AMD Athlon X4 850 vs Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9775 Comparison

AMD
AMD

AMD Athlon X4 850

CORE STATE Godaveri
CORE SPECS 4 Cores / 4 Threads
CLOCK SPEED 3.2 Base / 3.9 GHz Turbo
CACHE —
MAX TDP 65W
ARCHITECTURE Steamroller
nm
PROCESS 28 nm
LAUNCH DATE —
VS
Intel
INTEL

Core 2 Extreme QX9775

CORE STATE Yorkfield
CORE SPECS 4 Cores / 4 Threads
CLOCK SPEED 3.2 Base
CACHE —
MAX TDP 150W
ARCHITECTURE Core 2
nm
PROCESS 45 nm
LAUNCH DATE 2008

PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS

cinebench_cinebench_r15_multicore
235
238
cinebench_cinebench_r20_multicore
983
992
cinebench_cinebench_r20_singlecore
138
139
cinebench_cinebench_r23_multicore
2,342
2,363
cinebench_cinebench_r23_singlecore
330
333

Analysis: AMD Athlon X4 850 vs Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9775

# Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9775 vs AMD Athlon X4 850

The benchmark data presents an unusually tight contest between two very different quad-core desktop processors from different eras. The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9775, a 2008 flagship with a 150-watt TDP, and the AMD Athlon X4 850, a 28nm Steamroller part with a 65-watt TDP, finish within 1.3% of each other across every Cinebench test in the head-to-head comparison. The Intel part wins all five benchmark comparisons, but the margins are razor-thin, ranging from 0.7% in single-core tests to 1.3% in the Cinebench R15 multicore test. The average benchmark scores tell the same story: Intel sits at 813, AMD at 806, a difference of less than 1%.

The Verdict

The data supports a straightforward but nuanced conclusion: the Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9775 is the faster processor in every measured benchmark, but the AMD Athlon X4 850 achieves near-identical performance with dramatically lower power consumption. For workloads where raw Cinebench scores are the sole consideration, the Intel part wins, but the margin is so small that it borders on statistical noise. The Intel QX9775 posts a 1.3% lead in Cinebench R15 multicore (238 vs 235), a 0.9% lead in Cinebench R20 multicore (992 vs 983), and a 0.9% lead in Cinebench R23 multicore (2363 vs 2342). In single-core tests, the Intel chip leads by 0.7% in R20 (139 vs 138) and 0.9% in R23 (333 vs 330).

The AMD Athlon X4 850, however, delivers this nearly identical performance at 65 watts TDP compared to Intel's 150 watts — a 2.3x power efficiency advantage that the data makes clear. Both processors hold the 22nd percentile among all CPUs, indicating they occupy the same performance tier in the broader market. The Intel part's nearest rivals include the Intel Core i7-5550U (matching at 813 average score), the Intel Xeon X3440 (815, 0.2% ahead), and the AMD A10-6800K (809, 0.5% behind). The AMD Athlon X4 850's nearest rivals include the Intel Xeon X5482 (805, 0.1% behind), the AMD Ryzen 3 2200U (805, 0.1% behind), and the Intel Core i7-870S (809, 0.3% ahead).

For buyers choosing between these two specific parts, the decision hinges on platform priorities. The Intel QX9775 offers the highest benchmark scores in this comparison, making it the choice when every point matters. The AMD Athlon X4 850, with its 65-watt TDP and PCIe Gen 3 support, is the more sensible pick for systems where power draw and modern I/O matter more than a sub-1% performance difference.

Architecture Differences

The two processors represent fundamentally different design philosophies and manufacturing generations. The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9775 uses the Core 2 architecture on the Yorkfield codename, built on Intel's 45nm process. It integrates 820 million transistors across a dual-die package with each die measuring 107 mm². The AMD Athlon X4 850 uses the Steamroller architecture under the Godaveri codename, fabricated on GlobalFoundries' 28nm process, with 2,411 million transistors on a single 245 mm² die.

Cache configurations differ substantially. The Intel part offers 64 KB of L1 cache per core and 6 MB of L2 cache per die, with no L3 cache present. The AMD part provides 256 KB of L1 cache and 4 MB of L2 cache, also without L3 cache. Both processors feature four cores and four threads, with identical 3.20 GHz base clocks. The AMD Athlon X4 850 additionally supports a 3.90 GHz boost clock, a feature absent from the Intel QX9775's specifications.

