Intel Xeon Gold 5315Y vs Intel Xeon W-1290 Comparison
Intel Xeon Gold 5315Y
Xeon W-1290
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: Intel Xeon Gold 5315Y vs Intel Xeon W-1290
The Intel Xeon W-1290 and Intel Xeon Gold 5315Y are both active server/workstation processors from Intel, yet they represent distinctly different platform philosophies. The W-1290, a Comet Lake part on Socket 1200, and the Gold 5315Y, an Ice Lake-SP part on Socket 4189, are separated by a generation and a socket, yet their benchmark scores are remarkably close. The data shows a near-tie in raw compute performance, with the decision between them resting on platform features rather than headline core counts.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The benchmark results are exceptionally tight, with the Intel Xeon W-1290 winning every single head-to-head comparison, though by margins that are almost imperceptible in real-world terms. Across six Cinebench tests, the W-1290's largest advantage is a 0.2% lead in Cinebench R20 multi-core and Cinebench R23 multi-core, while its smallest edge is a 0.0% difference in Cinebench R15 single-core, where both chips score exactly 242 points.
In multi-core workloads, the W-1290 scores 1718 in Cinebench R15, 7162 in R20, and 17054 in R23. The Gold 5315Y trails by 0.1% in R15 (1716) and by 0.2% in both R20 (7151) and R23 (17027). These deltas are within run-to-run variance; the data indicates that neither processor has a meaningful throughput advantage in heavily threaded rendering tasks.
Single-core performance tells the same story. The W-1290 posts 242 in Cinebench R15, 1010 in R20, and 2407 in R23. The Gold 5315Y scores 242, 1009, and 2403 respectively. The 0.1% to 0.2% deltas in favor of the W-1290 are statistically negligible, suggesting that both architectures deliver nearly identical per-thread performance in these workloads. The overall average benchmark scores confirm the parity: the W-1290 averages 4932, while the Gold 5315Y averages 4887, a difference of 0.9%.
The head-to-head table lists the W-1290 as the winner in all six tests, but the underlying numbers reveal that this is a tie by any practical measure. The Gold 5315Y's nearestRivals entry shows a -0.9% delta against the W-1290, while the W-1290's listing shows a +0.9% delta against the Gold 5315Y. Both processors sit at the 59th percentile of all CPUs, reinforcing the conclusion that they are performance peers.
Architecture Differences
The architectural gap between these chips is substantial, even if the benchmark scores are not. The Intel Xeon W-1290 is built on Intel's 14 nm process node, using the Comet Lake architecture, while the Intel Xeon Gold 5315Y uses the newer 10 nm process node with the Ice Lake-SP architecture. The die size for the W-1290 is 206 mm², whereas the Gold 5315Y's die size is not listed in the data.
Core and cache configurations differ significantly. The W-1290 has 10 cores and 20 threads, while the Gold 5315Y has 8 cores and 16 threads. Despite having fewer cores, the Gold 5315Y allocates a larger L2 cache per core: 1 MB per core versus 256 KB per core on the W-1290. The L1 cache is identical at 64 KB per core. The L3 cache tells a different story: the W-1290 has 20 MB shared, while the Gold 5315Y has only 12 MB shared. This means the W-1290's extra cores are backed by more aggregate L3 cache, while the Gold 5315Y compensates with a more generous per-core L2 allocation.
Clock speeds also diverge sharply. Both chips have a 3.20 GHz base clock, but the W-1290 boosts to 5.20 GHz, while the Gold 5315Y tops out at 3.60 GHz. This 1.6 GHz boost advantage for the W-1290 explains why its single-core scores are marginally higher despite the architectural differences. The W-1290's TDP is 80 W, compared to 140 W for the Gold 5315Y, which reflects the latter's larger platform requirements.
Platform connectivity is another major differentiator. The W-1290 uses Intel Socket 1200, offers PCIe Gen 3 with 16 lanes (CPU only), and has a dual-channel memory bus with 46.9 GB/s bandwidth. The Gold 5315Y uses Intel Socket 4189, offers PCIe Gen 4 with 64 lanes (CPU only), and has an eight-channel memory bus with 187.7 GB/s bandwidth—four times the memory channels and roughly four times the bandwidth. The Gold 5315Y also includes integrated graphics in the form of Intel UHD Graphics P630 on the W-1290, while the Gold 5315Y has none listed.
Where Each One Wins
The Intel Xeon W-1290 wins on raw clock speed and core count. With 10 cores versus 8, and a 5.20 GHz boost clock versus 3.60 GHz, the W-1290 is better suited for workloads that are sensitive to per-core frequency or that can distribute work across more threads. Its 20 MB of shared L3 cache provides a larger pool for frequently accessed data, which can benefit certain database or virtualization scenarios. The W-1290 also carries integrated graphics, making it a more self-contained option for systems that do not require a discrete GPU.
The Intel Xeon Gold 5315Y wins on platform scalability and memory throughput. Its eight-channel memory bus with 187.7 GB/s bandwidth is a decisive advantage for memory-bandwidth-bound applications, such as large-scale data analytics, in-memory databases, or high-performance computing tasks that stream large datasets. Its 64 PCIe Gen 4 lanes allow for substantially more expansion capacity—four times the lanes and a newer generation than the W-1290's 16 Gen 3 lanes. The Gold 5315Y's larger per-core L2 cache (1 MB) can also reduce latency for working sets that fit within that footprint.
