Intel Core i5-7440HQ vs Intel Xeon E3-1268L v5 Comparison
Intel Core i5-7440HQ
Xeon E3-1268L v5
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: Intel Core i5-7440HQ vs Intel Xeon E3-1268L v5
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The benchmark record is strikingly one-sided. Across all six Cinebench comparisons, the Intel Xeon E3-1268L v5 takes every single win, with deltas that cluster tightly between 16.9% and 17.3%. There is no contest in the recorded data; the Xeon leads by nearly identical margins in both single-core and multi-core workloads.
Looking at the multi-core results first, the Xeon posts 542 points in Cinebench R15 against 463 for the Core i5-7440HQ, a 17.1% advantage. The R20 run shows 2260 versus 1933, again a 16.9% gap. The R23 multi-core test repeats the pattern: 5383 for the Xeon, 4603 for the i5, another 16.9% delta. These are consistent, not incidental differences. The Xeon’s lead does not shrink as the workload scales, which suggests a structural advantage rather than a single-test anomaly.
Single-core results tell the same story. In R15 single-core, the Xeon scores 76 against 65, a 16.9% win. R20 single-core shows 319 versus 272, a 17.3% margin, the largest of any comparison. R23 single-core has the Xeon at 760 and the i5 at 649, a 17.1% gap. What is curious here is that the single-core deltas are essentially identical to the multi-core deltas. Normally, one might expect a processor with more threads to stretch its lead in multi-threaded tests, but that is not what the data shows. The Xeon wins single-threaded by about 17% and multi-threaded by about 17%. The thread count difference appears to contribute nothing extra.
Interpreting the overall averages, the Xeon’s average benchmark score is 1557, while the i5-7440HQ sits at 1527. That is only a 2% difference in aggregate, yet the head-to-head deltas are much larger. The reason lies in the benchmark mix. The i5 has two additional Geekbench entries in its record, scoring 3043 multi-core and 1184 single-core, which pull its average up. The Xeon has no Geekbench data in the pack. So the Cinebench-focused head-to-head shows a decisive Xeon victory, but the broader average tells a more nuanced story. The i5 is not far behind on aggregate, even though it loses every shared benchmark.
Architecture Differences
Both processors are built on Intel’s 14 nm process, but they come from different architectural families. The Xeon E3-1268L v5 is Skylake-DT, a server and workstation part, while the Core i5-7440HQ is Kaby Lake-H, a mobile processor. Skylake and Kaby Lake are closely related, with Kaby Lake being a refined version of the same design, but the market positioning creates meaningful differences.
The core counts are identical at four physical cores, but the threading differs sharply. The Xeon supports 8 threads via Hyper-Threading, while the i5 is limited to 4 threads with no Hyper-Threading. That alone explains part of the multi-core gap, though the data shows the single-core gap is just as large, so the architecture’s per-clock efficiency must also differ.
Clock speeds favor the i5 on paper. The i5 has a base clock of 2.80 GHz and a boost clock of 3.80 GHz, while the Xeon runs at 2.40 GHz base and 3.40 GHz boost. Despite having lower clocks, the Xeon still wins every benchmark. This suggests the Skylake server part is achieving higher instructions per clock in these workloads, or the boost behavior under sustained load differs, though the exact reason is not in the recorded measurements. The Xeon’s 35 W TDP versus the i5’s 45 W TDP is notable: lower power draw and lower clocks, yet faster results.
Cache allocation is another differentiator. The Xeon has 8 MB of shared L3 cache, while the i5 has 6 MB. Both have 64 KB L1 per core and 256 KB L2 per core. The larger L3 on the Xeon could be helping with data locality in the Cinebench render workloads. The die size also differs: the Xeon measures 122 mm², the i5 measures 126 mm², despite the Xeon having more cache. The Xeon’s transistor count is listed at 1,750 million; the i5’s transistor count is not recorded.
Memory support is a point of distinction. Both support DDR3 and DDR4 in dual-channel configuration, but the Xeon lists a memory bandwidth of 34.1 GB/s, while the i5’s bandwidth is not recorded. The Xeon also supports ECC memory, a critical feature for server reliability, while the i5 does not. Integrated graphics differ as well: the Xeon has HD Graphics P530, the i5 has Intel HD Graphics 630. The i5’s graphics are likely newer, but the data does not include any graphics benchmarks.
The Verdict
The database is unambiguous: the Intel Xeon E3-1268L v5 wins every shared benchmark, with deltas between 16.9% and 17.3%. Anyone choosing purely on Cinebench performance should select the Xeon. It is faster in single-core and multi-core, runs at a lower TDP of 35 W versus 45 W, and adds ECC memory support. The Xeon also has a higher percentile rank against all CPUs: 39th percentile versus the i5’s 38th, a narrow but real edge.
However, the i5-7440HQ is not without its own data points. Its average benchmark score of 1527 is close to the Xeon’s 1557, within 2%. The i5’s Geekbench results, which the Xeon lacks, show strong performance: 3043 multi-core and 1184 single-core. If the workload set includes Geekbench, the i5 appears more balanced. The i5 also has higher clock speeds, 2.80 GHz base and 3.80 GHz boost, which could matter in workloads not captured by the Cinebench suite.
