Intel Core i5-4590S vs Intel Pentium Gold G7400E Comparison
Intel Core i5-4590S
Pentium Gold G7400E
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: Intel Core i5-4590S vs Intel Pentium Gold G7400E
The Intel Pentium Gold G7400E and the Intel Core i5-4590S represent two distinct eras of desktop computing, with the former being a modern entry-level part and the latter a legacy mid-range processor. While the i5-4590S offers twice the physical cores, benchmark data across the board shows the newer Pentium taking a decisive lead in raw performance. The data indicates a sweeping victory for the G7400E in every head-to-head comparison, making this less a contest of equals and more a demonstration of generational advancement.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The benchmark results are remarkably consistent, with the Pentium Gold G7400E securing a win in all six compared tests. The margins are uniform, hovering around the 21-22% mark in the Pentium’s favor. In the Cinebench R15 multicore test, the G7400E scores 531 against the i5-4590S’s 437, a delta of 21.5%. The single-core test for the same suite shows a similar story: 74 versus 61, a 21.3% advantage for the Pentium. This pattern continues into Cinebench R20, where the multicore score is 2213 for the G7400E against 1821 for the i5-4590S (21.5% delta), and the single-core score is 312 versus 257 (21.4% delta). The most demanding workload, Cinebench R23, reveals the largest gap: the Pentium Gold G7400E scores 5270 in multicore and 744 in single-core, while the i5-4590S manages 4338 and 612, respectively, translating to 21.5% and 21.6% deltas. The Pentium Gold G7400E wins 6 out of 6 head-to-head benchmarks, with zero wins for the Core i5-4590S.
These numbers are telling because the i5-4590S has four cores and four threads, while the Pentium has only two cores and four threads. The fact that the Pentium is 21.5% faster in the multicore R20 test, despite having half the physical cores, illustrates how much more efficient the newer architecture is per core. The average benchmark score reinforces this: the Pentium Gold G7400E sits at 1524, while the i5-4590S is at 1493. In the broader context of all CPUs, both parts land at the 38th percentile, meaning they occupy a similar position in the overall performance hierarchy, but the Pentium achieves that placement with significantly less hardware.
Architecture Differences
The architectural gap between these two processors is substantial. The Pentium Gold G7400E is built on Alder Lake architecture, specifically the Alder Lake-S codename, and uses a 10 nm process node. In contrast, the Core i5-4590S is based on the older Haswell architecture and codename, fabricated on a 22 nm process. This difference in manufacturing process is a primary driver of the performance disparity, as the smaller node allows for higher efficiency and greater transistor density.
The core configurations differ as expected: the Pentium Gold G7400E features 2 cores and 4 threads, while the Core i5-4590S offers 4 cores and 4 threads. The cache hierarchy also tells a story of generational change. The Pentium has a larger L2 cache per core at 1.25 MB, compared to the i5-4590S’s 256 KB per core. The L1 cache also differs, with the Pentium having 80 KB per core versus 64 KB per core on the i5. Interestingly, both share the same 6 MB of shared L3 cache. The Pentium Gold G7400E also lists a base clock of 3.60 GHz with no boost clock, while the i5-4590S has a lower base clock of 2.90 GHz but a boost clock of 3.60 GHz. The Pentium’s higher sustained clock speed, combined with its newer architecture, explains its superior single-core performance.
Platform support is another fundamental split. The Pentium Gold G7400E uses the Intel Socket 1700, supports PCIe Gen 5, and offers memory support for both DDR4 and DDR5 in a dual-channel configuration. The Core i5-4590S, on the other hand, uses the older Intel Socket 1150, supports PCIe Gen 3, and is limited to DDR3 memory. The integrated graphics also differ, with the Pentium featuring UHD Graphics 710 and the i5 featuring Intel HD 4600. The i5-4590S has documented transistor and die size figures of 1,400 million and 177 mm², respectively, while these are not listed for the Pentium. The G7400E was released in January 2022, while the i5-4590S was released in April 2014, showing a nearly eight-year gap in their introduction. The TDP also differs, with the Pentium rated at 46 watts and the i5 at 65 watts, indicating the newer part is more power-efficient despite being faster.
