AMD Phenom II X6 1065T vs Intel Core i5-2405S Comparison
AMD Phenom II X6 1065T
Core i5-2405S
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Phenom II X6 1065T vs Intel Core i5-2405S
The AMD Phenom II X6 1065T and Intel Core i5-2405S are two end-of-life desktop processors from different architectural eras, yet benchmark results show they land in nearly identical performance territory. The AMD part offers six physical cores on a 45 nm K10 design, while the Intel part counters with four cores on a 32 nm Sandy Bridge design. Across five Cinebench tests, the Intel Core i5-2405S wins every single one, but the margins are razor-thin, ranging from just 0.1% to 0.6% in its favor. The average benchmark scores tell the same story: the AMD chip scores 993, while the Intel chip scores 991, a difference of only 0.2%. Both processors sit at the 27th percentile of all CPUs, meaning they perform at the same level relative to the broader market. This is a rare head-to-head where the architectural divide produces virtually no measurable performance gap in the tested workloads.
The Verdict
The data presents a clear but unusual verdict: choose the Intel Core i5-2405S if you want marginally better benchmark scores across the board, but the difference is so small that it should not drive your decision. The Intel chip wins all five head-to-head Cinebench tests, including a 0.6% lead in Cinebench R20 single-core (171 vs 170) and a 0.3% lead in Cinebench R15 multi-core (291 vs 290). However, these margins are within run-to-run variance for most real-world testing, so the Intel part’s "victory" is more symbolic than substantive.
For users prioritizing lower power consumption, the Intel Core i5-2405S is the clear choice based on its 65 W TDP compared to the AMD part’s 125 W TDP. That 60 W difference is the largest numerical gap between the two processors and carries practical implications for cooling and system power draw. The AMD Phenom II X6 1065T, on the other hand, offers six cores versus four, which could matter in heavily threaded scenarios not covered by the Cinebench suite, though the benchmark data does not show any such advantage. Given that both processors perform within 0.6% of each other in every test, the selection should hinge on platform preferences, power budgets, and the specific workloads you plan to run, not on raw benchmark scores.
Architecture Differences
The two processors come from fundamentally different design philosophies. The AMD Phenom II X6 1065T uses the K10 architecture on the Thuban codename, built on a 45 nm process by GlobalFoundries. It packs 904 million transistors into a 346 mm² die. The Intel Core i5-2405S uses the Sandy Bridge architecture, built on a 32 nm process by Intel, with 1,160 million transistors in a much smaller 216 mm² die. This process advantage allows Intel to pack more transistors into less space while consuming significantly less power.
Core counts differ substantially. The AMD part features 6 cores and 6 threads, while the Intel part has 4 cores and 4 threads. Neither processor supports simultaneous multithreading, so thread counts equal core counts. Cache hierarchies also differ: the AMD part has 128 KB of L1 cache per core and 512 KB of L2 cache per core, while the Intel part has 64 KB of L1 per core and 256 KB of L2 per core. Both share 6 MB of L3 cache. The AMD chip supports both DDR2 and DDR3 memory with a dual-channel bus and 21.3 GB/s of bandwidth, while the Intel chip supports only DDR3 with dual-channel and no bandwidth figure provided. The AMD part supports ECC memory; the Intel part does not. PCIe support also differs: the AMD chip uses Gen 2, while the Intel chip uses Gen 3 with 16 lanes (CPU only). Integrated graphics present another distinction: the Intel chip includes Intel HD 3000, while the AMD part relies on a chipset feature on certain motherboards rather than an integrated GPU.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The five Cinebench tests show a consistent pattern of Intel winning by tiny margins. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the Intel Core i5-2405S scores 291 against the AMD Phenom II X6 1065T’s 290, a 0.3% lead. The Cinebench R20 multi-core test shows a similar result: 1213 vs 1212, a 0.1% margin. Single-core results follow the same trend. In Cinebench R20 single-core, the Intel part scores 171 vs 170, a 0.6% lead — the largest margin of any test. Cinebench R23 multi-core shows 2890 vs 2888 (0.1% lead), and Cinebench R23 single-core shows 408 vs 407 (0.2% lead). The Intel part also has two Geekbench results listed: 1425 multi-core and 541 single-core, but no comparable Geekbench scores exist for the AMD part, so those cannot be compared directly.
The average benchmark scores reinforce the near-tie. The AMD part averages 993, while the Intel part averages 991, a 0.2% difference. Interestingly, the AMD part’s nearest rival list includes the Intel Core i7-965 and i7-960, both with an average score of 993, and the Intel Xeon W3565 also at 993. The Intel Core i5-2405S’s nearest rivals include those same Intel parts with scores of 993, showing both processors sit in the same performance tier. The deltaPct values are telling: the AMD part is 0.1% behind the Intel Core i3-8130U, while the Intel part is 0.2% behind the Core i7-960 and the AMD Phenom II X6 1065T itself. These deltas are all under 1%, confirming that neither chip has a meaningful performance advantage in the tested benchmarks.
