AMD Athlon X4 880K vs Intel Xeon W3580 Comparison

AMD
AMD

AMD Athlon X4 880K

CORE STATE Godaveri
CORE SPECS 4 Cores / 4 Threads
CLOCK SPEED 4 Base / 4.2 GHz Turbo
CACHE —
MAX TDP 95W
ARCHITECTURE Steamroller
nm
PROCESS 28 nm
LAUNCH DATE —
VS
Intel
INTEL

Xeon W3580

CORE STATE Bloomfield
CORE SPECS 4 Cores / 8 Threads
CLOCK SPEED 3.33 Base / 3.6 GHz Turbo
CACHE 8 MB (shared)
MAX TDP 130W
ARCHITECTURE Nehalem
nm
PROCESS 45 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2009

PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS

cinebench_cinebench_r15_multicore
313
311
cinebench_cinebench_r20_multicore
1,307
1,298
cinebench_cinebench_r20_singlecore
184
183
cinebench_cinebench_r23_multicore
3,114
3,092
cinebench_cinebench_r23_singlecore
439
436

Analysis: AMD Athlon X4 880K vs Intel Xeon W3580

The AMD Athlon X4 880K and Intel Xeon W3580 are both end-of-life desktop processors from different eras and design philosophies, yet the benchmark data places them in almost the same performance class. The Athlon edges out the Xeon in every Cinebench test recorded, but the margins are razor-thin, making the choice between them less about raw speed and more about platform features and workload characteristics.

Where Each One Wins

The AMD Athlon X4 880K wins every single head-to-head benchmark in this comparison, but the victories are narrow. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the Athlon scores 313 versus the Xeon’s 311, a 0.6% difference. In Cinebench R20 multi-core, the gap is 1307 to 1298, or 0.7%. The single-core tests tell the same story: R20 single-core shows 184 for the Athlon against 183 for the Xeon, and R23 single-core shows 439 versus 436, both 0.5-0.7% margins. The R23 multi-core result is 3114 for the Athlon versus 3092 for the Xeon, again a 0.7% lead.

Since the Athlon wins all five recorded tests, it is the default pick for any Cinebench-style rendering workload, but the margins are so small that they are effectively noise for real-world use. The Xeon, however, brings capabilities the Athlon lacks entirely. It supports ECC memory, which the Athlon does not, and it runs a triple-channel memory bus compared to the Athlon’s dual-channel. For a workstation or server task that values memory integrity and bandwidth, the Xeon’s platform advantages could outweigh its slight benchmark deficit.

Architecture Differences

The two processors come from completely different design lineages. The Athlon X4 880K uses AMD’s Steamroller architecture on the Godaveri codename, built on a 28 nm process at GlobalFoundries. It packs 2,411 million transistors into a 245 mm² die. The Xeon W3580 uses Intel’s Nehalem architecture, codenamed Bloomfield, on a 45 nm process at Intel’s own fabs. It has 731 million transistors on a 263 mm² die. The process node gap is significant: 28 nm versus 45 nm means the Athlon is built on a much finer geometry, which helps explain how it matches a chip with a higher transistor count per area.

Core counts are identical at four, but threading differs. The Athlon has four threads total, one per core, while the Xeon has eight threads via Hyper-Threading. This means the Xeon can process two threads per core, yet it still loses to the Athlon in multi-core tests, indicating the Athlon’s higher clock speeds compensate for its lack of SMT. Cache layouts also diverge. The Athlon has 256 KB of L1 and 4 MB of L2, with no L3 cache. The Xeon has 64 KB of L1 per core and 256 KB of L2 per core, plus a shared 8 MB L3 cache. The Xeon’s L3 cache is a major architectural advantage for repeated data access, but it does not translate into a benchmark win here.

Memory support is another split. Both use DDR3, but the Athlon runs dual-channel with 34.1 GB/s of bandwidth, while the Xeon runs triple-channel with no bandwidth figure listed in the data. The Xeon also supports ECC memory, a feature absent from the Athlon. PCIe generations differ too: the Athlon has Gen 3 with 16 CPU lanes, while the Xeon has Gen 2. The Xeon’s socket is Intel Socket 1366, versus the Athlon’s AMD Socket FM2+. The Xeon is a server/workstation part, while the Athlon is a desktop part. The Athlon has an unlocked multiplier for overclocking; the Xeon does not.

