Intel Core i5-3450S vs Intel Pentium Gold G6605 Comparison
Intel Core i5-3450S
Pentium Gold G6605
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: Intel Core i5-3450S vs Intel Pentium Gold G6605
The Intel Pentium Gold G6605 and Intel Core i5-3450S represent two very different eras of desktop computing, yet their benchmark results place them in a near-identical performance class. The data shows that the newer dual-core Pentium, built on a 14 nm process, consistently edges out the older quad-core Ivy Bridge part across every tested workload, albeit by a narrow margin. Both processors occupy the 31st percentile of all CPUs, and their average benchmark scores differ by only four points (1103 vs. 1099), making this a closer contest than the generational gap suggests.
FAQ
Q: Which processor has more physical cores?
A: The Intel Core i5-3450S has four physical cores, while the Intel Pentium Gold G6605 has only two. However, the Pentium Gold supports four threads via Hyper-Threading, matching the i5's thread count of four.
Q: How do the multi-core Cinebench R23 scores compare?
A: The Pentium Gold G6605 scores 3814 in Cinebench R23 multi-core, which is 1.8% ahead of the Core i5-3450S's score of 3747. This means the two-core Pentium outperforms the four-core i5 in this threaded workload.
Q: What is the single-core performance difference?
A: In Cinebench R23 single-core, the Pentium Gold G6605 scores 538, while the Core i5-3450S scores 529. This represents a 1.7% advantage for the Pentium Gold, and the delta is similar across all single-core Cinebench tests.
Q: Which processor has a higher base clock speed?
A: The Pentium Gold G6605 has a base clock of 4.30 GHz, which is significantly higher than the Core i5-3450S's base clock of 2.80 GHz. The i5 does have a boost clock of 3.50 GHz, but the Pentium Gold's fixed clock remains higher.
Q: Do both processors support the same memory type?
A: No. The Pentium Gold G6605 supports DDR4 memory with dual-channel configuration, while the Core i5-3450S supports DDR3 memory. Both use dual-channel memory buses.
Q: What are the integrated graphics solutions?
A: The Pentium Gold G6605 features UHD Graphics 630, whereas the Core i5-3450S is equipped with Intel HD 2500. The data does not include performance metrics for either integrated GPU.
Architecture Differences
The two CPUs come from fundamentally different architectural lineages. The Pentium Gold G6605 is based on the Comet Lake architecture, specifically the Comet Lake-R codename, manufactured on Intel's 14 nm process node. In contrast, the Core i5-3450S uses the Ivy Bridge architecture, built on a 22 nm process. This process node difference is substantial, with the 14 nm node allowing for higher clock speeds and better power efficiency per clock.
The transistor count and die size also differ markedly. The Core i5-3450S contains 1,400 million transistors on a 160 mm² die, while the Pentium Gold's transistor count and die size are not listed in the data. This reflects the manufacturing maturity and design complexity of each generation.
Cache hierarchies are another point of divergence. Both processors share a per-core L1 cache of 64 KB and per-core L2 cache of 256 KB. However, the L3 cache differs: the Pentium Gold has 4 MB shared L3 cache, while the Core i5-3450S has 6 MB shared L3 cache. The i5's larger L3 pool provides a capacity advantage, though the Pentium's higher clocks compensate in practice.
The integrated graphics units are different generations as well. The Pentium Gold pairs with UHD Graphics 630, while the i5-3450S uses Intel HD 2500. Neither processor supports ECC memory, and both have non-unlocked multipliers, meaning they are not intended for overclocking.
Memory support represents a generational shift. The Pentium Gold G6605 uses DDR4 memory with a memory bandwidth of 42.7 GB/s, while the Core i5-3450S uses DDR3 with no memory bandwidth figure listed. Both operate on dual-channel memory buses, but the newer DDR4 standard offers higher potential bandwidth.
The socket interfaces are incompatible: the Pentium Gold uses Intel Socket 1200, while the Core i5-3450S uses Intel Socket 1155. This means motherboard compatibility is completely different, and an upgrade between these two would require a new platform.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
Across all six head-to-head Cinebench tests, the Intel Pentium Gold G6605 wins every single comparison. The largest margin of victory comes in the Cinebench R15 tests, where the Pentium leads by 1.9% in both multi-core and single-core. In multi-core R15, the Pentium scores 384 against the i5-3450S's 377; in single-core, the scores are 54 vs. 53.
The Cinebench R20 results show a similar pattern. The Pentium Gold wins multi-core with a score of 1601 against 1573, a 1.8% advantage. The single-core delta narrows slightly to 1.4%, with scores of 225 vs. 222. These margins are small but consistent, indicating that the Pentium's architectural efficiency and clock advantage outweigh the i5's core count advantage.
