AMD Athlon Silver PRO 3125GE vs Intel Core i5-4430 Comparison
AMD Athlon Silver PRO 3125GE
Core i5-4430
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Athlon Silver PRO 3125GE vs Intel Core i5-4430
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The benchmark data presents an unusually close contest between two processors from very different eras. The Intel Core i5-4430, a Haswell part from 2013, and the AMD Athlon Silver PRO 3125GE, a Zen+ based chip from 2020, trade blows within a razor-thin margin across all six Cinebench tests. The head-to-head results show the Intel chip winning every single test, but the margins are so narrow that they border on statistical noise.
In Cinebench R15 multicore, the i5-4430 scores 400 against the Athlon's 396, a delta of only 1 percent. The single-core R15 result is slightly more pronounced: 56 versus 55, a 1.8 percent advantage for Intel. Moving to Cinebench R20, the multicore delta shrinks to 1 percent again (1669 vs 1653), while single-core shows 235 against 233, a 0.9 percent gap. The R23 results continue the pattern: multicore 3974 versus 3938 (0.9 percent), single-core 561 versus 555 (1.1 percent). The i5-4430 wins all six comparisons, yet the largest margin anywhere is just 1.8 percent.
What makes these numbers striking is the architectural gulf between the two chips. The Intel part relies on four physical cores with no hyper-threading, running at a base clock of 3.00 GHz and boost of 3.20 GHz. The AMD chip counters with only two physical cores but four threads via SMT, at a base clock of 3.40 GHz with no boost clock listed. Despite the Intel chip's two additional physical cores, the AMD part's higher clock speed and simultaneous multithreading nearly erase that advantage. The average benchmark scores tell the same story: 1149 for Intel versus 1138 for AMD, a difference of under 1 percent.
The percentile rankings reinforce how similar these processors are in overall performance. The i5-4430 sits at the 33rd percentile of all CPUs, while the Athlon Silver PRO 3125GE sits at the 32nd percentile. Both are firmly in the lower-middle tier of processor performance, but their head-to-head parity is remarkable given the seven-year gap in release dates.
Where Each One Wins
The data shows a clean sweep for the Intel Core i5-4430 in raw benchmark scores, but the margins are so small that the practical differences are negligible for most workloads. The Intel chip's largest win comes in Cinebench R15 single-core, where its 1.8 percent lead suggests a slight per-thread advantage. This could translate to marginally snappier response in lightly-threaded applications like basic office tasks or web browsing.
The multicore tests tell a more nuanced story. The i5-4430's lead in R15 multicore is exactly 1 percent, identical to its R20 multicore margin. The R23 multicore delta narrows slightly to 0.9 percent. This consistency across generations of the Cinebench test suggests the Intel chip's four physical cores provide a small but persistent edge over the AMD chip's two cores with four threads. However, the AMD part's 3.40 GHz base clock partially compensates for its core deficit, keeping the gap under 2 percent in every test.
For users prioritizing raw multi-threaded throughput, the i5-4430 wins each multicore test by roughly 1 percent. For single-threaded workloads, the Intel chip again edges ahead, with deltas ranging from 0.9 to 1.8 percent. The AMD Athlon's only consolation is that it never loses by more than 1.8 percent, meaning the performance delta between these two chips is practically imperceptible in real-world use. The data implies that architectural differences — core count versus clock speed, older versus newer process node — cancel each other out to a remarkable degree.
The Verdict
The benchmark evidence points to the Intel Core i5-4430 as the marginally faster processor, winning all six head-to-head comparisons. Its 1.8 percent single-core lead in Cinebench R15 is the largest margin recorded, while its multicore wins hover around 1 percent. The 33rd versus 32nd percentile ranking confirms these are closely matched parts. A user choosing between them strictly on performance would pick the Intel chip, but the advantage is so slim that other factors would likely dominate the decision.
The AMD Athlon Silver PRO 3125GE holds its own despite having half the physical cores. Its four threads and higher base clock nearly neutralize the Intel chip's core advantage. The data suggests the AMD part is the more efficient design — its 35 watt TDP versus the Intel chip's 84 watt TDP means it achieves comparable performance at less than half the power draw. This makes the Athlon the rational choice for low-power or compact systems where thermal output matters more than a 1 percent performance edge.
