AMD Athlon X4 870K vs Intel Xeon W3570 Comparison
AMD Athlon X4 870K
Xeon W3570
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Athlon X4 870K vs Intel Xeon W3570
The AMD Athlon X4 870K and Intel Xeon W3570 are two end-of-life desktop and workstation processors that, despite vastly different origins, land almost exactly on top of each other in aggregate performance. The Athlon X4 870K wins every single head-to-head benchmark in this comparison, albeit by narrow margins ranging from 4.8% to 5.4%. The Xeon W3570, however, counters with a triple-channel memory bus, ECC support, and hyper-threading, making it the choice for systems requiring those specific features. For pure compute performance, the data favors the AMD chip; for platform capabilities, the Intel chip holds the edge. The Xeon W3570 is a server-class part with a 130W TDP and locked multiplier, while the Athlon is a 95W desktop chip with an unlocked multiplier, making it the better candidate for overclocking and general desktop use.
The Verdict
The benchmark data is unambiguous: the AMD Athlon X4 870K is the faster processor in every measured workload. It leads the Intel Xeon W3570 by 5.4% in Cinebench R15 multi-core, 5.2% in R20 multi-core, 4.9% in R20 single-core, 5.1% in R23 multi-core, and 4.8% in R23 single-core. If your priority is raw rendering or compute throughput, the Athlon X4 870K is the pick. However, the Xeon W3570 is not without merit. It supports ECC memory and a triple-channel memory bus, whereas the Athlon is limited to dual-channel DDR3 without ECC. For users building a workstation that demands error-correcting memory or higher memory bandwidth for data-intensive tasks, the Xeon W3570 is the only option here. The Athlon also has a significant advantage in power efficiency, with a 95W TDP versus the Xeon's 130W, and its unlocked multiplier makes it more flexible for tuning. In short: choose the Athlon X4 870K for faster single and multi-threaded application performance and lower power draw; choose the Xeon W3570 for ECC memory support and triple-channel memory architecture.
Architecture Differences
The two processors represent fundamentally different design philosophies from their respective eras. The AMD Athlon X4 870K is built on the Steamroller architecture, codenamed Godaveri, using a 28 nm process node from GlobalFoundries. It packs 2,411 million transistors into a 245 mm² die. The Intel Xeon W3570 uses the Nehalem architecture, codenamed Bloomfield, on a much older 45 nm process from Intel, with 731 million transistors on a 263 mm² die. This means the AMD chip crams more than three times the transistors into a smaller physical footprint, which explains its superior power efficiency.
The cache hierarchies are also distinct. The Athlon X4 870K has 256 KB of L1 cache and 4 MB of L2 cache, but no L3 cache at all. The Xeon W3570 has a smaller per-core L1 (64 KB per core) and L2 (256 KB per core), but compensates with a shared 8 MB L3 cache. The lack of L3 on the AMD part is notable, yet its benchmark scores still come out ahead, indicating that its higher clock speeds and newer architecture overcome the cache deficit. The Xeon also differs in memory support: it features a triple-channel memory bus and ECC memory support, while the Athlon uses dual-channel memory without ECC. The Athlon supports PCIe Gen 3 with 16 CPU lanes, whereas the Xeon is limited to PCIe Gen 2. The Athlon has an unlocked multiplier, the Xeon does not.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The head-to-head results show a consistent, if modest, victory for the AMD Athlon X4 870K across all five Cinebench tests. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the Athlon scores 294 against the Xeon's 279, a 5.4% advantage. That margin narrows slightly in Cinebench R20 multi-core, where the Athlon scores 1225 versus 1165, a 5.2% lead. Single-core performance tells a similar story: the Athlon posts 172 in R20 single-core against 164 for the Xeon, a 4.9% win, and 411 in R23 single-core against 392, a 4.8% edge.
The largest absolute gap appears in Cinebench R23 multi-core, where the Athlon scores 2917 and the Xeon finishes at 2776, a 5.1% difference. The data shows no workload in which the Xeon W3570 overtakes the Athlon X4 870K. This is despite the Xeon having 8 threads to the Athlon's 4, thanks to hyper-threading. The Athlon's higher base clock of 3.90 GHz and boost clock of 4.10 GHz, compared to the Xeon's 3.20 GHz base and 3.47 GHz boost, likely explain why the AMD part wins even in multi-threaded tests where the Xeon has twice the thread count. The newer 28 nm process and higher clocks of the Athlon simply overcome the Xeon's thread advantage.
Specification Differences
The specification sheet highlights several key divergences beyond the raw benchmark scores. The Athlon X4 870K has a base clock of 3.90 GHz and a boost clock of 4.10 GHz, while the Xeon W3570 operates at 3.20 GHz base and 3.47 GHz boost. The Athlon's TDP is 95W, significantly lower than the Xeon's 130W. The Athlon uses the AMD Socket FM2+ platform, whereas the Xeon uses Intel Socket 1366. The process node differs substantially: 28 nm for the AMD part versus 45 nm for the Intel part.
Memory architecture is a major differentiator. The Athlon supports dual-channel DDR3 with a memory bandwidth of 34.1 GB/s and no ECC. The Xeon supports triple-channel DDR3 with ECC memory enabled, though its memory bandwidth figure is not listed in the data. The Athlon has 4 MB of L2 cache and no L3, while the Xeon has 256 KB of L2 per core and 8 MB of shared L3. The Athlon has an unlocked multiplier and features PCIe Gen 3 with 16 CPU lanes; the Xeon has a locked multiplier and PCIe Gen 2. The market segments also differ: the Athlon is a Desktop part, while the Xeon is a Server/Workstation part. Both are end-of-life, but the Xeon W3570 has a known release date of March 2009, while the Athlon's release date is not listed.
FAQ
Q: Which processor is faster in multi-core workloads?
A: The AMD Athlon X4 870K wins all multi-core benchmarks. It scores 294 in Cinebench R15 multi-core versus 279 for the Xeon W3570, and 2917 in Cinebench R23 multi-core versus 2776.
Q: Does the Intel Xeon W3570 have any performance advantage?
A: No. In the head-to-head data, the Xeon W3570 loses all five benchmark comparisons. Its closest result is a 4.8% deficit in Cinebench R23 single-core.
Q: Can the AMD Athlon X4 870K support ECC memory?
A: No. The Athlon X4 870K does not support ECC memory. The Intel Xeon W3570 does support ECC memory, making it the only option here for error-correcting memory.
Q: Which processor has more memory channels?
A: The Intel Xeon W3570 has a triple-channel memory bus, while the AMD Athlon X4 870K has a dual-channel memory bus.
Q: Which processor is more power-efficient?
A: The AMD Athlon X4 870K has a TDP of 95W, compared to 130W for the Intel Xeon W3570, making the AMD part more power-efficient.
Q: Is the AMD Athlon X4 870K overclockable?
A: Yes, the Athlon X4 870K has an unlocked multiplier. The Intel Xeon W3570 has a locked multiplier, so it does not offer the same overclocking flexibility.