AMD Athlon X4 840 vs Intel Core i5-2400S Comparison
AMD Athlon X4 840
Core i5-2400S
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Athlon X4 840 vs Intel Core i5-2400S
The AMD Athlon X4 840 and the Intel Core i5-2400S are two end-of-life desktop processors from different architectural generations and process nodes. Both CPUs offer four physical cores and four threads, and both carry a 65 W TDP, making them comparable on paper in terms of core count and power envelope. Despite this surface-level similarity, benchmark data reveals a consistent performance gap favoring the AMD part across every tested workload, with the Athlon X4 840 posting margins between 8.8% and 9.1% over the Intel chip in the Cinebench suite.
FAQ
Q: Which processor has a higher average benchmark score?
A: The AMD Athlon X4 840 has an average benchmark score of 975, while the Intel Core i5-2400S scores 968. The Athlon also holds a 0.1% advantage over the i5-2400S in its nearest rival comparisons, while the Intel part trails one of its rivals by 0.3%.
Q: How do the two CPUs compare in multi-threaded rendering workloads?
A: The AMD Athlon X4 840 wins all multi-core tests in the head-to-head data. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the Athlon scores 285 versus 262 for the i5-2400S, an 8.8% lead. In Cinebench R20 multi-core, the Athlon scores 1189 versus 1092, an 8.9% lead, and in Cinebench R23 multi-core, the Athlon scores 2833 versus 2601, another 8.9% lead.
Q: Does the Intel Core i5-2400S win any single-core benchmark?
A: No. The AMD Athlon X4 840 wins both single-core tests. In Cinebench R20 single-core, the Athlon scores 168 versus 154 for the Intel part, a 9.1% margin, and in Cinebench R23 single-core, the Athlon scores 400 versus 367, a 9% lead.
Q: Are both processors unlocked for overclocking?
A: No. The AMD Athlon X4 840 has an unlocked multiplier, while the Intel Core i5-2400S does not. This distinction appears in the specification data, though no overclocking results are included in the benchmark pack.
Q: What is the process node difference between the two chips?
A: The AMD Athlon X4 840 is fabricated on a 28 nm process at GlobalFoundries, while the Intel Core i5-2400S uses a 32 nm process at Intel. The AMD chip also integrates 2,411 million transistors on a 245 mm² die, whereas the Intel chip has 1,160 million transistors on a 216 mm² die.
Q: Do both processors support the same memory type?
A: Both support DDR3 memory in dual-channel configuration. The AMD Athlon X4 840 lists a memory bandwidth of 34.1 GB/s, while the Intel Core i5-2400S does not have a memory bandwidth figure listed in the data.
Architecture Differences
The AMD Athlon X4 840 is built on the Steamroller architecture, part of the Kaveri codename family, using a 28 nm process at GlobalFoundries. It integrates 2,411 million transistors on a 245 mm² die. The CPU has 4 cores and 4 threads, with a base clock of 3.10 GHz and a boost clock of 3.80 GHz. Its cache hierarchy includes 256 KB of L1 cache and 4 MB of L2 cache, with no L3 cache present. The processor uses the AMD Socket FM2+ and supports PCIe Gen 3 with 16 lanes from the CPU. It has no integrated graphics listed.
The Intel Core i5-2400S is based on the Sandy Bridge architecture, also known by the codename Sandy Bridge, manufactured on a 32 nm process at Intel. It contains 1,160 million transistors on a 216 mm² die. This CPU also has 4 cores and 4 threads, with a lower base clock of 2.50 GHz and a boost clock of 3.30 GHz. Cache configuration differs significantly: the Intel part has 64 KB L1 per core, 256 KB L2 per core, and 6 MB of shared L3 cache. It uses the Intel Socket 1155, supports PCIe Gen 3 with 16 lanes, and includes integrated graphics in the form of Intel HD 2000.
The two chips diverge in several key architectural areas. The AMD part has a smaller L1 cache in total (256 KB versus the Intel per-core figure multiplied across four cores), but the Intel part provides a shared L3 cache that the AMD part lacks entirely. Clock speeds favor AMD, with a 0.60 GHz higher base clock and a 0.50 GHz higher boost clock. The process node gap is also notable: 28 nm versus 32 nm, with the AMD chip using a significantly higher transistor count despite its larger die size.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The head-to-head data is unambiguous: the AMD Athlon X4 840 wins all five benchmark comparisons, with zero wins for the Intel Core i5-2400S. The margins are remarkably consistent across different Cinebench versions and workload types.
In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the Athlon X4 840 scores 285 against 262 for the i5-2400S, a delta of 8.8%. This pattern repeats in Cinebench R20 multi-core, where the AMD chip scores 1189 versus 1092, an 8.9% advantage. The Cinebench R23 multi-core test shows the same 8.9% delta, with scores of 2833 and 2601 respectively.
