Intel Core i5-4440S vs Intel Pentium Gold G6505 Comparison
Intel Core i5-4440S
Pentium Gold G6505
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: Intel Core i5-4440S vs Intel Pentium Gold G6505
The Intel Core i5-4440S and Intel Pentium Gold G6505 are two desktop processors from different eras, yet benchmark results show they land in nearly the same performance tier. The i5-4440S, a Haswell-era quad-core from 2013, and the G6505, a Comet Lake dual-core from 2021, both sit at the 30th percentile of all CPUs. Their average benchmark scores are separated by a razor-thin margin, with the i5-4440S posting 1078 and the G6505 posting 1074. The data reveals a fascinating generational clash where a newer, higher-clocked dual-core matches an older quad-core across the board.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The benchmark comparison between these two chips is remarkably tight, with the Core i5-4440S winning all six head-to-head tests but by margins so small they are nearly imperceptible in real-world use. In Cinebench R15 multicore, the i5-4440S scores 375 against the G6505’s 374, a delta of just 0.3%. The single-core test in R15 is a dead heat, with both processors scoring 52 points and a deltaPct of 0. Moving to Cinebench R20, the multicore result shows the i5-4440S at 1566 versus the G6505 at 1560, a 0.4% advantage. The R20 single-core score is again identical at 220 points for both chips.
The pattern continues in Cinebench R23, the most current test in the data. The i5-4440S scores 3729 in multicore, while the G6505 scores 3715, giving the older chip a 0.4% lead. In the R23 single-core test, the i5-4440S posts 526 against the G6505’s 524, another 0.4% margin. The data shows a consistent but minuscule advantage for the i5-4440S in every workload tested. The largest delta across all six benchmarks is just 0.4%, which is within run-to-run variance for most benchmarking software.
What makes these results striking is the architecture gap. The i5-4440S relies on four physical cores running at a base clock of 2.80 GHz with a boost of 3.30 GHz. The G6505 counters with only two physical cores but four threads and a much higher base clock of 4.20 GHz with no boost clock listed. The higher clock speed of the G6505 apparently compensates for its core deficit, allowing it to nearly match the quad-core i5 in both single-threaded and multi-threaded tests. The i5-4440S’s win in every test, however small, suggests that its four cores provide a slight edge even against the G6505’s clock advantage.
Where Each One Wins
Looking strictly at the benchmark data, the Core i5-4440S wins every single test, but the practical implications of that sweep are minimal given the tiny deltas. The i5-4440S shows its best relative performance in Cinebench R20 multicore and R23 multicore, where it leads by 0.4% in both. These are the tests where its four physical cores can flex their muscle without a clock-speed handicap. The i5-4440S also edges out the G6505 in Cinebench R15 multicore by 0.3%, and in R23 single-core by 0.4%. Even in the tests where the delta is 0%, the i5-4440S is declared the winner by the data.
The Pentium Gold G6505, despite losing all six tests, has its own strengths that the benchmark scores reveal indirectly. Its 4.20 GHz base clock is substantially higher than the i5-4440S’s 3.30 GHz boost clock, which explains why the single-core scores are so close. In Cinebench R15 single-core, both chips score 52, and in R20 single-core, both score 220. The G6505’s ability to match the i5-4440S in single-threaded workloads with half the physical cores confirms its clock speed and newer architecture. For workloads that are lightly threaded and clock-sensitive, the G6505 would be expected to perform similarly to the i5-4440S based on these numbers.
The G6505 also brings advantages outside raw compute benchmarks that are relevant to certain use cases. It supports DDR4 memory with a memory bandwidth of 42.7 GB/s, whereas the i5-4440S is limited to DDR3. The G6505 also features UHD Graphics 630 integrated graphics compared to the i5-4440S’s Intel HD 4600. The G6505 has a lower TDP of 58 watts against the i5-4440S’s 65 watts, making it a more power-efficient choice. These factors do not show up in Cinebench scores but can influence platform-level decisions.
The Verdict
The data presents a clear but narrow verdict: the Core i5-4440S is the better processor in benchmark terms, but the margin is so small that it would be difficult to notice in everyday use. The i5-4440S wins all six head-to-head benchmarks, with the largest lead being 0.4% in Cinebench R20 multicore, R23 multicore, and R23 single-core. Its average benchmark score of 1078 is 0.4% higher than the G6505’s 1074, and it sits at the same 30th percentile of all CPUs. For users who want the absolute highest Cinebench scores in this comparison, the i5-4440S is the pick.
