Intel Core i7-4860HQ vs Intel Core i7-4910MQ Comparison
Intel Core i7-4860HQ
Core i7-4910MQ
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: Intel Core i7-4860HQ vs Intel Core i7-4910MQ
The Intel Core i7-4860HQ and Intel Core i7-4910MQ are two 2014-era Haswell mobile processors that, despite their similar lineage, deliver meaningfully different performance profiles. Both are 4-core, 8-thread parts with a 47 W TDP, but the benchmark data reveals a clear split: the i7-4910MQ dominates in most compute workloads, while the i7-4860HQ posts a surprising victory in one major test. This analysis breaks down the head-to-head numbers, architectural distinctions, and the use cases where each chip holds an advantage.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The head-to-head results show a near-sweep for the Intel Core i7-4910MQ, which wins 6 of the 8 benchmark comparisons. The margins, however, are consistently slim in the Cinebench suite. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the i7-4910MQ scores 536 against the i7-4860HQ’s 533, a delta of -0.6% from the latter’s perspective. The single-core R15 test is a dead heat, with both CPUs scoring 75 points. Moving to Cinebench R20, the i7-4910MQ again takes multi-core with 2236 versus 2224 (a -0.5% delta), and single-core with 315 versus 313 (-0.6%). The pattern holds in Cinebench R23: the i7-4910MQ leads multi-core 5326 to 5297 (-0.5%) and single-core 752 to 747 (-0.7%). These are marginal victories, indicating that in sustained rendering workloads, the two chips are virtually interchangeable in practice.
The story changes dramatically in Geekbench. The i7-4860HQ wins the multi-core test decisively, scoring 3527 against the i7-4910MQ’s 3368 — a 4.7% advantage. This is the largest delta in the entire comparison and suggests the i7-4860HQ handles certain multi-threaded workloads more efficiently. However, the i7-4910MQ strikes back in Geekbench single-core, posting 1116 versus 1045, a 6.4% lead. This is the biggest single-core gap in the data, and it highlights a fundamental divergence: the i7-4910MQ excels in lightly-threaded tasks, while the i7-4860HQ pulls ahead when all cores are hammered in the Geekbench test’s specific way.
Looking at the broader competitive landscape, both chips sit at the 41st percentile among all CPUs. The i7-4860HQ’s average benchmark score is 1720, placing it right next to the AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150GE (1722, -0.1%) and just ahead of the i7-4910MQ itself (1716, 0.3%). The i7-4910MQ’s average of 1716 puts it on par with the AMD Ryzen 7 PRO 2700U (1715, 0%) and the Intel Core i7-990X (1713, 0.2%). Neither chip is a performance outlier in its peer group; they are both solidly mid-pack processors whose differences are measured in single-digit percentages.
The Verdict
The data points to a straightforward conclusion for most users: the Intel Core i7-4910MQ is the better all-around processor. It wins the majority of benchmarks, including every Cinebench test, and its single-core advantage in Geekbench (6.4%) is more pronounced than the i7-4860HQ’s multi-core win (4.7%). For tasks like photo editing, spreadsheet work, or any application that leans on single-threaded performance, the i7-4910MQ is the clear pick. Its 6-of-8 win record in the head-to-head is not a fluke; it reflects a consistent, if modest, edge across rendering and general compute.
That said, the i7-4860HQ is not without merit. Its Geekbench multi-core score of 3527 is notably higher, and this is not a trivial result. If a user’s workload specifically resembles the Geekbench multi-core test — which often involves mixed integer and floating-point operations rather than pure rendering — the i7-4860HQ could be the better choice. It also matches the i7-4910MQ in Cinebench R15 single-core with an identical 75-point score, meaning it is not wholly inferior in single-threaded scenarios. However, given that the i7-4910MQ wins more tests and posts higher scores in the more demanding R20 and R23 suites, it is the safer recommendation for general-purpose use. The i7-4860HQ is for the niche user who values that specific multi-core Geekbench result above all else.
