AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE vs Intel Core i7-4870HQ Comparison
AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE
Core i7-4870HQ
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE vs Intel Core i7-4870HQ
The benchmark data presents a clear generational and architectural split. The Intel Core i7-4870HQ and AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE are closely matched in overall average score, but they achieve their results through very different means. The Intel part leverages its eight threads to dominate Geekbench, while the AMD part uses its higher clocks and newer core design to win every Cinebench test. The data indicates that the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE is the more consistent performer in rendering workloads, while the Intel Core i7-4870HQ holds a distinct advantage in the Geekbench suite.
The Verdict
Based strictly on the benchmark results, the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE is the preferred choice for users prioritizing Cinebench rendering performance. It wins six of the eight head-to-head benchmarks, taking all Cinebench R15, R20, and R23 tests with a consistent margin of 7.2% to 7.3% over the Intel chip. Its single-core advantage is particularly notable, as it scores 816 in Cinebench R23 single-core versus the Intel’s 757, a 7.2% gap that reflects its higher 4.00 GHz boost clock and newer Zen+ architecture.
The Intel Core i7-4870HQ is the pick for workloads modeled by Geekbench. It wins both multi-core and single-core Geekbench tests, with a massive 26.7% lead in multi-core (3701 vs 2921) and a 9.7% lead in single-core (1143 vs 1042). This is despite having a lower base and boost clock, indicating that its eight threads and larger 6 MB shared L3 cache provide a significant edge in this specific benchmark suite.
For a general-purpose desktop user, the AMD chip is the better all-rounder due to its wins in the more modern Cinebench R23 tests and its active production status. However, for a user with a legacy workload that scales with the specific characteristics measured by Geekbench, the Intel processor remains competitive. The data does not support a single "best" choice; it supports a workload-dependent decision.
Architecture Differences
The two processors represent distinct design philosophies and manufacturing eras. The Intel Core i7-4870HQ is built on Intel’s 22 nm process, while the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE uses a 12 nm process from GlobalFoundries. This process difference is reflected in their transistor counts: the AMD chip packs 4,940 million transistors on a 210 mm² die, versus 1,400 million transistors on Intel’s larger 264 mm² die.
The core configurations are similar but not identical. Both have four physical cores, but the Intel part supports eight threads through Hyper-Threading, while the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE has only four threads. This is a critical distinction, as the Intel part can process two threads per core, which likely contributes to its Geekbench multi-core victory.
Cache hierarchies also differ. The Intel Core i7-4870HQ has 64 KB of L1 and 256 KB of L2 per core, with a 6 MB shared L3 cache. The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE has larger per-core L1 (96 KB) and L2 (512 KB) caches but a smaller 4 MB shared L3 cache. The Intel part compensates for its smaller per-core caches with a larger pool of shared L3 memory.
Platform and memory support are radically different. The Intel chip uses the Intel BGA 1364 socket and is limited to dual-channel DDR3 memory with 25.6 GB/s bandwidth. The AMD chip uses the AM4 socket and supports dual-channel DDR4 with 46.9 GB/s bandwidth, a substantial increase in memory throughput. The AMD part also supports ECC memory, which the Intel part does not. Both CPUs provide Gen 3 PCIe with 16 lanes.
The integrated graphics also differ: the Intel Core i7-4870HQ features Intel HD 5200, while the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE comes with Radeon Vega 8. The release dates are far apart, with Intel launching in June 2014 and AMD in September 2019, and the Intel part is marked end-of-life while the AMD part remains active. The Intel part is also a mobile segment chip, whereas the AMD is a desktop part.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The head-to-head results show a stark split between the two benchmark families. In all six Cinebench tests, the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE emerges victorious. The margin is remarkably consistent: 7.2% in the multi-core tests (R15, R20, R23) and 7.3% in the single-core tests (R15, R20). For example, in Cinebench R15 multi-core, the AMD scores 582 against Intel’s 540, a 7.2% difference. In Cinebench R23 multi-core, the scores are 5785 for AMD and 5366 for Intel, again a 7.2% gap. This uniformity suggests a fundamental clock-for-clock advantage for the AMD architecture in this workload, likely due to its higher boost clock of 4.00 GHz versus 3.70 GHz.
