AMD Athlon X4 870K vs Intel Xeon W3550 Comparison
AMD Athlon X4 870K
Xeon W3550
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Athlon X4 870K vs Intel Xeon W3550
The AMD Athlon X4 870K and Intel Xeon W3550 are two very different processors that nonetheless land on the exact same average benchmark score of 956, placing both in the 26th percentile of all CPUs tracked. The Athlon is a desktop part built for a different era of AMD, while the Xeon is a workstation/server chip from Intel’s Nehalem generation. Despite their shared average score, the benchmark data reveals a consistent, if modest, edge for the AMD chip across every tested workload, with margins ranging from 4.8% to 5.4%. This head-to-head is less about raw dominance and more about how two aging architectures with opposing design philosophies (high clocks versus high thread counts) converge on similar real-world performance.
FAQ
Q: Which processor has the higher average benchmark score?
A: Both processors have an identical average benchmark score of 956. The data shows a perfect tie, with the Athlon X4 870K and Xeon W3550 each holding a 0% delta relative to one another in the nearest rivals list.
Q: How does the AMD Athlon X4 870K perform in multi-core Cinebench tests compared to the Xeon W3550?
A: The Athlon wins all multi-core Cinebench tests. It scores 294 versus 279 in Cinebench R15 (5.4% faster), 1225 versus 1166 in R20 (5.1% faster), and 2917 versus 2778 in R23 (5% faster).
Q: Does the Intel Xeon W3550 win any benchmark comparisons?
A: No. In the head-to-head benchmark data, the Athlon X4 870K wins all five tests. The Xeon W3550 records zero wins, with its closest margin being a 4.8% deficit in Cinebench R23 single-core.
Q: What are the core and thread counts for each processor?
A: The AMD Athlon X4 870K has 4 cores and 4 threads. The Intel Xeon W3550 also has 4 cores but doubles the thread count to 8 threads via Hyper-Threading.
Q: Which processor has a higher base clock speed?
A: The AMD Athlon X4 870K has a base clock of 3.90 GHz, which is significantly higher than the Xeon W3550’s 3.07 GHz base clock. The Athlon also has a higher boost clock at 4.10 GHz versus 3.33 GHz.
Q: What is the difference in memory channel support?
A: The Athlon X4 870K supports dual-channel DDR3 memory with a bandwidth of 34.1 GB/s. The Xeon W3550 supports triple-channel DDR3 memory, though its memory bandwidth figure is not listed in the data pack.
Architecture Differences
The two CPUs represent fundamentally different architectural eras. The AMD Athlon X4 870K is built on the Steamroller architecture (codenamed Godaveri) using a 28 nm process from GlobalFoundries. It packs 2,411 million transistors into a 245 mm² die. The Intel Xeon W3550, in contrast, uses the much older Nehalem architecture (codenamed Bloomfield) on Intel’s 45 nm process, with only 731 million transistors spread across a larger 263 mm² die. This process gap largely explains the Athlon’s higher clock speeds and better power efficiency.
The cache hierarchies are also structured differently. The Athlon has a 256 KB L1 cache and a 4 MB L2 cache, with no L3 cache at all. The Xeon has a smaller per-core L1 (64 KB per core) and L2 (256 KB per core), but compensates with a shared 8 MB L3 cache. This means the Xeon relies on a large pool of shared cache for multi-threaded workloads, while the Athlon depends on its higher clocks and lower-latency L2.
Threading is another major divide. The Athlon is a pure 4-core/4-thread part with no SMT, while the Xeon is a 4-core/8-thread part. Despite the Xeon’s thread advantage, the benchmark data shows it cannot overcome the Athlon’s clock speed lead. The Athlon also has an unlocked multiplier, making it overclockable, whereas the Xeon’s multiplier is locked. The Xeon supports ECC memory and targets the server/workstation segment with a 130 W TDP, while the Athlon is a desktop part rated at 95 W. The Athlon features PCIe Gen 3 with 16 CPU lanes; the Xeon uses the older PCIe Gen 2 standard.
