Intel Core i7-4712HQ vs Intel Xeon E3-1515M v5 Comparison
Intel Core i7-4712HQ
Xeon E3-1515M v5
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: Intel Core i7-4712HQ vs Intel Xeon E3-1515M v5
The Intel Xeon E3-1515M v5 and Intel Core i7-4712HQ are both quad-core, eight-thread mobile processors aimed at very different buyers: one is a Skylake-era workstation part, the other a Haswell-era mainstream mobile chip. Benchmark data shows a clear and consistent victory for the Xeon, but the i7 retains relevance in specific scenarios. This analysis breaks down the performance gap, architectural differences, and where each processor still holds an advantage.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The performance disparity between these two CPUs is remarkably uniform across all tested workloads. In Cinebench R15 multicore, the Xeon E3-1515M v5 scores 507 against the i7-4712HQ’s 454, a decisive 11.7% advantage. The single-core test in the same suite shows a similar story: 71 points for the Xeon versus 64 for the i7, a 10.9% lead. This pattern is not an isolated incident; it repeats itself with striking consistency across every generation of the Cinebench benchmark.
Moving to Cinebench R20, the Xeon again wins multicore with 2115 points versus 1895 for the i7, a margin of 11.6%. The single-core result is identical in percentage terms: 298 against 267, also an 11.6% edge. Cinebench R23 continues the trend, with the Xeon scoring 5036 in multicore and 711 in single-core, while the i7 manages 4512 and 637 respectively. Both R23 deltas sit at 11.6%. The data shows a clean sweep: the Xeon wins all six head-to-head benchmarks, with every victory falling within the narrow range of 10.9% to 11.7%.
This consistency suggests the performance gap is not workload-specific but rather a fundamental difference in execution efficiency. The Xeon’s lead is slightly larger in multicore tests than single-core, indicating its advantage scales with thread utilization. For users rendering video, compiling code, or running multi-threaded simulations, the Xeon’s 11.7% multicore margin translates directly into shorter wait times. Even in lightly threaded tasks, the 10.9% to 11.6% single-core lead is noticeable in everyday responsiveness.
The i7-4712HQ does not win a single benchmark in this comparison. However, its average benchmark score of 1436 places it at the 37th percentile of all CPUs, only one point behind the Xeon’s 38th percentile. This proximity in overall ranking highlights that while the Xeon is faster, the i7 is not a slouch; it sits in the same performance tier, surrounded by comparable rivals like the AMD Ryzen 5 2400G, which scores 1439, and the Intel Core i7-2600K at 1433.
Architecture Differences
The two processors come from different architectural eras and manufacturing processes. The Xeon E3-1515M v5 is built on Intel’s 14 nm Skylake architecture, produced on a die size of 171 mm² with 2,300 million transistors. In contrast, the i7-4712HQ uses the older 22 nm Haswell design, with a slightly larger die at 177 mm² but significantly fewer transistors at 1,400 million. This 900 million transistor difference on a smaller die reflects the density improvements of the 14 nm node.
Cache configurations also differentiate the two. Both share the same 64 KB L1 and 256 KB L2 cache per core, but the L3 cache tells a different story. The Xeon offers 8 MB of shared L3 cache, while the i7 is limited to 6 MB. This 2 MB difference can matter in workloads with large working sets, where the Xeon has more room to store frequently accessed data closer to the cores.
Memory support is another significant divider. The Xeon supports both DDR3 and DDR4 memory in a dual-channel configuration, delivering a memory bandwidth of 34.1 GB/s. The i7 supports only DDR3, also dual-channel, but with a lower bandwidth of 25.6 GB/s. The Xeon’s 8.5 GB/s bandwidth advantage is substantial and will benefit memory-intensive applications like database queries or large data analysis.
Integrated graphics further separate these chips. The Xeon packs Iris Pro Graphics P580, a high-end integrated GPU, while the i7 uses the older Intel HD 4600. The Xeon also supports ECC memory, a critical feature for workstation reliability, whereas the i7 does not. Both processors use the same PCIe Gen 3 interface with 16 CPU lanes, but they mount on different sockets: the Xeon uses Intel BGA 1440, and the i7 uses Intel BGA 1364, meaning they are not interchangeable in the same motherboard.
