AMD Opteron 3350 HE vs Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 Comparison
AMD Opteron 3350 HE
Core 2 Extreme QX9770
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Opteron 3350 HE vs Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770
The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 and the AMD Opteron 3350 HE are separated by almost five years of development, yet their benchmark scores tell a story of remarkable convergence. Both chips land at the 21st percentile of all CPUs, with average benchmark scores of 790 and 789, respectively. The data shows a near-total dead heat in raw compute, but the two processors achieve that parity through wildly different architectural philosophies and are aimed at entirely different market segments.
Where Each One Wins
Based on the head-to-head benchmark data, the Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 claims a clean sweep, winning all five Cinebench comparisons. However, the margins are so slim that calling them "wins" requires context. In Cinebench R15 multicore, both processors score exactly 231, meaning the Intel chip wins only by tiebreaker. The same is true for Cinebench R20 multicore, where both post identical scores of 963. The largest victory for the Intel part is in Cinebench R20 single-core, where it edges ahead by 0.7% with a score of 136 versus 135.
The AMD Opteron 3350 HE, despite losing every head-to-head, has its own clear domain of advantage: efficiency. Its TDP is 45 watts compared to the Intel chip's 136 watts, a difference that makes it the obvious choice for dense server deployments where heat and power budgets are constrained. The Opteron also brings a boost clock of 3.80 GHz versus the Intel's fixed 3.20 GHz, meaning in lightly threaded workloads that can leverage the higher frequency, the AMD part can pull ahead in real-world scenarios not captured by these specific benchmarks. The Intel chip wins on raw benchmark scores; the AMD chip wins on operational cost per socket over time.
Architecture Differences
These two processors represent fundamentally different design eras. The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770, codenamed Yorkfield, is built on Intel's 45 nm process with 820 million transistors spread across a dual-die design measuring 2x 107 mm². It uses the Core 2 architecture and fits into the aging Intel Socket 775. The AMD Opteron 3350 HE, codenamed Delhi, is a 32 nm part from GlobalFoundries with 1,200 million transistors on a single 315 mm² die. It uses the K10 architecture and mounts to AMD Socket AM3+.
The cache configurations diverge sharply. Intel gives each core 64 KB of L1 cache and pools 12 MB of shared L2 cache, with no L3. AMD provides 192 KB of L1, 4 MB of L2, and adds 8 MB of shared L3. That L3 cache is a significant architectural advantage for the Opteron in server workloads where data is shared across cores. The Intel part compensates with a larger L2 pool that is shared across all four cores, which can be more efficient for certain parallel workloads.
Memory support also differs. Intel's chip supports DDR1, DDR2, and DDR3 memory in a dual-channel configuration, offering backwards compatibility with older platforms. The AMD part supports only DDR3, but it does so with a specified memory bandwidth of 29.9 GB/s. Both use PCIe Gen 2 and both lack integrated graphics, relying on chipset features on certain motherboards for display output. The Intel part has an unlocked multiplier, making it a desktop overclocker's dream, while the AMD part is locked. The AMD chip is classified as Server/Workstation, the Intel as Desktop, and both are end-of-life products.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The benchmark results are almost suspiciously close. In Cinebench R15 multicore, both CPUs score exactly 231. That is a perfect tie, with the Intel chip awarded the win via a deltaPct of 0. The same occurs in Cinebench R20 multicore, where both score 963. In these heavily threaded tests, the Intel's higher base clock of 3.20 GHz versus the AMD's 2.80 GHz appears to offset the AMD's L3 cache advantage and boost capability.
Single-core results are where the Intel chip ekes out its narrowest real victories. In Cinebench R20 single-core, the QX9770 scores 136 against the Opteron's 135, a 0.7% margin. In Cinebench R23 single-core, the gap narrows further to 0.3%, with scores of 324 and 323. These differences are within run-to-run variance for most benchmarking, but they do consistently favor Intel. The largest single-core margin is in Cinebench R23 multicore, where the Intel chip scores 2295 versus 2294, a 0% deltaPct that still counts as a win in the ledger.
What is not in the benchmarks is a test that stresses the AMD's boost clock. The Opteron's 3.80 GHz boost could theoretically win a lightly threaded test, but the Cinebench single-core workloads apparently do not trigger it effectively, or the Intel's architectural efficiency at lower clocks wins out. The data shows 5 wins for Intel and 0 for AMD, but the average benchmark scores of 790 and 789 tell a more nuanced story of two chips that perform identically in aggregate.
Specification Differences
The two processors differ on nearly every spec sheet line except core and thread counts, both being 4-core, 4-thread parts.
- Base Clock: Intel runs at 3.20 GHz; AMD at 2.80 GHz.
- Boost Clock: Intel has none; AMD boosts to 3.80 GHz.
- TDP: Intel is 136 W; AMD is 45 W, a 91-watt gap.
- Socket: Intel uses Socket 775; AMD uses Socket AM3+.
- Process Node: Intel uses 45 nm; AMD uses 32 nm.
- Foundry: Intel fabricated in-house; AMD used GlobalFoundries.
- Transistors: Intel has 820 million; AMD has 1,200 million.
- Die Size: Intel is 2x 107 mm²; AMD is 315 mm².
- L1 Cache: Intel has 64 KB per core; AMD has 192 KB total.
- L2 Cache: Intel has 12 MB shared; AMD has 4 MB.
- L3 Cache: Intel has none; AMD has 8 MB shared.
- Memory Support: Intel supports DDR1, DDR2, DDR3; AMD supports DDR3 only.
- Memory Bandwidth: Intel lists none; AMD specifies 29.9 GB/s.
- Release Date: Intel launched March 2008; AMD launched December 2012.
- Launch MSRP: Intel has none listed; AMD had a launch MSRP of $125.
- Multiplier: Intel is unlocked; AMD is locked.
- Market Segment: Intel is Desktop; AMD is Server/Workstation.
FAQ
Q: Which processor has the higher average benchmark score?
A: The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770 has an average benchmark score of 790, while the AMD Opteron 3350 HE scores 789. The Intel chip is 0.1% ahead in average score.
Q: How do the two chips compare in Cinebench R20 single-core performance?
A: The Intel chip scores 136, which is 0.7% higher than the AMD chip's score of 135. This is the largest single-core margin in the head-to-head data.
Q: Does the AMD Opteron 3350 HE have a higher clock speed than the Intel chip?
A: The AMD chip has a lower base clock of 2.80 GHz versus Intel's 3.20 GHz, but it offers a boost clock of 3.80 GHz. The Intel chip has no boost clock.
Q: Which chip is more power-efficient?
A: The AMD Opteron 3350 HE has a TDP of 45 watts, compared to 136 watts for the Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9770. This makes the AMD part substantially more efficient for power-constrained environments.
Q: What cache configurations do the two processors use?
A: The Intel chip uses 64 KB of L1 per core and 12 MB of shared L2, with no L3. The AMD chip uses 192 KB of L1, 4 MB of L2, and adds 8 MB of shared L3.
Q: Did the Intel chip win any benchmark by a significant margin?
A: No. The Intel chip won all five head-to-head benchmarks, but the largest margin was 0.7%, and three of the five wins had a deltaPct of 0.0%, meaning identical scores.