AMD Athlon X4 845 vs AMD PRO A12-8870 Comparison
AMD Athlon X4 845
PRO A12-8870
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Athlon X4 845 vs AMD PRO A12-8870
The AMD PRO A12-8870 and the AMD Athlon X4 845 are near-identical silicon, separated by clock speed, platform, and a few key features. Across all five head-to-head Cinebench tests, the PRO A12-8870 wins every single round, but by margins so thin they are effectively statistical noise. The data shows a 0.1% to 0.2% advantage for the PRO part, which translates to a single point in most workloads. In practical terms, these are the same CPU in different clothing; the real differentiators lie in platform support and integrated graphics, not raw compute.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The benchmark results paint a picture of extreme parity. In the Cinebench R15 multi-core test, both processors score a dead-even 324 points, with the PRO A12-8870 declared the winner only by tiebreaker, as the delta is 0%. This is a pure tie. Moving to Cinebench R20 multi-core, the PRO A12-8870 scores 1351 against the Athlon’s 1350, a 0.1% lead. The single-core R20 result is another exact tie at 190 points for both chips. The pattern holds in newer workloads: in Cinebench R23 multi-core, the PRO A12-8870 posts 3218 versus 3215, again a 0.1% difference. The largest gap in the entire suite appears in Cinebench R23 single-core, where the PRO A12-8870 scores 454 and the Athlon X4 845 scores 453, a 0.2% lead.
These deltas are the smallest possible measurable differences. A 0.1% lead means one additional point out of a thousand; a 0.2% lead means one point out of five hundred. Neither result would be visible in real-world application performance. The average benchmark scores confirm this: the PRO A12-8870 averages 1107, while the Athlon X4 845 averages 1106. This places the PRO part 0.1% ahead of the Athlon, and both sit exactly alongside the AMD Opteron 4280 (1107) and within 0.1% of the Intel Core i5-4570T (1108). The Athlon’s rival list shows the same cluster, with the AMD Opteron 3280 at 1106 and the AMD PRO A12-9800 at 1104, which the Athlon leads by 0.2%.
The verdict from the head-to-head data is unambiguous: there is no performance winner. The PRO A12-8870 sweeps the scoreboard with 5 wins, but every win is a rounding error. If a workload runs faster on one, it is due to thermal state or background activity, not architectural superiority. The only meaningful takeaway is that both CPUs deliver identical compute throughput, placing them in the 31st percentile of all CPUs, which indicates entry-level desktop performance.
Architecture Differences
Both processors are built on the same Excavator architecture with the Carrizo codename, fabricated on GlobalFoundries’ 28 nm process. Both have exactly 3,100 million transistors on a 250 mm² die. Core and thread counts are identical: 4 cores and 4 threads. The cache hierarchy is also a perfect match: 320 KB of L1 cache and 2 MB of L2 cache, with no L3 cache on either part. The memory bus is dual-channel on both, and neither supports ECC memory. PCIe is Gen 3 on both, though the Athlon X4 845 lists “Gen 3, 8 Lanes (CPU only)” while the PRO A12-8870 simply says “Gen 3,” implying a fuller implementation.
The critical divergences begin with the clock speeds. The PRO A12-8870 has a base clock of 3.70 GHz and a boost clock of 4.20 GHz. The Athlon X4 845 runs lower, with a 3.50 GHz base and a 3.80 GHz boost. This 200 MHz base and 400 MHz boost gap is the source of the tiny benchmark advantages seen in the PRO part. The memory support differs substantially: the PRO A12-8870 uses DDR4 memory with a bandwidth of 38.4 GB/s, while the Athlon X4 845 uses DDR3 with a reduced bandwidth of 34.1 GB/s. That 4.3 GB/s difference is the second major architectural split.
The platform sockets are entirely incompatible. The PRO A12-8870 fits AMD Socket AM4, while the Athlon X4 845 uses AMD Socket FM2+. This means they cannot be swapped into the same motherboard, forcing a choice of platform before considering the CPU. The integrated graphics also split the pair: the PRO A12-8870 includes a Radeon R7 iGPU, while the Athlon X4 845 has no integrated graphics at all. The Athlon compensates with an unlocked multiplier, allowing overclocking, whereas the PRO part is locked. Production status differs too: the PRO A12-8870 remains active, while the Athlon X4 845 is end-of-life and carries a release date of 2016-02-01.
FAQ
Q: Which processor is faster in multi-core workloads?