FAQ
Q: Which processor is faster in multi-threaded workloads?
A: The Intel Xeon E3-1515M v5 wins all multicore benchmarks. It scores 507 versus 454 in Cinebench R15 multicore, 2115 versus 1895 in R20, and 5036 versus 4512 in R23, consistently delivering an 11.6-11.7% advantage over the Core i7-4712HQ.
Q: Is the single-core performance gap as large as the multicore gap?
A: The gap is slightly smaller but still significant. In Cinebench R15 single-core, the Xeon leads 71 to 64, a 10.9% difference. In R20 and R23, the margin is 11.6% in both cases, with scores of 298 versus 267 and 711 versus 637 respectively.
Q: Does the Core i7-4712HQ have any benchmark where it wins?
A: No. In the six head-to-head benchmarks recorded, the i7-4712HQ wins zero. The Xeon takes all six, with wins ranging from 10.9% to 11.7%.
Q: What is the main architectural advantage of the Xeon?
A: The Xeon is built on a newer 14 nm process with 2,300 million transistors, compared to the i7’s 22 nm process with 1,400 million. It also has more L3 cache (8 MB versus 6 MB) and higher memory bandwidth (34.1 GB/s versus 25.6 GB/s).
Q: Can the i7-4712HQ use DDR4 memory?
A: No. The i7-4712HQ supports only DDR3 memory. The Xeon E3-1515M v5 supports both DDR3 and DDR4.
Q: Do both processors have the same core and thread counts?
A: Yes, both have 4 cores and 8 threads. However, the Xeon’s higher base clock of 2.80 GHz and boost clock of 3.70 GHz, compared to the i7’s 2.30 GHz and 3.30 GHz, contribute to its performance lead.
Specification Differences
| Specification | Intel Xeon E3-1515M v5 | Intel Core i7-4712HQ |
|---|---|---|
| Architecture | Skylake | Haswell |
| Process Node | 14 nm | 22 nm |
| Transistors | 2,300 million | 1,400 million |
| Die Size | 171 mm² | 177 mm² |
| Base Clock | 2.80 GHz | 2.30 GHz |
| Boost Clock | 3.70 GHz | 3.30 GHz |
| TDP | 45 W | 37 W |
| L3 Cache | 8 MB (shared) | 6 MB (shared) |
| Memory Support | DDR3, DDR4 | DDR3 |
| Memory Bandwidth | 34.1 GB/s | 25.6 GB/s |
| ECC Memory | Yes | No |
| Integrated Graphics | Iris Pro Graphics P580 | Intel HD 4600 |
| Socket | Intel BGA 1440 | Intel BGA 1364 |
| Launch MSRP | $489 | $378 |
Where Each One Wins
The Intel Xeon E3-1515M v5 is the clear winner in raw performance. It dominates all six benchmark tests, with its largest margins in multicore workloads. The Xeon’s 11.7% multicore lead in Cinebench R15 makes it the better choice for video editing, 3D rendering, and any professional application that leverages all available threads. Its support for ECC memory and higher memory bandwidth (34.1 GB/s versus 25.6 GB/s) further cements its position for workstation tasks where data integrity and throughput are paramount. The newer 14 nm process and larger 8 MB L3 cache also provide efficiency and caching benefits that pay off in sustained, complex workloads.
The Core i7-4712HQ, despite losing every benchmark, has its own niche. Its TDP of 37 W is significantly lower than the Xeon’s 45 W, making it more suitable for thinner, lighter laptops where thermal headroom and battery life are critical. The i7’s lower launch MSRP of $378, compared to the Xeon’s $489, positioned it as a more accessible option for mainstream high-performance laptops. While it lacks ECC support and DDR4 compatibility, its 4-core, 8-thread configuration still handles everyday multitasking, office productivity, and moderate content creation competently. For users who do not require ECC memory or maximum rendering speed, the i7’s lower power draw and cost make it a pragmatic choice. However, for pure performance per clock and absolute throughput, the data unequivocally favors the Xeon E3-1515M v5.