Single-core performance tells the same story. The Athlon X4 840 leads in Cinebench R20 single-core with 168 points against 154 for the Intel part, a 9.1% margin. In Cinebench R23 single-core, the AMD chip scores 400 versus 367, a 9% lead. These figures indicate that the Athlon's advantage is not limited to multi-threaded scaling but extends to per-core efficiency as well.
The Intel Core i5-2400S does have additional benchmark data not present for the AMD part, including Geekbench scores of 1709 multi-core and 593 single-core, but these tests cannot be compared head-to-head because the Athlon X4 840 lacks corresponding entries in the data pack. The overall wins tally stands at 5 for AMD and 0 for Intel.
Specification Differences
The two processors differ in several specification fields. Base clock speeds are 3.10 GHz for the AMD Athlon X4 840 versus 2.50 GHz for the Intel Core i5-2400S. Boost clocks are 3.80 GHz versus 3.30 GHz respectively. Process nodes differ at 28 nm (AMD, GlobalFoundries) versus 32 nm (Intel). Transistor counts are 2,411 million versus 1,160 million, and die sizes are 245 mm² versus 216 mm².
Cache layouts are fundamentally different. The AMD part has 256 KB L1 and 4 MB L2 with no L3 cache, while the Intel part has 64 KB L1 per core, 256 KB L2 per core, and 6 MB shared L3. Memory bandwidth is listed only for the AMD chip at 34.1 GB/s; the Intel chip has no value in this field. Sockets differ: AMD Socket FM2+ versus Intel Socket 1155.
Integrated graphics are present only on the Intel Core i5-2400S, which features Intel HD 2000; the AMD Athlon X4 840 has no integrated graphics listed. The multiplier is unlocked on the AMD part but locked on the Intel part. Release dates differ substantially, with the Intel chip launching in early 2011 and the AMD chip in mid-2014. Part numbers are also distinct, with the AMD unit identified as AD840XYBJABOXAD840XYBI44JA and the Intel unit as SR00S.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Athlon X4 840 wins in every benchmark category represented in the head-to-head data. This includes multi-core rendering across three Cinebench versions (R15, R20, R23) and single-core rendering across two versions (R20, R23). The margins are consistent, ranging from 8.8% to 9.1%, suggesting a uniform performance advantage rather than workload-specific strengths. Users prioritizing raw Cinebench performance in either single-threaded or multi-threaded tasks should favor the AMD part based on this data.
The Intel Core i5-2400S does not win any head-to-head benchmark. However, it does offer features that may be relevant outside of raw compute scores. It includes integrated graphics (Intel HD 2000), which the AMD part lacks entirely. It also has a shared L3 cache of 6 MB, which may benefit certain workloads, though the benchmark data does not capture any such advantage in the tests conducted. The Intel chip also has a lower base clock, which might imply different power characteristics, but both chips are rated at the same 65 W TDP.
The AMD part's unlocked multiplier is a differentiating feature for users who intend to overclock, though no overclocking benchmark results are included in the data. The AMD chip's higher clock speeds at stock settings appear to drive its benchmark victories, given the consistent margins across both single and multi-core tests.
The Verdict
Based strictly on the benchmark data, the AMD Athlon X4 840 is the superior processor in this comparison. It wins all five head-to-head Cinebench tests, with margins between 8.8% and 9.1%. Its average benchmark score of 975 is higher than the Intel Core i5-2400S's 968, and both CPUs sit at the 26th percentile among all CPUs, indicating similar overall market positioning.
Users who prioritize multi-core and single-core rendering performance in Cinebench applications should choose the AMD Athlon X4 840. The data shows a clear and consistent advantage across all tested workloads, with the largest single margin of 9.1% occurring in Cinebench R20 single-core. The AMD part also offers an unlocked multiplier for potential overclocking, a feature the Intel chip lacks.
Users who require integrated graphics should consider the Intel Core i5-2400S, as it includes Intel HD 2000 while the AMD part has no integrated graphics listed. The Intel chip also provides a shared L3 cache, which is absent on the AMD part, though the benchmark results do not show this translating into a performance win in any tested scenario. For workloads beyond Cinebench, no comparative data exists in this pack, so conclusions must be limited to the tests presented.
The verdict is straightforward: the AMD Athlon X4 840 delivers better benchmark performance in every measured category, while the Intel Core i5-2400S offers integrated graphics and a different cache structure. For pure compute performance, the AMD part is the clear winner. For systems needing a built-in GPU or specific L3 cache behavior, the Intel part has unique attributes, but it cannot match the AMD chip in the benchmarks provided.