FAQ

Q: Which processor has a higher base clock speed?

A: The AMD Athlon X4 880K runs at 4.00 GHz base, compared to the Intel Xeon W3580’s 3.33 GHz base. The Athlon also boosts to 4.20 GHz versus the Xeon’s 3.60 GHz.

Q: Does the Intel Xeon W3580 support ECC memory?

A: Yes, the Xeon W3580 supports ECC memory, while the AMD Athlon X4 880K does not. This makes the Xeon the only option here for error-correcting memory in a workstation or server role.

Q: Which processor has more threads?

A: The Intel Xeon W3580 has 8 threads from 4 cores, while the AMD Athlon X4 880K has 4 threads from 4 cores. Despite this, the Athlon wins all multi-core Cinebench tests in the head-to-head data.

Q: What is the cache configuration difference?

A: The Athlon has 256 KB of L1 and 4 MB of L2, with no L3. The Xeon has 64 KB of L1 per core, 256 KB of L2 per core, and an 8 MB shared L3 cache. The Xeon’s L3 cache is a substantial addition that the Athlon lacks.

Q: Which processor has a smaller manufacturing process?

A: The AMD Athlon X4 880K is built on a 28 nm process at GlobalFoundries, while the Intel Xeon W3580 uses a 45 nm process at Intel. The Athlon’s node is significantly more advanced.

Q: How do their average benchmark scores compare?

A: The Athlon has an average benchmark score of 1071, placing it in the 30th percentile of all CPUs. The Xeon has an average score of 1064, placing it in the 29th percentile. The Athlon’s nearest rival is the AMD Opteron 3380 with an identical 1071 score and 0% delta, while the Xeon’s nearest rival is the Intel Core i3-9100HL at 1065, a -0.1% delta.

Specification Differences

The two processors differ on nearly every specification except core count, DDR3 memory support, and the absence of integrated graphics. The AMD Athlon X4 880K has 4 threads, a 4.00 GHz base clock, a 4.20 GHz boost clock, a 95 W TDP, and uses AMD Socket FM2+. The Intel Xeon W3580 has 8 threads, a 3.33 GHz base clock, a 3.60 GHz boost clock, a 130 W TDP, and uses Intel Socket 1366.

The Athlon is built on the Steamroller architecture at 28 nm with 2,411 million transistors on a 245 mm² die. The Xeon uses Nehalem at 45 nm with 731 million transistors on a 263 mm² die. Cache differs: the Athlon has 256 KB L1 and 4 MB L2 with no L3, while the Xeon has 64 KB L1 per core, 256 KB L2 per core, and 8 MB shared L3. Memory channels differ: dual-channel for the Athlon with 34.1 GB/s bandwidth, triple-channel for the Xeon with no bandwidth listed. ECC support is false for the Athlon and true for the Xeon. PCIe is Gen 3 with 16 lanes for the Athlon versus Gen 2 for the Xeon. The Athlon has an unlocked multiplier; the Xeon is locked. The Xeon was released on 2009-08-08, while the Athlon’s release date is not listed. Both are end-of-life, and neither has a launch MSRP in the data.

Head-to-Head Benchmarks

The head-to-head results are uniform: the AMD Athlon X4 880K wins every test, but by fractions of a percent. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the Athlon scores 313 against the Xeon’s 311, a 0.6% lead. That is a two-point difference, which is negligible in practical rendering tasks. Cinebench R20 multi-core shows the same pattern: 1307 versus 1298, a 0.7% delta. The Athlon’s advantage here is nine points, still well within run-to-run variance.

