AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U vs Intel Core i5-8600T Comparison
AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U
Core i5-8600T
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U vs Intel Core i5-8600T
The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U and Intel Core i5-8600T present a fascinating contrast in CPU design philosophy, pitting a modern, efficient mobile chip against an older, higher-power desktop part. The benchmark data reveals a clear split: the Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U dominates in Cinebench tests across the board, while the Intel Core i5-8600T fights back decisively in Geekbench workloads. This division suggests that the two processors are optimized for different types of tasks, and the data provides a rich basis for analyzing where each architecture excels.
Where Each One Wins
The most striking pattern in the head-to-head results is the complete separation of victories by benchmark suite. The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U wins all six Cinebench tests, covering R15, R20, and R23, in both single-core and multi-core variants. This is a sweeping victory for the Zen 2 architecture, with the AMD chip consistently outperforming the Intel part by margins ranging from 5.5% to 5.7%. The consistency of these deltas across different Cinebench versions is remarkable, suggesting a stable performance advantage that scales with the workload's characteristics.
Conversely, the Intel Core i5-8600T wins both Geekbench tests, with a 10.2% lead in multi-core and a 7.6% lead in single-core. This is not a small margin, and it indicates that the Coffee Lake architecture has specific strengths that Cinebench does not capture. The Geekbench suite often tests a broader range of real-world scenarios, including memory latency, encryption, and integer performance, which may favor the Intel chip's design. The data implies that for users running Geekbench-style applications, the i5-8600T is the stronger choice, despite its older 14 nm process node.
The use-case split is therefore quite clear. For rendering tasks, which Cinebench simulates, the Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U is the superior processor. For a more general mix of computing workloads, the i5-8600T holds the advantage. This is a classic example of how benchmark selection can dramatically influence the perceived performance of a CPU, and it underscores the importance of matching the test to the intended application.
Architecture Differences
The two processors are built on fundamentally different foundations. The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U uses the Zen 2 architecture, codenamed Renoir, manufactured on a 7 nm process by TSMC. The Intel Core i5-8600T, in contrast, is based on the Coffee Lake architecture, built on Intel's 14 nm process. This process node difference is significant, as the 7 nm node allows for smaller transistors and potentially better power efficiency, which is reflected in the AMD chip's 15 W TDP compared to the Intel chip's 35 W TDP.
Core and thread counts also differ substantially. The Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U has 4 cores and 8 threads, while the i5-8600T has 6 cores and 6 threads. This means the Intel chip has two more physical cores, but the AMD chip benefits from simultaneous multi-threading (SMT), which allows each core to handle two threads. The data suggests that the AMD chip's SMT implementation is effective, as it manages to beat the Intel chip in multi-core Cinebench tests despite having fewer physical cores.
Cache configurations reveal another key difference. The Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U has 64 KB of L1 cache per core, 512 KB of L2 cache per core, and a shared 4 MB L3 cache. The i5-8600T has the same 64 KB L1 per core, but only 256 KB of L2 per core, and a much larger 9 MB shared L3 cache. The larger L3 cache on the Intel chip likely helps it in certain workloads, particularly those that benefit from a bigger pool of shared data, which could be a factor in its Geekbench victories.
Memory bandwidth is another area of divergence. The AMD chip supports a memory bandwidth of 68.3 GB/s, while the Intel chip is rated at 42.7 GB/s. This significant difference in theoretical bandwidth could explain the AMD chip's strong Cinebench performance, as rendering workloads often rely heavily on memory throughput. Both chips support DDR4 memory in a dual-channel configuration, but the AMD chip's higher bandwidth rating suggests a more efficient memory controller.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The Cinebench R15 multi-core test sets the tone for the AMD chip's dominance. The Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U scores 829, while the i5-8600T scores 784, giving the AMD chip a 5.7% advantage. This pattern repeats in Cinebench R15 single-core, where the AMD chip scores 116 against the Intel chip's 110, a 5.5% lead. The consistency of these margins suggests a fundamental architectural advantage for Zen 2 in this workload.
Moving to Cinebench R20, the results are nearly identical in relative terms. The Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U scores 3456 in multi-core versus the i5-8600T's 3270, again a 5.7% delta. In single-core, the AMD chip scores 487 against 461, a 5.6% difference. These scores confirm that the AMD chip's advantage is not a fluke of one test version but a persistent trait across the Cinebench lineage.