Memory and platform support diverge sharply. The Intel QX9775 uses the Intel Socket 771 interface and supports DDR2 memory, with the actual memory type depending on the motherboard. It includes ECC memory support and PCIe Gen 1 connectivity. The AMD Athlon X4 850 uses the AMD Socket FM2+ interface, supports DDR3 memory through a dual-channel memory bus with 34.1 GB/s bandwidth, and offers PCIe Gen 3 with 16 lanes from the CPU. ECC memory is not supported on the AMD part.

The process node gap is significant: 45nm for Intel versus 28nm for AMD. This explains the transistor density difference, with AMD packing nearly three times as many transistors (2,411 million vs 820 million) into a larger die. The AMD part's smaller process node also accounts for its 65-watt TDP, less than half of the Intel part's 150-watt rating. Both processors have unlocked multipliers, and both are end-of-life products. The Intel QX9775 launched with a $1499 MSRP; no launch MSRP is available for the AMD Athlon X4 850.

Where Each One Wins

The benchmark results show the Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9775 winning all five head-to-head comparisons. The largest margin comes in Cinebench R15 multicore, where Intel leads by 1.3% (238 vs 235). The smallest margin is in Cinebench R20 single-core, where Intel leads by 0.7% (139 vs 138). Across the remaining tests — R20 multicore, R23 multicore, and R23 single-core — the Intel advantage holds steady at 0.9% (992 vs 983, 2363 vs 2342, and 333 vs 330, respectively).

The consistent but narrow margins across both single-core and multi-core workloads suggest that the Intel architecture holds a slight IPC advantage in Cinebench rendering tasks. However, the AMD Athlon X4 850's boost clock capability up to 3.90 GHz appears to offset much of this architectural gap in single-threaded performance, resulting in the close 0.7-0.9% single-core deltas.

The AMD part's advantages are not visible in Cinebench scores but are clear in platform specifications. The 65-watt TDP versus 150 watts represents a substantial efficiency win for AMD. The PCIe Gen 3 support with 16 CPU lanes offers modern connectivity compared to Intel's PCIe Gen 1. The DDR3 memory support with a specified 34.1 GB/s bandwidth provides a defined memory performance envelope, whereas the Intel part's DDR2 support depends entirely on motherboard selection.

In the broader competitive landscape, both processors sit at the 22nd percentile among all CPUs. The Intel QX9775's average benchmark score of 813 places it level with the Intel Core i7-5550U, while the AMD Athlon X4 850's 806 average places it just behind the Intel Xeon X5482 and AMD Ryzen 3 2200U, both at 805 but with the AMD part leading by 0.1%.

FAQ

Q: Which processor has the higher multi-core performance?

A: The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9775 wins every multi-core benchmark in the head-to-head comparison. It leads by 1.3% in Cinebench R15 (238 vs 235), 0.9% in Cinebench R20 (992 vs 983), and 0.9% in Cinebench R23 (2363 vs 2342).

Q: How do the single-core scores compare?

A: The Intel QX9775 also wins both single-core tests. It scores 139 vs 138 in Cinebench R20 single-core (a 0.7% lead) and 333 vs 330 in Cinebench R23 single-core (a 0.9% lead).

Q: What is the power consumption difference?

A: The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9775 has a TDP of 150 watts, while the AMD Athlon X4 850 has a TDP of 65 watts. The AMD part consumes less than half the power of the Intel part according to these TDP ratings.

Q: Do both processors support the same memory types?

A: No. The Intel QX9775 supports DDR2 memory, with the specific type depending on the motherboard. The AMD Athlon X4 850 supports DDR3 memory through a dual-channel bus with 34.1 GB/s bandwidth.

Q: Are these processors overclockable?

A: Yes, both processors have unlocked multipliers. The Intel QX9775 and AMD Athlon X4 850 both allow multiplier adjustment for overclocking.

Q: How do these chips compare to their nearest rivals?

A: The Intel QX9775 has an average benchmark score of 813, matching the Intel Core i7-5550U exactly. It sits 0.2% behind the Intel Xeon X3440 (815) and 0.5% ahead of the AMD A10-6800K (809). The AMD Athlon X4 850 averages 806, sitting 0.1% ahead of the Intel Xeon X5482 and AMD Ryzen 3 2200U (both at 805), and 0.3% behind the Intel Core i7-870S (809).

