AMD Athlon X4 840 vs Intel Core i5-5257U Comparison
AMD Athlon X4 840
Core i5-5257U
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Athlon X4 840 vs Intel Core i5-5257U
The Intel Core i5-5257U and AMD Athlon X4 840 are both end-of-life processors that land in the 26th percentile of all CPUs, but they achieve that status through entirely different design philosophies. The Intel chip is a 14 nm mobile part with integrated graphics, while the AMD chip is a 28 nm desktop part with no GPU at all. Their average benchmark scores are nearly identical — 976 for the Intel and 975 for the AMD — yet the head-to-head benchmark data tells a more one-sided story, with the Athlon winning all five compared tests by a margin of roughly 15%.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The AMD Athlon X4 840 dominates the multi-core Cinebench tests, which is expected given its four physical cores versus the Intel’s two. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the AMD scores 285 against the Intel’s 242, a 15.1% advantage. That same 15.1% gap persists in Cinebench R20 multi-core, where the Athlon posts 1189 to the i5-5257U’s 1010. The pattern holds in Cinebench R23 multi-core, with the AMD at 2833 and the Intel at 2406 — again a 15.1% difference. These results show a consistent, not incidental, multi-threaded performance lead for the AMD chip.
Single-core performance also favors the Athlon, though the margin is slightly larger in percentage terms. In Cinebench R20 single-core, the AMD scores 168 versus the Intel’s 142, a 15.5% gap. Cinebench R23 single-core shows the AMD at 400 and the Intel at 339, a 15.2% difference. This is notable because Intel’s 14 nm process and higher per-core efficiency are often assumed to confer a single-thread advantage; the data does not support that assumption here. The Athlon’s higher base clock of 3.10 GHz and boost clock of 3.80 GHz, compared to the Intel’s 2.70 GHz and 3.10 GHz, likely explain much of this lead.
The Intel i5-5257U does have additional benchmark results in the Geekbench suite that are not part of the head-to-head comparison. Its Geekbench multi-core score is 1773 and single-core is 922. These numbers are not directly compared against the Athlon in the provided data, so they do not contribute to the win count. The Intel also has a Cinebench R15 multi-core score of 242, which is its only other comparable test result. Across the five shared tests, the Athlon wins all five, with a total win count of 5 to 0.
The average benchmark scores are remarkably close — 976 for the Intel and 975 for the AMD — which places both chips in the same percentile bracket. This suggests that while the Athlon wins individual tests, the overall performance profile is closer than the head-to-head deltas imply. The Intel’s Geekbench scores, which are not in the head-to-head set, likely contribute to its slightly higher average, though the exact weighting is not specified in the data.
The Verdict
The AMD Athlon X4 840 is the clear winner in every directly compared benchmark. If your workload is heavily threaded — video encoding, 3D rendering, or multitasking with many background processes — the Athlon’s 15% lead in multi-core tests is substantial. Its four cores at higher clocks deliver more consistent throughput in these scenarios. The Intel i5-5257U, despite its lower core count, holds its own in average score only because of Geekbench results that are not part of the head-to-head comparison; those results do not translate into wins in Cinebench tests.
For a desktop user with a dedicated GPU, the Athlon X4 840 is the straightforward choice. It offers a 15% performance advantage in the most common rendering benchmarks, and its unlocked multiplier provides additional headroom for tuning, a feature the Intel lacks. The Intel part is a mobile chip on a BGA socket, which means it is not a practical upgrade for most desktop systems. Its integrated Iris 6100 graphics make it a viable option for a compact laptop or embedded system where a discrete GPU is not an option, but its compute performance is simply lower in every measured test.
The data does not support choosing the Intel for raw performance. It wins zero of the five head-to-head tests. The only reason to pick the i5-5257U is its integrated graphics and lower power envelope, but those are qualitative advantages — the benchmark numbers do not show any performance superiority. For anyone comparing these two chips as potential CPU upgrades, the Athlon X4 840 is the one that delivers on the benchmarks.
Architecture Differences
The two processors come from different architectural lineages. The Intel Core i5-5257U is built on the Broadwell architecture, specifically the Broadwell-U codename, using a 14 nm process node from Intel’s own foundry. It integrates 1,900 million transistors on a die size of 133 mm². The AMD Athlon X4 840 uses the Steamroller architecture under the Kaveri codename, manufactured by GlobalFoundries on a 28 nm process. Its transistor count is higher at 2,411 million, and its die is nearly double the size at 245 mm². The larger die and higher transistor count on an older process node explain the AMD chip’s higher 65 W TDP versus the Intel’s 28 W.
