AMD Opteron 4274 HE vs Intel Core i7-4712HQ Comparison
AMD Opteron 4274 HE
Core i7-4712HQ
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Opteron 4274 HE vs Intel Core i7-4712HQ
The AMD Opteron 4274 HE and Intel Core i7-4712HQ are both end-of-life processors that occupy the same 37th percentile in the benchmark database, yet they achieve this parity through fundamentally different designs. In every head-to-head benchmark recorded, the Opteron wins, with a consistent margin of approximately 8% across Cinebench tests, making it the faster chip in both single-threaded and multi-threaded workloads despite its server-oriented heritage.
FAQ
Q: Which processor wins the most head-to-head benchmark comparisons?
A: The AMD Opteron 4274 HE wins all six head-to-head comparisons, covering Cinebench R15, R20, and R23 in both single-core and multi-core tests. The Intel Core i7-4712HQ records zero wins.
Q: How large is the performance gap between the two chips?
A: The Opteron leads by 7.2% in Cinebench R15 single-core and by 8.1% to 8.2% in all other tests. The multi-core margin in R15, R20, and R23 is consistently 8.1%, while the single-core gap ranges from 7.2% to 8.2%.
Q: Do the processors have similar average benchmark scores?
A: Yes, the average benchmark scores are very close. The Opteron averages 1420 points, while the Core i7-4712HQ averages 1436 points, a difference of only 1.1% despite the Opteron winning every head-to-head test.
Q: What are the core and thread counts for each chip?
A: The Intel Core i7-4712HQ has 4 cores and 8 threads, while the AMD Opteron 4274 HE has 8 cores and 8 threads. The Opteron has double the physical cores but the same thread count.
Q: What type of memory does each processor support?
A: Both support DDR3 memory with dual-channel buses and identical memory bandwidth of 25.6 GB/s. The Opteron supports ECC memory, while the Core i7 does not.
Q: Which processor has integrated graphics?
A: Only the Intel Core i7-4712HQ features integrated graphics, specifically the Intel HD 4600. The AMD Opteron 4274 HE has no integrated graphics, consistent with its server/workstation market segment.
Architecture Differences
The two processors come from entirely different design philosophies. The Intel Core i7-4712HQ is a mobile chip built on the Haswell architecture, manufactured on a 22 nm process by Intel. It contains 1,400 million transistors on a 177 mm² die. The AMD Opteron 4274 HE uses the Bulldozer architecture with the Valencia codename, built on a 32 nm process by GlobalFoundries, with 1,200 million transistors on a much larger 315 mm² die.
The core configurations diverge sharply. Intel implements 4 cores with 8 threads via Hyper-Threading, while AMD provides 8 physical cores but only 8 threads, which reflects the Bulldozer module-based design. Cache hierarchies also differ: the Intel part has 64 KB of L1 and 256 KB of L2 per core, plus 6 MB of shared L3. The Opteron has a single 384 KB L1, 8 MB of L2, and 8 MB of shared L3.
Process node advantages favor Intel, whose 22 nm process is smaller than AMD's 32 nm process. However, the Opteron's larger die and higher transistor density in cache-heavy areas compensate in raw throughput. The Intel chip is designed for mobile use with a 37 W TDP and operates on the BGA 1364 socket, while the Opteron targets servers and workstations with a 65 W TDP on Socket C32. The Opteron also adds ECC memory support, a feature absent from the Core i7.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The AMD Opteron 4274 HE dominates every recorded benchmark, but the margins are narrow and consistent. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the Opteron scores 494 against Intel's 454, an 8.1% advantage. The single-core R15 result shows the Opteron at 69 versus 64, a 7.2% lead. These are the smallest gaps in the comparison.
Moving to Cinebench R20, the Opteron extends its lead slightly. Multi-core results show 2061 against 1895, again an 8.1% difference. Single-core R20 gives the Opteron 291 points versus 267, an 8.2% margin, the largest single-core gap recorded. The pattern holds in Cinebench R23, where the Opteron posts 4909 in multi-core against 4512 (8.1% delta), and 693 in single-core against 637 (8.1% delta).
The consistency of these results is striking. Across six tests, the deltaPct never deviates outside the narrow 7.2% to 8.2% range. This suggests a uniform performance advantage rather than workload-specific optimization. Notably, the Opteron wins both single-threaded and multi-threaded tests, which is unusual for a server chip against a mobile part. The 4-core Intel chip cannot leverage its 8 threads to overcome the Opteron's 8 physical cores, and the Opteron's higher base clock of 2.50 GHz and boost clock of 3.50 GHz, compared to Intel's 2.30 GHz and 3.30 GHz, likely contribute to the single-core wins.
