 5317 boosts to 3.60 GHz. This 0.10 GHz boost advantage for the Gold 6154 contributes to its single-core wins. The data shows that in every single-core test, the Gold 6154 is ahead by at least 1.2%, which aligns with its higher boost clock.

Specification Differences

The two processors differ in several key specification fields. The most obvious is core and thread count: the Gold 6154 has 18 cores and 36 threads, while the Gold 5317 has 12 cores and 24 threads. This is a 50% difference in core count, which explains the multi-core performance lead for the Gold 6154. The TDP also differs significantly, with the Gold 6154 rated at 200 and the Gold 5317 at 150, making the newer part more power-efficient per core.

The process node is a major differentiator: 14 nm for the Gold 6154 versus 10 nm for the Gold 5317. The L3 cache is larger on the Gold 6154 (24.75 MB shared) compared to the Gold 5317 (18 MB shared). The memory support is where the Gold 5317 pulls ahead in platform features: it offers eight-channel memory and a specified memory bandwidth of 187.7 GB/s, while the Gold 6154’s memory bus and bandwidth are not listed. The Gold 5317 also explicitly supports PCIe Gen 4 with 64 lanes (CPU only), whereas the Gold 6154’s PCIe capability is not specified.

The sockets are different (3647 vs 4189), and the release dates are nearly four years apart (2017-07-10 vs 2021-04-05). The Gold 5317 is marked as "Active" in production status, while the Gold 6154’s production status is not specified. The Gold 6154 has a part number (SR3J5CD8067303592700), while the Gold 5317 does not have one listed. Both have locked multipliers and no integrated graphics.

FAQ

Q: Which processor has more cores?

A: The Intel Xeon Gold 6154 has 18 cores and 36 threads, while the Intel Xeon Gold 5317 has 12 cores and 24 threads.

Q: What is the performance difference in multi-core workloads?

A: The Gold 6154 wins all multi-core tests. In Cinebench R23 multi-core, it scores 23521 versus 23199 for the Gold 5317, a 1.4% advantage. The R20 multi-core scores are 9878 vs 9743, also a 1.4% delta.

Q: Does the newer Gold 5317 have a higher clock speed?

A: No. Both have a base clock of 3.00 GHz, but the Gold 6154 has a boost clock of 3.70 GHz, which is higher than the Gold 5317’s 3.60 GHz boost.

Q: What are the memory bandwidth capabilities?

A: The Gold 5317 supports eight-channel memory with a bandwidth of 187.7 GB/s. The Gold 6154’s memory bus and bandwidth are not specified in the data.

Q: Are these processors socket-compatible?

A: No. The Gold 6154 uses Intel Socket 3647, while the Gold 5317 uses Intel Socket 4189.

Q: How do the cache sizes compare?

A: Both have 64 KB L1 and 1 MB L2 per core. The Gold 6154 has 24.75 MB of shared L3 cache, while the Gold 5317 has 18 MB of shared L3 cache.

The Verdict

The data presents a straightforward conclusion: the Intel Xeon Gold 6154 is the faster processor in every benchmark test. It wins all six head-to-head comparisons, with margins ranging from 1.2% to 1.4%. Its 18 cores provide a clear advantage in multi-threaded workloads, and its higher boost clock of 3.70 GHz helps it win single-core tests as well. The Gold 6154’s average benchmark score of 6803 places it in the 63rd percentile of all CPUs, while the Gold 5317’s average score of 6710 places it in the 62nd percentile.

However, the Gold 5317 is not without merit. Its 10 nm process and lower TDP of 150 make it a more power-efficient choice, and its eight-channel memory support with 187.7 GB/s bandwidth and PCIe Gen 4 with 64 lanes offer a more modern platform foundation. The Gold 5317 is also listed as "Active" in production, whereas the Gold 6154’s status is not specified. For users prioritizing raw compute performance in Cinebench-type workloads, the Gold 6154 is the clear pick. For those who need the latest I/O capabilities, higher memory bandwidth, and lower power consumption, the Gold 5317 is the more future-proof option, provided the 1.4% performance deficit is acceptable. The data shows that both are closely matched, but the Gold 6154 wins on performance, while the Gold 5317 wins on platform features and efficiency.

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS

SPECIFICATION
Gold 5317
Gold 6154
Core Specs
Cores
12
18 +50.0%
Threads
24
36 +50.0%
Base Clock (GHz)
3
3 0.0%
Boost Clock (GHz)
3.6
3.7 +2.8%
Frequency (GHz)
3
3 0.0%
Turbo Clock (GHz)
3.6
3.7 +2.8%
Multiplier
30
30 0.0%
SMP CPUs
2
4 +100.0%
Cache
L1 Cache
64 KB (per core)
64 KB (per core)
L2 Cache
1 MB (per core)
1 MB (per core)
L3 Cache
18 MB (shared)
24.75 MB (shared)
Power
TDP (W)
150
200 +33.3%
Architecture
Architecture
Ice Lake
Skylake
Codename
Ice Lake-SP
Skylake-SP
Generation
Xeon Gold (Ice Lake-SP)
Xeon Gold (Skylake-SP)
Process Size
10 nm
14 nm
Transistors
—
8,000 million
Foundry
Intel
Intel
Memory
Memory Support
DDR4
DDR4
Memory Bus
Eight-channel
—
Memory Bandwidth
187.7 GB/s
—
ECC Memory
Yes
Yes
Platform
Socket
Intel Socket 4189
Intel Socket 3647
PCIe
Gen 4, 64 Lanes(CPU only)
—
Other
Market
Server/Workstation
Server/Workstation
Production Status
Active
—
Part Number
—
SR3J5CD8067303592700
Package
FC-LGA4189
FC-LGA3647
View Xeon Gold 5317 Details View Xeon Gold 6154 Details