Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 vs Intel Core i5-4210U Comparison
Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770
Core i5-4210U
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 vs Intel Core i5-4210U
Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 and Intel Core i5-4210U are separated by six years of silicon evolution, yet they land within 0.3% of each other in average benchmark score. The QX9770, a 2008 desktop flagship, and the i5-4210U, a 2014 mobile part, both sit at the 21st percentile of all CPUs. That parity is the headline; the details of how they achieve it are where the decision gets interesting.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The QX9770 wins every single benchmark in the head-to-head comparison, and it does so by a nearly uniform margin. In Cinebench R15 multicore, the QX9770 scores 231 against the i5-4210U's 197, a 17.3% advantage. The pattern repeats across all four other Cinebench tests: R20 multicore shows 963 versus 824 (16.9% ahead), R20 singlecore shows 136 versus 116 (17.2% ahead), R23 multicore shows 2295 versus 1962 (17% ahead), and R23 singlecore shows 324 versus 277 (17% ahead). When a CPU wins by 17% in both single-threaded and multi-threaded workloads, it indicates a fundamental per-clock advantage rather than a core-count quirk.
The single-core margins are particularly telling. The i5-4210U has a higher boost clock of 2.70 GHz against the QX9770's fixed 3.20 GHz base, yet the older chip still leads by 17% in single-threaded Cinebench tests. The QX9770's higher base clock and older Core 2 architecture are evidently enough to overcome the newer Haswell design's efficiency gains. Meanwhile, in multicore tests, the QX9770's four physical cores without hyper-threading beat the i5-4210U's two cores with four threads. The i5-4210U's extra logical threads help it close the gap slightly—the multicore deltas range from 16.9% to 17.3%—but they do not erase the QX9770's lead.
The data shows a clean sweep: 5 wins for the QX9770, 0 for the i5-4210U. However, the absolute scores reveal how close these parts are in real-world terms. A 17% difference in Cinebench R23 multicore translates to 2295 versus 1962 points—both are firmly in entry-level territory by modern standards. Neither chip is breaking any speed records; they are simply trading blows within a narrow performance band.
Where Each One Wins
The QX9770 wins everywhere in raw compute, but the i5-4210U wins in contexts that benchmarks do not capture. The i5-4210U's 15 W TDP versus the QX9770's 136 W TDP means the mobile chip can operate in thin-and-light laptops with passive or minimal cooling, while the desktop part requires a substantial cooler and a power supply capable of feeding a hungry processor. The i5-4210U also integrates Intel HD 4400 graphics, eliminating the need for a discrete GPU in basic systems. The QX9770's graphics are a chipset feature that depends on the motherboard, making it less self-contained.
For use-case split: the QX9770 is the pick for a stationary desktop where power draw is irrelevant and every percentage point of compute matters. Its unlocked multiplier allows overclocking, which the benchmark data does not quantify but the hardware design supports. The i5-4210U is the pick for a laptop where battery life, heat output, and package size dominate. The i5-4210U's 22 nm process node versus the QX9770's 45 nm node is the architectural reason for this efficiency gap; the newer chip packs 1,400 million transistors into a 118 mm² die, while the older chip uses 820 million transistors across a 2x 107 mm² layout.
The i5-4210U's boost clock of 2.70 GHz gives it a temporary speed advantage when only one or two cores are active, but the benchmark data shows this does not translate into a win. The QX9770's sustained 3.20 GHz clock on all four cores is a simpler, more predictable performance profile. For tasks that are short and bursty, the i5-4210U's boost behavior may feel snappier in a laptop context, but for sustained render workloads, the QX9770's consistent clock wins out.
Architecture Differences
The QX9770 is built on Intel's Core 2 architecture, codenamed Yorkfield, on a 45 nm process. The i5-4210U uses the Haswell architecture on a 22 nm process. That process shrink is the single biggest differentiator: it allows the i5-4210U to fit 1,400 million transistors into a 118 mm² die, compared to the QX9770's 820 million transistors spread across 2x 107 mm². The i5-4210U is denser, more power-efficient, and integrates more functionality per square millimeter.
The QX9770 has 4 physical cores and 4 threads, with a 12 MB shared L2 cache and 64 KB L1 per core. The i5-4210U has 2 physical cores and 4 threads via hyper-threading, with a 3 MB shared L3 cache, 256 KB L2 per core, and 64 KB L1 per core. The cache topology is fundamentally different: the QX9770 relies on a large shared L2, while the i5-4210U uses a smaller L2 per core plus a shared L3. The i5-4210U has no L3 on the QX9770, and the QX9770 has no L3 at all.