Specification Differences
The specification sheets reveal significant divergence across nearly every category. The Intel Core i7-4712HQ uses 4 cores and 8 threads, while the AMD Opteron 4274 HE uses 8 cores and 8 threads. Clock speeds differ: Intel runs at 2.30 GHz base and 3.30 GHz boost, while the Opteron runs at 2.50 GHz base and 3.50 GHz boost. TDP is another major split, with Intel at 37 W and AMD at 65 W.
Sockets are incompatible: Intel uses BGA 1364, AMD uses Socket C32. The architectures are Haswell versus Bulldozer, with process nodes of 22 nm versus 32 nm. Transistor counts are close at 1,400 million for Intel and 1,200 million for AMD, but die sizes differ substantially at 177 mm² versus 315 mm². Cache structures are completely different: Intel has per-core L1 and L2 plus 6 MB shared L3; AMD has a single 384 KB L1, 8 MB L2, and 8 MB shared L3.
Memory support is similar in type and bandwidth, but the Opteron adds ECC capability. PCIe generations differ, with Intel supporting Gen 3 with 16 lanes (CPU only) versus AMD's Gen 2. Integrated graphics exist only on the Intel chip. Market segments are mobile versus server/workstation. The launch MSRP for the Intel Core i7-4712HQ was $378, and the AMD Opteron 4274 HE launched at $377. Release dates differ by roughly two and a half years, with Intel launching in March 2014 and AMD in November 2011.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Opteron 4274 HE wins in every benchmark category recorded, making it the clear choice for raw compute performance. Its advantages are most pronounced in multi-core Cinebench workloads, where it holds a consistent 8.1% edge. The Opteron also wins single-core tests, though by a slightly smaller margin in R15. For anyone running Cinebench-style rendering tasks or heavily threaded server workloads, the data unambiguously favors the Opteron.
The Intel Core i7-4712HQ has no benchmark wins, but its specification sheet shows areas where it could be preferable in a system context. Its 37 W TDP is significantly lower than the Opteron's 65 W, making it better suited for power-constrained mobile environments. The integrated Intel HD 4600 graphics eliminate the need for a discrete GPU, which is critical for laptops. The smaller 22 nm process and 177 mm² die also suggest efficiency advantages, though no efficiency benchmarks are provided.
The Opteron's ECC memory support is a clear win for server reliability, while the Intel chip's PCIe Gen 3 support offers higher bandwidth for connected devices. The core count difference matters for workloads that scale with physical cores: the Opteron's 8 cores versus Intel's 4 cores explains its multi-core lead, even though both have 8 threads.
The Verdict
The data presents an unambiguous conclusion: the AMD Opteron 4274 HE outperforms the Intel Core i7-4712HQ in every measured benchmark. With all six head-to-head wins and an average benchmark score of 1420 versus 1436, the Opteron is the faster processor by approximately 8% across Cinebench tests. Its 8 physical cores, higher clocks, and larger caches deliver consistent victories in both single-threaded and multi-threaded workloads.
However, the choice is not purely about speed. The Intel Core i7-4712HQ serves a completely different use case with its 37 W TDP, integrated graphics, and mobile BGA socket. For a laptop or ultrabook requiring adequate CPU performance with minimal power draw and no discrete GPU, the Intel chip is the only viable option of the two. Its 4 cores and 8 threads provide reasonable multi-threading, and its PCIe Gen 3 support is modern.
For a server or workstation where performance matters most and power efficiency is secondary, the AMD Opteron 4274 HE is the clear winner. Its 8 cores, ECC memory support, and 65 W TDP are appropriate for that role, and its benchmark superiority is consistent. The near-identical launch MSRPs ($378 versus $377) mean price was not a differentiator at launch.
The Opteron's 37th percentile ranking, matching the Intel chip's percentile, shows that despite its age and Bulldozer architecture, it competes with much newer processors. The Core i7-4712HQ, despite its more modern 22 nm Haswell design, cannot overcome the Opteron's core count and clock advantage. Buyers seeking maximum Cinebench performance should choose the Opteron; buyers needing mobile integration and low power should choose the Core i7. The benchmark data offers no third option.