FAQ
Q: Which processor has more cores?
A: The AMD Phenom II X6 1065T has 6 cores and 6 threads, while the Intel Core i5-2405S has 4 cores and 4 threads. Despite the 2-core advantage for AMD, the Intel part wins all five Cinebench comparisons by margins of 0.1% to 0.6%.
Q: How much does the Intel chip lead in single-core performance?
A: The Intel Core i5-2405S leads in both single-core tests: 171 vs 170 in Cinebench R20 single-core (0.6% lead) and 408 vs 407 in Cinebench R23 single-core (0.2% lead). These are the smallest and largest margins among the five tests, respectively.
Q: Which chip has a lower TDP?
A: The Intel Core i5-2405S has a TDP of 65 W, while the AMD Phenom II X6 1065T has a TDP of 125 W. This 60 W difference means the Intel part will generate less heat and require less robust cooling.
Q: Do both processors support ECC memory?
A: No. The AMD Phenom II X6 1065T supports ECC memory, while the Intel Core i5-2405S does not. This could be a deciding factor for users running memory-sensitive workloads.
Q: What is the biggest benchmark margin between the two?
A: The largest margin is in Cinebench R20 single-core, where the Intel Core i5-2405S leads by 0.6% (171 vs 170). All other margins are 0.3% or smaller.
Q: How do these chips compare to older Core i7 processors?
A: Both chips perform at the same level as the Intel Core i7-965 and i7-960, which have an average score of 993. The AMD part matches them exactly at 993, while the Intel part is 0.2% behind at 991.
Where Each One Wins
The Intel Core i5-2405S wins every single benchmark test in the data set, making it the superior choice based purely on measured performance. Its wins span both single-core and multi-core workloads, from Cinebench R15 to R23. The margins are small — the largest is 0.6% — but they are consistent. The Intel part also wins decisively on power efficiency with its 65 W TDP versus 125 W for the AMD part. For builders building a compact system with modest cooling, the Intel chip’s lower power draw is a practical advantage. Additionally, the Intel chip includes integrated graphics via Intel HD 3000, which means it can run without a discrete GPU, while the AMD part requires a motherboard with a chipset feature for graphics output.
The AMD Phenom II X6 1065T does not win a single benchmark in the head-to-head comparison, but it does offer advantages outside of the tested metrics. Its 6 cores provide more raw thread capacity than the Intel part’s 4 cores, which could benefit workloads that scale beyond what Cinebench measures. The AMD chip also supports ECC memory, a feature absent on the Intel part, making it a candidate for systems that require error-correcting RAM. Its support for both DDR2 and DDR3 memory gives it more flexibility with older memory modules, and its Gen 2 PCIe is backward-compatible with a wider range of expansion cards. For users who already own an AM3 motherboard or have a stock of DDR2 memory, the AMD part offers a path to six cores without a full platform overhaul.
Specification Differences
The two processors differ in nearly every core specification. The AMD Phenom II X6 1065T uses the K10 architecture on a 45 nm process, while the Intel Core i5-2405S uses Sandy Bridge on a 32 nm process. Core counts are 6 vs 4, and thread counts match those numbers. Base clocks are 2.90 GHz for the AMD part and 2.50 GHz for the Intel part, while boost clocks are 3.40 GHz and 3.30 GHz, respectively. TDP is a major differentiator: 125 W for AMD vs 65 W for Intel. Socket compatibility is entirely separate: AMD Socket AM3 vs Intel Socket 1155.
Cache configurations differ at every level. The AMD part has 128 KB of L1 per core and 512 KB of L2 per core, while the Intel part has 64 KB of L1 and 256 KB of L2. Both have 6 MB of shared L3. Transistor counts and die sizes reflect the process node difference: AMD uses 904 million transistors on a 346 mm² die, while Intel uses 1,160 million on a 216 mm² die. Memory support is broader on the AMD side with DDR2 and DDR3, while Intel only supports DDR3. Memory bandwidth is listed for AMD at 21.3 GB/s, but no figure is given for Intel. ECC memory is supported on AMD but not Intel. PCIe generation differs: Gen 2 for AMD vs Gen 3 with 16 lanes (CPU only) for Intel. Integrated graphics are present on the Intel chip via Intel HD 3000, while AMD relies on a chipset feature. Release dates are roughly six months apart: the AMD part launched in December 2010, the Intel part in May 2011. Neither has a launch MSRP listed, and neither has an unlocked multiplier.