Memory support diverges sharply. The QX9770 supports DDR1, DDR2, and DDR3 across a dual-channel bus, while the i5-4210U supports only DDR3. The QX9770 uses Intel Socket 775, a desktop platform with PCIe Gen 2; the i5-4210U is soldered to Intel BGA 1168, a mobile socket with no listed PCIe generation. The i5-4210U includes integrated Intel HD 4400 graphics; the QX9770's graphics are "on certain motherboards" as a chipset feature, not part of the CPU itself.
The QX9770 has an unlocked multiplier, making it overclockable; the i5-4210U is locked. The QX9770 is end-of-life production, while the i5-4210U's production status is not listed. Release dates are 2008-03-23 for the QX9770 and 2014-04-13 for the i5-4210U. Neither chip supports ECC memory.
FAQ
Q: Which CPU has a higher average benchmark score?
A: The QX9770 scores 790 on average, while the i5-4210U scores 788. That is a 0.3% difference, which is within run-to-run variance.
Q: How does the i5-4210U's single-core performance compare to the QX9770's?
A: The QX9770 leads by 17.2% in Cinebench R20 singlecore (136 versus 116) and by 17% in R23 singlecore (324 versus 277), despite the i5-4210U having a higher boost clock.
Q: Does the i5-4210U have more cores than the QX9770?
A: No. The QX9770 has 4 cores and 4 threads; the i5-4210U has 2 cores and 4 threads. The QX9770 has two more physical cores, while the i5-4210U uses hyper-threading to match thread count.
Q: What is the TDP difference between these two CPUs?
A: The QX9770 has a 136 W TDP, while the i5-4210U has a 15 W TDP. The i5-4210U draws roughly one-ninth the power of the QX9770.
Q: Can the i5-4210U be overclocked?
A: No. The i5-4210U has a locked multiplier, while the QX9770 has an unlocked multiplier.
Q: Which CPU supports integrated graphics?
A: The i5-4210U has Intel HD 4400 integrated graphics. The QX9770 does not include integrated graphics in the CPU; it relies on a chipset feature on certain motherboards.
Specification Differences
| Specification | Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 | Intel Core i5-4210U |
|---|---|---|
| Cores | 4 | 2 |
| Threads | 4 | 4 |
| Base Clock | 3.20 GHz | 1700.00 MHz |
| Boost Clock | None | 2.70 GHz |
| TDP | 136 W | 15 W |
| Socket | Intel Socket 775 | Intel BGA 1168 |
| Architecture | Core 2 | Haswell |
| Codename | Yorkfield | Haswell |
| Process Node | 45 nm | 22 nm |
| Transistors | 820 million | 1,400 million |
| Die Size | 2x 107 mm² | 118 mm² |
| L2 Cache | 12 MB (shared) | 256 KB (per core) |
| L3 Cache | None | 3 MB (shared) |
| Memory Support | DDR1, DDR2, DDR3 | DDR3 |
| PCIe | Gen 2 | None listed |
| Integrated Graphics | Chipset feature | Intel HD 4400 |
| Market Segment | Desktop | Mobile |
| Production Status | End-of-life | Not listed |
| Release Date | 2008-03-23 | 2014-04-13 |
| Multiplier Unlocked | Yes | No |
| Part Number | SLAWM | SR1EF |
The Verdict
The data points to the QX9770 as the faster processor in every measured benchmark. If your priority is raw compute and you have a desktop platform with adequate cooling and power delivery, the QX9770 is the clear choice. It delivers a consistent 17% edge across both single-threaded and multi-threaded workloads, and its unlocked multiplier gives you headroom that the i5-4210U cannot offer. The 136 W TDP is the price you pay for that performance, and it is a non-issue in a desktop case with a proper cooler.
The i5-4210U is the sensible pick when power consumption, heat, and physical size are constraints. Its 15 W TDP is a fraction of the QX9770's, its integrated graphics eliminate a separate GPU for basic display output, and its 22 nm process makes it viable in a thin laptop chassis. The benchmark deficit of roughly 17% is real, but it comes with a power savings of over 120 W and a form factor that the QX9770 cannot physically match.
For a desktop user who already has a Socket 775 motherboard and a capable cooler, the QX9770 is the better processor. For anyone building or buying a mobile system, the i5-4210U is the only realistic option of the two, and its performance is close enough that most users will not notice the gap outside of sustained rendering tasks. Neither chip is a modern powerhouse—both sit at the 21st percentile of all CPUs—but within their respective contexts, each serves its purpose. The QX9770 wins on compute; the i5-4210U wins on efficiency and integration. Choose accordingly.