Where Each One Wins
The benchmark results are unambiguous: the AMD Athlon X4 870K wins every single test in the head-to-head comparison. Its victories range from 4.8% in Cinebench R23 single-core to 5.4% in Cinebench R15 multi-core. This suggests that for all tested applications—primarily Cinebench rendering workloads—the Athlon’s higher clocks (3.90 GHz base, 4.10 GHz boost) are more valuable than the Xeon’s extra threads (8 versus 4) and larger L3 cache.
The Xeon W3550’s only theoretical advantage lies in its platform features rather than raw speed. It supports ECC memory and triple-channel DDR3, which are meaningful for workstation stability and memory bandwidth in server environments. However, since the data pack does not include a memory bandwidth figure for the Xeon, its triple-channel advantage cannot be quantified here. In every measured compute benchmark, the Xeon trails by a consistent margin of roughly 5%.
For a user choosing between these two, the Athlon is the clear winner in the tested workloads. The Xeon’s case would rest entirely on ECC support and platform longevity on Socket 1366, not on processing speed. The data shows a narrow but consistent performance gap that favors the AMD part across the board.
Specification Differences
The specification sheets for these two CPUs differ in nearly every major category. The Athlon X4 870K has a base clock of 3.90 GHz and a boost clock of 4.10 GHz, while the Xeon W3550 sits at 3.07 GHz base and 3.33 GHz boost. The Athlon’s TDP is 95 W; the Xeon’s is 130 W. The Athlon uses AMD Socket FM2+, while the Xeon uses Intel Socket 1366.
The process node separates them by a full generation: 28 nm for the Athlon versus 45 nm for the Xeon. This is reflected in transistor counts (2,411 million versus 731 million) and die size (245 mm² versus 263 mm²). Cache configurations differ significantly: the Athlon has 256 KB L1 and 4 MB L2 with no L3; the Xeon has 64 KB L1 per core, 256 KB L2 per core, and 8 MB shared L3.
Memory support diverges on channel count: the Athlon is dual-channel with a listed bandwidth of 34.1 GB/s, while the Xeon is triple-channel with no bandwidth figure provided. The Athlon does not support ECC memory; the Xeon does. PCIe generations differ (Gen 3 for AMD, Gen 2 for Intel), and the Athlon’s multiplier is unlocked while the Xeon’s is locked. The Athlon is a desktop part; the Xeon is a server/workstation part. Both are end-of-life and neither has a launch MSRP listed in the data.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The head-to-head results tell a consistent story of AMD dominance. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the Athlon scores 294 against the Xeon’s 279, a 5.4% advantage—the largest margin in the entire comparison. This is notable because Cinebench R15 is a classic multi-threaded test where the Xeon’s 8 threads should theoretically help. The Athlon’s clock speed advantage (3.90 GHz versus 3.07 GHz base) overcomes the Xeon’s thread advantage.
The pattern continues in Cinebench R20 multi-core, where the Athlon posts 1225 versus 1166, a 5.1% win. The single-core R20 test shows a 4.9% edge (172 versus 164), demonstrating that the Athlon’s architectural efficiency is not just a multi-threaded artifact. In Cinebench R23, the margins hold steady: 2917 versus 2778 in multi-core (5% delta) and 411 versus 392 in single-core (4.8% delta).
The Geekbench data is only available for the Athlon (1205 multi-core, 468 single-core), so a direct comparison there is impossible. However, the five Cinebench results that do include both CPUs all point the same way. The Xeon’s best relative performance is in the R23 single-core test, where it trails by 4.8%; its worst is in R15 multi-core, where it trails by 5.4%.
The consistency of these margins—all falling between 4.8% and 5.4%—suggests a fixed performance-per-clock advantage for the Athlon, rather than workload-specific swings. The Xeon’s 8 threads do not rescue it in heavily threaded tests, and its lower clocks hurt it in single-threaded tests. The Athlon X4 870K wins all five head-to-head benchmarks, with the final tally reading 5 wins for AMD and 0 for Intel.