AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE vs Intel Xeon D-1581 Comparison
AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE
Xeon D-1581
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE vs Intel Xeon D-1581
The Intel Xeon D-1581 and AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE occupy opposite ends of the CPU spectrum, yet their average benchmark scores are nearly identical. The Xeon D-1581 is a 16-core Broadwell server chip from 2016, while the Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE is a 4-core Zen 3 desktop part from 2021. Despite a 12-core difference, the Ryzen closes the gap with modern architecture and higher clocks. The data shows the Xeon winning every Cinebench test, but by narrow margins of roughly 4%. This is a classic battle between core count and per-core efficiency.
FAQ
Q: Which CPU has more cores and threads?
A: The Intel Xeon D-1581 has 16 cores and 32 threads. The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE has 4 cores and 8 threads. The Xeon has four times the core count and four times the thread count.
Q: How do their average benchmark scores compare?
A: The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE has an average benchmark score of 3218. The Intel Xeon D-1581 has an average score of 3238. The Xeon leads by 0.6% according to the nearestRivals deltaPct data.
Q: What is the clock speed difference?
A: The Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE has a base clock of 3.60 GHz and a boost clock of 4.20 GHz. The Xeon D-1581 has a base clock of 1800.00 MHz and a boost clock of 2.40 GHz. The Ryzen's clocks are substantially higher.
Q: Do both CPUs support ECC memory?
A: Yes. Both the Intel Xeon D-1581 and the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE list ECC memory support as true in their specifications.
Q: Which processor has integrated graphics?
A: Only the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE includes integrated graphics, specifically a Radeon Vega 6. The Intel Xeon D-1581 has no integrated graphics listed.
Q: What is the TDP difference between the two?
A: The Intel Xeon D-1581 has a TDP of 65 watts. The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE has a TDP of 35 watts. The Ryzen is rated for nearly half the thermal envelope.
Architecture Differences
The architectural gap between these two parts is generational. The Intel Xeon D-1581 uses the Broadwell architecture on a 14 nm process node, manufactured by Intel. It contains 3,200 million transistors on a 246 mm² die. The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE uses the Zen 3 architecture on a 7 nm process node, manufactured by TSMC. It packs 10,700 million transistors on a smaller 180 mm² die. The shrink from 14 nm to 7 nm allows AMD to fit more than three times the transistors into a smaller physical space.
Cache layouts differ significantly. The Xeon D-1581 provides 64 KB of L1 cache per core, 256 KB of L2 cache per core, and 1.5 MB of L3 cache per core. The Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE also has 64 KB of L1 per core, but doubles the L2 to 512 KB per core. For L3, the Ryzen has a shared 8 MB pool rather than a per-core allocation. This is a fundamental design shift; the Xeon's per-core L3 scales with core count, while the Ryzen uses a unified cache for its four cores.
The memory controllers also reflect their different eras. The Xeon D-1581 supports both DDR3 and DDR4 memory in a dual-channel configuration. The Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE supports only DDR4, also dual-channel, but provides a specific memory bandwidth figure of 51.2 GB/s. PCIe support is similar in generation — both use Gen 3 — but the Xeon offers 24 lanes while the Ryzen offers 16 lanes. The Xeon's socket is Intel BGA 1667, which is a ball-grid array for soldered server installation. The Ryzen uses the standard AMD Socket AM4.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The head-to-head results are consistent across all six Cinebench tests: the Intel Xeon D-1581 wins every single one. The margins, however, are remarkably tight. In Cinebench R15 multicore, the Xeon scores 1128 against the Ryzen's 1083, a 4.2% lead. The single-core test in R15 shows the Xeon at 159 versus 152, a 4.6% advantage. This is notable because single-core performance usually favors the newer architecture with higher clocks, but the Xeon still edges ahead.
Moving to Cinebench R20, the pattern repeats. The Xeon D-1581 scores 4702 in multicore, beating the Ryzen's 4515 by 4.1%. In single-core, the Xeon scores 663 against 637, another 4.1% victory. The Cinebench R23 results show the same delta: the Xeon scores 11197 in multicore versus 10750 for the Ryzen, a 4.2% difference. Single-core R23 sees the Xeon at 1580 and the Ryzen at 1517, again a 4.2% lead.