Strictly from the benchmark numbers, the i5-4430 is the faster CPU. But the practical difference is negligible, and the AMD chip's architectural advantages — newer process node, lower power consumption, DDR4 memory support — are not captured in the Cinebench scores. The verdict depends entirely on what the user values beyond raw performance, since the raw performance is essentially a tie.
FAQ
Q: Which processor wins more benchmark tests?
A: The Intel Core i5-4430 wins all six head-to-head tests, including every Cinebench R15, R20, and R23 multicore and single-core comparison.
Q: What is the largest performance gap between the two?
A: The largest margin is 1.8 percent, recorded in Cinebench R15 single-core, where the i5-4430 scores 56 against the Athlon's 55.
Q: How do their overall performance percentiles compare?
A: The i5-4430 sits at the 33rd percentile of all CPUs, while the Athlon Silver PRO 3125GE sits at the 32nd percentile, a difference of one percentile point.
Q: What are the average benchmark scores for each processor?
A: The Intel chip has an average benchmark score of 1149, while the AMD chip averages 1138, a difference of 11 points or roughly 1 percent.
Q: Which processor has more physical cores?
A: The Intel Core i5-4430 has 4 physical cores, while the AMD Athlon Silver PRO 3125GE has 2 physical cores but 4 threads total.
Q: What is the TDP difference between the two chips?
A: The Intel chip has a TDP of 84 watts, while the AMD chip has a TDP of 35 watts, making the AMD part significantly more power-efficient.
Architecture Differences
The two processors come from fundamentally different design philosophies and manufacturing eras. The Intel Core i5-4430 uses the Haswell architecture, built on a 22 nm process at Intel's foundries. It packs 1,400 million transistors into a 177 mm² die. The AMD Athlon Silver PRO 3125GE uses the Zen+ architecture, specifically the Picasso variant, manufactured on a 12 nm process at GlobalFoundries. Despite having only two cores, the AMD chip contains 4,940 million transistors on a 210 mm² die — over three times the transistor count and a larger die than the Intel part.
Cache hierarchies differ substantially. The Intel chip provides 64 KB of L1 and 256 KB of L2 per core, plus 6 MB of shared L3 cache. The AMD chip offers larger per-core caches: 96 KB of L1 and 512 KB of L2 per core, but only 4 MB of shared L3. The AMD part's larger per-core caches reflect its design as a dual-core chip, while the Intel chip's larger shared L3 pool benefits its four-core configuration.
Memory support marks another clear division. The Intel chip uses DDR3 memory on a dual-channel bus, while the AMD chip supports DDR4 with a dual-channel bus and a specified memory bandwidth of 42.7 GB/s. The AMD part also supports ECC memory, which the Intel chip does not. Both use PCIe Gen 3, though the AMD chip specifies 8 lanes from the CPU only.
The integrated graphics differ as well: Intel HD 4600 on the i5-4430 versus Radeon Vega 3 on the Athlon. The release dates span seven years — June 2013 for Intel, July 2020 for AMD — yet the performance parity suggests the AMD chip's architectural efficiency compensates for its lower core count.
Specification Differences
The core specifications highlight the fundamental design differences between these processors. The Intel Core i5-4430 offers 4 cores and 4 threads, while the AMD Athlon Silver PRO 3125GE offers 2 cores and 4 threads. Base clocks differ: 3.00 GHz for Intel versus 3.40 GHz for AMD. The Intel chip has a boost clock of 3.20 GHz, while the AMD chip lists no boost clock. TDP ratings diverge sharply: 84 watts for Intel versus 35 watts for AMD.
The sockets are incompatible — Intel Socket 1150 for the i5-4430, AMD Socket AM4 for the Athlon. Process nodes differ at 22 nm versus 12 nm. The Intel chip has no ECC support, while the AMD chip supports ECC memory. The AMD part lists a memory bandwidth of 42.7 GB/s, while the Intel chip's bandwidth is not specified. Transistor counts and die sizes also differ significantly: 1,400 million transistors on a 177 mm² die for Intel, versus 4,940 million on a 210 mm² die for AMD.
Both processors have locked multipliers, but their market segments align as Desktop parts. The AMD chip is marked as Active in production status, while the Intel chip's production status is not listed. The part numbers differ (SR14G for Intel, YD3125C6M2OFH for AMD), and neither has a listed launch MSRP.