Architecture Differences
Both processors share the same Haswell architecture and are built on Intel’s 22 nm process node with 1,400 million transistors. The core counts are identical: 4 cores and 8 threads. The L1 and L2 caches match at 64 KB per core and 256 KB per core, respectively. The divergence begins with the codename and die size. The i7-4860HQ uses the Crystalwell codename and has a 264 mm² die, while the i7-4910MQ is simply Haswell with a smaller 177 mm² die. This size difference is significant and reflects the i7-4860HQ’s integrated Iris Pro graphics, which require additional silicon.
The L3 cache also differs: the i7-4860HQ has 6 MB shared, while the i7-4910MQ has 8 MB shared. This 2 MB difference could contribute to the i7-4910MQ’s single-core advantage, as a larger cache can improve hit rates for latency-sensitive workloads. Clock speeds tell a similar story. The i7-4910MQ has a base clock of 2.90 GHz and a boost of 3.90 GHz, while the i7-4860HQ is slower on paper at 2.40 GHz base and 3.60 GHz boost. These higher clocks are likely the primary driver behind the i7-4910MQ’s wins in Cinebench and Geekbench single-core.
The integrated graphics are another major split. The i7-4860HQ features Intel HD 5200 (Iris Pro), while the i7-4910MQ uses the more basic Intel HD 4600. This explains the die size difference and makes the i7-4860HQ more suitable for tasks that leverage the iGPU, though the benchmark data provided does not include graphics tests. Memory support is identical: both use DDR3 with a dual-channel bus and 25.6 GB/s bandwidth. Neither supports ECC memory. Both are mobile parts with a 47 W TDP, but they use different sockets — the i7-4860HQ is on Intel BGA 1364, and the i7-4910MQ is on Intel Socket G3. The i7-4910MQ carries a launch MSRP of $570; the i7-4860HQ has no listed MSRP. Both CPUs have locked multipliers and are end-of-life products.
FAQ
Q: Which CPU has a higher clock speed?
A: The Intel Core i7-4910MQ has a base clock of 2.90 GHz and a boost of 3.90 GHz, compared to the i7-4860HQ’s 2.40 GHz base and 3.60 GHz boost.
Q: Do both processors have the same number of cores and threads?
A: Yes, both have 4 cores and 8 threads.
Q: Which processor has more L3 cache?
A: The Intel Core i7-4910MQ has 8 MB of shared L3 cache, while the i7-4860HQ has 6 MB.
Q: What is the difference in their integrated graphics?
A: The i7-4860HQ uses Intel HD 5200, while the i7-4910MQ uses Intel HD 4600.
Q: Can you use ECC memory with either processor?
A: No, neither processor supports ECC memory.
Q: Which chip won the Geekbench multi-core test?
A: The Intel Core i7-4860HQ won with a score of 3527, beating the i7-4910MQ’s 3368 by 4.7%.
Where Each One Wins
The Intel Core i7-4910MQ is the victor in the majority of scenarios. It wins every Cinebench test, including R15 multi-core (536 vs 533), R20 multi-core (2236 vs 2224), R20 single-core (315 vs 313), R23 multi-core (5326 vs 5297), and R23 single-core (752 vs 747). It also wins Geekbench single-core with a 6.4% margin. This makes it the go-to choice for rendering workloads, 3D modeling, video encoding, and any application that benefits from higher clock speeds. The larger 8 MB L3 cache and higher boost clock are clear assets here. Users who prioritize single-threaded responsiveness or run software that is not fully multi-threaded will find the i7-4910MQ consistently faster.
The Intel Core i7-4860HQ has a narrower, but real, winning profile. Its only benchmark victory is Geekbench multi-core, where it scores 3527 — a 4.7% lead over the i7-4910MQ. This test is known for its diverse workload mix, and the i7-4860HQ’s superior performance there suggests it handles certain parallel integer and floating-point operations better. Additionally, its Intel HD 5200 integrated graphics are far more capable than the HD 4600, making it a better choice for systems that rely on the iGPU for light gaming or media acceleration, even though no graphics benchmarks are in the data. Users who run heavily multi-threaded, non-rendering applications — or who want the superior integrated graphics — should lean toward the i7-4860HQ. For everyone else, the i7-4910MQ’s six benchmark wins make it the data-backed favorite.