Cinebench R23 continues the trend, with the Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U scoring 8230 in multi-core and 1161 in single-core, while the i5-8600T scores 7787 and 1099 respectively. The deltas of 5.7% and 5.6% are nearly identical to the R20 results, indicating a stable performance relationship. This consistency is notable and suggests that the AMD chip's architecture provides a robust advantage in rendering tasks that is independent of the specific Cinebench version.
The Geekbench results tell a completely different story. In Geekbench multi-core, the i5-8600T scores 4277, while the Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U scores 3840, giving the Intel chip a 10.2% lead. This is a substantial margin, and it reverses the trend seen in Cinebench. In Geekbench single-core, the Intel chip scores 1278 against 1181, a 7.6% advantage. The fact that the Intel chip wins in both Geekbench tests, and loses in all Cinebench tests, points to a fundamental difference in how the two benchmark suites stress the processors.
The Verdict
The data presents a nuanced picture for potential buyers. The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U is the clear winner for Cinebench-style workloads, which are indicative of 3D rendering and content creation tasks. Its consistent 5.5-5.7% advantage across all Cinebench versions makes it the safer choice for users who prioritize these applications. The AMD chip also offers a lower TDP of 15 W, making it more suitable for mobile or power-constrained systems, and it has a higher memory bandwidth rating of 68.3 GB/s.
The Intel Core i5-8600T, on the other hand, is the better performer in Geekbench, with a 10.2% multi-core and 7.6% single-core lead. This suggests it may be better suited for a broader range of general-purpose computing tasks, including those that involve complex data manipulation, encryption, or other workloads that Geekbench measures. The Intel chip also has two additional physical cores, which could be beneficial in certain multi-threaded scenarios, and a larger 9 MB L3 cache.
The percentile rankings for both CPUs are identical at 48, and their average benchmark scores are close, with the AMD chip at 2413 and the Intel chip at 2383. The nearest rivals for each chip also show similar performance levels, with the AMD chip's closest competitor being the Intel Xeon E5-2630L v3 at a 0.2% delta, and the Intel chip's closest being the Intel Xeon E-2234 at a 0.4% delta. This indicates that both processors sit in the same performance tier on average, but they achieve that tier through different strengths.
Ultimately, the choice depends on the user's primary applications. For rendering and Cinebench-style workloads, the Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U is the data-backed pick. For Geekbench-style general computing, the i5-8600T holds the edge. The i5-8600T is also noted as end-of-life, while the Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U is still active, which may influence long-term availability and support considerations.
FAQ
Q: Which processor is faster in Cinebench R23 multi-core?
A: The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U is faster, scoring 8230 compared to the Intel Core i5-8600T's 7787, a 5.7% advantage.
Q: Does the Intel Core i5-8600T win any benchmark tests?
A: Yes, the Intel Core i5-8600T wins both Geekbench tests, with a 10.2% lead in multi-core and a 7.6% lead in single-core.
Q: How do the core counts compare between the two CPUs?
A: The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U has 4 cores and 8 threads, while the Intel Core i5-8600T has 6 cores and 6 threads.
Q: What is the TDP difference between the two processors?
A: The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U has a TDP of 15 W, while the Intel Core i5-8600T has a TDP of 35 W.
Q: Which processor has a larger L3 cache?
A: The Intel Core i5-8600T has a larger shared L3 cache of 9 MB, compared to the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U's 4 MB.
Q: What are the production statuses of the two chips?
A: The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U is listed as Active, while the Intel Core i5-8600T is listed as End-of-life.
Specification Differences
| Specification | AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 4450U | Intel Core i5-8600T |
|---|---|---|
| Cores | 4 | 6 |
| Threads | 8 | 6 |
| Base Clock | 2.40 GHz | 2.30 GHz |
| TDP | 15 W | 35 W |
| Socket | AMD Socket FP6 | Intel Socket 1151 |
| Architecture | Zen 2 | Coffee Lake |
| Process Node | 7 nm | 14 nm |
| L2 Cache | 512 KB (per core) | 256 KB (per core) |
| L3 Cache | 4 MB (shared) | 9 MB (shared) |
| Memory Bandwidth | 68.3 GB/s | 42.7 GB/s |
| Integrated Graphics | Radeon Graphics 320SP | UHD Graphics 630 |
| Market Segment | Mobile | Desktop |
| Production Status | Active | End-of-life |
| Release Date | 2020-05-06 | 2018-04-01 |
| Part Number | 100-000000104 | SR3X3 |