Head-to-Head Benchmarks

The five-way benchmark sweep for the Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9775 is consistent but narrow. The largest relative win occurs in the Cinebench R15 multi-core test, where Intel scores 238 against AMD's 235, a 1.3% delta. This test, being the oldest in the suite, may favor the Intel architecture's memory latency characteristics or scheduling behavior, but the data does not specify the cause.

In Cinebench R20 multi-core, the Intel part scores 992 versus 983, a 0.9% advantage. The R23 multi-core test shows a similar pattern: Intel at 2363, AMD at 2342, again a 0.9% delta. The consistency between R20 and R23 results suggests that the performance relationship is stable across these newer rendering workloads.

Single-core performance tells a slightly different story. In Cinebench R20 single-core, the Intel QX9775 scores 139 against 138 for the AMD Athlon X4 850 — a 0.7% margin, the smallest of the entire comparison. The R23 single-core test shows Intel at 333 and AMD at 330, a 0.9% lead. The fact that the AMD part, with its 3.90 GHz boost clock, comes this close to the Intel part (which lacks a boost clock and runs at a fixed 3.20 GHz) highlights the architectural differences at play.

The average benchmark scores reinforce the head-to-head results. Intel's average of 813 exceeds AMD's 806 by 7 points, approximately 0.9%. Both processors share the 22nd percentile ranking among all CPUs, confirming that they occupy the same performance class despite their different architectures and release eras.

The Intel part's nearest rival data shows a cluster of processors within a narrow band: the Core i7-5550U matches at 813, the Xeon X3440 leads by 0.2% at 815, the Core i5-L16G7 leads by 0.4% at 816, and the A10-6800K trails by 0.5% at 809. The AMD Athlon X4 850's rival cluster is similarly tight: the Xeon X5482 and Ryzen 3 2200U both trail by 0.1% at 805, the Core i7-870S leads by 0.3% at 809, and the A10-6800K leads by 0.4% at 809.

The complete picture is one of near-parity in rendering performance, with the Intel QX9775 holding a slight edge in every measured test. The AMD Athlon X4 850 counters with a 65-watt TDP, PCIe Gen 3, and DDR3 memory support — platform features that may matter more in real-world system building than the sub-1% benchmark deltas. Both processors are end-of-life products, but the data shows they remain competitive with each other across the Cinebench suite.

DETAILED SPECIFICATIONS

SPECIFICATION
Athlon X4 850
2 Extreme QX9775
Core Specs
Cores
4
4 0.0%
Threads
4
4 0.0%
Base Clock (GHz)
3.2
3.2 0.0%
Boost Clock (GHz)
3.9
—
Frequency (GHz)
3.2
3.2 0.0%
Turbo Clock (GHz)
3.9
—
Multiplier
32
8 -75.0%
SMP CPUs
1
2 +100.0%
Cache
L1 Cache
256 KB
64 KB (per core)
L2 Cache
4 MB
6 MB (per die)
Power
TDP (W)
65
150 +130.8%
Architecture
Architecture
Steamroller
Core 2
Codename
Godaveri
Yorkfield
Generation
Athlon (Godaveri)
Core 2 Extreme (Yorkfield XE)
Process Size
28 nm
45 nm
Transistors
2,411 million
820 million
Die Size
245 mm²
2x 107 mm²
Foundry
GlobalFoundries
Intel
Memory
Memory Support
DDR3
DDR2 Depends on motherboard
Memory Bus
Dual-channel
—
Memory Bandwidth
34.1 GB/s
—
ECC Memory
No
Yes
Platform
Socket
AMD Socket FM2+
Intel Socket 771
Chipsets
A88X, A85X, A78, A75, A68H
—
PCIe
Gen 3, 16 Lanes(CPU only)
Gen 1
Other
Market
Desktop
Desktop
Production Status
End-of-life
End-of-life
Launch Price
—
$1499
Part Number
AD835XACI43KA
SLANYEU80574XL088N
Package
µPGA
FC-LGA6
Tj Max
90°C
—
View Athlon X4 850 Details View Core 2 Extreme QX9775 Details