A: The AMD PRO A12-8870 leads in all multi-core tests, but by the slimmest margins. In Cinebench R15, both score 324. In R20, the PRO scores 1351 versus 1350, a 0.1% lead. In R23, the PRO scores 3218 versus 3215, also 0.1% ahead. These differences are negligible.
Q: Is the Athlon X4 845 a good choice for a system without a discrete GPU?
A: No. The Athlon X4 845 has no integrated graphics, so a discrete GPU is mandatory. The PRO A12-8870 includes a Radeon R7 iGPU, making it the only viable option for a build without a separate graphics card.
Q: Can I overclock either processor?
A: Only the Athlon X4 845 has an unlocked multiplier, so it supports overclocking. The PRO A12-8870 is multiplier-locked, preventing manual clock adjustment.
Q: Do these CPUs support DDR4 memory?
A: Only the PRO A12-8870 supports DDR4, with a dual-channel bandwidth of 38.4 GB/s. The Athlon X4 845 is limited to DDR3, offering a lower dual-channel bandwidth of 34.1 GB/s.
Q: Are these processors compatible with the same motherboards?
A: No. The PRO A12-8870 requires an AMD Socket AM4 motherboard, while the Athlon X4 845 requires an AMD Socket FM2+ board. They cannot be interchanged.
Q: How do these chips compare to other CPUs in the database?
A: Both sit in the 31st percentile of all CPUs. The PRO A12-8870 averages 1107, matching the AMD Opteron 4280 and trailing the Intel Core i5-4570T (1108) by 0.1%. The Athlon X4 845 averages 1106, trailing the PRO part by 0.1%.
Specification Differences
| Specification | AMD PRO A12-8870 | AMD Athlon X4 845 |
|---|---|---|
| Base Clock | 3.70 GHz | 3.50 GHz |
| Boost Clock | 4.20 GHz | 3.80 GHz |
| Socket | AMD Socket AM4 | AMD Socket FM2+ |
| Memory Support | DDR4 | DDR3 |
| Memory Bandwidth | 38.4 GB/s | 34.1 GB/s |
| Integrated Graphics | Radeon R7 | None |
| Multiplier Unlocked | No | Yes |
| Production Status | Active | End-of-life |
| Release Date | Not listed | 2016-02-01 |
| Part Number | AD887BAUM44AB | AD845XACI43KA |
All other fields — cores, threads, architecture, process node, transistor count, die size, L1/L2 cache, memory bus, ECC support, PCIe generation, market segment, and TDP (65 W for both) — are identical.
Where Each One Wins
The PRO A12-8870 wins every benchmark category, but only by fractions of a percent. Its real advantages are platform-level. The DDR4 memory support yields a higher theoretical bandwidth of 38.4 GB/s versus 34.1 GB/s, which can benefit memory-sensitive applications. The integrated Radeon R7 graphics make it the sole choice for a system without a discrete GPU, enabling basic display output and light graphical tasks. The active production status also makes it a viable option for current system builds via the AM4 socket.
The Athlon X4 845 wins in flexibility for enthusiasts. Its unlocked multiplier allows overclocking, potentially closing the small clock-speed gap with the PRO part. It also has a defined release date of 2016-02-01, which may matter to collectors or those seeking a specific vintage. However, it loses on memory bandwidth, has no iGPU, and is end-of-life, which limits its long-term viability. For pure compute, the data shows no scenario where the Athlon outperforms the PRO A12-8870; the 0.2% lead for the PRO in R23 single-core is the largest margin, and the Athlon never takes a single win.
The Verdict
From the data, the AMD PRO A12-8870 is the superior processor, but not because of its compute scores. The benchmark results are effectively identical, with the PRO part leading by 0.1% to 0.2% across all tests. The decision rests entirely on the surrounding feature set. The PRO A12-8870 offers a modern AM4 platform, DDR4 memory with higher bandwidth, and an integrated Radeon R7 GPU. These are concrete, usable advantages. The Athlon X4 845 counters with an unlocked multiplier and a legacy FM2+ socket, but it requires a discrete GPU and uses slower DDR3 memory. For any new system, the PRO A12-8870 is the clear pick. For an overclocking hobbyist with an existing FM2+ board and a spare GPU, the Athlon X4 845 remains a functional option, but the benchmark data offers no reason to prefer it on performance. The PRO A12-8870 wins 5-0, even if each win is by a hair.