AMD Athlon X4 860K vs Intel Xeon X5560 Comparison
AMD Athlon X4 860K
Xeon X5560
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Athlon X4 860K vs Intel Xeon X5560
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The benchmark data is strikingly one-sided. Across five Cinebench tests, the AMD Athlon X4 860K wins every single matchup, though the margins are far from dramatic. The largest gap appears in Cinebench R15 multi-core, where the Athlon scores 294 against the Xeon's 276—a 6.1% advantage. That pattern holds almost identically across every other test, with the delta hovering near 5.8% for Cinebench R20 multi-core (1225 vs 1154), R20 single-core (172 vs 162), and R23 multi-core (2918 vs 2749). The single-core R23 result shows a slightly narrower 5.6% edge (411 vs 388).
What makes these numbers interesting is their consistency. Usually, a multi-core workload favors the chip with more threads, and a single-core test favors the chip with higher clock speed. Here, the Athlon wins both categories by nearly the same percentage. That suggests the Xeon's hyper-threading advantage—8 threads against 4—does not translate into a meaningful performance lead in these Cinebench workloads. Instead, the Athlon's higher base clock (3.70 GHz vs 2.80 GHz) and boost clock (4.00 GHz vs 3.20 GHz) appear to outweigh the Xeon's extra logical cores.
The overall average benchmark scores tell a similar story, albeit with less separation. The Xeon averages 946 points, while the Athlon averages 943 points—nearly identical figures. Both chips sit at the 25th percentile among all CPUs, meaning they occupy the same performance tier in the broader market. The head-to-head deltas, however, show a clear if modest winner: the Athlon leads in every direct comparison. The only benchmark the Xeon does not lose is Geekbench, where the Athlon has additional data (1126 multi-core, 454 single-core) but no Xeon counterpart exists for comparison.
Interpreting these deltas requires context. A 5-6% performance gap is noticeable in daily use but not transformative. The Xeon's 8 threads might help in heavily parallel, non-Cinebench workloads, yet within this benchmark suite, the Athlon's architectural efficiency per clock appears to deliver consistent wins. The data does not support any claim of a dominant victory, but it does point to the Athlon as the more capable processor in these specific rendering tests.
Architecture Differences
The two processors come from fundamentally different design philosophies and eras. The Xeon X5560 uses Intel's Nehalem architecture, codenamed Gainestown, built on a 45 nm process node by Intel's own foundry. It packs 731 million transistors into a 263 mm² die. The Athlon X4 860K, by contrast, uses AMD's Steamroller architecture, codenamed Kaveri, manufactured by GlobalFoundries on a 28 nm node. That process advantage allows AMD to integrate 2,411 million transistors—more than three times the Xeon's count—into a slightly smaller 245 mm² die.
Cache layouts diverge sharply. The Xeon offers 64 KB of L1 and 256 KB of L2 per core, with 8 MB of shared L3 cache. The Athlon provides 256 KB of L1 total and 4 MB of L2 total, with no L3 cache at all. The Xeon's large shared L3 is typical of server designs, where multiple cores frequently access shared data sets. The Athlon's reliance on L2 alone reflects its desktop-oriented, cost-conscious design. This cache difference could explain why the Athlon's per-clock performance holds up despite fewer threads—its smaller, faster cache hierarchy may reduce latency for single-threaded tasks.
Memory support also differs. Both chips use DDR3, but the Xeon employs a triple-channel memory bus, while the Athlon uses dual-channel with a rated 34.1 GB/s bandwidth. The Xeon also supports ECC memory, a feature the Athlon lacks entirely. The Xeon's PCIe implementation is Gen 2, whereas the Athlon supports PCIe Gen 3 with 16 lanes from the CPU. That newer PCIe standard gives the Athlon a potential advantage for fast storage or discrete GPUs, though the benchmark data does not directly test this.
The Xeon is a server/workstation part on Intel Socket 1366, while the Athlon targets desktops on AMD Socket FM2+. The Xeon's multiplier is locked; the Athlon's is unlocked, allowing user overclocking. Process node differences—45 nm vs 28 nm—imply the Athlon should run more efficiently per watt, but both chips carry a 95 W TDP. The Xeon launched in March 2009, the Athlon in August 2014, a five-year gap that explains the architectural advancements.
Where Each One Wins
The benchmark results point to a clear if narrow victory for the Athlon in rendering workloads. Cinebench R15, R20, and R23 all show the AMD chip ahead by roughly 5.8-6.1% in multi-core tests and 5.6-5.8% in single-core tests. For users running Cinebench-style rendering tasks—which stress both integer and floating-point throughput—the Athlon is the better choice based on this data alone.