Single-core performance is equally close. Cinebench R20 single-core has the Athlon at 184 and the Xeon at 183, a 0.5% difference. Cinebench R23 single-core has 439 versus 436, a 0.7% margin. The largest absolute gap is in Cinebench R23 multi-core, where the Athlon scores 3114 against the Xeon’s 3092, a 22-point difference that is still only 0.7%. Across all five tests, the Athlon’s average benchmark score is 1071 versus the Xeon’s 1064, and the Athlon sits in the 30th percentile of all CPUs while the Xeon sits in the 29th.

The data suggests that the Athlon’s higher clock speeds — 4.00/4.20 GHz versus 3.33/3.60 GHz — are enough to overcome the Xeon’s extra threads and larger L3 cache in these Cinebench workloads. The Xeon’s 8 threads should theoretically help in multi-threaded tests, but the Athlon’s faster clocks and newer 28 nm process appear to give it the edge. For Cinebench specifically, the Athlon is the winner, but the margins are so small that they indicate near-identical real-world performance for most applications.

The Verdict

The AMD Athlon X4 880K is the better choice for pure Cinebench performance, as it wins all five recorded head-to-head benchmarks. It also offers a lower TDP of 95 W versus the Xeon’s 130 W, a more advanced 28 nm process, a higher base and boost clock, faster PCIe Gen 3, and an unlocked multiplier for overclocking. Its average benchmark score of 1071 is higher than the Xeon’s 1064, and it ranks at the 30th percentile versus the Xeon’s 29th. For a desktop user who wants to squeeze out every bit of multi-core and single-core Cinebench score, the Athlon is the pick.

The Intel Xeon W3580 is the pick for platform-specific needs. It supports ECC memory, which the Athlon does not, and it runs a triple-channel memory bus that can offer higher aggregate bandwidth for memory-intensive workloads. It also has 8 threads versus the Athlon’s 4, which could benefit non-Cinebench applications that scale well with thread count, even though the benchmark data does not show that advantage here. The Xeon’s 8 MB shared L3 cache is a significant architectural feature that the Athlon lacks entirely, potentially aiding workloads with high cache reuse. Its server/workstation market segment and Intel Socket 1366 platform target a different use case than the Athlon’s desktop FM2+ socket.

If you are building a desktop and care about Cinebench scores, the Athlon’s consistent, albeit tiny, wins make it the default. If you need ECC memory or a triple-channel memory controller for a workstation or server role, the Xeon’s feature set matters more than a 0.7% benchmark delta. The data does not show the Xeon winning a single test, but it also does not show a performance gap large enough to dismiss the Xeon’s unique capabilities. Choose by platform requirements, not by these benchmark numbers.

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS

SPECIFICATION
Athlon X4 880K
W3580
Core Specs
Cores
4
4 0.0%
Threads
4
8 +100.0%
Base Clock (GHz)
4
3.33 -16.8%
Boost Clock (GHz)
4.2
3.6 -14.3%
Frequency (GHz)
4
3.33 -16.8%
Turbo Clock (GHz)
4.2
3.6 -14.3%
Multiplier
40
25 -37.5%
SMP CPUs
1
1 0.0%
Cache
L1 Cache
256 KB
64 KB (per core)
L2 Cache
4 MB
256 KB (per core)
L3 Cache
—
8 MB (shared)
Power
TDP (W)
95
130 +36.8%
Architecture
Architecture
Steamroller
Nehalem
Codename
Godaveri
Bloomfield
Generation
Athlon (Godaveri)
Xeon (Bloomfield)
Process Size
28 nm
45 nm
Transistors
2,411 million
731 million
Die Size
245 mm²
263 mm²
Foundry
GlobalFoundries
Intel
Memory
Memory Support
DDR3
DDR3
Memory Bus
Dual-channel
Triple-channel
Memory Bandwidth
34.1 GB/s
—
ECC Memory
No
Yes
Platform
Socket
AMD Socket FM2+
Intel Socket 1366
Chipsets
A88X, A85X, A78, A75, A68H
—
PCIe
Gen 3, 16 Lanes(CPU only)
Gen 2
Other
Market
Desktop
Server/Workstation
Production Status
End-of-life
End-of-life
Part Number
AD880KXBJCSBX
SLBET
Package
µPGA
FC-LGA8
View Athlon X4 880K Details View Xeon W3580 Details