However, the Pentium Gold G6505 is far from a poor choice. It matches the i5-4440S in two single-core tests with a 0% delta, and it trails by only 0.3-0.4% in the other four tests. The G6505’s newer Comet Lake architecture, DDR4 memory support, higher clock speed, and lower TDP make it a compelling option for users building a modern system. The i5-4440S requires DDR3 memory and an older Socket 1150 platform, while the G6505 uses Socket 1200 with current DDR4 support. The launch MSRP of the G6505 is $75, which the data does not compare against any price for the i5-4440S.
For users who prioritize benchmark performance above all else, the i5-4440S wins by a hair. For users who want a newer platform with modern memory support, lower power draw, and a higher clock speed, the G6505 is the logical choice. The data does not show a meaningful performance gap between the two, so platform and feature preferences should drive the decision. The verdict is essentially a tie, with the i5-4440S holding a symbolic but insignificant edge in every measured test.
FAQ
Q: Which processor has the higher average benchmark score?
A: The Intel Core i5-4440S has an average benchmark score of 1078, while the Intel Pentium Gold G6505 scores 1074, a difference of 0.4%.
Q: How do the two chips compare in single-core performance?
A: They are virtually identical. In Cinebench R15 single-core, both score 52, and in Cinebench R20 single-core, both score 220. In Cinebench R23 single-core, the i5-4440S scores 526 against the G6505’s 524.
Q: What are the core and thread counts for each processor?
A: The Intel Core i5-4440S has 4 cores and 4 threads. The Intel Pentium Gold G6505 has 2 cores and 4 threads.
Q: Which processor supports DDR4 memory?
A: The Intel Pentium Gold G6505 supports DDR4 memory with a bandwidth of 42.7 GB/s. The Intel Core i5-4440S supports DDR3 memory.
Q: What is the TDP difference between the two?
A: The Intel Core i5-4440S has a TDP of 65 watts, while the Intel Pentium Gold G6505 has a lower TDP of 58 watts.
Q: How many head-to-head benchmarks did each processor win?
A: The Intel Core i5-4440S won all 6 head-to-head benchmarks. The Intel Pentium Gold G6505 won 0.
Architecture Differences
The two processors come from fundamentally different eras of Intel design. The Core i5-4440S uses the Haswell architecture on a 22 nm process node, fabricated by Intel with 1,400 million transistors on a 177 mm² die. The Pentium Gold G6505 uses the Comet Lake-R architecture on a 14 nm process node, though the data does not list its transistor count or die size. The i5-4440S is a quad-core design with 4 threads, while the G6505 is a dual-core design with 4 threads enabled by Hyper-Threading.
Clock speeds differ significantly. The i5-4440S has a base clock of 2.80 GHz and a boost clock of 3.30 GHz. The G6505 has a base clock of 4.20 GHz and no boost clock listed, meaning it runs at a fixed 4.20 GHz across all workloads. This clock advantage helps the G6505 compensate for having half the physical cores of the i5-4440S.
Cache configurations also differ. Both chips have 64 KB of L1 cache per core and 256 KB of L2 cache per core. However, the i5-4440S has 6 MB of shared L3 cache, while the G6505 has 4 MB of shared L3 cache. The i5-4440S’s larger L3 cache provides an advantage in workloads that benefit from more shared cache, while the G6505’s higher clock speed helps in latency-sensitive tasks.
Memory support marks a major platform divergence. The i5-4440S uses DDR3 memory with a dual-channel bus, while the G6505 uses DDR4 memory with a dual-channel bus and a listed bandwidth of 42.7 GB/s. The i5-4440S supports PCIe Gen 3, and the G6505 also supports PCIe Gen 3 with 16 lanes on the CPU. Both processors have integrated graphics, with the i5-4440S featuring Intel HD 4600 and the G6505 featuring UHD Graphics 630. Neither chip supports ECC memory, and both have locked multipliers.
Socket compatibility is a key differentiator. The i5-4440S uses Intel Socket 1150, while the G6505 uses Intel Socket 1200. This means the two processors are not interchangeable in any motherboard. The G6505 is listed as having an active production status, while the i5-4440S has no production status listed. The G6505 was released in 2021, while the i5-4440S was released in 2013, representing an eight-year gap in release dates.