For a server or workstation build, the Xeon is the clear choice from this data. ECC memory, lower power draw, and consistent benchmark wins make it the superior part for reliability-focused tasks. For a mobile or laptop scenario, the i5-7440HQ is the only realistic option due to its BGA 1440 socket, but the data cannot recommend it on performance grounds. The Xeon wins every recorded comparison.
Specification Differences
The two processors differ in several key fields, and those differences align with the benchmark results.
- Threads: The Xeon has 8 threads, the i5 has 4. This explains part of the multi-core lead.
- Base Clock: The Xeon runs at 2.40 GHz, the i5 at 2.80 GHz. The i5 is clocked higher but loses.
- Boost Clock: The Xeon boosts to 3.40 GHz, the i5 to 3.80 GHz. Again, the i5 is higher.
- TDP: The Xeon draws 35 W, the i5 draws 45 W. The Xeon is more power-efficient.
- Socket: The Xeon uses Intel Socket 1151, a desktop platform. The i5 uses Intel BGA 1440, a soldered mobile platform.
- Architecture: The Xeon is Skylake-DT, the i5 is Kaby Lake-H.
- L3 Cache: The Xeon has 8 MB shared, the i5 has 6 MB shared.
- Die Size: The Xeon is 122 mm², the i5 is 126 mm².
- ECC Memory: The Xeon supports ECC, the i5 does not.
- Memory Bandwidth: The Xeon lists 34.1 GB/s, the i5 has no recorded bandwidth.
- Integrated Graphics: The Xeon has HD Graphics P530, the i5 has Intel HD Graphics 630.
- Market Segment: The Xeon is server and workstation, the i5 is mobile.
- Release Date: The Xeon launched on 2015-10-18, the i5 on 2017-01-02. The i5 is newer by over a year.
- Launch MSRP: The Xeon had a launch MSRP of $377, the i5 had a launch MSRP of $250.
- Part Number: The Xeon is SR2LQ, the i5 is SR32R.
FAQ
Q: Which processor is faster in multi-core Cinebench R23?
A: The Intel Xeon E3-1268L v5 scores 5383, while the Intel Core i5-7440HQ scores 4603. The Xeon leads by 16.9%.
Q: Does the Core i5-7440HQ win any benchmark in the head-to-head comparison?
A: No. The Xeon wins all six recorded Cinebench comparisons, with wins in R15, R20, and R23, both single-core and multi-core. The i5 has zero wins.
Q: Why does the i5-7440HQ have a higher boost clock but still lose?
A: The i5 boosts to 3.80 GHz versus the Xeon’s 3.40 GHz, yet the Xeon wins every benchmark. The data does not specify the cause, but the Xeon’s larger L3 cache, 8 MB versus 6 MB, and its 8 threads versus 4 threads are likely contributing factors.
Q: What is the average benchmark score difference?
A: The Xeon averages 1557, and the i5 averages 1527. That is a 2% difference, much smaller than the head-to-head deltas, because the i5 has Geekbench scores in its record that the Xeon lacks.
Q: Does the Xeon support ECC memory?
A: Yes, the Xeon E3-1268L v5 supports ECC memory. The Core i5-7440HQ does not.
Q: Which processor has a lower TDP?
A: The Xeon has a TDP of 35 W, while the i5 has a TDP of 45 W. The Xeon draws less power despite being faster in the recorded tests.
Q: What are the clock speed differences?
A: The Xeon has a base clock of 2.40 GHz and a boost clock of 3.40 GHz. The i5 has a base clock of 2.80 GHz and a boost clock of 3.80 GHz.
Where Each One Wins
The Xeon E3-1268L v5 wins in every category that has recorded data. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, it wins by 17.1%. In R15 single-core, it wins by 16.9%. The R20 tests show a 16.9% multi-core win and a 17.3% single-core win. The R23 tests show 16.9% and 17.1% wins. There is no benchmark in the shared set where the i5 comes out ahead.
The i5-7440HQ’s wins are indirect. It has Geekbench scores that the Xeon does not have: 3043 multi-core and 1184 single-core. These are not head-to-head comparisons, so they do not count as wins, but they show the i5 is a capable processor in its own right. The i5 also has higher clock speeds, which could translate to wins in workloads that are not latency-sensitive to cache size or thread count. Its newer release date, 2017 versus 2015, and its integrated Intel HD Graphics 630, which is a different generation than the Xeon’s HD Graphics P530, give it a more modern feature set.
For server and workstation tasks, the Xeon is the winner. ECC memory support, lower TDP, and consistent benchmark leads make it the superior choice. For mobile deployments, the i5 is the only option due to its BGA 1440 socket, but the data shows it is the slower processor in every shared test. The Xeon’s wins are comprehensive, and the i5’s only advantages are in specifications that do not appear in the benchmark record.