Where Each One Wins
Given the benchmark sweep, the Pentium Gold G7400E is the clear winner for any workload that relies on single-threaded performance. Its higher base clock of 3.60 GHz and modern 10 nm architecture make it ideal for everyday tasks, office productivity, and light web browsing. In Cinebench R23 single-core, the Pentium scores 744 versus 612, a 21.6% lead that will translate to snappier application launches and more responsive general use. For users who prioritize a modern platform with PCIe Gen 5 and DDR5 memory support, the Pentium Gold G7400E is the only choice between these two, as the i5-4590S is locked to older standards.
The Core i5-4590S, despite its losses, retains a theoretical advantage in heavily threaded scenarios that can utilize its four physical cores. However, the benchmark data shows this advantage does not materialize in practice. In the multicore Cinebench R23 test, the i5-4590S scores 4338, which is lower than the Pentium’s 5270. This suggests that the i5’s older Haswell cores are so inefficient that they cannot compete even when outnumbering the Pentium’s cores two-to-one. The only scenario where the i5-4590S might be preferable is if you have a legacy Socket 1150 motherboard and DDR3 memory already on hand, as it would avoid a full platform upgrade. But in terms of pure benchmark performance, there is no test in the data where the i5-4590S comes out ahead.
FAQ
Q: Which processor has more cores?
A: The Intel Core i5-4590S has 4 cores, while the Intel Pentium Gold G7400E has 2 cores.
Q: Is the Pentium Gold G7400E faster than the Core i5-4590S in multicore performance?
A: Yes. In Cinebench R23 multicore, the Pentium Gold G7400E scores 5270, which is 21.5% higher than the Core i5-4590S’s score of 4338.
Q: What is the difference in single-core performance?
A: The Pentium Gold G7400E leads in Cinebench R23 single-core with a score of 744, beating the Core i5-4590S’s score of 612 by 21.6%.
Q: Do these processors support the same memory types?
A: No. The Pentium Gold G7400E supports DDR4 and DDR5, while the Core i5-4590S only supports DDR3.
Q: What are the TDP ratings for each processor?
A: The Pentium Gold G7400E has a TDP of 46 watts, while the Core i5-4590S has a TDP of 65 watts.
Q: What are the average benchmark scores for these CPUs?
A: The Pentium Gold G7400E has an average benchmark score of 1524, and the Core i5-4590S has an average benchmark score of 1493.
Specification Differences
The two processors differ in almost every fundamental specification. The Pentium Gold G7400E has 2 cores and 4 threads, whereas the Core i5-4590S has 4 cores and 4 threads. The base clock is higher on the Pentium at 3.60 GHz, compared to the i5’s 2.90 GHz, but the i5 has a boost clock of 3.60 GHz that the Pentium lacks. The TDP is lower on the Pentium at 46 watts versus 65 watts for the i5. The sockets are incompatible: the Pentium uses Intel Socket 1700, and the i5 uses Intel Socket 1150. The architecture and process node differ, with the Pentium on Alder Lake at 10 nm and the i5 on Haswell at 22 nm. The cache layout is different, with the Pentium having 80 KB L1 and 1.25 MB L2 per core, while the i5 has 64 KB L1 and 256 KB L2 per core; both have 6 MB of shared L3. Memory support is broader on the Pentium (DDR4, DDR5) versus the i5 (DDR3). The PCIe version is Gen 5 on the Pentium and Gen 3 on the i5. The integrated graphics are UHD Graphics 710 on the Pentium and Intel HD 4600 on the i5. The release dates are far apart, with the Pentium from 2022 and the i5 from 2014. The i5 also has documented specs for transistors (1,400 million) and die size (177 mm²) that are not available for the Pentium.
The Verdict
The data is unambiguous: the Intel Pentium Gold G7400E is the superior processor in every benchmark category. It delivers a 21.5% advantage in multicore and a 21.6% advantage in single-core Cinebench R23 performance, all while consuming less power (46 watts vs 65 watts). The Pentium also brings a modern platform with PCIe Gen 5 and support for DDR5 memory, which the i5-4590S cannot offer. For any new build, the Pentium Gold G7400E is the clear choice, offering better performance and a forward-looking feature set.
The Core i5-4590S should only be considered if you are constrained to an existing Socket 1150 motherboard and DDR3 memory. Its four cores do not help it overcome the architectural disadvantage, as the benchmarks show it losing even in multicore tests. The i5-4590S matches the Pentium in percentile ranking (38th percentile) but with a lower average benchmark score of 1493 versus 1524. Given the uniform 21%+ win margin across all tests, the Pentium Gold G7400E is the practical recommendation for anyone building a new system, providing a better balance of performance, efficiency, and platform longevity.