The data shows no wins for the AMD part in any Cinebench test. The Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE does have additional Geekbench results in its benchmark list — 5311 multicore and 1779 single-core — but the Intel part has no corresponding Geekbench scores in the data, so no comparison is possible there. The overall benchmark score and percentile tell the same story: both CPUs sit at the 53rd percentile versus all CPUs, and their average scores differ by only 20 points out of roughly 3200.
Specification Differences
The specification sheets show stark contrasts between these two processors. The Intel Xeon D-1581 offers 16 cores and 32 threads, while the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE offers 4 cores and 8 threads. Clock speeds are reversed in favor of AMD: the Ryzen runs at 3.60 GHz base and 4.20 GHz boost, while the Xeon runs at 1800.00 MHz base and 2.40 GHz boost. The TDP difference is substantial — 65 watts for Intel versus 35 watts for AMD.
The sockets are incompatible: Intel BGA 1667 for the Xeon versus AMD Socket AM4 for the Ryzen. The process nodes differ by a full generation: 14 nm for Intel versus 7 nm for AMD. Transistor counts are wildly different, with the Ryzen's 10,700 million exceeding the Xeon's 3,200 million despite having far fewer cores. Die size is smaller for the Ryzen at 180 mm² versus 246 mm². Cache configurations differ in L2 (256 KB vs 512 KB per core) and L3 (1.5 MB per core vs 8 MB shared). Memory support differs: the Xeon accepts DDR3 and DDR4, while the Ryzen uses only DDR4. PCIe lane counts differ (24 vs 16). The Ryzen includes Radeon Vega 6 integrated graphics; the Xeon has none. The Ryzen is classified as a desktop part, while the Xeon is a server/workstation chip.
Where Each One Wins
The Intel Xeon D-1581 wins in raw multi-threaded throughput. With 16 cores and 32 threads, it takes the top spot in every Cinebench multicore test included in the data. Its victories are narrow — 4.1% to 4.2% — but they are consistent. The Xeon also wins every single-core Cinebench test, which is surprising given its much lower clock speeds. This suggests the Broadwell architecture's per-core efficiency, combined with its large L3 cache per core, holds up well against Zen 3 in these specific workloads.
The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE wins in efficiency and platform flexibility. Its 35 watt TDP is nearly half the Xeon's 65 watts, making it far easier to cool in a compact desktop build. The integrated Radeon Vega 6 graphics means no separate GPU is required for basic display output. The Ryzen's higher clock speeds — 4.20 GHz boost versus 2.40 GHz — make it more responsive for lightly threaded tasks, even if the Cinebench scores don't reflect a win there. The AM4 socket is a mainstream consumer platform, while the Xeon's BGA 1667 requires a soldered server board.
The Ryzen also brings a modern memory bandwidth specification at 51.2 GB/s, a figure the Xeon does not list. For workloads that are memory-latency sensitive, the Ryzen's higher clocks and newer architecture may offer a smoother experience, even where the benchmark deltas are small.
The Verdict
The data paints a clear picture: the Intel Xeon D-1581 is the faster processor in every measured Cinebench test. It wins by roughly 4% across the board, whether the workload is single-core or multi-core. If raw benchmark score is the only criterion, the Xeon is the pick. Its 16-core, 32-thread configuration delivers a 4.2% advantage in R15 multicore and R23 multicore, and a 4.6% edge in R15 single-core. The average benchmark score of 3238 versus 3218 reinforces this, though the 0.6% delta is within noise.
The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE is the better choice for a different set of priorities. It achieves nearly identical average performance with a quarter of the cores and a 35 watt TDP. The integrated Radeon Vega 6 graphics eliminate the need for a discrete GPU. The AM4 socket offers upgrade paths and consumer board availability. The Ryzen's 7 nm process and 10,700 million transistors represent a much more modern design.
For a builder prioritizing peak Cinebench results, the Xeon D-1581 wins. For a builder prioritizing efficiency, integrated graphics, and a mainstream platform, the Ryzen 3 PRO 5350GE is the logical choice. The benchmark data shows the Xeon ahead, but the margin is small enough that platform and power considerations should drive the decision. Both CPUs sit at the 53rd percentile, and both are active production parts. The Xeon is the performance winner on paper; the Ryzen is the practical winner for most desktop scenarios.