Cinebench R23 continues the trend. The multi-core test shows the Pentium Gold scoring 3814, which is 1.8% higher than the i5-3450S's 3747. The single-core test yields a 1.7% lead for the Pentium, with scores of 538 vs. 529. Notably, even with two fewer physical cores, the Pentium Gold maintains a multi-core advantage, which speaks to the significant per-core performance uplift from the newer Comet Lake architecture.
The overall benchmark average tells a slightly different story. The Pentium Gold G6605 has an average benchmark score of 1103, while the Core i5-3450S averages 1099. This four-point difference (0.4%) is smaller than the Cinebench deltas, partly because the i5-3450S has additional Geekbench results that are not present for the Pentium Gold. The i5-3450S scores 1712 in Geekbench multi-core and 581 in single-core, though no comparable Geekbench data exists for the Pentium Gold in this dataset.
The nearest rivals for each processor reinforce the overall performance parity. The Pentium Gold G6605 sits exactly level with the Intel Xeon E5-2603 v3 (0% delta), while the Core i5-3450S matches the Intel Pentium 6805 (0% delta). Both CPUs have rivals within a 0.3% range, showing they occupy the same performance tier despite their different core configurations.
Specification Differences
The table below highlights the key specifications where the two processors differ, based solely on the provided data:
| Specification | Intel Pentium Gold G6605 | Intel Core i5-3450S |
|---|---|---|
| Cores | 2 | 4 |
| Threads | 4 | 4 |
| Base Clock | 4.30 GHz | 2.80 GHz |
| Boost Clock | None listed | 3.50 GHz |
| TDP | 58 W | 65 W |
| Socket | Intel Socket 1200 | Intel Socket 1155 |
| Architecture | Comet Lake | Ivy Bridge |
| Process Node | 14 nm | 22 nm |
| Transistors | Not listed | 1,400 million |
| Die Size | Not listed | 160 mm² |
| L3 Cache | 4 MB (shared) | 6 MB (shared) |
| Memory Support | DDR4 | DDR3 |
| Memory Bandwidth | 42.7 GB/s | Not listed |
| Integrated Graphics | UHD Graphics 630 | Intel HD 2500 |
| Release Date | 2021-03-15 | 2012-04-28 |
| Launch MSRP | $86 | Not listed |
| Part Number | SRH3T | SR0P2 |
The TDP figures show the Pentium Gold consumes 58 W, which is lower than the Core i5-3450S's 65 W, despite the Pentium's much higher base clock. The i5's boost clock of 3.50 GHz is still well below the Pentium's fixed 4.30 GHz base clock. The release dates are nearly nine years apart, with the Pentium Gold launched in March 2021 and the i5-3450S in April 2012. The Pentium Gold has a launch MSRP of $86, while no MSRP is listed for the older i5.
The Verdict
The benchmark data is unambiguous: the Intel Pentium Gold G6605 wins all six head-to-head comparisons against the Intel Core i5-3450S. While the margins are narrow, ranging from 1.4% to 1.9%, the Pentium Gold achieves these wins despite having half the physical core count. This indicates that the Comet Lake architecture's per-core performance, driven by its 4.30 GHz base clock and 14 nm process, more than compensates for the i5-3450S's two additional cores and larger 6 MB L3 cache.
The Core i5-3450S does offer advantages that are not captured in these specific Cinebench tests. Its four physical cores and 6 MB L3 cache could theoretically benefit workloads that scale with core count and cache size. However, the data provided shows no benchmark where the i5-3450S comes out ahead. The i5 also has additional Geekbench results available, but no direct comparison is possible since the Pentium Gold lacks corresponding Geekbench scores.
For a user choosing between these two processors based strictly on the data, the Pentium Gold G6605 is the better performer in every measured test. It also offers lower TDP, newer memory support, a more recent release date, and a known launch MSRP of $86. The i5-3450S's only quantitative advantages are its longer list of published benchmarks and its larger L3 cache, neither of which translates to a performance win in the head-to-head results.
The practical choice depends on platform requirements. The Pentium Gold G6605 requires an Intel Socket 1200 motherboard with DDR4 support, while the Core i5-3450S is tied to the older Socket 1155 platform with DDR3 memory. The data does not include platform costs or availability, so the decision rests on which system a user already owns or intends to build. Performance-wise, both CPUs sit at the 31st percentile of all processors, and their average scores are within 0.4% of each other, making the Pentium Gold G6605 the clear winner in this direct comparison.