In benchmark terms, the W-1290 edges out the Gold 5315Y in every Cinebench test, but the margins are so small that they do not constitute a real win. The data suggests that for single-socket, general-purpose compute, the W-1290 is marginally faster per clock, while the Gold 5315Y is designed for systems that need massive memory bandwidth and I/O expansion.
Specification Differences
The two processors differ across nearly every major specification category. Here are the fields where the data shows direct contrasts:
- Cores: 10 (W-1290) vs 8 (Gold 5315Y)
- Threads: 20 (W-1290) vs 16 (Gold 5315Y)
- Boost Clock: 5.20 GHz (W-1290) vs 3.60 GHz (Gold 5315Y)
- TDP: 80 W (W-1290) vs 140 W (Gold 5315Y)
- Socket: Intel Socket 1200 (W-1290) vs Intel Socket 4189 (Gold 5315Y)
- Architecture / Codename: Comet Lake (W-1290) vs Ice Lake-SP (Gold 5315Y)
- Process Node: 14 nm (W-1290) vs 10 nm (Gold 5315Y)
- Die Size: 206 mm² (W-1290) vs not listed (Gold 5315Y)
- L2 Cache: 256 KB per core (W-1290) vs 1 MB per core (Gold 5315Y)
- L3 Cache: 20 MB shared (W-1290) vs 12 MB shared (Gold 5315Y)
- Memory Bus: Dual-channel (W-1290) vs Eight-channel (Gold 5315Y)
- Memory Bandwidth: 46.9 GB/s (W-1290) vs 187.7 GB/s (Gold 5315Y)
- PCIe: Gen 3, 16 lanes (W-1290) vs Gen 4, 64 lanes (Gold 5315Y)
- Integrated Graphics: Intel UHD Graphics P630 (W-1290) vs none (Gold 5315Y)
- Release Date: 2020-05-12 (W-1290) vs 2021-04-05 (Gold 5315Y)
- Launch MSRP: $498 (W-1290) vs not listed (Gold 5315Y)
The base clock, L1 cache, memory support type (DDR4), ECC support, market segment, production status, and multiplier unlock status are identical between the two.
FAQ
Q: Which processor has more cores?
A: The Intel Xeon W-1290 has 10 cores and 20 threads, while the Intel Xeon Gold 5315Y has 8 cores and 16 threads.
Q: Is there a significant performance difference in Cinebench tests?
A: No. The W-1290 wins all six head-to-head Cinebench tests, but the largest margin is 0.2% in R20 and R23 multi-core. The R15 single-core test is a tie at 242 points.
Q: What is the memory bandwidth advantage of the Gold 5315Y?
A: The Gold 5315Y has an eight-channel memory bus with 187.7 GB/s bandwidth, compared to the W-1290's dual-channel bus with 46.9 GB/s, giving the Gold 5315Y approximately four times the bandwidth.
Q: Which processor has a higher boost clock?
A: The Intel Xeon W-1290 boosts to 5.20 GHz, while the Intel Xeon Gold 5315Y boosts to 3.60 GHz. Both have a 3.20 GHz base clock.
Q: Do both processors support ECC memory?
A: Yes, both the Intel Xeon W-1290 and the Intel Xeon Gold 5315Y list ECC memory support as true.
Q: What is the PCIe generation and lane difference?
A: The W-1290 offers PCIe Gen 3 with 16 lanes, while the Gold 5315Y offers PCIe Gen 4 with 64 lanes.
The Verdict
The benchmark data shows that the Intel Xeon W-1290 and Intel Xeon Gold 5315Y are functionally equivalent in raw CPU throughput. The W-1290's 0.9% higher average benchmark score and its clean sweep of the six Cinebench tests are real, but they are too small to influence workload selection. The decision must be made on platform attributes.
Pick the Intel Xeon W-1290 if you need a higher core count (10 vs 8), a much higher boost clock (5.20 GHz vs 3.60 GHz), lower power consumption (80 W vs 140 W), and integrated graphics. Its larger 20 MB L3 cache and smaller 206 mm² die also make it a more compact and potentially simpler system to build. The W-1290's launch MSRP is $498.
Pick the Intel Xeon Gold 5315Y if your workload is dominated by memory bandwidth or I/O expansion. Its 187.7 GB/s bandwidth and 64 PCIe Gen 4 lanes are transformative for data-heavy applications, and its 1 MB per-core L2 cache may reduce latency for certain access patterns. The 10 nm process node also indicates a more power-efficient transistor design per operation, even though the TDP is higher due to the platform's scale. The Gold 5315Y has no integrated graphics and a lower boost clock, but for a server designed around discrete accelerators and high-throughput memory, those are acceptable trade-offs.
Both processors sit at the 59th percentile of all CPUs, and their average benchmark scores (4932 vs 4887) are within 1% of each other. The data does not support a verdict based on compute performance alone. The correct choice is dictated entirely by whether the system needs the W-1290's high-frequency, multi-core simplicity or the Gold 5315Y's memory-and-I/O-centric server platform.