However, the Xeon retains structural advantages that these benchmarks do not capture. Its 8 threads could benefit workloads that scale well beyond 4 threads, even if Cinebench does not show that benefit here. The triple-channel memory bus doubles the Athlon's memory channels, potentially improving bandwidth-sensitive applications like database servers or virtualized environments. ECC memory support makes the Xeon viable for error-tolerant computing, a feature completely absent from the Athlon.
The Athlon counters with a newer PCIe Gen 3 interface, which matters for modern GPUs and NVMe storage. Its unlocked multiplier offers overclocking headroom, though the data does not quantify any performance gains from that. The Athlon's higher base clock (3.70 GHz vs 2.80 GHz) gives it a raw speed advantage in lightly threaded tasks, which the single-core Cinebench results confirm.
For gaming or typical desktop use, the Athlon's per-core strength likely translates to snappier response, even if no gaming benchmarks are present in the data. For server-style workloads—long-running, memory-intensive, or multi-threaded beyond 4 cores—the Xeon's architecture and memory features make it the more robust platform despite losing every head-to-head test.
FAQ
Q: Which CPU wins in Cinebench R23 multi-core?
A: The AMD Athlon X4 860K scores 2918, while the Intel Xeon X5560 scores 2749. The Athlon leads by 5.8%.
Q: Does the Xeon's 8 threads help it outperform the 4-thread Athlon?
A: No. In every Cinebench test, the Athlon wins despite having half as many threads. The multi-core deltas range from 5.8% to 6.1% in the Athlon's favor.
Q: Do both CPUs support DDR3 memory?
A: Yes, both support DDR3. The Xeon uses a triple-channel memory bus, while the Athlon uses dual-channel with a rated 34.1 GB/s bandwidth.
Q: Which chip has more L3 cache?
A: The Xeon has 8 MB of shared L3 cache. The Athlon has no L3 cache, relying instead on 4 MB of L2 cache.
Q: Are these processors still in production?
A: Both are end-of-life. The Xeon released on March 29, 2009; the Athlon released on August 11, 2014.
Q: What are the average benchmark scores for each?
A: The Xeon averages 946 points, and the Athlon averages 943 points. Both sit at the 25th percentile among all CPUs.
The Verdict
The data presents a curious case. The AMD Athlon X4 860K wins every head-to-head benchmark, yet the average scores are nearly identical (946 vs 943). This suggests the Athlon's wins are consistent but modest, not transformative. For rendering tasks measured by Cinebench, the Athlon is the clear if narrow choice—5.8% faster in multi-core and 5.6% faster in single-core, with no test where the Xeon pulls ahead.
But the Xeon's value lies outside these benchmarks. Its 8 threads, triple-channel memory, and ECC support target a different use case entirely. The data shows the Xeon loses every rendering test, but it does not test server workloads, memory bandwidth saturation, or error-correcting memory scenarios. A buyer choosing between these two should weigh the Athlon's proven benchmark edge against the Xeon's unmeasured but structurally superior server features.
The Athlon also offers practical advantages: an unlocked multiplier for overclocking, PCIe Gen 3 for modern components, and a newer 28 nm process. The Xeon counters with older 45 nm technology and a locked multiplier. For a desktop user prioritizing raw Cinebench performance, the Athlon is the data-driven pick. For a workstation or server environment requiring ECC and triple-channel memory, the Xeon remains relevant despite its benchmark losses.
Neither chip is a winner in the broader market—both sit at the 25th percentile—but between the two, the Athlon's benchmark consistency gives it the edge for general-purpose computing. The Xeon's architectural features make it a specialist tool, best chosen for specific server workloads rather than general performance.
Specification Differences
| Field | Intel Xeon X5560 | AMD Athlon X4 860K |
|-------|------------------|--------------------|
| Cores | 4 | 4 |
| Threads | 8 | 4 |
| Base Clock | 2.80 GHz | 3.70 GHz |
| Boost Clock | 3.20 GHz | 4.00 GHz |
| Socket | Intel Socket 1366 | AMD Socket FM2+ |
| Architecture | Nehalem | Steamroller |
| Codename | Gainestown | Kaveri |
| Process Node | 45 nm | 28 nm |
| Foundry | Intel | GlobalFoundries |
| Transistors | 731 million | 2,411 million |
| Die Size | 263 mm² | 245 mm² |
| L1 Cache | 64 KB (per core) | 256 KB |
| L2 Cache | 256 KB (per core) | 4 MB |
| L3 Cache | 8 MB (shared) | None |
| Memory Bus | Triple-channel | Dual-channel |
| Memory Bandwidth | Not specified | 34.1 GB/s |
| ECC Memory | Yes | No |
| PCIe | Gen 2 | Gen 3, 16 Lanes (CPU only) |
| Market Segment | Server/Workstation | Desktop |
| Release Date | 2009-03-29 | 2014-08-11 |
| Multiplier Unlocked | No | Yes |