The Geekbench results tell the opposite story. The Intel Core i7-4870HQ wins both tests by substantial margins. In Geekbench multi-core, the Intel chip scores 3701 versus AMD’s 2921, a massive 26.7% lead. This is the single largest performance gap in the entire comparison. The Intel part’s eight threads are clearly being utilized effectively in this test, overcoming its clock speed disadvantage. In Geekbench single-core, the Intel part also wins, scoring 1143 versus 1042, a 9.7% margin. This is surprising given the AMD chip’s higher clock speed and newer architecture, suggesting that the Intel’s larger 6 MB L3 cache or other architectural factors are decisive in this specific test.
The overall win tally is 6 for AMD and 2 for Intel. However, the magnitude of the Intel’s Geekbench multi-core win is nearly four times larger than any single Cinebench margin the AMD chip achieves. This means the average benchmark scores are very close: Intel’s average is 1769, and AMD’s is 1750, a difference of only 1.1%. The Intel Core i7-4870HQ’s nearest rival is the AMD Ryzen 5 2400GE with an average score of 1766 (0.2% delta), while the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE’s closest competitor is the Intel Core i5-8269U at 1748 (0.1% delta).
FAQ
Q: Which processor is faster in Cinebench R23 multi-core?
A: The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE is faster, scoring 5785 compared to the Intel Core i7-4870HQ’s 5366, a 7.2% difference.
Q: Does the Intel Core i7-4870HQ win any benchmark?
A: Yes, it wins both Geekbench tests. It scores 3701 in multi-core (a 26.7% lead over AMD) and 1143 in single-core (a 9.7% lead).
Q: How do their core and thread counts compare?
A: Both have 4 physical cores, but the Intel Core i7-4870HQ has 8 threads while the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE has 4 threads.
Q: What is the memory bandwidth difference?
A: The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE supports DDR4 with 46.9 GB/s bandwidth, while the Intel Core i7-4870HQ supports DDR3 with 25.6 GB/s bandwidth.
Q: Are both processors currently in production?
A: No. The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE is listed as active, while the Intel Core i7-4870HQ is end-of-life.
Q: What is the difference in their average benchmark scores?
A: The Intel Core i7-4870HQ has an average benchmark score of 1769, and the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE has an average of 1750. Both are in the 41st percentile of all CPUs.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE wins in all Cinebench workloads, which are classic rendering and 3D modeling tasks. Its consistent 7.2% to 7.3% lead across all versions of the test suggests it is the stronger choice for video editing, 3D rendering, and any application that uses Cinebench-style multi-threaded and single-threaded rendering. Its higher base clock of 3.30 GHz and boost clock of 4.00 GHz, combined with a smaller, more efficient 12 nm process, give it an edge in these tasks. The AMD chip also benefits from faster DDR4 memory with 46.9 GB/s bandwidth, which could help in memory-intensive workloads. Its active production status also makes it a more viable option for new system builds.
The Intel Core i7-4870HQ wins exclusively in the Geekbench suite. Its 26.7% lead in Geekbench multi-core is a dominant result, suggesting it is superior for workloads that are highly parallel and can leverage its 8 threads. The Geekbench single-core win is also significant, indicating that its architecture is more efficient in certain integer and floating-point operations measured by that benchmark. This makes the Intel chip the better choice for users whose primary applications are Geekbench-dependent, such as certain scientific computing or encryption tasks. Its larger 6 MB L3 cache is a likely contributor to this performance, providing more shared data storage for the 8 threads.
In summary, the AMD Ryzen 3 PRO 3200GE is the winner for rendering and modern multi-threaded applications, while the Intel Core i7-4870HQ is the winner for Geekbench-specific workloads. The Intel chip’s two wins may be fewer, but the 26.7% margin in Geekbench multi-core is a much larger performance swing than any of the AMD chip’s 7.2% wins. Users should choose based on which benchmark suite better represents their actual application usage.