Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 vs Intel Core i5-3610ME Comparison

Intel
INTEL

Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770

CORE STATE Yorkfield
CORE SPECS 4 Cores / 4 Threads
CLOCK SPEED 3.2 Base
CACHE —
MAX TDP 136W
ARCHITECTURE Core 2
nm
PROCESS 45 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2008
VS
Intel
INTEL

Core i5-3610ME

CORE STATE Ivy Bridge
CORE SPECS 2 Cores / 4 Threads
CLOCK SPEED 2.7 Base / 3.3 GHz Turbo
CACHE 3 MB (shared)
MAX TDP 35W
ARCHITECTURE Ivy Bridge
nm
PROCESS 22 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2012

PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS

cinebench_cinebench_r15_multicore
231
230
cinebench_cinebench_r20_multicore
963
961
cinebench_cinebench_r20_singlecore
136
135
cinebench_cinebench_r23_multicore
2,295
2,289
cinebench_cinebench_r23_singlecore
324
323

Analysis: Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 vs Intel Core i5-3610ME

The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 and the Intel Core i5-3610ME are separated by over four years of silicon evolution, yet their benchmark scores tell a story of remarkable convergence. The desktop Extreme edition, launched in March 2008, and the mobile Ivy Bridge chip, released in May 2012, land within 0.3% of each other in average benchmark score, with the QX9770 at 790 and the i5-3610ME at 788. Both processors sit at the 21st percentile of all CPUs tested, placing them in identical company. The head-to-head results show the older chip winning all five Cinebench tests, but by margins so thin they are effectively statistical ties.

Head-to-Head Benchmarks

The QX9770 takes the multi-core Cinebench R15 test with a score of 231 against the i5-3610ME’s 230, a 0.4% edge. In Cinebench R20 multi-core, the gap narrows to 0.2%, with scores of 963 and 961 respectively. The single-core results follow the same pattern: the QX9770 posts 136 in Cinebench R20 single-core versus 135 for the i5-3610ME, a 0.7% advantage, and 324 versus 323 in Cinebench R23 single-core, a 0.3% lead.

The largest delta in the entire comparison is that 0.7% single-core R20 result, which is still within run-to-run noise for most benchmark suites. The Cinebench R23 multi-core test shows the QX9770 at 2295 and the i5-3610ME at 2289, a 0.3% difference. Across all five tests, the QX9770 wins five and the i5-3610ME wins zero, but the average delta is just 0.38%. These are not victories in any meaningful sense; they are two processors producing functionally identical Cinebench output despite radically different architectures.

The nearest rival data reinforces this picture. The QX9770’s closest competitor is the Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 and the AMD Opteron 3350 HE, both at 789 average score, with a delta of 0.1%. The i5-3610ME’s nearest rival is the Intel Core i5-4210U at 788, with a 0% delta, and the AMD Opteron 3350 HE at 789, with a -0.2% delta. The two chips in this comparison are themselves near-identical rivals, separated by just 0.3% in average score.

Architecture Differences

The QX9770 is a desktop part built on Intel’s 45 nm process, packing 820 million transistors across a dual-die design measuring 2x 107 mm². It uses the Core 2 architecture under the Yorkfield codename, with four physical cores and four threads. The i5-3610ME is a mobile chip on Intel’s 22 nm process, with a single die of 118 mm² and no transistor count listed in the data. It uses the Ivy Bridge architecture, with two physical cores and four threads via Hyper-Threading.

Cache configurations diverge sharply. The QX9770 offers 64 KB of L1 per core and a massive 12 MB of shared L2 cache, with no L3. The i5-3610ME also has 64 KB of L1 per core, but only 256 KB of L2 per core, and adds 3 MB of shared L3 cache. The older chip’s enormous L2 is a hallmark of the Core 2 generation, while the newer part relies on a smaller L2 backed by L3.

Clock speeds tell a different story. The QX9770 runs at a fixed 3.20 GHz base clock with no boost capability, while the i5-3610ME starts at 2.70 GHz base and boosts to 3.30 GHz. The i5-3610ME’s boost clock exceeds the QX9770’s base clock by 100 MHz, yet the older chip still edges ahead in every benchmark. The QX9770 has an unlocked multiplier, while the i5-3610ME’s multiplier is locked.

Thermal and power profiles are drastically different. The QX9770 carries a 136 W TDP, while the i5-3610ME is rated at just 35 W. The mobile chip sips power relative to the desktop behemoth. The QX9770 uses Intel Socket 775, while the i5-3610ME uses Intel Socket G2 (988B). The QX9770 supports DDR1, DDR2, and DDR3 memory in dual-channel configuration, while the i5-3610ME’s memory support is not specified in the data, though it also uses dual-channel memory. Neither chip supports ECC memory.

Integrated graphics separate the two further. The i5-3610ME includes Intel HD 4000 graphics, while the QX9770 relies on chipset-based graphics available on certain motherboards. The QX9770 supports PCIe Gen 2, while the i5-3610ME’s PCIe generation is not listed. The QX9770 is marked as end-of-life, while the i5-3610ME’s production status is not specified.