Cache layouts differ significantly between the two. The Intel i5-5257U has 64 KB of L1 cache per core, 256 KB of L2 per core, and 3 MB of shared L3 cache. The AMD Athlon X4 840 has a single 256 KB L1 cache figure and 4 MB of L2 cache, with no L3 cache listed. The Intel’s three-tier cache hierarchy is a more modern design, but the AMD’s larger L2 cache and higher clocks compensate in the benchmark results. Neither chip supports ECC memory, and both use dual-channel DDR3 memory, though the AMD’s memory bandwidth is rated higher at 34.1 GB/s versus the Intel’s 29.9 GB/s.
The integrated graphics situation is a major architectural divergence. The Intel chip includes Intel Iris 6100 graphics, making it a complete system-on-chip capable of driving a display without a separate GPU. The AMD Athlon X4 840 has no integrated graphics at all, requiring a discrete graphics card for any video output. This is a fundamental difference in target use: the Intel is a mobile part designed for compact systems, while the AMD is a desktop CPU meant to pair with a dedicated GPU.
Specification Differences
The core and thread counts are the most obvious difference: the Intel has 2 cores and 4 threads, while the AMD has 4 cores and 4 threads. Clock speeds also favor the AMD, with a base clock of 3.10 GHz and boost of 3.80 GHz, compared to the Intel’s 2.70 GHz base and 3.10 GHz boost. The TDP gap is substantial — 28 W for the Intel versus 65 W for the AMD — reflecting the different process nodes and market segments. The Intel uses an Intel BGA 1168 socket, which is soldered to the motherboard, while the AMD uses an AMD Socket FM2+, a socketed design that allows for CPU replacement.
The AMD has an unlocked multiplier, enabling overclocking, while the Intel’s multiplier is locked. The Intel supports PCIe Gen 2 with 12 lanes from the CPU, while the AMD supports PCIe Gen 3 with 16 lanes. The Intel’s memory bandwidth is 29.9 GB/s, and the AMD’s is 34.1 GB/s. The Intel includes integrated graphics, the AMD does not. The Intel was released on 2015-02-28 with a launch MSRP of $315; the AMD was released earlier on 2014-08-11 and has no launch MSRP listed. Both are end-of-life products.
FAQ
Q: Which CPU has better multi-core performance?
A: The AMD Athlon X4 840 wins all multi-core Cinebench tests by roughly 15.1%. In Cinebench R23 multi-core, the AMD scores 2833 versus the Intel i5-5257U’s 2406.
Q: Is the Intel i5-5257U better at single-core tasks?
A: No. The AMD Athlon X4 840 also wins single-core tests, with a 15.5% lead in Cinebench R20 single-core (168 vs 142) and a 15.2% lead in Cinebench R23 single-core (400 vs 339).
Q: Do these CPUs support integrated graphics?
A: The Intel Core i5-5257U includes Intel Iris 6100 integrated graphics. The AMD Athlon X4 840 has no integrated graphics and requires a separate GPU.
Q: Can either CPU be overclocked?
A: Only the AMD Athlon X4 840 has an unlocked multiplier. The Intel i5-5257U has a locked multiplier, preventing overclocking.
Q: What are the power consumption differences?
A: The Intel i5-5257U has a TDP of 28 W. The AMD Athlon X4 840 has a TDP of 65 W, more than double the Intel’s power draw.
Q: Which chip has more cores?
A: The AMD Athlon X4 840 has 4 physical cores. The Intel Core i5-5257U has 2 physical cores but supports 4 threads via Hyper-Threading.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Athlon X4 840 wins in every benchmark category that is directly compared. Its five head-to-head victories span multi-core and single-core tests across Cinebench R15, R20, and R23. The 15% performance lead in both single- and multi-threaded workloads makes it the superior choice for any CPU-bound task, from rendering to compilation to general desktop responsiveness. Its higher clocks, larger L2 cache, and four physical cores are the likely contributors to this consistent advantage. The unlocked multiplier adds another layer of potential performance for users willing to overclock, which the data suggests could widen the gap further.
The Intel Core i5-5257U wins in scenarios that are not captured by the Cinebench benchmarks. Its integrated Iris 6100 graphics make it the only viable option of the two for a system without a discrete GPU. Its lower 28 W TDP means it can be used in compact, passively cooled or low-power mobile systems where the AMD’s 65 W draw would be impractical. The Intel’s Geekbench scores — 1773 multi-core and 922 single-core — hint at strengths in workloads that are not represented in the head-to-head tests, though these are not directly compared to the AMD. For a builder prioritizing power efficiency and integrated graphics over raw compute, the Intel is the pick. For anyone who already has a GPU and wants the best CPU performance, the AMD Athlon X4 840 is the clear winner in every measured test.