Where Each One Wins

The QX9770 wins all five benchmark tests, but the margins are negligible. Its largest advantage comes in Cinebench R20 single-core, where it leads by 0.7%. In multi-core workloads, it leads by 0.2% to 0.4%. This suggests the four physical cores of the QX9770 provide a slight edge over the i5-3610ME’s two cores with four threads, even though the newer architecture and higher boost clock of the i5-3610ME nearly close the gap.

The i5-3610ME’s wins are not in benchmark scores but in efficiency and features. Its 35 W TDP versus 136 W means it can operate in mobile form factors where the QX9770 cannot. The integrated Intel HD 4000 graphics eliminate the need for a discrete GPU for basic display output, whereas the QX9770 requires motherboard chipset graphics. The i5-3610ME’s 3.30 GHz boost clock gives it a raw clock speed advantage over the QX9770’s fixed 3.20 GHz, even though that advantage does not translate to benchmark victories.

For workloads that rely on single-threaded performance, the two chips are effectively tied, with the QX9770 ahead by less than 1%. For multi-threaded workloads, the QX9770’s four physical cores give it a slight edge, but the i5-3610ME’s Hyper-Threading keeps it within 0.4%. The i5-3610ME’s 22 nm process node versus the QX9770’s 45 nm node explains the massive TDP difference, but the benchmark results show that architectural efficiency cannot overcome the raw core count advantage in this comparison.

FAQ

Q: Which processor has a higher average benchmark score?

A: The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 has an average benchmark score of 790, while the Intel Core i5-3610ME scores 788, a difference of 0.3%.

Q: How do the core counts compare between the two chips?

A: The QX9770 has four cores and four threads, while the i5-3610ME has two cores and four threads.

Q: What is the TDP difference between these two processors?

A: The QX9770 is rated at 136 W, while the i5-3610ME is rated at 35 W.

Q: Does the i5-3610ME have integrated graphics?

A: Yes, the i5-3610ME includes Intel HD 4000 integrated graphics, while the QX9770 relies on chipset-based graphics on certain motherboards.

Q: What is the largest benchmark margin in this comparison?

A: The largest margin is in Cinebench R20 single-core, where the QX9770 leads by 0.7%, scoring 136 versus 135.

Q: Which processor has a higher clock speed?

A: The QX9770 has a base clock of 3.20 GHz with no boost, while the i5-3610ME has a base clock of 2.70 GHz and a boost clock of 3.30 GHz.

Specification Differences

| Specification | Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 | Intel Core i5-3610ME |

|---|---|---|

| Cores | 4 | 2 |

| Threads | 4 | 4 |

| Base Clock | 3.20 GHz | 2.70 GHz |

| Boost Clock | None | 3.30 GHz |

| TDP | 136 W | 35 W |

| Socket | Intel Socket 775 | Intel Socket G2 (988B) |

| Architecture | Core 2 | Ivy Bridge |

| Codename | Yorkfield | Ivy Bridge |

| Process Node | 45 nm | 22 nm |

| Die Size | 2x 107 mm² | 118 mm² |

| Transistors | 820 million | Not specified |

| L2 Cache | 12 MB (shared) | 256 KB (per core) |

| L3 Cache | None | 3 MB (shared) |

| Memory Support | DDR1, DDR2, DDR3 | Not specified |

| PCIe | Gen 2 | Not specified |

| Integrated Graphics | On certain motherboards (Chipset feature) | Intel HD 4000 |

| Market Segment | Desktop | Mobile |

| Production Status | End-of-life | Not specified |

| Release Date | 2008-03-23 | 2012-05-31 |

| Multiplier Unlocked | Yes | No |

| Part Number | SLAWM | SR0QJ |

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS

SPECIFICATION
2 Extreme QX9770
i5-3610ME
Core Specs
Cores
4
2 -50.0%
Threads
4
4 0.0%
Base Clock (GHz)
3.2
2.7 -15.6%
Boost Clock (GHz)
—
3.3
Frequency (GHz)
3.2
2.7 -15.6%
Turbo Clock (GHz)
—
3.3
Multiplier
8
27 +237.5%
SMP CPUs
1
1 0.0%
Cache
L1 Cache
64 KB (per core)
64 KB (per core)
L2 Cache
12 MB (shared)
256 KB (per core)
L3 Cache
—
3 MB (shared)
Power
TDP (W)
136
35 -74.3%
Architecture
Architecture
Core 2
Ivy Bridge
Codename
Yorkfield
Ivy Bridge
Generation
Core 2 Extreme (Yorkfield XE)
Core i5 (Ivy Bridge)
Process Size
45 nm
22 nm
Transistors
820 million
—
Die Size
2x 107 mm²
118 mm²
Foundry
Intel
Intel
Memory
Memory Support
DDR1, DDR2, DDR3
—
Memory Bus
Dual-channel
Dual-channel
ECC Memory
No
No
Platform
Socket
Intel Socket 775
Intel Socket G2 (988B)
PCIe
Gen 2
—
Graphics
Integrated Graphics
On certain motherboards (Chipset feature)
Intel HD 4000
Other
Market
Desktop
Mobile
Production Status
End-of-life
—
Part Number
SLAWM
SR0QJ
Package
FC-LGA4
FC-PGA12F
View Core 2 Extreme QX9770 Details View Core i5-3610ME Details